Preview

Arnold Shwarzenegger's Lack Of Ethos

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
505 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Arnold Shwarzenegger's Lack Of Ethos
The debate over the United States immigrant policy has been going an issue since the first immigrant stepped foot in America. Many Americans believe that it is unfair that people from other countries can come to America and take opportunities from people born in America. Arnold Schwarzenegger writes, An Immigrant Writes, to shed some light on his belief that our policy should be revised to help both immigrants and Americans. Mr. Schwarzenegger’s article, An Immigrant Writes, was a compelling argument but was not successful because of his lack of ethos, detail, and refutation.

Mr. Schwarzenegger’s lack of ethos makes his article seem underdeveloped and less creditable. Schwarzenegger believes immigration is an issue in our country but it can be solved with a good policy. To make his argument stronger he needs to quote someone with experience to give their opinion on the subject of immigration. He makes some compelling points but without someone with authority backing up what he is saying, his argument looks solely based on Mr. Schwarzenegger’s opinion. The uses of pathos throughout the article are helpful to his argument but would have been more effective with more detail. Schwarzenegger refers to moms and dads doing everything they can to
…show more content…
In the conclusion of the paper Mr. Schwarzenegger states “Yes immigration is a difficult issue” (page 27). If he had given reasons to why immigration is a difficult issue or how the other side of the argument could right. It would make his argument stronger because he can compare the sides and then give the audience a chance to decide for themselves making them feel heard. It is important to do this because the audience feels like the author understands both sides and is basing his opinion on the stronger evidence. If he had added this into the article it would have made it look well researched and thought

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    With a topic as versatile as immigration with social, political and economic ties in American policy the use of deductive reasoning does not dispense much trust in the author’s reasoning since it comes after the conclusion. The immediate presentation of his claim has the rest of the article trying its best to meet the qualification of making it true. And true or not, the evidence given lacks in sound logic.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to the the article “Who’s Worthy if Immigrating Here?”, by George F. Will, there are about 80 million immigrants living in the United states. These 80 million people have created debates on whether they are Americans or if the really should be. The divided views on who is an American and what it should take to become a citizen shows what America is. The different views on immigration creates a lot of tension around the subject.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethos for the article is established at the beginning with the list of authors. The some of the authors have Ph.D.’s and others have experience working within the field of immigration. This helps create credibility of the argument, since all of the author’s credentials are given to the reader. Also the article is supported by multiple sources, which shows extensive research and gives a variety of perspectives. The argument is set up neatly; the authors place subtitles at the beginning of a section then proceed to explain them with a series of bullet points.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author begins with including facts, which are fake, but due to the satirical nature of her piece, help support her argument and demonstrate her tone. She opens the piece by saying, “According to a study recently released from Royue Staric, a demographic center, it turns out that immigrants are here to steal your jobs! The study shows that 0% of immigrants surveyed said they had “come for a job”.” Through including these “facts,” the author is able to emphasize her point that immigrants are not here to steal jobs because she over-exaggerates…

    • 638 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States of America originally a nation of immigrants is rapidly becoming a nation of native born citizens. We have by now had an opportunity to produce the native-born individual someone we might label as an “American”. Today, the number of foreign-born persons in the United States is about 3,000,000 of the population, and about 5,000,000 of Americans are the children of immigrants. Due to the new Immigration Reform and Control Act the days of mass immigration are over, but the influence of the movement will never be eased. (Arun and Daniel p.1)…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Immigration Debate We Need” was written by George Borjas, a professor at Harvard, reporter, and economist of The New York Times. Borjas claimed that Trump’s immigration policy is more beneficial than what people make it to be. In the article, he said, “I am [the] living proof that immigration policy can benefit some people.” that supports the idea that the policy is not bad, but useful in society. In the article, he targeted people who are against the immigration policy because he wanted to spread the awareness that Trump’s policy is beneficial. While I was reading this article, I was starting to agree with his viewpoint because he said, “The climate suggests that many Americans view that number as too high”, that means the policy can…

    • 176 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Immigrants create San Francisco” is common sense people around the world acknowledge to praise the contributions immigrants have made. America, as we all know, positioned as the most prosperous and humanistic country in the world, gives immigration a very crucial role due to its function forming the diverse culture of America. Every year, thousands of immigrants move to the United States, seeking superior living conditions such as employment, welfare and education. However, that movement inevitably raises a bunch of social issues, of which the most apparent and controversial one is illegal immigration. Based on this situation, debates about immigration reform were fiercely triggered in public recently. My topic is how to treat illegal immigrants in immigration reform, and the argument is mainly divided into two groups. A group of people thinks illegal immigrants are more risky than we think. They must be deported. While another group believes that the advantages illegals bring to America outweigh any harm they do, so Americans should treat them with justice and give them a pathway to citizenship. Based on the information I have gathered during my previous assignments, I support the latter position.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since immigration has been a divisive issue in American Politics and since candidates can easily be identified by their views on immigration, there is much said about the impacts and effects of more immigrants. Some candidates embrace an open policy to let people in so they can find a better life. Those who want a tighter immigration policy cite economic issues as reasons for limiting entrance. Their arguments claim that immigrants will take American jobs and make the work environment more…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In March of 2005 a journalist by the name of David R. Francis form the Christian Science Monitor wrote “Why the New Jobs Go to Immigrants”. He argued that millions of American jobs had been taken by illegal immigrants; this was because former president George Bush was letting them. He figured it would grant them a way for U. S. citizenship. Many people would agree with David Francis’s claim and why he expressed that more illegals have jobs than Americans. Throughout the article he provides examples from Aristotle’s three strategies for argumentation: logos, ethos, and pathos. Mr. Francis not only gave lots of evidence to support his thought process but he gave real life examples.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigration in Texas

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Immigration has been a topic for while. In this debate, they state facts that show why immigration is either a positive or negative effect in the U.S. Some people are against it and some people are completely fine with it. While watching this debate about immigration, you find out information pertaining to poverty in our country. However going back and forth, they’re arguing their point but also trying to convince the audience and listeners on how immigration has a big impact in our world.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For many years, the immigrant population of the United Stated had faced many hardships and obstacles during their lives; some during their short lives, due to the way America feels about immigration. This great nation was not established overnight, but it came to be through a process; a process called immigration. Immigration is America’s heart and soul, in fact, America dwells and depends on it. For some reason though, Americans more and more have begun to think of immigration as a bug that needs to be squashed. Beginning with making ridiculous immigration laws, spending millions of [needed] dollars on border security, and withholding peoples’ rights, America has fallen so low, it seems impossible to get back up. Because of the many hindrances this country has put in the immigrants, many of them, unable to afford the great…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many people in the United States do not realize how hard existence is for an illegal immigrant to live in the United States. Many illegal’s live in fear everyday, of not only being sent back to their country, but starting again from zero. For an illegal immigrant, being in the U.S. illegally is not something they pride themselves on, but it is their only option for a better life. According to a recent poll “Between 12 and 20 million illegal immigrants live in the United States” (usimmigrationsupport.com). Millions of people are impossible amount to get rid of but definitely a problem that should be addressed responsibly. Legalizing the status of immigrants…

    • 2032 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Border Control

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In recent years, Illegal immigration has been a contemporary political and social debate. It has been the platform of many politicians, especially in the southwest, and it is often a popular subject in news media. People in favor of strict immigration policy often claim that illegal immigrants are costly to the American economy and that they take American jobs. The border control policy is ineffective, it is often too costly for its effectiveness. Border policies have increased the number of immigrant deaths in the deserts of border states. Not only that but the US/Mexico border is harmful to the environment. The anti-immigration policy that's currently in effect goes against a rich cultural history in North America. Lastly, popular arguments made for strict immigration will be brought to light.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Legrain, P. (2007). Immigrants: You country needs them. United States of America: Princeton University Press.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, the author has a hasty generalization logical fallacy, which can be found in the following: “white immigrants are always seen as ‘intrepid’ people with ‘vigorous’ blood which adds to the receiving nation; similarly ambitious immigrants with darker skin or other ‘alien’ characteristics are always presumed to be carriers of chaos and untold problems” (Alibhai-Brown, 2002, p.322). Here, Alibhai-Brown generalizes all white immigrants as fearless with superior blood, while all immigrants whom carry other characteristics are seen as dangerous. Secondly, Alibhai-Brown uses the logical fallacy, personal attack, in the subsequent sentence: “these leaders pretend that they are responding to ‘illegal’ immigrants but it is pernicious racism and xenophobia which is animating their zeal and policies”. She mentions how leaders are not dealing with the illegal immigrants while not obtaining evidence to support her proclamation. Thirdly, an additional use of logical fallacies is the use of red herring. In the following lines: “His smart suit, beautifully, groomed long hair …”, the author mentions the man’s physical appearance, which has no significant importance to the article. Another aspect that negatively supports her strategies is the use of pathos, where the author uses the words “destroying” “suffer”, “beautifully”, and “pernicious” to appeal to the reader’s emotion. Then, the article is neglected of surveys, studies, and expert opinion, which would have been ideal support if added. Next, Alibhai-Brown states numerous statistics, which are not accurately supported. For instance, in the following: “…, the city which received 4,000 asylum seekers last March” here, the author overlooked citing her source, making her statement less…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays