Preview

Australian Identity: 'I Was Only Nineteen' Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1506 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Australian Identity: 'I Was Only Nineteen' Analysis
The text I have chosen to analyse in this written review is called ‘I Was Only Nineteen’, but also goes by the names ‘Only Nineteen’ and ‘A Walk in the Light Green’. It was composed by John Schumann, the lead singer/songwriter of the folk group Redgum. This examination will focus on topics such as the poetic techniques used, how Australian identity is portrayed, the effect the text has on the reader and my opinions. I Was Only Nineteen tells the story of an Australian digger’s experiences preparing for, fighting in, and reflecting upon the Vietnam War as an old man, psychologically and physically damaged from the chemical defoliant Agent Orange. Although it may seem like a long time ago – the war ended in mid 1975 – the scars it left behind will never fade.

John Schumann uses numerous poetic devices throughout his hit song. The most frequently used techniques include rhyme (as is the same for most lyrical songs), repetition, rhetorical questions and multitudes of colloquialisms. Many of the mentioned techniques – as well as others in the song – provided the reader/listener with an opportunity to think about the theme of Australian identity. The colloquialisms applied to this ballad allow the reader to associate and relate to their own lifestyles in Australia. “Drinking tinnies” ¬– an Australian vernacular term meaning ‘drinking cans of beer’ – connects with the stereotypically casual attitudes of pub attendees Down Under. Schumann’s broad Australian accent for the entirety of this piece also expresses a feeling of Australia. Schumann makes a habit of mentioning genuine Australian and Vietnamese locations. “Puckapunyal”, “Canungra”, “Shoalwater”, “Townsville”, “Nui Dat” and “Vung Tau” are some of the several places noted in this song. By citing factual towns/cities, Schumann creates yet another bond with the audience, as most members would have heard of at least one of these before. The rhetorical questions used in this have

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tom Brennan Analysis

    • 146 Words
    • 1 Page

    when people study Australian voices, it can broaden their perspective of Australian by knowing the diversity of Australian culture, but also support audience learn more about the Australian values and beliefs. in order to know Australian voices more deeper. I choose two text which is 《The story of Tom Brennan》and 《Eating in》.The novel, ”The story of Tom Brennan” by J.C.Burke clearly demonstrate how Tom Brennan’s life and his whole family’s life is changed following a tragic car accident caused all by his older brother, and the 1980s poem “Eating in” by Richard James Allen which is about the composer use sarcasm tone to describe with understatement about war . Both of these texts reveal strong Australian voices of an accident victims and…

    • 146 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    2014 Assessment Task 1

    • 1014 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In this unit, students have explored Indigenous Australian Poetry with a specific focus on the poetry of…

    • 1014 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nevertheless, Leser continues the article with the added details of the sentimental love for the song from Australians, the song as a reverence. “[Gregʼs flute line] was a salute to another iconic part of Australian musical history. His motivation wasnʼt to steal, it was to pay homage.” The emotive language and serious tone, inflicts an interested response from the readers creating a sympathetic stance towards the song and Greg Ham. Thus, through examining the way in which the memory of Greg Ham and the song has combined with the tragedy resulting from the trial, audiences perceive a resolute yet unforeseen circumstance that continues to enshrine Down Under as an iconic Australian song. The most salient act of representation which interplays both personal memory and public perception is Frearsʼ usage of the extended metaphor and anthropomorphic image of the Monarch of the Glen. In this scene, Elizabeth II drives into the wilderness and encounters a majestic 14 pointer stag, and in a deliberate MIS-en-scene, a far shot frames the stag in the same manner as the painting by Edward Lanseer “Monarch of the Glen.” The stag motif represents the Queenʼs position as the monarch of her nation, an untouchable and distant figure which represents the dignity and cultural heritage of her nation. The monarch, the stag, is alone, it does not have companions, metaphorically standing firm in the captured scene. However, a latter scene reveals that the stag was shot. Metaphorically, Frears utilizes this idea of the hunted to illustrate the vulnerability of the Queen as a human being who can be hurt. This is further metaphorically shown in an over the shoulder shot where the queen notes, “Oh, it was wounded.” Her sentiment reveals to the audience that even the Queen is only human. Together, history and memory, Frears again demonstrates that the connection of history and memory produces a required and unpredicted appreciation for the film. As such, in studying the…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Bruce Dawe Essay

    • 2017 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Bruce Dawe, an Australian known poet, born 1930 is still one of the biggest selling and most highly regarded poets of Australia. His ability to write such influential poems has made an impact on a number of people, as each poem can be related to the ordinary living lives of Australians throughout the years. Bruce Dawe's poems are interesting because they comment on the lives of ordinary people. This statement is agreed on. In relation to the statement, three key poems can be linked being Enter Without So Much as Knocking (1959), Homo Suburbiensis (1964) and Drifters (1968).…

    • 2017 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    'I was only 19' is a song written/composed by Redgum, it is about a first-person account of a typical Australian soldiers' experience in the Vietnam War. The poem focuses on the after effects of what happens to the soldiers after war, how they experience PTSD (post- traumatic stress disorder) and that leads us to believe that an internal war is ongoing. In this text, the technique used is imagery. Redgum uses this technique to describe what their experience was like. This prompts the audience to feel sympathy for the soldiers.…

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “I was only 19” is a protest song by Redgum which reflects a physical journey of a young boy who is going off to the Vietnam War. When reading the song lyrics it can also be seen as a ballad or a retrospect because the way it has been composed. Throughout the entirety of the song there are many themes like the Vietnam War and Culture which is shown through mention of multiple traditional towns like “Nui Dat” and “Vung Tau”, there is also reference to agent orange which was used during the Vietnam war. Other themes include Australian history, anti-war protest and returned soldiers or veterans.…

    • 296 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Her childhood was filled with memories such as "[camping] out often". In page 9 and 10 Ellie compares her life to her friend Fiona's saying; "unlike us rurals, she [lives] in town and spends more time playing piano then drenching sheep or marking lambs". Ellie is a genuine rural. Throughout the book Ellie also exhibits another element of Australian Identity, a fighting spirit. Many times she is pushed to the limits and comes up with brilliant plans and keeps going in desperate and tough times whcih ensure her friends and her own survival, for example the time when Ellie bravely stepped into the light of the car park to see what was going o ndown at the show…

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Young Man in Vietnam

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Young Man in Vietnam” by Charles Coe goes against the 1980 patriotic views of Vietnam veterans, as he positions readers to be sympathetic towards veterans. Through the use of characterisation and symbolism Coe has positioned readers to be sympathetic towards the young man in Vietnam.…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Backyard Poem

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In backyard this concept is presented in the last stanza when it says ¡°but don¡¯t ask too much: some cold beer, a few old friends in the afternoon¡± beer, friends, afternoon. John Tranter puts this character in the perfect setting where he should relax. Drinking beer with his friends in the afternoon at a backyard barbeque. In the second stanza another rhetorical question can be seen. It says, ¡°who cares?¡¯ this again accentuates the laid back attitude Australians have to life. In this case not caring about what is happening around them but only trying to enjoy life at that specific…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It’s within this that we see the Australian Voice is made up of many unique individuals, with each to their own personalities and traits. I wanted to present this poem to this audience today to be able tell you that the ‘Australian Voice’ has no set criteria or one idea behind it. It…

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Australian Identity

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Australian identity refers to how a country is depicted as a whole whilst encompassing its culture, traditions, language and politics. Australia is the smallest, youngest continent with the lowest population density, which often struggles to define its national identity. As Australia originates from British descent, it lacks originality in culture and heritage. One aspect as portrayed by Tim Winton in his narrative style article Tide of Joy is an Australian identity revolving around summer by the sea with family. Danny Katz emphasises the difference between those considered ‘worthy’ of celebrating Australia Day and those that do not meet the criteria in his editorial Aussie, Aussie, Aussie? No, No, No. These two texts help to define the open-ended question of, ‘How do we define Australian identity?’ However, the texts both represent a narrow range of individuals in Australian society and therefore by reading these two texts alone, it is a rather biased view of the Australian stereotype.…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Peter Carey

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The creative non-fiction piece ‘30 Days in Sydney’ written by Peter Carey is an interesting insight to an expatriates experience of coming back to Sydney for a 30 day holiday. This piece was written in an almost journal like sense, with the intentions of giving readers an account on Sydney and its history. The work is written to show the carefree city of Sydney which he is fond of, however also to show the reader how Sydney is a place of contrast, with a deep convict history and reveals the dark side of Sydney, hidden underneath the relaxed city it appears to be. He convinces the reader using his apparent knowledge in history as well as his own personal experiences in Sydney. I believe the target audience for this piece would be anyone who has had any kind of experience in Sydney. A reader who has been to or lived in Sydney would be able to understand and connect more with the piece than someone who hasn’t. This isn’t to say, however, that a reader who has never been to or had any connections to the city of Sydney wouldn’t be able to enjoy the piece.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Australian Identity Essay

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Peter Porter was a British based Australian poet, who grew up in Australia then migrated to England in 1951. The poem “Sydney Cove, 1788” is mainly about the culture of Australia, presented through poetic techniques such as personification and imagery. Porter portrays Australia as a seemingly well-established country, involving aspects of religious devotion, working environment, and a civilized mindset within the society. Evidence of Religion is found in the poem where Port utilizes imagery such as “hymns it with a unison of feet” symbolize a religious devotion regarding the process of getting to know a foreign land. Evidence of Australia’s over developed working environment is shown when Porter states that even “Genocide or Jesus can’t work on this land” and “A convict selling a baby for a jug of rum”. This shows that Australia was a developed country and is currently on the decline, having working environments with and overload of tasks and has started to corrupt the minds of its members of society. This poem indicates the ideal mindset that the government wants from it’s citizens. This is shown where Porter Personifies the country…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poem “I am Australian” relates to the concept of belonging to and national identity. Repetition of 'I Am Australian' reinforces this, imagery of the environment and creates a link between the nation and the self, and thus the person is intimately connected to the country. The Poem is about celebrating diversity in Australia, between the people and the land.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “I was Only 19” by Redgum conveys their ideas about the violent and disturbing nature of war, the long-lasting psychological effects of war on the soldiers and the misleading nature of the ANZAC legend through the use of language techniques such as repetition, hyperbole, visual comparisons, rhetorical questions, metaphor and code, etc.…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics