English 1101
“The “Banking” Concept of Education” and the Modern Workplace
In “The “Banking” Concept of Education” by Paulo Freire, he widely expresses that the “oppressors” (teachers) just throw information at the students and they have no choice but to accept it. There is no real learning between the teacher and the student. The students are basically forced to memorize the information they’re being “taught”. His theory about the most crucial skills that a teacher should possess is accurate in so many different ways; not only should an instructor help a student know material but also build the confidence that they learned all the material. This is what a lot of instructors lack in this day and age. This lack of concern and effort from some of teachers make students feel that they are just there for a paycheck. Instead of taking the time to observe if students are learning or not, many teachers would just talk and flip through a powerpoint that contained the notes. Paulo Freire listed a number of ways that students are being taught in the classroom and considers our society to be oppressive; I’ll list a few I believe are important. One of the most important quality that Paulo Freire listed was “the teacher knows everything and the student knows nothing”. The teachers do not care about the students’ education. The teachers are “force-feeding” students. The students do not know anything that they are supposed to know because the teachers frankly don’t care. The only thing that they care about is getting their paycheck every two weeks. The teacher has very little to do with the teaching and learning process; it is not really a process considering that the students aren’t technically learning. The students have learned how to memorize the work they’re supposed know. They know if the work is not memorized that’ll result in them getting a bad grade on the assignments that the teacher will give them. Again, the “force-feeding” process begins again when Paulo Freire states “the teacher chooses the program content, and the students (who are not consulted) adapt to it”. Ultimately the teachers teach the standard for the state. Most times the teacher has no control of what is supposed to be taught, but the way it can be taught is a different story. In the beginning of the year/semester the teacher could take a survey on the way different students learn. Then the teacher could….. The last important thought that Paulo Freire expresses is that “the teacher confuses the authority of knowledge with his or her own professional authority, which she and he sets in opposition to the freedom to the students”. In many classrooms the statement just listed is ironically true. Many teachers confuse their actual command of their subject with the power given them over the students' command of the subject without the work submitted by the students, there wouldn’t even have been a class. Nothing the professor ever said could have been generated without first reading the work of the students. The students, should always be the subjects of the class, and the professor's opinion, secondary to ours, should be the object. Then students and teachers could work together to ultimately better themselves in the teaching situation.
The “banking” system creates a minimum wage worker. Most Americans are settling for minimum wage. They think that is okay to make minimum wage is good, because they are at least putting money in their pockets and able to feed their families. It is not okay, we need the generations behind us to make more money than we did. The “banking concept of education”, is not the education we would like our kids to have. We need good hearted teachers and administrators to give our kids the education they deserve.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Freire tells that the education system is like dictatorship. Teachers are the dictators while students are the people who being dictated. Students have been oppressed without realizing it; furthermore, they are just fear in getting their freedom. They are just giving commitment to their teachers and getting involved in class without understanding what it really means.…
- 298 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
My experience in the education system was not anything like ‘The “Banking” Concept of Education’ critiques it. It specifies on critiquing the teacher-student relationship and I would like to argue a few points made in this reading. Such as, how the teacher presents himself or herself, the relationship involving the teacher and student, and how students never discover that they also educate the teacher. I could argue these points through experiences I’ve had over my years as a student throughout the education system, I will focus on high school.…
- 514 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Freire says that teacher’s cannot just see themselves as teachers, “we are political militants because we are teachers.” (Freire) Every day teachers go above and beyond as he tells in his story of Carla when his daughter was teaching. Carla was a poor, dirty child and her grandmother could not pay for her education so she went to Madalena for help. Madalena agreed to waive the school fee if Carla would come to school dressed and cleaned up (there were plenty of other students whose fee was surrendered as well). Because of this Carla was able to thrive in school and no one noticed that she was poor; she looked like any of the other students. “A naïve bystander would say that the educator’s intervention had been somewhat bourgeois, elitist, alienated- after all, how can one require that a child of the slums come to school bathed?” (Freire) But, because of this there was no chaos in the classroom, no one was above another. Basically she was able to remove the distraction and teach the class. This story is relevant to progressive teaching because it is important not to have rankings in the classroom. No teacher should be above or below their students, just as no students should be seen as above or below their peers. Everything in the classroom should be equal, to an extent, so that the classroom can be best…
- 950 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
The math teacher was babbling on about how this specific formula worked and halfway through her example I noticed that she had made a mistake. I hesitated a hundred times before raising my hand. It felt almost wrong because usually no one spoke up unless they had to go to the bathroom or get a drink which we all know that was just an excuse so we didn’t have to hear the teacher talk about something we weren’t interested in at that moment. According to Freire, we were taught within the banking system of education to accept our ignorance as justifying the teacher’s existence (319). In other words, students were “trained” in a way to keep their opinions and thoughts to themselves within a classroom setting.…
- 1032 Words
- 3 Pages
Better Essays -
His idea that the students are an "empty vessel" is at the core of the banking concept where the curriculum does not take into consideration the needs of the students as libertarians, the means by which men and women deal with reality in either a critical or creative way. He makes this point because in education today the information is chosen by the educator as the "depositor" and "deposited" into the student; "the scope of action allowed the student extends only as far as receiving, filing and storing; which the students patiently receive, memorize and repeat" (319). The more a teacher does this to his students the more reality is taken away from them to learn the true meanings of life. This can be related back to Freire 's argument against the education system, because one can only memorize things for so long, after that one will lose his true purpose in the world. To go against the system of education Freire has established new methods to turn the idea of education aroundThe method of education that Freire asserts as an alternative to the banking concept is to encourage students to question and pursue the world. He calls this his "problem-posing" method on education (325). This change in focus is facilitated by a shift in the student-teacher relationship; the student learns from the teacher, and the teacher learns from the students. This is a relationship where all…
- 1260 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Education has become an important part of everyday life as means to teach knowledge and get students for their life after school out in the “Real world”. And yet, a question that has brought a ton of controversy is “what does it mean to be Educated and who decides”. Is it right to claim that today’s education system has been influenced by teachers and a series of hand selected published textbooks.…
- 1091 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In what ways does this essay point out the education system’s effect on teachers as well as students?…
- 1336 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
In Freire's opinion, mindlessly feeding the student material cannot lead to success. We should sink to the lowest common denominator. By setting such a low bar for our student's intellectual curiosity can never be fostered. Private schools have different methods, but they are not always the correct ones either.…
- 556 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“Letter by letter; syllable by syllable, the child learns to read and in good time can convey to all the domestic circle the sense of Shakespeare” (Emerson 191). The teacher presents one way for her pupils to learn and that is the only correct way. The students have no room to be creative and to imagine new possibilities for completing a task. The teacher sees the student’s way as wrong. This forced method of teaching does not work for a student. He cannot focus and understand what the teacher explains so he gives up. He breaks down. He cries and hates school. This student has zero say in his education, so he has a false view of true learning and hates it. Providing students an opportunity to actually become involved with how they learn allows them to feel excited about learning. Sitting in a desk all day does not appeal to the learning style of most students, but they are sadly stuck with it in the modern learning environment of public…
- 684 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The banking approach is a one-sided way of teaching where the professor "deposits" knowledge into the students. It's based on the idea that the students are completely ignorant and without anything meaningful to contribute-that the teacher is the only one who can bring insight and knowledge to the subject. Also, it discounts inquiry and mutual discovery as valid ways of learning. I have experienced this in several classes based on the model of lecturing, including a class where definitions for vocabulary words had to learned verbatim as they were given to us, down to the punctuation.…
- 538 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
There is no communication in this style of teaching. “This is the ‘banking’ concept of education, in which the scope of action allowed to the students extends only as far as receiving, filing, and storing the deposits” (244). Because of my “special” moment, a moment of humility that has haunted me through my educational career, school became an institution where I would go to memorize information but never really understood what I was being “taught”. I became a receptacle, a depository, and my teachers became the depositors. Education became a process of teachers making deposits which I would receive, memorize and regurgitate (Freire 244). Looking back, the trouble with the situation was that I was sacrificing the most important part of education: learning how to…
- 1359 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Paulo Freire says teachers are narrators that only feed students information. The students act like containers, turning into receptacles that the only way taught are by being filled with what the teachers tell them or narrates to them (Freire 1). This is why education suffers from narration sickness. Throughout the years many teachers around the world have been applying the “Banking concept” towards the way they teach their students; and in my perspective it is not the best way of implementing the kind of learning our children need in the future to help them succeed in life. Throughout my education teachers have expected me to memorize facts. They would narrate details without thinking about how the concepts of their teachings would relate to the real world. This “Banking Concept” prevents students from using their cognitive skills; therefore, they are not prepared to make clear decisions in the real world where as the problem- posing method offers a solution to this narration sickness.…
- 983 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
A key element that Rodriguez and Freire both speak of is banking education. Freire feels that this type of education is almost useless. Banking is no more than just listening to someone speak at you and then regurgitating the information. Both speak about education in the context of the student-teacher relationship. The banking theory of education only allows for the teacher to rule over the classroom and allows for little interaction with students. Banking turns students into "receptacle" (pg 260) bins that are crammed with information that the teacher chooses to fill…
- 853 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Education itself is like a religion. You only get out what you put in. It’s fair to say that some take it seriously, while others don’t. The pressure to succeed is enough to make you rebel and the influences along the way are bound to affect the choices and decisions you take along the way. The teachers themselves are committed to the students, desperately trying to make their education worthwhile….or are they?…
- 973 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Both Holt (1997, cited in Gardner 2005:59-63) and Rothenberg (1969, cited in Gardner 2005:68-72) suggest that teachers have contributed to the negative attitudes and poor learning habits of students. Both writers suggest that student¡¦s poor direction of viewing and bad habits of learning is due to the way of treating others, learning and thinking they are taught by teachers. Both of them think that As Holt (1997, cited in Gardner 2005:59-63) has described, students are taught to feel indifferently towards other students. Even when their classmates are just beside them, they have to act as their neighbours do not exist. In some cases, students are not allowed to talk to one anther during lunchtime. Besides not permitting to talk while they are having their lunch, Holt (1997, cited in Gardner 2005:59-63) suggests that children are taught to learn in a passive way instead of actively participating in the process of gaining knowledge. Students are told that they are considered not able to do the task properly if they do not complete it in the exact way as teachers tell them to. For instance, answers are only considered right when they are exactly the same as the answers in teacher¡¦s heads. In addition, Rothenberg claimed that teachers do not teach students how to judge critically and logically (1969, cited in Gardner 2005:70). As mentioned by Rothenberg (1969, cited in Gardner 2005:68-72), students are not taught how to ¡§work through arguments, to synthesize disparate sources to come up with original thought.¡¨ In the end, students simply copy directly from books in the library or from the internet without processing the materials. To sum up, from the three reasons given by Holt (1997, cited in Gardner 2005:59-63) and Rothenberg (1969, cited in Gardner 2005:68-72), it is obvious that to an important extent teachers are responsible for their student¡¦s negative attitudes and poor learning habits.…
- 380 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays