Barbarian Empire Dbq

In the year 476, the last Roman emperor was deposed. Over the previous two centuries, Barbarian invasions had brought the once-mighty Rome to its knees, and this is taken as the final fall of the Roman Empire in Western Europe. What are the political, economical and social implications of this event, and to what extent does it constitute a true turning-point in history?

In the period immediately after 476 it is possible to see the structure of medieval Europe emerging. Most obviously, the empire was quite quickly replaced by nation-states, vaguely resembling those Europe consists of now: a Frankish Kingdom that would become Spain, and an Ostrogothic Kingdom that would split into Italy, Greece, and Balkans. There would be much movement of borders and struggles for superiority before the countries we now recognise would appear (after all, Germany as we know it only arrived in 1870 's). But the pattern of a diverse continent with numerous small states was quickly established.

A clear consequence of the birth of these nation states was the beginning of modern monarchies. Late Roman leadership had fluctuated between elected, appointed and hereditary emperors; in the new Barbarian kingdoms, the hereditary principle became the standard. Educated statesmen were replaced by hardened warriors who earned their positions of power by warfare.
Under pressure from both invaders and internal turmoil, the general upkeep and control of the provinces had disintegrated. The autocratic monarchies, rural lifestyles and barbarian societies were a continuation of, not a change from, the culture of the late Western Roman Empire. As J.M. Roberts puts it, "It is hard to say when the Western Empire ceased to exist. Names and symbols were, like the Cheshire cat 's smile, the last things to