This reaction with L-Proline not only showed poor yield but also obtained some known side products with the benzimidazole [20-22]. However, under similar reaction condition we have also used poly phosphoric acid (PPA) and Sc(OTf)3 as catalyst for the benzimidazole formation in ethanol. These reaction results obtained, 61% and 28% selective yield of benzimidazole in 12 h reaction time (Table I, Entries 7 and 8). Furthermore, the reactions with PPA and Sc(OTf)3 having certain drawbacks such as long reaction time, in-efficient yield and highly expensive catalysts and lengthy product separation process. Additionally, we have also tested ZnSO4 as catalyst for the same reaction in same reaction condition. This catalyst also fails to obtain good to efficient yield of respective c and ended with 47% yield in 12 h reaction time (Table I, Entry
This reaction with L-Proline not only showed poor yield but also obtained some known side products with the benzimidazole [20-22]. However, under similar reaction condition we have also used poly phosphoric acid (PPA) and Sc(OTf)3 as catalyst for the benzimidazole formation in ethanol. These reaction results obtained, 61% and 28% selective yield of benzimidazole in 12 h reaction time (Table I, Entries 7 and 8). Furthermore, the reactions with PPA and Sc(OTf)3 having certain drawbacks such as long reaction time, in-efficient yield and highly expensive catalysts and lengthy product separation process. Additionally, we have also tested ZnSO4 as catalyst for the same reaction in same reaction condition. This catalyst also fails to obtain good to efficient yield of respective c and ended with 47% yield in 12 h reaction time (Table I, Entry