Preview

Bicameral Senate Power

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
626 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Bicameral Senate Power
Bicameral Legislature – does the House or the Senate have more power? Our Founding Father’s created a bicameral legislature for three reasons: First, it was what they knew, their ideologies came from Britain. The British Parliament has two houses; the House of Commons and the House of Lords (Shmoop Editorial Team).
Second, was the emphasis on checks and balances. An unicameral legislature might consolidate too much power, and they also knew from Britain, that could cause corruption. Dividing the chambers provides a check against tyranny (Shmoop Editorial Team).
The third was “a matter of practical politics” (Shmoop Editorial Team). Small states wanted all the states to have equal representation in Congress, but the larger (and more populous) states wanted congressional representation to be based on population. A bicameral legislature provided
…show more content…
Not that they have the same powers, but equal in that neither the Senate nor the House can make a law without the other. Under the U.S. Constitution, the two chambers are equal, however; the Constitution gives certain exclusive powers to each chamber. For an example the Senate has powers to confirm Presidential nominees that they do not share with the House, and the House has powers to originate all tax/spending bills that are not shared with the Senate (Nickels n.d.).
Dye and Zeigler’s Elite Theory claims that representative democracy is not really based on the will of the people, but a small elite class that governs the masses. “Only one branch of the new government, the House of Representatives, was to be elected by popular vote. The other three controlling bodies-the president, the Senate, and the Supreme Court–were removed from direct voter participation” (2009). According to Dye and Zeigler none of the delegates showed any enthusiasm for mass participation in democracy. The two chamber split appears to support Dye and Zeigler’s argument on Elite Theory

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Framers established a bicameral legislature for three reasons. First, they were familiar with the bicameral British Parliament. Second, a bicameral structure resolved conflicts between the Virginia and New Jersey plans. Third, the bicameral structure was meant to provide a system of checks and balances within the legislative branch itself.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Senate’s purpose is to be a second thought on legislative proposals after the House of Commons.[1] Members of the Senate are supposed to be a check and balance on the House of Commons. The Father of Confederacy designed the Senate for that reason. They are to be always checking on the other chamber and making sure legislation is going as it should be. Bicameral legislatures are common throughout the world and date back to early as the seventeen hundreds. Such countries as the United States of America (1787), German Confederation (1871), Australia (1901), Germany (1949), and India (1950).[2] Having a “…second chamber promotes democracy and protects democracy and protects minority rights by curbing high-handedness and arrogance in Cabinet and Commons.”[3] The Senate is a second chamber that the founder’s of this country envisioned and it serves as a check on the House and is apart of the bicameralism system.…

    • 3508 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The additional guard against tyranny was Separation of Powers which means the government was separated into different branches. The Constitution states that the Separation of powers were legislative, executive and judicial branches. Separation of power can defend against tyranny simply because there is 3 powers, not one; which does not make America have an absolute power.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The textbook talks about three different factors that played a role in how Congress has shifted from the textbook legislative process to an unorthodox legislative process. The three factors that causes the shift in the legislative process is the internal reforms in both of the chambers, the overall congressional budget process, and the political climax have really influenced the change in the legislative process. The first factor is the internal reforms of the chambers because the Senate and the House of Representatives made some kind of dramatic change in overall influence from the chambers. The Senate’s view were originally “unequally distributed” (Sinclair, 134) and that cause a lot of tension since most of the senior members were considered to be “predominantly conservative” (Sinclair, 134).…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    By ensuring that the legislature contains both equal and proportional representation and finding a way to give both the federal government and the individual states a voice through Dual Levels of Federalism, the United States Constitution manages to reconcile the varied interest groups, small states and big states, Localists and Federalists to form a more perfect union.…

    • 2487 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Senators represent an entire state, as members of the House of Representatives only represent districts, highlighting from the outset their different abilities to reach a broader spectrum of people, along with Senates being 1 of 100, and House members being 1 of 435. Therefore Senators have an easier avenue to implement their work, as a House representative has far less status, due to them being far denser in numbers a clear example of this is that of Bill Frist who in January 2003 became majority leader after only eight years in the Senate. While at the same time Representative Nancy Pelosi became House minority leader, but she had been a member in the house since 1987. This further highlights the ability of those with the senate to gain more status. Power within Congress is very much concentrated within committees, rather than that of the Chamber floor in question, which further highlights the Senates greater status, as Senators are far more likely to chair committees, which further heightens their status on Capitol Hill.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a perfect world, this would lead to effective representation for each state. Normally a bicameral congress issues an abundant say to both houses in deciding laws. Furthermore, the founders vied for this in efforts to smother and hinder any sort of dictatorships on U.S. soil.” Larger states wanted representation purely by population. Smaller states did not appreciate that method, because they felt it lessened their say. They would have minimal say in national government, and fewer representatives. A compromise was eventually agreed on every state would have two representatives in the Senate and have representatives based on population (the house).…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    One of these is the Virginia Plan, also called the Large State Plan, which advised that the representation in a bicameral legislature be proportional to property or population. The other is the New Jersey Plan, which called for equal representation for all states regardless to population in a unicameral legislature. Had the Virginia Plan been adopted entirely, large states would always have a dominant voice over the smaller states. On the other hand, if the New Jersey plan had been adopted entirely, bigger states with bigger needs would never prevail. When the delegates began to discuss this issue, they willingly agreed that a bicameral legislature is necessary for the new national government. They differed widely, however, in the representation of the two houses. Bitter debates followed until, finally, the compromise of equal representation in the House and proportional representation in the Senate was reached. In Henry Steele Commager 's article, "The Constitution, Was It an Economic Document?", he remarked that the framers "feared the powers of the majority, as they feared all power unless controlled" (141); the compromise of the representation of the houses underscores exactly this point because it prevents an absolute body majority which would prove to be fatal to the country had they had a malevolent intent. Furthermore, the compromise effectively appealed to all states and therefore…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    * Legislative Assemblies were formed out of the same principle of the British House of Commons.…

    • 430 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Originally, Congress would be seen as a 1 chamber with only a certain number of representatives per state. The debate was how many representatives should each state have and with this came up 2 plans. Delegates from the larger states came up and supported the Virginia plan which called for different number of representatives per state based on population. Delegates from smaller…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are also similarities between the two. For example, both houses are made up of men and women. Both houses work towards one big, main goal: to create, discuss, debate, and vote upon bills. Before the President can sign a bill into law, it must first receive a majority vote by both the Senate and the House of Representatives.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This Congress was in place not to be a permanent structure, but something that created the structure for the future. Assuming the role of the legislature, there was only one house of Congress, called a unicameral. While this Congress was in the process of forming the structure to run a country, it became necessary for a group to take control and make decision, but also allow the wills…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    We believe that the legislature have the most power in our society. Legislature is a branch of the government who are also often known as the legislative branch and the congress. The legislatures are most commonly known to be able to create laws. Laws are defined as a system of rules that regulate actions. The legislature has control over what the citizens can or cannot do. Some might say that the president also has control over the laws created because of the fact that in order for a law to pass, the president must write his signature of approval. This is true, however in reality; the president cannot stop a law from being created by the legislature. Why, because although the president can veto the legislature’s decision, the legislature can also return the favour and veto his decision. For example, if the legislature decided that marijuana should be legalized and the president refuses to sign his or her approval, the legislature can veto that decision and the law will pass. Countries are controlled by laws, not the president. The legislative is also the branch in the government that declares war. They have the sole power to decide whether war will happen or not. Not only does that, but the congress also regulate our military system. They have power over weapons that can destroy the world. Another reason why the legislature has the most power in our society is because they regulate and control money. They control the international commerce. They control the taxes. They can make the taxes skyrocket if they pass the bill. They can borrow money at their will. They have economic power. The legislation is made up from two very important parts in our government: the House of Commons and the Senate. The Senate examines the bills, and decide whether or not they will become laws. They can also make their own bills. No bill can become a law without the Senate approving it. Together with the House of Commons and also the queen, they become the Parliament of Canada. The…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Constitutional Letter

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I find the issue of representation is very important to the new system of government that is wanted to be set up. The way to determine the representation can have different approaches, whether it’s one or two houses, or representation based on population or equal. Without the right system, the states will not be represented correctly and it could become unfair to other states because they are either not powerful enough or neglected because of their size. The idea has been pitched of two houses and one is equal and the other is based on the contribution to the treasury. The many different ideas about how to represent seem endless but the right one must be chosen.…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, seat apportionment. In the Senate, there are twos seats for each state, giving us a total of 100 Senators, each will equal representation. In the Senate, each state carries the same amount of weight when it comes to making legislative decisions, thus making sure that smaller states always have a say in the matter. In the House, the number of seats that each state has is proportional to that state's population, leading to larger states have more representation. This leads to larger states like California and Texas pulling more weight for laws that benefit their own states rather than what is good for everyone.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays