This article was written by Loraine Gelsthorpe to ‘tease out Wacquant’s treatment of gender’ in his two books ‘Punishing the Poor’ and ‘Prisons in Poverty’ (Wacquant) Loraine takes a feminist approach towards Wacquant’s work and feels he needs to look into gender more. Agreeing with Loraine although Wacquant has written about the vulnerability of women in the regimes of workfare, he fails to understand how social policies escalate penal outcomes for women. Other contributions agree also, Peter Squires (2012) and John Lea (2012) state ‘Wacquant’s work does not consider gender in any detail’ and ‘does not trace the intricate ways that gender based differences play out in the contemporary world he analyses’
The books being critiqued by Loraine Gelsthorpe written by Loic Wacquant explaining his views on the neoliberal state as a ‘penal state’ which in Loraine’s eyes is full of young men, she wants to show that a lot less attention is shown to women, her argument here is that ‘the penal treatment of women is often indistinguishable from ‘welfare’ treatment’ (Gelsthorpe 2010)
Loraine feels very strongly about women and criminal justice, in other pieces of her work for example ‘saying it again, again and again’ she writes about sentencing women and states ‘women’s needs have to be recognised’(Gelsthorpe 2006) reading other work from her makes her ideology of the article very clear. The article Loraine is critiquing lacks greatly in what she is passionate about, Wacquant sees women as ‘recipients of the workfare programmes’ he also states they are ‘victims’ To make her point that Wacquant needs to look into gender she references many arguments to add to the existing body of knowledge. For example using Ann Orleff’s (2002) analysis on ‘gender sameness’ supports her argument by talking about equality between women and men’ Also work from Chesney-Lind (1995) has ‘drawn attention to the steep increases in women’s imprisonment in the USA’
Using ways to extend Wacquant’s work on gender in Loraine’s work shows strengths in her argument, Wacquant mainly talks about ‘prisonfare’ which is the unemployed sections of society, basically penalising poverty. By adding feminist criminologist work, the extra information on punitive outcomes for women allowed the audience to examine the trends on a greater gendered basis. It is also significant to today’s world where people especially feminists will want gender to be discussed as it is a key issue in today’s society. Compared to Wacquant’s thoughts where his analysis demonstrates that when’ considering the experience of offenders, there is no need to do this on a gendered basis’ (Squires) this shows a controversial view from both the authors.
In her conclusion Loraine does demonstrate some agreement with Wacquant’s work by saying it is a ‘refreshing read which makes reference to women.’ Wacquant’s issues in his work are significant however again, Loraine uses many devices to influence her audience, arguing against Wacquant she wants to look at ‘interrelationships with other discourses or moral tutelage’
Adopting a feminist approach against Wacquant’s neoliberalism approach helps the audience see the different treatments towards men and women by criminal justice agencies, this approach makes her ideological position appropriate to the topic she is critiquing, Loraine uses the chapter of ‘women, poverty and control in the UK’ to discuss the issue of gender, with references such as Millar (1992) writing about the ‘feminisation of poverty’ Gelsthorpe has been able to use research on female offenders to back up her argument on extending Wacquant’s account to the experience of women.
Many other writers have previously critiqued Wacquant’s work, for example Peter Squires (2012) and Compte Rendu (1996) they both believe that Wacquant’s work ‘makes a coherent and important argument’ (Rendu) but both feel his work has weaknesses, just as Loraine argues. Having previous work stating the same downfall Loraine’s thesis in her writing is strongly supported.
In conclusion, Loraine has taken an appropriate ideological position, using her feminist approach she has been able to critique Wacquant’s work well as gender was not his favourite topic. Wacquant did not as stated in the introduction, understand how social policies escalate penal outcomes for women. This argument has been proven throughout Loraine’s work. Agreeing with Loraine’s thesis she has used numerous references to add to Wacquant’s work. However Loraine does look at empirical work on diversion from the court for female offenders in other pieces of her work, adding this to her critique would give the audience an idea of real life stories on women, crime and control. references Wacquant, L (2009) ‘Punishing the Poor, The Neoliberal Government of social insecurity’’ Duke University Press: 2009
Rendu, C (1996) Punishing the Poor: ‘The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity’ Book review Canadian Journal of Sociology
Gelsthorpe, L. (2010) ‘counterblast: women and criminal justice: saying it again, again and again’ Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 2006.
Squires, P and Lea, J. (2012) ‘Criminalisation and advanced marginality’ Bristol: SAGE Publications
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the article by Kevin Johnson, talks about programs that inmates are able to use for when they leave prison. With a sixty-six percent chance of returning after being released from prison a program in Chino California that trains prisoners to be a deep sea divers in order to find a steady job after they are released. The prisoner’s normally find jobs with the oil company for fixing or cleaning the pipes which is a dangerous and physical job which naturally deters others people from working there. Due to the pay rate (50-100 thousand dollars a year) due to the job being dangerous most people do want to do it, most ex-convicts do not return to prison and lowers the chance of returning to six percent. Another program is at a women correction…
- 249 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Prisoners of the Andersonville prison camp often found that life in the prison has been much worse than on the battlefield. The prison was often unsanitary and overcrowded, which led to disease. Many prisoners who were once healthy, died because of disease or malnutrition. These prisoners were not in these camps for doing wrong, but for fighting in the war. Furthermore, the Andersonville prisoner was not only in prison for different reasons than people of today, but also had much harder lives to live.…
- 199 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The prison system is a topic that is widely debated. Many are either for or against how they are ran. Though I am only an observer; I have no ties to the prison system. I do agree with many points that Wilbert Rideau made in his original article.…
- 509 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
PD Penitentiary is a moderate security prison. At the PD Penitentiary our main goal is to rehabilitate troubled teens and young adults between the ages of 18 and 25. The PD penitentiary is a male penitentiary located on Douglas island, British Columbia. It offers psychological therapy to help tackle the root causes behind the crimes the committed, and to provide problem solving techniques to help cope with their development. It has been proven that the male mind is not fully developed until the age of 25, without a fully developed brain, males have difficulty making decisions and are more likely to make more negative than positive ones. By offering…
- 1061 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In recent years, the lawmakers and criminal justice experts have conveyed alarm regarding the growing prison population in elder prisons, along with the crumbling prison structures housing these inmates. While a majority of individuals agree this issue warrants immediate attention, the concurrence diminishes about how to attack this problem. A review of decisions set into place with laws, it has become clear that monetary confinements of elder prisons have become invisible barriers to the bargaining table. The paper compares the cost of renovating elder prisons…
- 2041 Words
- 9 Pages
Best Essays -
I believe that health care and safety are two significant changes that have occurred during the 20th century. We now have more advanced technology and more income coming into the prisons to provide efficient care for the inmate’s health issues or accidents that may occur within the facilities. Before the 20th century the death rate of inmates was extremely high, due to the fact of overcrowding and not having the means and resources to efficiently take care of any diseases, illnesses and wounds that passed through.…
- 322 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The growing rate of women in prison has spawned widespread awareness in our society; leading people to question why the percentage multiplied exponentially over the past three decades. In the past, female offenders have not only been compared to their male counterparts, but to society’s view on the role of women; the roles that labeled them as housewives and mothers. But how did these housewives and mothers go from the home to the prisons? The subject of women’s issues has sporadically been discussed in our society, and it has just recently being uncovered that women operate differently than men in situations; and those differences are now starting to effect the growth rate in the population of women in prisons.…
- 2738 Words
- 11 Pages
Best Essays -
Many may believe that Perry Smith shouldn’t be killed and given the punishment of life in prison. While others may believe the defendant will be able to evolve and reflect upon their decisions and will be able to evolve into a better person. But before you decide, you cannot forget that Perry Smith has been in prison in his past. Prison has become a prescription in which Smith has become immune to. The immoral individual you see here today is like a cancer, you need to kill it before it attacks those that surrounds it, and strengthens. The fact that Perry killed Kenyon, an innocent child, and his father, Herb Clutter, a child of God shows how prison only gives Smith time to plot his next scheme to murder. When Perry first went to prison, he was punished for larceny. Now we see him here today, on trial for the murder of the Clutter Family. Prison has made no impact on his virtue, but has…
- 435 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Life In Prison by Reilly was an exceptional read. The information was fairly recent; the last year he was a correctional officer was 2007. Reilly has been a correctional officer for a little over six years, during that time he worked at two different prisons; a prison in Pennsylvania and Maine State Prison. Both prisons are considered high security prisons. The demographics of both prisons included over 900 prisoners mostly males, ranging from 20 to 65 years of age, and varied racial backgrounds but predominantly African American. The crimes that inmates committed were all felonies, ranging from drug distribution to murderers.…
- 244 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The general argument made by author Pascal Emmanuel-Gobry in his work, “Abolish Prison”, is that prison is not the correct form of punishment for serious crimes. More specifically, Emmanuel-Gobry argues that prison makes the inmates behave worse due to the fact that they are deprived of desired luxuries, typical social interactions, and freedom. He writes, “The alternatives are actually countless, and all better. But it all depends on the kind of crime we’re talking about” (Emmanuel-Gobry 1). In this passage, Emmanuel-Gobry is suggesting that prison is the worst place to put criminals and any other option of rehabilitation would be better and more effective. In conclusion, Emmanuel-Gobry’s belief is that prison is not the…
- 286 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
With women only making up nine percent of all inmates in Canada; the lack of population results in enforcement to small provincial prisons.(WHO) These institutions are few and far away from many of the women’s homes. Also, the provincial prisons do not have the same upkeep as larger women only prisons, therefor this can lead to many negative results and experiences. The ignorance of female specific needs in prisons allow for failures in basic human rights creating unsanitary conditions, improper pregnancy protocol and cycles of sexual abuse.…
- 1431 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Towards the end of the 19th century, women could still not vote in general elections, nor become MP’s. Many men of all classes believed that women were the inferior sex and that it was wrong for women to be involved in politics, regardless of a woman’s education and academic abilities. It was these attitudes towards women’s rights that influenced groups such as the suffragettes and suffragists. There were many differences between the suffragettes and suffragists whereas they both shared the same goal; to achieve women’s suffrage in National Elections. However, unlike the suffragists, the suffragettes preferred to take militant action to gain publicity. It was the WSPU (Women’s Social and Political Union), founded by Emmeline Pankhurst in 1903, whose militant actions reflect what society was like between 1886-1914. Members of the WSPU would campaign at by-elections, disrupt political meetings and threaten public order by committing offenses such as breaking windows and chaining to railings. It was these actions which resulted in many women being arrested and sentenced to serve time in prison. It was in prison where many suffragettes would starve themselves; resulting in them being force fed by officers. This suggests that there weren’t significant improvements made to British society as for much of 1886-1914, women were being held down and brutally force fed against their will and continued to be unrepresented in society. In addition, the government introduced the Cat and Mouse Act in 1913 which allowed women to be released from prison if they became too weak due to a hunger strike. Despite this suggesting that the government were willing to improve the lives of the suffragettes, the act allowed women to be rearrested once they had regained strength. This suggests that there weren’t significant improvements made to British…
- 658 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
We make up a large amount of this country’s workforce and indeed it’s population, thereby we contribute largely to its wealth we deserve respect rather than insult. We need to change the view British society has of women. We are considered creatures of emotion and impulse and cannot decide questions on the grounds of reason like men could apparently, words of a man I’m sure my child. The women of this country were changing, they were becoming educated and started to challenge the preconceptions that society had of them. Women’s interests were not being addressed in politics, they were being neglected and women were becoming increasingly frustrated with the lack of advancement they were making. Women now had the skills, motivation and time to engage in politics. So along comes, the suffrage…
- 1624 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Sawer, M. 2006. “From Women’s Interests to Special Interests: Reframing Equality Claims” in Chappell, L and L. Hill (eds). The Politics of Women’s Interests. Routladge, Oxford…
- 4672 Words
- 19 Pages
Best Essays -
<br>Equal status for women of all races, classes, sexualities and abilities - in the 21st century these feminist claims for equality are generally accepted as reasonable principles in western society; yet the contradiction between this principle of equality and the demonstrable inequalities between the sexes that still exist exposes the continuing dominance of male privilege and values throughout society (patriarchy). This essay seeks to move beyond the irrepressible evidence for gender inequality and the division of labour. Rather, it poses the question of gender inequality as it manifests itself as an effect of patriarchy drawing from a theoretical body of work which has been developed so recently that it would have been impossible to write this essay thirty years ago.…
- 3181 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays