Preview

Brock Turner Case Study

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
393 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Brock Turner Case Study
I have a huge issue with the sentencing of Brock Turner, a former student of Stanford University. Turner was charged and convicted of three counts of felony sexual assault. He sexually assaulted a 22 year-old-woman who was unconscious and intoxicated behind a dumpster on the college campus. At the end, the judge sentenced turner to six months in a county jail and three years of probation. He also must register as a sex offender, and participate in a sex-offender treatment program. Turner is scheduled to be released tomorrow from a county jail – three months early for good behavior.
Turner is wrong ethically and morally – there is no question here. As for the judge who presided during the trial and the sentencing, however, is questionable. There is no recovering from sexual assault - the victim is emotionally and physically ruined for life. The offenders, on the other hand, often go free after a short sentence and commit the same crime again and again. I have seen many repeated sex offenders go in and out of the system twice sometime even more. To make the matter worse, most of the victims are young children. Some of the victims even grow up to be sex offenders themselves – it’s a vicious cycle.
…show more content…
Three months in jail out of possible six is just a slap on the wrist. While I understand that alcohol might have been a factor, the light sentencing gives future sex offenders an excuse to use in court. Ethical reasoning serves as an outline to evaluate human conducts by suggesting what is right and wrong, connoting commitment and duty that should be fulfilled in the society. (Paul & Elder, 2012) It’s a tool to evaluate behaviors that can impact others and in this case, Judge Persky clearly lacked ethical reasoning in this

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In June of 2013, Brandom Vandenburg and two other young males raped an “unconscious female student” at Vanderbilt University located in Nashville, Tennessee. At the time Vandenburg and the victim were dating, and he was a member of the Vanderbilt football team. Vandenburg took the victim into a dorm room, and with the help of three other teammates from the football team, they raped her. The case went to court where Vandenburg was charged “five counts of aggravated rape, two counts of aggravated sexual battery, and one count of unlawful photography.” Vandenburg blames his ignorance with alcohol for the reason why he raped his at the time girlfriend. The victim failed to be at the court hearing, but she send a written statement saying she hopes…

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adnan Syed's Case Study

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages

    On February 25, 2000 Adnan Syed’s world came crumbling down around him. Adnan was convicted to life plus thirty years for the murder of his high school ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee. Although Adnan was convicted, he is not guilty. The prosecution's case was shaky and was built around one witnesses constantly changing testimony. The witness was Jay Wilds, the neighbourhood drug dealer and a former schoolmate of Adnan’s. As well as the prosecution's main witness being unreliable, the cell phone tower data that they used to convict Adnan says on the cover sheet that the cell phone data from incoming calls can't be used to reliably and precisely locate a cell phone. Lastly, the autopsy report of Hae Min Lee showed fixed frontal lividity, the phenomenon…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ex-Brock Turner Case

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page

    In the September 6 issue of the LA Times, reporter Sarah Parvini published an article about a former rapist registering as a sex offender, and his sentence. Ex-Stanford swimmer, Brock Turner, was convicted of sexually assaulting a woman behind a dumpster. The woman was completely unconscious and due to this, he was charged with three felony counts: assault with the intent to commit rape of an unconscious person, sexual penetration of an unconscious person and sexual penetration of an intoxicated person. Turner originally faced 14 years and jail but got 6 months instead. He was later released 3 months earlier than his 6-month sentence because of good behavior. This article contains conflict, drama, and oddity. This story contains a man vs.…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adnan Syed Case Study

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Adnan Syed, 19, was convicted of murder fifteen years ago that placed him in prison for life. Mr. Syed, a Muslim, was charged with the murder of his ex girlfriend, Hae Min Lee, by strangling her and burying her body in Leakin Park. With this in mind, Adnan had a friend, Jay Wilds, who had assisted Adnan in the crime, but walked free out of his trial without having to serve any time in prison. Jay’s testimony of the crime had many inconsistencies that should’ve made him untrustworthy, but the jury still used his story as evidence to decide if Adnan is guilty of murder. Furthermore, the Serial podcast episodes, with Sarah Koenig as the narrator, involves Sarah reviewing the whole case of the crime as she also added many pieces of evidence from family and friends of Adnan and Hae, criminal detectors and the cops to try and discover the truth. The search for the truth without any clear details or information can make it very difficult to come to a conclusion. And after listening to all 12 Serial podcasts, I believe that Adnan deserves another trial, but it wouldn’t change the outcome from the first trial without more evidence.…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jesse Timmendequas was already convicted twice before the rape and murder of Megan Kanka. He was sentenced to ten years in the Adult Diagnostic and Treatment Center, a prison for sex offenders. After spending six years there, he was released early for good behavior. Timmendequas lived in a home that was owned by his mother with two other convicted sex offenders. Timmendequas invited Megan into his home he told her he had a puppy if she wanted to see him, when they got in his room, he tried to molest her, but Megan was screaming too loud, so he pushed her down to the floor and repeatly hit her in the head. After a few minutes he twisted a belt around her neck until she was unconscious.…

    • 2901 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Adnan Syed Case

    • 1626 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Adnan Syed is a convicted murderer and sentenced to life at the Baltimore Corrections Facility. The woman he murdered was a senior at Woodlawn High School, Hae Min Lee, who was also his ex-girlfriend. Hae Min Lee went missing after school on Friday, January 13, 1999. On February 9, 1999, her body was found in Leakin Park, a victim of manual strangulation. Fifteen years later her story was brought to Sarah Koenig by Adnan’s close family friend Rabia Chaudry, who thinks Adnan Syed was wrongfully convicted of the murder. Sarah began researching this case with her team and started a podcast called Serial, a twelve episode long series. In this series, Sarah addresses the background of the case, Adnan’s alibi and other information they had gathered…

    • 1626 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I believe it’s as wrong to not report a sexual assault just as much as its wrong to sexually assault someone, because not reporting it makes the perpetrators fearless of repeating their actions. Therefore, when you do not report the assault you are allowing it to happen to someone else in the future. Nevertheless, the victim is blamed for the rape or sexual assault sometimes, such as stated in the article; Justice Robin Camp once questioned a complainant in a 2014 case, “why she didn’t keep her legs closed.” We have judges who make such statements as if it is the victims fault for getting raped or sexually assaulted. I feel that the 17 women who did not file a complaint against Ghomeshi for his actions, are the type of people who cause these things to happen even more in our society because they do not take action immediately, so the police don’t know and can’t take action against people like Ghomeshi. Kathryn Borel dropped her charges against Ghomeshi for an apology. I believe that was a wrong action to take because it sets a bad example for all the other victims and woman in society. The article also briefly talks about Mustafa Ururyar’s case, where he was sentenced to jail for 18 months but got bail for appeal. The court allowing suspects bail for appeal on such serious issues does not help in reducing these type of crimes, consequently it makes other sexual assaulters not fear the law. In addition, the ending of the article is very important in my opinion, because it argues that no matter what situation the victim is in, it is not their fault they get raped or assaulted, because they never asked for…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Movie “ Sleepers” a story about four male friends who stole a hot dog cart, accidently rolled it down some subway steps and ended up crushing a man. All four friends end up going to a reformatory prison and got sexually assaulted by a guard there named Nokes. All four boys were traumatized by these horrible events that happened but two of the boys held anger and venedict. Years later, these two boys happened to see Nokes at a bar. They approached him where he was sitting, and they both shot him various times all over his body. The few people there that were in the same bar, testified what had happened but either way it went, both friends got not guilty. I personally think that the two defendants were morally incorrect in killing the guard Nokes because even though Nokes traumatized them so badly, that that might be all they ever think about - i think that taking a life is not justified and it is not the place of the victims to determine whether or not they are guilty, this is a matter for the court to decide. Even though in a greater chance of them not being able to, they could move on just like their other two friends that went through that also. They could be able to take a little bit of counseling and faith that they’ll forget the horrific events or maybe to just move forward from that time of their life. The rest of the other boys went into college and through this they probably got distracted and they didn’t really think about those prison times. The two boys probably still felt dirty inside that they just wanted revenge, because possibly just like them many more of the other prisoners there had gone through the same exact things as themselves, but revenge is not the answer. Under any circumstance i honestly feel that if someone is raped they are going to automatically want revenge of some type, the two boys were kind of “an eye for an eye, ear for an ear “kind of type of people, but with all the little boys that he obviously must have raped Nokes will…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “terrible person.” However, he’s or she could have just been 18 while their partner was 16 and then they were convicted. Males go through so much hate and judgment more than women if people found out they are a registered sex offender. People think their mindset is all about messing with kids, and how nasty they are. On the other hand women have a better chance of explaining themselves before the public gets to judging them. They get to explain into further details about the case, and why the verdict came to the decision, also and get to explain convince the people that it was a onetime thing and how it will never happen again. Everyone makes mistakes, but people believe that males are held to a higher standard and that they should know right from wrong, but women have the window to make as many…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Protect Yourself, Family from Sex Offenders,” Rick Schneider takes the position that sex offenders should be observed at all times (PA 657-658). One of the hardest and sensitive subjects to talk about is about sex offenders. In America it could go two ways, either the convicted is sent to jail and that isn’t even enough for the family that is suffering because of the convict’s actions. It is very difficult to discuss the problems with the results of a convicted sex offender’s life out of jail because in some states they are let go like wild animals and the government doesn’t hear from them again. Sex offenders are morally wrong and ill hearted people who are given a second chance and many argue that they should serve the longest prison sentence of all convicts. There must be impurities in a person’s heart if they truly find enjoyment in being a sex offender, the worst are child sex offenders, they are the worlds bottom of the…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Georgia Sex Offender Laws

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Georgia sex offenders laws are unfair and distorted in that they treat all sex offenders equally without considering the sex crime. This problem needs to be addressed because people who are not violent offenders are being treated as such by Georgia laws and Bills such as House Bill 1059.…

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Just the thought of having a child being molested by someone is outraging enough. But to actually find out that the offender has actually committed the same crime before is unbelievable. There have been a lot of stories where a child molester has been incarcerated and released from prison before serving a full prison sentence. In Tulsa two Police officers found Marcus Berry a known child molester truck and inside was a partially clothed two-year-old girl. Berry had been convicted before for the molestation of another child and was released early. (The News on 6). Once a child molester has committed a crime once they should without a doubt be put to death because they will commit the crime again. Under the measure signed by Gov. Brad Henry, anyone convicted twice for rape, sodomy or lewd molestation involving children under 14 can face the death penalty. (CNN).…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pallone states there was failure in the criminal justice system. He supports his facts by stating, “ Megan’s Law came to be , not only without legislative hearings on any of the several proposed bills but also without even a cursory reconstructive analysis of the chain of events that placed a twice-convicted sex offender at liberty without even the mild deterrence of parole supervision”. Pallone is trying to let people know that seven year old Megan kanka could be alive today if the criminal system would have taken on treatment for megan’s killer, instead of releasing him back to the community to inflict more pain to families. This is a good argument because Pallone describes how sex offenders can be released without the right tool to help reconstruct their character. He explains that with the proper treatment and well maintained behavior , a sex offender can make a remarkable recovery and return to society.…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though this happens to someone we often have to think about the other person and the fact there could be something wrong with them. A person convicted of a sex crime also will face penalties other than jail or prison. Sex offenders normally are required to undergo treatment either in jail or prison or as a condition of probation (Author.) The person that commits the crime could be just as hurt as he one that they did it to. And they have a right to get the help that they need no matter what they did. No matter what we always have to help someone no matter what they did. There could be something wrong with them and they could just need someone to talk to.…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    and is then released into the public to most likely prey again. Sure they have to register as sex offenders, but when is the last time you checked for sex offenders in your neighborhood? The numbers are astounding. It should be held in as high a regard as murder and the sentence should be life imprisonment or death. As a society we can not allow the opportunity for these heinous crimes to occur again. Our children are at stake. The seriousness of a crime should label the punishment. Our empathy as to what made these criminals become criminals can not be taken into account, because to do so endangers the lives of the innocent.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays