Critic’s View
Critics like John Chamberlain, Kenneth C. Kaufman, complained and showed their disappointment. Kaufman noted, “ Through her eyes we see, as through a peep hole, a gigantic stage where Titans play their destine roles and come to heroic ends. The effect, according to Carl Van Doren, in the New York Herald Tribune Books, was to create a domesticated novel. Obliged by her method to forego heroism at first hand, Van Doren …show more content…
The story begins in 1697, in the city of Quebec, Cather tries to bring to our eyes its inhabitants, values, ideals and beliefs that prevailed there. The people in the city struggled and tried hard to accept the transformation from the Old World to the New World. Cecile following her father, came to understand, that she has to prepare herself to be in France. Cather displays her mood in this novel, she had a great pain, because she lost her father and her mother ws also affected by stroke. In her letter published in “The Saturday Review of Literature” she asserted