Chapter 6 Case Study
Chapter 6
Case Study 1
Job Candidate Assessment Test Go Virtual 1. What do you think are the prime advantages and disadvantages of National City Corporation’s virtual tryouts?
The advantages of using virtual tryouts are competitive edge against other companies. Allows them to pick candidates better suited for their work environment, allows candidates the knowledge that they are applying for a company that is at the cutting edge of technology and they want to move forward with the times. Unfortunately there are also disadvantages associated with virtual tryouts. Employers may grab the interest of candidates, however if real day to day activities at work do not contain some of the aspects that the virtual test had, then employees will get uninterested and quit.
2. Do you think there would be any EEO concerns regarding this system?
I don’t think there would be any EEO issues with this system, otherwise it would not be offered in the market. However I do believe that this new system “Virtual Tryouts” is not necessarily right for all hiring aspects for every type of position/ company. There are aspects of a perfect employee to company match that a computer test cannot guarantee. Example, you can have a candidate that gets great results in the virtual tryouts given the situation that they are told to address, yet in the real day to day situation of the position they do not do very well, and vice-versa. 3. Would you suggest the company tailor its system for different types of candidates?
Yes, I recommend that the company tailor its system for the different types of positions and the different types of candidates required to fill those positions.
Chapter 8
Case Study
Appraising Employees at the San Diego Zoo. 1. Do you think the San Diego Zoo’s old appraisal system needed to be changed?
I think it needed to be changed because before they weren’t taking it seriously and it was a low priority to
Case Study 1
Job Candidate Assessment Test Go Virtual 1. What do you think are the prime advantages and disadvantages of National City Corporation’s virtual tryouts?
The advantages of using virtual tryouts are competitive edge against other companies. Allows them to pick candidates better suited for their work environment, allows candidates the knowledge that they are applying for a company that is at the cutting edge of technology and they want to move forward with the times. Unfortunately there are also disadvantages associated with virtual tryouts. Employers may grab the interest of candidates, however if real day to day activities at work do not contain some of the aspects that the virtual test had, then employees will get uninterested and quit.
2. Do you think there would be any EEO concerns regarding this system?
I don’t think there would be any EEO issues with this system, otherwise it would not be offered in the market. However I do believe that this new system “Virtual Tryouts” is not necessarily right for all hiring aspects for every type of position/ company. There are aspects of a perfect employee to company match that a computer test cannot guarantee. Example, you can have a candidate that gets great results in the virtual tryouts given the situation that they are told to address, yet in the real day to day situation of the position they do not do very well, and vice-versa. 3. Would you suggest the company tailor its system for different types of candidates?
Yes, I recommend that the company tailor its system for the different types of positions and the different types of candidates required to fill those positions.
Chapter 8
Case Study
Appraising Employees at the San Diego Zoo. 1. Do you think the San Diego Zoo’s old appraisal system needed to be changed?
I think it needed to be changed because before they weren’t taking it seriously and it was a low priority to