Preview

Class in America

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
480 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Class in America
Class in America ---2006 page 319

1. (1)Myth1 : “ The United State is fundamentally a classless society” and “ class distinctions are largely irrelevant today” are wrong. Myth2 : “We are, essentially, a middle-class nation” and “ most Americans have achieved relative affluence in what is widely recognized as a consumer society.” are wrong. Myth3: “ We are all getting richer.” and “ each generation propels itself to greater economic well-being.” are wrong. Myth4: “ Everyone has an equal chance to succeed.” and “ In America, anyone can become a millionaire.” are wrong. He provided specific percentages in the middle rage of the economic spectrum. Also, he said the gap between rich and poor and between rich and the middle class is larger than it has ever been. Different class affects more than life-style and material well-being. Class standing has a significant impact on our chances for survival. He used some specific percentages and numbers to provide his opinion, also, he gave the average combined scores by income. These real number would prove his opinions.
2. Yes. the essay make a case that the wealthy are exploiting the poor. For example, the author stated that the wealthiest 1 percent of the American population holds 34 percent of the total national wealth. That is, they own over one-third of all the consumer durables and financial assets. The richest 20 percent of Americans hold nearly 85 percent of the total household wealth in the country. Another example, the author said that approximately 183,000 Americans, or approximately three-quarters of 1 percent of the adult population, earn more than $1 million annually. There are nearly 400 billionaires in the U.S. Today, more than three dozen of them worth more than $10 billion each. It would take the average American a total of 28,033 years to earn just $1 billion. In my opinion, from these number, it can proved that poor people have very little chance to be rich.
3. I think it is too

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Families in the bottom 50% of income distribution made up only 10% of the Princeton freshman class in 1997, and just 8% of Yale freshman were first generation students in 2001 (Karabel 537). This should worry those that believe that the American dream is still alive. Because if it is—if people are rewarded based on their talents—wouldn’t these statistics suggest that there is something inherent and genetic about merit? This type of conjecture would rouse indignant anger in most, but is nevertheless what the system we subscribe to implies. The majority of Americans believe that we have equal opportunities to get ahead and only 27% favor sanctioned minimum standard of living (Karabel 556).…

    • 1663 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Gregory Mantsios’s essay, “Class in America” he discusses his point of view on social classes in America and the impact it has on people. Mantsios pulls information from a number of different sources. He looks at differences in wealth distribution. He discusses the health concerns. He then looks at educational success, and the correlation between social class and better economic success. He claims that, “we mistakenly hold a set of beliefs that obscure the reality of class differences and their impact on people’s lives.” (698). Gregory Mantsios succeeds at proving his claim because of the amount of evidence he presents.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay of "Class in America-2003" by, Gregory Mantsios is basically about the rich and the poor of America. In Mantsios essay he talks about upper class, middle class, and lower class Americans. The most common clad the Gregory Mantsios talks about is the middle class. The reason middle class Americans are talked about so much in this essay is because; the majority of the American population is middle class people. Mantsios discuses a few points o how…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Does the old saying still stand as of today? Is America still the land of opportunity to become successful financially and mentally? Whether it be empty-handed immigrants or people born into poverty and burdened lives; they have nothing more than a mere picture of themselves living the American dream someday as long as they are “persistent in working hard.” The American culture has lead us to believe we can achieve what America has outlined as success; but the ones who say we can achieve financial achievement, despite our initial state, are the luxurious one percent, who are the result of unequal distribution. If people in America are supposed to be equal, then why is there unequal distribution?…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In The Working Poor Shipler goes on to explain both of the myths. Shipler states that the American Myth “still supposes that any individual from the humblest origins can climb to well-being” (Shipler, pg.5), but the thing is that is not true because, there are many people who are humble that work hard and don’t go from rag to riches. The American myth has a demanding standard for both the nation and every resident that the nation” has to strive to make itself the fabled land of opportunity; the resident must strive to use that opportunity” (Shipler, pg.5). Not only that but the American myth also provides a means for laying blame; “if a person’s diligent work leads to prosperity(…) and anyone in society can attain prosperity through work, then the failure to do so is a fall from righteousness” (Shipler, pg.6). George W. Bush also gave a voice to the myth weather he meant it or not that “people who work hard and make the right decision in life can achieve anything they want in America” (Shipler, pg.5), but when we examine examples in this book there are many of those who work hard in America but are hit with the circumstances of life and they fail or they are unable to achieve what they want in America; the land of prosperity for all.…

    • 1506 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Gregory Mantsios’s article, Class in America he says, "The lower one's class standing, the more difficult it is to secure appropriate housing, the more time is spent on the routine tasks of everyday life, the greater is the percentage of income that goes to pay for food and other basic necessities, and the greater is the likelihood of crime victimization. Class can accurately predict chances for both survival and success. " Mantsios also argues that while most Americans, both rich and poor, are keenly aware of class differences, "Class is not discussed or debated in public because class identity has been stripped from popular culture. The institutions that shape mass culture and define the parameters of public debate have avoided class issues.…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is shown in the article “What is The Great Gatsby Curve?” by David Vandivier when he talks about the Great Gatsby Curve and predictions for success and wealth for people in America. In the article it talks about how the rich have more of an advantage and opportunities than the poor, but just because they have more resources and advantages doesn’t mean that poor people can’t obtain wealth. There are many things out there to help the poor and middle class have a sustainable life in society and to reach their dreams. Opportunities have advanced because “President Obama has advanced a number of policies to give greater opportunity for the middle class and those striving to join the middle class” (Vandivier). The president proposed for high-quality preschool regardless of family background, and to raise the minimum wage to $9 per hour. Also there are programs out there such as affordable care act, programs that provide food stamps, support for unstable families, free education from elementary school to high school, because of this there are opportunities which can help the poor reach success and wealth. Although it’s a given that “Children of wealthy parents already have much more access to opportunities to succeed than children of poor families” (Vandivier) but opportunities help poor families reach wealth, but it will definitely but harder for them than the…

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aldous Huxley wrote the book Brave New World in hoping to create an alternate society showing that utopia’s can have dystopia aspects. One of those aspects are class distinction where people are classed before they are born and are labeled as specific and robot-like people. Another aspect is the use of drugs and how it is oftenly used to persuade people into thinking the way the government thinks and a third aspect is consumerism where people are constantly consuming products and rules and the way other people are living their life so you feel like you should follow their lead. In today’s society, class distinction is also used, it is used to separate different levels of intelligence and resources, it is used to have a lifestyle that fits…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book Money and Class in America, Lewis Lapham claims that American culture idolizes the wealthy, believing that wealth is necessarily belied by quality of character and wisdom. He gives both cross-cultural and cross-historical examples to show that other cultures and at other times the highest esteem was given not only to the wealthy, but also to the intellectual, the powerful, and the artistic individuals of those societies. In contrast Lapham discusses Americans’ idolization of the wealthy, as well as their conflation of wealth and individual merit and worth. He then questions if Americans -- a supposedly egalitarian people who are all created equal. Nonetheless, this cult of wealth still pervades, though seemingly there is nothing to cause it, as similar nations are not afflicted by such an absurd ardor.…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Class In America Summary

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Myth 2 states we are a middle class nation. Maybe that was a true statement 30 or 40 years ago, but not in 2010. It really feels like we do not even have a middle class. You are either rich or poor in today’s economy. People barely making it or living large. I know I am not living large. I really like the statement Montsios makes “ America has the best dressed poverty the world has ever known”. Myth 3 states “We are all getting richer”. I want to know who we are? It feels as a whole we are just getting by from year to year. Then again, I am not wealthy. I am curious on what their thoughts are about the economy? We do have Americans getting richer like Actors, Sports figures, Politian’s, Lawyers and Doctors. These are just some examples I came up with. But to say all Americans are getting richer is ridiculous. I feel as Americans we are all getting poorer. Myth 4 states “Everyone has a chance to succeed in America”. I really feel that this is a true statement. Does everyone succeed in America? No. But I feel we all have that chance living in America. In my reading I find Montsios point regarding class in America is that we as a whole do not like to talk about class. It…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Money and Class

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The observations made by Lewis Lapham's Money and Class in America distinguishes the meaning of success and the required level for respect for Americans to that of other strong societies. In his supposed defense of the popular opinion that America is a place that wrongfully shows respect to those of higher economic class than other nations that hold art and intellect at a pedestal. With this, he agrees with Henry Adams that Americans are ignorantly herded to find "success" in the materialistic wealth because they have been "deflected by the pursuit of money". Though the idea that Americans favor and respect superficial matters is held true, Lapham's claim that they do so because they are socially forced to is invalid simply because there is still a choice. As shown through his contradictions in the essay, and the many artistic and intellectual American successes, it makes the average materialistic American too idle in their comfort to search for the other direction that they are so "deflected" from, which he denies.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Claim 2: The belief instilled by a consumerist society that one's monetary value is directly proportionate to their happiness in life forces people to experience the disappointment of realizing the American Dream is a myth; that their dreams can never be realized.…

    • 127 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Granting to the authors of They Say / I Say, "income for the wealthiest Americans has increased while the center and lower incomes have remained stagnant". Today, middle class incomes have stayed still and millions have not reached the so-called American Dream. A recent issue of The Economist captures how far the illusion has become a reality. Summarizing a series of works, the article shows that the gap is larger than was ever imagined and set forth to widen in the 1980s.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Contemporary class analysis must embrace the study of a wider range of social relationships than just those located within the sphere of work and production. Patterns of consumption and the lifestyles and opportunities that they facilitate have become particularly important in understanding the divisons and inequality on which the system of stratification is based in modern industrial societies.…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As said in the Huffington post, to be an American is synonymous with the dream (Frost). This exemplifies that although we all want the dream to be in our favor once we reach upwards mobility, we do not seek the same for others. Grey Mater from New York times editorial wrote that “the idea that any American, with enough resolve and determination, can climb the economic ladder, regardless of where they start in life implies false advermation.” This was written opinionated towards whether economic equality is the matter of choice. Regardless whether the dream brings up falsification it shows attributes that those who believe that upward mobility can be achieved through working hard is an allusion that covers up the suffering that undergoes to achieve a financially stable…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays