Preview

Cleopatra and Anthony

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1103 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Cleopatra and Anthony
What does this passage suggest about the relationship between Cleopatra and Antony? Compare this with how the relationship is portrayed in the other written source material from the classical period in Book 1, Chapter 1.

The relationship portrayed in the extract, between Anthony and Cleopatra seems at first to be one sided. Anthony is depicted as an ‘insensitive brute with a heart of stone’ in comparison to Cleopatra who is ‘utterly devoted to him alone’. This show of devotion is a continuous theme in the passage and is further illustrated by the fact that she ‘was content to be called his mistress’ whilst she was the ‘sovereign of many nations’ unlike his wife who married Anthony out of political convenience. References are made to that idea that Anthony’s refusal of Cleopatra ‘would be the death of her’ further illustrates this. Later in the passage Anthony is shown to have been ‘melted and unmanned’ by this show of affection and that ‘he began to believe that she would take her own life’. This is shown to be true by that fact that he ‘returned to Alexandria and put off his Median expedition’ even though this would have a detrimental effect on his military activities in Parthia which ‘was said to be greatly weakened by internal dissensions’. This seems to show that although Anthony had many pressing issues to contend with he was willing to put the issue of Cleopatra’s well being before personal gain and return to be by her side.

In comparison to other written material concerning Anthony and Cleopatra’s relationship the first extract focuses on personal feelings and their romantic relationship which is implied to be reciprocated by both parties. Plutarch shows the relationship in an entirely different light, in which Anthony is bewitched by Cleopatra. Anthony is ‘excited to the point of madness’ and his ‘many passions which had hitherto lain concealed’ were drawn out of him implying that Cleopatra was a corrupting influence. Any redeeming qualities



References: Look carefully at Plate 1.3.5, Paul Cézanne, Bathers (c.1894–1906), and Plate 1.3.6, Palma Vecchio, Bathing Nymphs (c.1525/8), in the Illustration Book. Discuss what you think are the most significant differences between the two paintings.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    It is very obvious when reading both passages that whilst Plutarch and Octavian had similar but also differing opinions about Mark Anthony and his relationship with Cleopatra, they are both guilty of putting their own negative spin on the situation. They both use different approaches to the subject but the end result is the same. Anthony is portrayed as a man who has lost his way and in doing so, has sunk to the lowest levels of society .The one thing they both agree on, is that Cleopatra had a very negative effect on Anthony and is responsible for his decline. To answer the above question we need to explore the relationship between Anthony and Cleopatra in more detail, to understand why Octavian and Plutarch had formed such negative opinions in the first place.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    * Cleopatra was a very complicated character… she had volatile and tempestuous relationships with both mark Anthony and Julius Caesar , which eventually led to the deaths of Cleopatra and mark Anthony by suicide.…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    AA100 TMA01

    • 506 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Cleopatra is shown on film as an almost caring being and an intelligent woman. In the 1934 production, Cleopatra tells Antony as she kisses his hand “I am no longer Queen, I am a woman.” This suggests that in that particular moment, she is allowing her emotions to rule, perhaps even going as far to say that as a Queen she is quite a stony and hard character, but as an ordinary woman, she is allowing herself to love.…

    • 506 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    aa1oo

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It’s almost immediately clear from this passage that Plutarch believed Antony to be a prisoner in the relationship. He was kept in “constant tutelage” and Cleopatra “released him neither night nor day.” Tutelage meaning “protection of, or authority over, someone or something”  (http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/tutelage?view=uk – Accessed 6th November 2008) - these validations are great but it would be even better if you put them in a bibliography and had a reference here – it would also reduce your word count, makes it clear this is not a relationship of mutual love. Antony is rarely allowed out of Cleopatra’s sight. She did everything with him: “She played at dice…of a serving maiden.” – this quote is unclear, you need more of it in order to make sense She joined in on all activities that he did, despite how debasing they might be to a Queen. But isn’t the emphasis on how much more debasing they were to an ‘Imperator’ ? Although this might have been an act of love, Plutarch portrays it as something that stems from Cleopatra’s obsessive need to be with Antony and watch him constantly. Plutarch re-iterates his view that Antony is a prisoner, not a lover.  Is this linked to the disapproval of romantic love as discussed in Book 1 p 11 ?…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cleopatra Leader

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Cleopatra VII was a remarkably intelligent woman with great charisma and political astuteness. The ancient historian, Plutarch, stated that “to know her was to be touched with an irresistible charm. Her delightful manner of speaking was such as to win the heart.” (Bradford 14). She utilized these assets to win over the favor of two of the most powerful man of Ancient Rome, Julius Caesar and Marc Antony. Cleopatra is portrayed as being manipulative, conniving; and accused of utilizing her relationships for the advancement for power and the expansion of her empire. Although this is true, there were stark differences in the two relationships Cleopatra had with each man. She reached out to Caesar in her time of no power and continued to be submissive to him throughout their relationship. Even though there was a speculated love connection between the two, Caesar never lost sight of his priority as a politician and did not concede to every one of his mistresses’ requests. While a reversal of roles occurred with Marc Antony, she had the upper hand and he eventually became fiscally and emotionally dependent on her. In addition, he was easily manipulated, thus Cleopatra frequently got her way. Overall, the territorial gain and the power she had over him proved that Cleopatra’s relationship with Marc Antony was more politically beneficial than with Julius Caesar.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Importance Of Cleopatra

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages

    During the spring of 51 BC Auletes died and declared Cleopatra (now 18yrs) would wed her brother Ptolemy XIII (now 10yrs) and rule together. Cleopatra wanted to plan a way to eliminate her brother from power. The first two years of Cleopatra’s reigning, the Nile did not flood and Alexandra civilisation was deteriorating from the famine. This rooted a rebellion amongst society holding Cleopatra responsible and also she had her brother trying to eradicate her. She then left for Syria and compiled an army to return to Egypt and restore her position on the throne. Cleopatra realised that with the help of Caesar (Roman support) she would more likely repossess her position. Both Caesar and Cleopatra were intent to use the other. Caesar desired the repayment of Auletes’s debt and Cleopatra was insistent on regaining the throne. They later became lovers and spent the winter surrounded by forces in Alexandria. The following Spring Roman reinforcement arrived and Ptolemy XII had tried to skip town but drowned in the Nile. Cleopatra got married to her brother Ptolemy XIV and regained her…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Julius and Caesar

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages

    So basically Julius Caesar is a huge character in which people looked upon on. Except the conspirators whom wanted him gone. They tried to avoid him from the beginning to not cause the death of him. But as time came and they noticed how everyone wanted him as their king. They became jealous of him. Let’s get to know who the conspirators are and why they did this to Julius Caesar. Was it for jealousy, anger, or was it for something that no one knows.…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Images and interpretations of a person can change over time. Such movement is paralleled with changes in opinion and morals throughout generations. Cleopatra the seventh is subject to this fluctuation. Ancient images and interpretations differ greatly to the impression left today merely by her name. Chris Dumasis, a modern day historian amplifies this theory in ‘Interpretations of Cleopatra’. She argues, “women have been demeaned of their true substance since the early time of patriarchal society.” Taken into account, this argument entails that when studying ancient sources it must be understood that at times, only a very narrow view of the events are presented in history. Cleopatra is a victim of this view. Roman and Latin interpretations are extremely one sided and are the few ancient sources of her that remain today. But they do not count for the entire story, as they were only two of the few literate societies at the time. As a result, the true image of Cleopatra may have been suffocated for centuries, only capably of being fully appreciated by modern day images and interpretations of her.…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Julius Caesar

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages

    •Antony is looked upon as an irresponsible kid who likes to attend plays and go out at night. He was Caesar's loyal assistant. That Antony loved Caesar there is no doubt. There is, however, ample evidence that Antony was the "sleek-headed man" of whom Caesar warns in Act I. His oration at Caesar's funeral was more than an attempt to avenge Caesar's death. It was a power grab. Antony speaks of Caesar's will. During the civil war that follows, he changes the will. Antony ruthlessly orders the murder of hundreds of citizens.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This tragedy, “Antony and Cleopatra”, written by William Shakespeare, was first printed in 1623. The title itself already announces some information: first of all, that these two are great characters; one is a Roman triumvir, the other is the most famous queen of Egypt. The second main information is the duality, which announces a great theatrical theme and the variations between a duel and a duo. Having previously defeated Caesar in a land battle, Antony is again defeated at sea. He blames Cleopatra. Because the play’s dramatic structure suggests that the battle in Act IV will be climactic and probably result in Antony’s death, Antony’s victory in these scenes is surprising and makes the plot much less predictable. After Antony’s flight from battle in Act III, and after Cleopatra’s apparent willingness to betray her lover, all seems lost for them. Indeed, the opening scenes of Act IV confirm and build upon this impression.…

    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is obvious that Atia was in love with Antony because she stated that she could perhaps love him. She is an example of this desire that Fantham explains that women began to have, however, it is not the celebration of love and marriage that is explained in chapter ten. Although it is not exactly what is stated to be characteristics of this model, it is a mixture of the model as well as previous beliefs of love and sex. Antony’s laughter towards the silliness of the love that Atia was professing is an example of previous beliefs. Although Atia does have the satisfaction of indulging in this fantasy, in the end she is still slapped physically and emotionally in the face. This rejection she received was not only a rejection, but a representation that in the end, Antony was still in charge. The reason why Antony was still in charge was because in the end, she was the one offering, and he had the power from the beginning of accepting or rejecting her. He was still the one who had the power, because if it were completely like the poems of this new behavior of love, Atia would be the one choosing-not Antony. Previous beliefs of sexuality were explained by McGinn’s book, “Prostitution, Sexuality, and the Law in Ancient Rome”, where he explains how a woman disgraced through conviction under law as a prostitute had that label everywhere she went through the toga- a symbol and badge of shame (p.339). Nonetheless, women’s sexuality and the actions she took could quickly escalate to harsh consequences if she did not follow society’s norms and this new model was one that was very different. In the end, it was an interesting example of the complexity that can come with this, as the scene had aspects of heterosexual love, as well as previous beliefs related to…

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Portia and Brutus

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In our scene Portia presents the classic wife, worrying for her husband’s health of body and of mind. This is the first and only time that Portia is seen in Julius Ceasar. This is pretty important, because it doesn’t allow our view of her to change, therefore, everything she says can be taken at face value. We first hear of her saying “Brutus, my lord!” Which shows the interesting factor of subservience of women, in Ancient Roman times. Portia, in her next line, which is basically a monologue, proceeds to ask Brutus what is wrong with him. “Make me acquainted with your cause of grief.” This extremely long monologue is a good way of showing Shakespeare’s “above the iceberg” writing style. She is somewhat offended that Brutus seems to have put her off in the past couple of days when she asked what was troubling him. “And when I ask’d you what the matter was,” … “But, with an angry wafture of your hand, gave me sign to leave you, so I did.” Cleary she is mad that she isn’t being told of Brutus’s problem. Like any wife, when she feels that she isn’t being kept fully in the flow of things, she brings up the marriage thing. “Within the bond of marriage, Brutus, tell me.” Then naturally if she doesn’t get what she wants she gets all offended. “Portia is Brutus’s harlot, not his wife.” She also shows that she is very devoted to Brutus by stabbing her thigh and not getting any treatment to show that she could keep a secret. “Giving myself a voluntary wound. Here, in the thigh: can I bear that with patience.” Overall I have a positive view of Portia. She is a devoted wife, who expects to be included in her partners life, like any good spouse. Plus she proves that she can hold Brutus’s secrets with the thigh thing. Unfortunately, we hear about her killing herself later in the…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The behaviour of Cleopatra and Antony described in the extract such as “she was saluted by him as ‘queen’ and ‘mistress’” or she “rode with him on horseback even in the cities or else was carried in a litter, while Antony followed on foot” brings no doubt that he, Dio, believed that Cleopatra enslaved Antony and this relationship was fatal to Antony’s rulership over Rome.…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Eutropian Translation

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages

    You may use William Whitaker’s Words as a resource to help you with unknown vocabulary. Do NOT use Google Translate or any other online translator!…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary of All for love

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Act II: Cleopatra complains to Alexas and Irasthat Antony is going to leave her: he refuses to come see her before he goes to war. Iras encourages Cleo. to…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics