Preview

Comparison Of A River Runs Through It And Montana 1948

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
425 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison Of A River Runs Through It And Montana 1948
Imagine to live in Montana - quiet, beautiful place, to spend your childhood playing outdoors, going fishing and just enjoying the wildness of Montana. The book Montana 1948 by Larry Watson and the film A River Runs Through It by Robert Redford have many similarities. Settings, characters and problems they have are only few of the many common things the book and the film share. The most general similarity is the setting where the both works take place in, and the time when it is happening. Also the main characters from both works have a lot in common. And the racism, it was showed in both works, the prejudices towards American Indians.
The both works take place in Montana in the first part of the 20th century. The book Montana 1948, as the title of it shows, is about the time period in 1948, but the events in the film are mostly in 1926. ‘’The harshness of the land and the flattening effect of wind and endless sky’’ (16) characterizes Bentrock - small town in Montana where the characters from Montana 1948 live. Other small town in Montana - Missoula, ‘’a world with dew still on it’’, is the place where the film’s characters are located.
…show more content…
Wes and Frank in Montana 1948; Norman and Paul in A River Runs Through It. Wes and Norman are the older brother in these both works. They have a couple of similarities, for instance, they both are sober and have serious attitude towards work. The younger brothers in these works - Frank and Paul - also have few things in common. For example, both got into trouble, got arrested and died in the end. However, the problems they had were not so similar. Paul liked to drink, and he gambled a lot, where Frank did more serious crimes - he abused American Indian

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Have you ever read a book, then watched the movie on it and wanted to throw the book at the director’s face and tell them to actually read the book? This is what happened when I read a novel titled Where The Rivers Flow North by Howard Frank Mosher, and then watched the movie on it. In 1927, in Kingdom County, Vermont, a large dam is to be built; however, Noel Lord, a logger and cedar-oil harvester, won't give up his lifetime lease on the land. The dam company increases its offer of cash, but Noel refuses time after time. He asks for a trade; the white pines for his lease. Noel, meanwhile, talks with his wife, Bangor, about them moving to Oregon and buying a saw mill. She wants him to take the company's money; but he’s stubborn. His stubbornness is what ultimately leads them to their death, causing them both to be victims. Yet in the movie, only one of them meets with their untimely death. Between the book and the movie, three major differences were Noel’s death scene, Bangor’s death, the showing of the panther and Noel becoming a legend and story to tell just like his ancestors. I’m not satisfied with these differences because they don’t portray the book accurately. These key differences can really impact ones thoughts on both the book and the movie and the way one feels about how the director and producers of the movie chose to represent the book.…

    • 1007 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Blazing Saddles review

    • 2065 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The movie takes place in two main locations, the little town of Rock Ridge and the capital where the governor resides. There is a railroad that is being built but it ran into an area of quicksand and now needs a new route. That new route that the railroad needs to take is right through the little all-white frontier town of Rock Ridge. Rock Ridge is full of simple townsfolk who all have the last name of Johnson, which exemplifies the homogeneity of the town. It shows the townsfolk in church and they are discussing the troubles that have been happening in the town, to which they decide they need to wire the governor for a new one since the last one they had was murdered.…

    • 2065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The first similarity was that in both their were taverns. They had forests and that's how they make the taverns, farms, and homes. Also, speaking of homes the other similarities are their prisons.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both of these stories take place along the Hudson River, past NYC. In both of the works, within the first few sentences, it even mentions the words “river Hudson,” which helps us to picture where in America both of these stories supposedly have taken place. The difference about the location within each of these plots is that one is on the eastern side of the river, while the other on the western side. In RVW, the story seems to hint that the story is taking place BEFORE the revolutionary war while LSH seems to take place AFTER the same war. In LSH, it was stated that the closest town was that of Terrytown, and in RVW, no close town was ever mentioned. LSH never seems to have much going on within the town itself. The town is pretty relaxed and nothing ever interesting happens within it. In RVW it seems like the town is that of a working class town. It is hinted that RVW even had some farmland where he lived.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I believe that the book and the movie version of Our America have more differences than similarities because there were a lot of things that were different. For example, in the book the story of how 5 year old Eric Morse got dropped out of the 14th floor window was different from the story in the movie. In the movie it…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Colorado River is one of the biggest rivers in the U.S. that isn’t connected to the Mississippi River. The Colorado river runs through the Grand Canyon. It helped form the Grand Canyon. The Colorado River is 1,450 miles long and runs through seven states. Wyoming Colorado, Utah, New Mexico, Nevada, Arizona, and California. For 17 miles the Colorado river forms the boundary between Mexico and Arizona. The Colorado River starts at La Poudre Pass Lake. The Colorado river ends at the Gulf of California.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Flowing in two directions, east and south, for 2,341 miles (3.767 km), North America’s longest river, the Missouri River, is a gem of natural resources and a vital transportation pathway. Nicknamed the “Big Muddy” because of its silt material, the river begins at the confluence of the Madison, Jefferson, and Gallatin Rivers in the Rocky Mountains of western Montana, and meanders through mountainous canyons and from bluff to bluff across the Great Plains.…

    • 298 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    "The Hawk Is Hungry" is about a guy living in the rural areas of Montana and trying to convince his younger sister, Anne Elizabeth, to move to his ranch in Montana and live with him. The only problem he had was that he wasn't sure himself if West was the right place to live. "My sister had come to spend the summer at my Montana ranch. It was a long ten years since I had seen her, I was fond of her, and I was hoping to keep her in the West. I wasn't subtle about it. I was bragging shamelessly about…

    • 1401 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Racism is an underlying force in the Novel Montana 1948, written by Larry Watson. The racist attitudes shown towards the Indians in Bentrock escalate to a point where a catastrophe overtakes the Hayden Family. In the town Bentrock in 1948, it was accustomed that racial attitudes towards the Indians were apart of the culture and nature of the town. Marie Little Soldier’s confession about Frank’s antics could prove to be a vital point when all the secrets started to unravel and eventually contributed to the catastrophe that took over the Hayden family. Gail Hayden, David’s mother, comes from a completely different region with different customs and morals. She sees the racial slurs towards Indians from a different perspective and slowly unravels the true nature of how Indians are being treated, especially Frank’s crimes. The arrogant nature and racist attitudes shown by the Hayden family also eventually boils over to a point where everything collapses. Watson shows how a small town like Bentrock can suddenly turn into a dystopia where power, corruption and racism is the root of all evil.…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A River Runs Through It by Norman Maclean is about the bond between brothers, and more generally the bond between family. It showcases many events that support the idea of this bond. The story allows for many different themes to be conveyed. The main theme of the story however, is the idea that family is everything; it can be supported by the way Norman tries to help Paul, by the way Jessie blames Norman for her brother, and by the way Norman goes along with Paul.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When you compare the two books they have a very similar tone. Though the locations different they still connect through the same tone. Phoenix Jackson is on a trail walking to town to buy some medicine for her Grandson, while Miss Emily is locked up in her house with a dead man. If you were to not focus as much on the location and put your attention to their state of mind then you can see that they are in the same atmosphere. The…

    • 809 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Colorado River

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Threats to river and delta: Water flow is decreasing. This water serves 30 million people in seven U.S. states and Mexico, with 70 percent of its water siphoned off to irrigate 3.5 million acres of cropland. Possible actions between the United States and Mexico could significantly reduce the flow of water into the delta, increase its salinity, and alter the natural vegetation. Drought has lowered water levels in upstream reservoirs, eliminating the occasional floods the delta needs to maintain and extend the partial recovery of the 1980s and 1990s. The drought has left the Southwest grasping for water. South of Yuma, where the river forms a 23-mile boundary between the United States and Mexico, the International Boundary and Water Commission is considering proposals to straighten the channel and plan for a flood flow of 140,000 cub feet per second. Digging a channel capable of containing that flood level would require removing cottonwoods, willows, and other vegetation from both sides of the river. If this happens, as much as 500 acres of vegetation might be lost. Digging the channels would destroy the richest natural area along the river. The Mesa de Andrade Marshes is home to 75 species of birds, while also providing a lot of greenery amongst the Sonoran Desert. These marshes are not fed by Mexican water though. The water comes from leaking, unlined portions of the All- American Canal in the U.S. It carries Colorado River water from the Imperial Dam west to California’s Imperial and Coachella valleys. The lost water supports the marshes and Mexiali Valley farms. This will change to help California use water more efficiently. The effect would be as significant as drying up the Mesa de Andrade marshes. Water is available, we just have to find a way to get it to the delta.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rural Maine is where the story takes place. The film accurately portrays the setting with all of the trees and where the train tracks are high above the river which causes them to walk on the train tracks. Stephen King studied at the University of Maine which is how he adds just a little bit more of himself into the story. As the boys are…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brokeback Mountain

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The movie opens in 1963 in Wyoming when two young cowboys are looking for work as sheep herder. The two cowboys, Ennis Del Mar (Heath Ledger) and Jack Twist (Jake Gyllenhaal), are sent to Brokeback mountain to herd sheep’s and it is there that both fall in love with each other. After this realization, both go their separate ways; Ennis back home to his sweetheart, Alma (Michelle Williams) and Jack to Texas to be a rodeo rider. Four years later, the two are reunited when Jack visits Ennis. At this point both men are married with kids; Ennis to Alma and Jack to Lureen (Anne Hathaway). The two meet together once a year in Brokeback Mountain, the one place both men feel safe and comfortable to express their love for each other, over a 20-year period.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    twilight

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The story takes place in the 20th century and the surrounding environment is the town Forks, the rainiest place in America. The surrounding is not described so well, I think it’s easier for me to imagine it because I know the environment from the movies. She’s more focused on describing feelings and persons. I think it’s also because she’s described the same environment 3 times before, so she maybe assumes that people know. I actually couldn’t find an example which is obvious for the environment.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays