Preview

Conflicting Perspectives - Stolen by Jane Harrison

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
868 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Conflicting Perspectives - Stolen by Jane Harrison
Stolen! What if you were ‘stolen’ from your family… but the kidnappers thought they had ‘rescued’ you? The kidnapper/s then tried to brainwash you to make you like them and eventually you started to be confused about what the truth was … These are the conflicting perspectives that I have experienced in my chosen text which is a stage play called ‘Stolen’ written by Jane Harrison.
What makes this text more frightening is the fact that the scenario is real and that it happened in our own backyard (Australia) - and legally! A conflicting perspective is an alternate point of view to the dominant mainstream perspective. The White Australia Policy was in conflict with Aboriginal families, needs, culture and identity.
‘Stolen’ traces the lives of five Aboriginal children removed from their families in the 1900’s under the official Australian policy of ‘Assimilation’. It is very persuasive in that it enables the reader to experience with great empathy this ‘alternate’ perspective; through the use of a variety of dramatic techniques and Didactical theatre. Stolen presents varying perspectives and the positive and negative experiences from 5 different people; all from the Stolen Generation. This looks at the context of their times and regions and is representative of the diverse experiences of the thousands of stolen children, fighting their homogenous representation and stereotypes.
The play is not set in actual real time and the characters do not actually interact, but this shows their 5 similar but parallel universes in their journeys and conflicting perspectives.
Out of the five main characters the best character for this focus was Anne. Anne is a pale skinned child who is adopted and grows up not knowing she is Aboriginal. She discovers her two conflicting perspectives, her identity within opposite cultures, and is internally conflicted; torn between the two.
In ‘ANNES’S SCENE’ Anne addresses the audience directly with her conflicting perspective when talking of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Stolen is a powerful play that highlights the trauma and alienation felt by the children both as children and as adults. The opening scene ‘Arriving' is particularly effective due mainly to the lack of dialogue. Harrison employs mime, pause, body language and facial expressions to convey meaning in the unintended dialogue. ‘Arriving'…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Reading is an active process of making meaning of the world we live in specifically the past; therefore our reading of novels is strongly influenced by the connections we can make to other texts. The construction of identity of a character often reflects or challenges the dominant ideologies circulating at the time of a text setting. The Book Thief explores Nazi Ideology in war-torn Germany in the 1940’s, Hans Hubermann and Rudy Steiford openly and secretively defies and challenges the dominant ideologies of this time era. The Secret River is set in the 18th century and focuses on one man man’s journey through life and is progression to Australia were the audience is introduced to the brutal world of Australia and the separation between cultures. The unrequired hate that many men have for Aboriginal men is contagious and due to the fact that it is different to their own culture and there lack of willingness to understand prevents any progression and results in misery for all.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The writer opens his piece providing context on the issue, clearly outlining the debacle that has prompted such fierce debate within the media. The example he presents is one in which a ‘young Aboriginal boy’ is charged with the ‘criminal offence of receiving stolen property (a chocolate Freddo frog). He attempts to show the outrageousness of the police’s treatment of Aboriginal youths through showing the insignificance of the ‘stolen object’.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Understanding that at the time, such a decision was very complicated, helps us as readers to understand that the novel is trying to suggest that perhaps it shouldn’t have been as problematic as it was, and is nostalgic towards a time that maybe never existed; where races lived in harmony and resolved their problems at ease with one another, in typical Australian backyard…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Aboriginals in Canada have always suffered and experienced hardships since the day their land was stolen. Despite all the rights, treaties, or equality statements presented they still feel the inequality and their problems remain out of the spotlight. Even though Aboriginal men go through many difficulties throughout their lives, Aboriginal women tend to suffer face more struggles than the men. These women do not have equal rights, have been forgotten, are being murdered without notice, and are not treated as second-class citizens and at times not even human. Aboriginal women remain undeterred; however, by these struggles, and persevere, while maintaining their strength and cultural identity. This essay will portray the analysis of different authors and their texts, portraying…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Australian Government's assimilation policy was a policy of absorbing Aboriginal people into white society through the process of removing children from their families. The idea of this policy was to breed out and abolish the aboriginal society and to assimilate them into the white community. The impact that this policy had on the indigenous Australians was very negative as many children were forcibly taken from their families. One way the assimilation policy impacted the aboriginals was by ‘stealing’ the aboriginal children. These children were named ‘the stolen generation’.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    For centuries, drama has acted as a mirror for culture and society. Through the power of dramatic form, we have been invited to be entertained yet also engaged in the social concerns, which can both be provocative and surprising. Both 'Stolen' by Jane Harrison and 'A Beautiful Life' by Michael Futcher and Helen Howard address contemporary social concerns and issues in Australian society. Stolen employs dramatic styles, techniques and conventions to portray the social issues caused by the stolen generation. On the other hand, A Beautiful Life again employs dramatic styles, techniques and conventions to portray the unforgettable story of a refugee family who escaped the hardships of Tehran Jail, only to find themselves suffering racism and injustice in the High Court of Australia.…

    • 1124 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Racism In The Sapphires

    • 310 Words
    • 1 Page

    The strong presence of racism among Australian communities as depicted in the film caused such events, namely the Stolen Generation, to occur. This significant event was a period in late 1800s-1960s where children from both Indigenous, and non-Indigenous (i.e. ‘white’) origins were forcefully taken away from their families as a result of official Australian Government policy. In relation to the film, Gail’s recall of a bitter memory associated with Kay particularly sheds light upon this key historical event.…

    • 310 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cultural heritage defines who we are as a person or society. It is a bond that ties the people of a region or community together. This is learned and passed from the elders to the new generation but to achieve this, it has to be translated into representations such as art, language and religion. Hence to force a human being to reject and change these things is subduing or taking control over their culture. This action is practically taking away their identity and forcibly changing their values. The importance of culture lies in the fact that it is a link between people and their value systems. The ‘Stolen Generation’ which refers to the generations of children that were an Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander descent who were taken from their families by the Australian Federal and State government agencies and church missions, under acts of their respective parliaments, is an epitome of this damaging action. This action of subduing of a culture lost was a significant theme represented in Matt Ottley’s remarkable multi modal work entitled Requiem for a beast. Ottley cleverly utilised several visual conventions, symbolic codes, and written techniques that enhanced my understanding of this theme.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The stolen generation was a shameful period in Australia’s history. They, the stolen generation, were a large amount of aborigines called half-castes that were taken away from their family if they were part non-indigenous. These half-castes would have been taken away without any notice, then brought to an orphanage like place, where the girls would have been trained to become a domestic servant and the boys would be trained to become stockmen. The plan for the stolen generation was to breed aboriginal blood out, which was why it was mostly girls that were taken away.…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Stolen Generation describes the period of time in which the many Aboriginal children were forcibly removed from their families in order to discontinue the passing down of their culture, language and identity. These young children were sent to institutions or adopted by non-Indigenous families and received little to no form of education in comparison to the level of schooling offered to the white Australian children. Life was immeasurably harsh for the Aboriginal children as they were growing up within a society which taught them to believe their culture was nothing more than rubbish and were encouraged to deny their own heritage. This disabled their ability to flourish and explore their potential in the world due to their racial discrimination which vastly limited their future pathways as they…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indigenous Australians are a prominently disadvantaged group that are subject to extreme discrimination impacting on their life’s. The Stolen generation had severe negative impacts on the victims of the stolen generation and has continued to negatively affect future generations. Further negative implications have stemmed from this extreme action. And it is the cause of many issues of inequality today among Indigenous Australians. This essay will define the stolen generation, outline and discuss the negative impacts that have stemmed from it and then link the impacts of assimilation to theories such as functionalist theory, structural, etc.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    From the time that Europeans landed in Australia ‘Pastoralists were pushing into Indigenous territory, robbing Aboriginal people of the land they had lived on and nurtured for thousands of years. ‘But Aboriginal communities did not just stand by as the land which they had formed rich bonds with, both spiritually and physically, was taken from their hands. Through a mixture of fear and hatred of the Aboriginals, European settlers engaged in many brutal clashes with them to attempt to seize their land. The Myall Creek massacre and the genocide that occurred in Van Diemens land are two prominent examples of the vicious and inhumane treatment of Aboriginals and the story of Pemulwuy is a reminder of the courage shown that was shown in adversity by many Aboriginal people.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Stolen Generation was a time of grief, sorrow and sadness for many indigenous people. To say that it is something of the past would be distorting the seriousness of the issue, the Stolen Generation was and always will be a contemporary issue affecting indigenous people. Although race relations in Australia have been signified for many decades there still remains a historic distinction between ‘black’ and ‘white’ people and this is why Australians are faced with the implications of recognizing the need for national healing.…

    • 1954 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sitting in the lecture theatre and taking in all the information that was put forward, really opened my mind up to a lot of the horrific issues surrounding the Indigenous people of Australia. When first being exposed to the Stolen Generation, I didn’t know how to feel toward innocent children being taken away from their homes. This was done by social workers and police officers that would invade the homes of the Indigenous people for the removal of their children (Gerrett 2013). It was concluded in 1989 the national Indigenous survey on health found almost half (47%) of Aboriginal children had been forcibly removed from both their parents (Gerrett 2013). This left me in distress, that something like this could happen to innocent children and their families. When saying this, I’m not implying that there are no children in the Indigenous community that weren’t mistreated, but this too happens in other racial communities. It is seen that incidence of sexual abuse of minors is far more worrying in other communities other than the…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays