Preview

Critical Analysis on Hird's "Gender's Nature: Intersexuality, Transsexualism and the Sex Gender Binary"

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
912 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Critical Analysis on Hird's "Gender's Nature: Intersexuality, Transsexualism and the Sex Gender Binary"
Critical Reading on Gender’s Nature: Intersexuality, Transsexualism and the Sex/Gender Binary

In this article, Hird’s uses feminist theory to support her studies, involving postmodernist concepts to the morphological notion of ‘sex’. She advanced on by unifying her study with evidence from two bodily forms: intersexuality and transsexualism that are currently challenging the modern ‘sex/gender’ binary. The purpose for Hird to take intersexuality and transsexualism into her argument is to demonstrate that it is not unusual for people to be born with an indefinite sex; ‘sex’ is socially inscribed and ambivalent; transsexuals who refuse to identify themselves undermine the two-sex and gender system or determine on an obscure sexual identity.
Hird recognizes that the sex/gender binary result in women’s oppression and the bifurcation between ‘sex’ and ‘gender’ rise the issue of challenging the hierarchical relationship that subservient women to men. However, she argues that these fix notions of feminism and ‘sex/ gender’ need rigorous attention in order to perceive understandings about nature and it’s relevancy to sex/ gender.

Hird illustrates how feminist theories respecting ‘sex/ gender’ binary and indicate that ‘sex’ is biological and natural that initiates the social construction of gender.
She clarifies how interrelated assumptions occur and ‘sex/gender’ binary often taken for granted due to the combination between nature and biology. Futhermore, when understanding the natures value, she supports her arguments base on feminist theorist Judith Butler (1990) points that “gender operates as an act of cultural inscription’.
Hird seems to be successful in supporting her notion that challenges the ‘sex/gender’ binary, where the constitution of the physical body inflict the cultural inscription of gender. Hird applies Wittig’s (1993) theory of lesbian identity as an example, where the ‘sex/gender’ premise fails to work. Lesbians

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    According to Professor Heather Paxson (2006) of MIT, gender refers to the characteristics that differentiate men and women’s behaviors and it includes value judgments connected to masculinity and femininity and everything in between. However, as one learns more and more about gender, they question the necessity of gender and even its existence. In the piece X: A Fabulous Child’s Story by Lois Gould (1978 or 2006) gender is portrayed as unimportant in order to have a good life; gender doesn’t matter. It shows that people have a need to categorize everything into groups because if they don’t, the unknown lingers in their minds and they fear it. People fear the unknown and the different, therefore they fear any gender other than the binary. But…

    • 161 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Girl By Aaron Devoor

    • 177 Words
    • 1 Page

    In today’s society, people tend to group one and an another into different categories according to their own social identity. An individual’s gender identity refers to which group where one belongs to. The attributes assigned to both males and females are different because of gender differences. In “Becoming members of Society: Learning the Social Meanings of Gender” by Aaron Devor, the author argues that factors such as beliefs and behaviors help differentiate the sexual identity of a person. In addition, Devor views sex as an instrument of determining gender. It is believed that there are only two types of sexes that exist. Which are male and female. On the other hand, “Girl”, by Jamaica Kincaid, the mother tries to forces prescribe behavior,…

    • 177 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The ideology that gender is socially constructed is a view that has been present in a number of philosophical, sociological and psychological theories. This view shares the understanding that gender is a result of enculturation through a prescribed ideal, and that society deems what is considered socially appropriate behaviour. Carol Vance, a feminist scholar, argues that gender and sexuality are not to be understood as “natural”, but rather as a socially constructed truth (Grewal, Kaplan 29). This reflects that society is shaped globally through social order. Each culture and society shares a social order that is unique to a particular set of customs, values and practices. These customs are engrained within society as individuals share a…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the progress of understanding human development, the notion of gender has commonly been the topic of discussion and debate when attempting to understand its foundation. While it is argued to be a societal and cultural manifestation, others suggest it is a biological…

    • 208 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Butler questions whether these gendered behaviors are natural as they are learned from one’s performance of a “gendered” individual to keep heterosexuality among their culture. If she had it her way, she would simply like to let one subject “be” and see how he/she becomes on his/her own. This would determine the true natural gender of subjects, instead of having them act in specific roles they might not agree with. However, this would never happen as many feminists defend the idea of a concrete identity because they believe it’s crucial for the advancement of interests of women. Butler argues, “My point is simply that one way in which this system of compulsory heterosexuality is reproduced and concealed is through the cultivation of bodies into discrete sexes with ‘natural’ appearances and ‘natural’ heterosexual dispositions” (905). Ultimately, Butler is stating it is a mistake to characterize women as possessing the same assets. Because by doing this, gender regulations are reinforced by staying divided into two categories, men and women. But more importantly, where does this leave individuals who are “confused” or “not able to identify” with a…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    essay #2

    • 1163 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout the decades, human beings from a small age start learning the characteristics of a male and female. Whether it is from media, clothing and to the way one is brought up, society has similar views of what it means to be a man or a women. Men are envisioned to be strong, aggressive, successful, and someone who avoids feminine characteristics. Women are perceived to be submissive, delicate, passive, dependent, vulnerable, having the ability to care for children and at times worthless. These views of gender identity have been engraved in humanities minds due to the amount of exposure to television, advertisements and the way one is raised in their households.…

    • 1163 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The gendering process frequently involves creating hierarchies between the divisions it enacts. One or more categories of sexed identities are privileged or devalued. In modern western societies, gender divides into two. This is not necessarily the case in other times, places and colures. Gender in the modern west usually refers to two distinct and separate categories of human beings as well as to the division of social practices into two fields. “The gendering of social practices”, according to Beardsley, “may be found, for example in contemporary western societies, in a strong association between men and public life and between women and domestic life, even though men and women occupy both spaces” (10). The more gender differences are narrowed down, the more optimistic scope feminism…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    From the article I have read, this demonstrated the differentiation between the two words “sex” and “gender.” This revealed how many individuals display certain characteristics of what gender they choose to be. Others like to stay in what is considered normal and full of structure because of the ability of being able to reproduce. The article describes how it affects society whether it’s in the personal life and in the work place. We are made to be set in certain gender roles because of culture such as their example of African culture and other cultures who proclaims the ways of how to act, how to dress, and mature and nurtured in the sex they were born with.…

    • 380 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A person’s sex is determined by their physical aspects, whether they have a penis or a vagina, and by their chromosomes which they have at birth (Soc 1001 Lecture 22, The Social Construction of Gender). Sometimes, though, people may fall outside of the two “main” sexes and be born as an intersex person, then given the choice to identify as male, female or neither (Psy 3666 Human Sexuality Lecture 10, Sex Education and Sexual Orientation), but are typically assigned a sex at birth via surgery and/or hormonal intervention (Soc 1001 Lecture 22, The Social Construction of Gender). Not only do intersex individuals have the choice to identify themselves as they please, everyone has a choice as to what they want to be identified as no matter if a surgery had taken place or…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Biology alone determines whether a person is female or male, not culture, but cultural myths outline the roles women and men play in society. These cultural myths constitute to the lack of differentiation between sex and gender, imposing the idea of nature versus nurture. While one is born either female or male due to biology, one’s culture ultimately makes one into a woman or a man. Society has predisposed images of what it means to be feminine or masculine. These gender roles limit the individual’s potential, making humans into performers that must conform to their “appropriate” roles. Being a man should not rely on appearing dominant, aggressive, or never admitting to weaknesses, nor should a woman’s life depend on her reproductiveness…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Final Paper

    • 1290 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Throughout gender and sexuality study, ideas and theories has been brought to surface. A very important central theory that has been brought to surface is queer theory. Queer theory is centered on sexuality and sexuality is centered on queer theory. Queer theory is known essentiality as the process of formation (Jagose). The approach of queer theory has led to many discussions on the idea and interpretation of sexuality. Just as queer theory is a formation so is sexuality. There is no set direction or definition of sexuality or queer. There should not be labels or definitions…

    • 1290 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Compulsory Heteronormativity

    • 4212 Words
    • 17 Pages

    will be dominantly on heteronormativity. I will try to prove that both heteronormativity and gender are social constructs, which means that they are all learned behaviours by society through culture, tradition and religion. I will show a world where any norms and taboos exist, to turn our origins of nature. I will support my argument…

    • 4212 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Radicalesbians reminds us how the term ‘lesbian’ was historically utilized by men (and by other women) as a mechanism of humiliation. By highlighting this politics of this socially constructed stigma, Radicalesbians also demarcate the equally-constructed boundary of hetero-patriarchal normalcy and, as importantly, the sexual subjectivation underscoring that border. Yet this oppressed sexual subjectivity can in turn be used as leverage to both decenter hetero-patriarchy and prioritize same-sex desire as a literal, political, and spiritual means of resistance. In taking this argumentative turn, Radicalesbians pull back the cover on the underlying concerns of this hegemonic interpolation noting that “when you strip off all the packaging, you must finally realize that the essence of being a ‘woman’ is to get fucked by men” (Dear Sister 2000 108). Lesbianism becomes by default the means to disrupt being literally and metaphorically getting ‘fucked by…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gayle Rubin created the sex/gender system concept in the year 1975. She created this term to offer a new way of thinking about the difference between sex and gender. She defined the sex/gender system as “the set of arrangements by which a society transforms biological sexuality into products of human activity, and which these transformed sexual needs are satisfied” (WRWC, 2015). The sex/gender system has many explanations that attempt to address how our sex plays a role in how we learn gender. A few of these theories include: cognitive-developmental theory, social learning theory, gender schema theory, social interactions and gender roles, and lastly, performativity theory. In this essay I will explain how the sex/gender system is created and reinforced from the perspectives of feminist theorists.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Queer Theory Essay

    • 2816 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Queer theorists have different ideas on what is 'Queer ' and what is not 'Queer ' and some Queer theorists believe there is no set doctrine in which to be 'Queer ' because that would adhere to the 'norm 's ' of heteronormativity. Examining different 'Queer ' thoughts can help aid our own formulation of what is 'Queer ' and what 'Queer theory ' is to the individual and how it can help develop understandings around sexuality, gender, history, societies, cultures and heteronormativity.…

    • 2816 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics