Preview

A Critical and Rhetorical Analysis of William Cronon's Only Connect.

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1720 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Critical and Rhetorical Analysis of William Cronon's Only Connect.
A Liberal Education? Not According to Cronon. A Critical and Rhetorical Analysis of Cronon's Only Connect.

While the term liberal education is heard from the most prestigious university to an inner city community college, the phrase itself has a hazy definition at best. While educators across America struggle with the definition of the phrase, William Cronon uses purpose, structure, and appeals in his essay "Only Connect: The Goals of Liberal education," to define a liberally educated being and the characteristics that such an education should impart. Cronon capitalizes on inductive structuring to lead the reader along, gently building each new statement upon a foundation of previous ideas. This effectively leads the reader to a strange and new concept that a liberal education should nurture the human mind and inspire students to have love for their fellow humanity.

One purpose of Cronon's essay is to emancipate the phrase liberal education from the debates and misconceptions that have swirled around the words since their creation while also inspiring educators to embody a teaching philosophy that attempts to create a spiritual love for those around them. While having no definition himself, Cronon states that he is able to answer his question with "a list [...] of personal qualities: the ten values [he] most admire[s] in the people who seem to embody the values of a liberal education"(159). He wishes to move away from the "mantra-like"(156) and "empty"(156) definition that these words hold to a more functional, working explanation of a liberal education. Cronon's list of characteristics provides the reader with a plausible understanding of a liberal education. While Cronon is unable to define a liberal education, he is competent in defining what a liberal education produces. By admitting that he is unable to define a liberal education and instead focusing on the characteristics that such an education embodies, Cronon is laying the groundwork for his revolutionary

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Cronon Only Connect

    • 3338 Words
    • 9 Pages

    should serve. So what exactly do we mean by liberal education, and why do we…

    • 3338 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his speech “This is water” David F. Wallace (2005) states the advantage of being open-minded and describes the effectiveness of proper way of thinking. At the beginning the speaker claims that throughout life people may not be able to notice and discuss what is really important in life by illustrating the example of fish talk about the water. He argues that even though people have the ability to analyze, nevertheless they may not be able to realize how exactly to do it, and this is what liberal arts education tries to teach.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Several authors, like Bill Coplin and Marshal Gregory have very strong views about liberal education. Coplin, believes schools should be more job preparation oriented, while Gregory feels the need of liberal arts isn’t just about getting a job, but about being able to find our purpose in life and live our lives fully. Another article written by Jerry Logan and Janel Curry expresses feelings very similar to those of Gregory’s. The approach taken by Gregory, Logan, and Curry gives a very strong case for why Christians should pursue a liberal education. Christian liberal arts education prepares people for their careers, while also preparing people to be ready to do whatever God may ask of them.…

    • 115 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Can a liberal arts education really make us better?” by Richard Kamber, he argues that even though a liberal arts education can make us better, it depends solely on that person’s definition of better. Now the question on everyone’s mind, “What are liberal arts?” A liberal arts education gives us a general review of humanities, arts, and sciences. Liberal arts are usually delivered in small classes, full of active participants, by “seasoned faculty.” They aim to develop our character and provide us with an immense amount of skills, which ultimately gives us more money. Though often looked down upon, liberal arts have helped shape many great people such as Socrates, Giordano Gentile, Galileo, and Martin Heidregger.…

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    What is Education? It is clear to us that education is an essential part of everyone’s lives and our future depends on it. Despite the differences found in both Edmundson and Graff’s works, Graff supports the different ideas Edmundson has toward education. Edmundson, who writes “On the Uses of Liberal Education”, tells us that today’s priority of education has changed; colleges have turned into a market mentality. Graff’s focus in “Other Voices, Other Rooms” is not this market mentality, but to stress the different factors as to why education has deteriorated. One of the factors is compartmentalization. Both, Edmundson…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    David Foster Wallace was a novelist and essayist. He delivered a commencement speech to liberal arts graduates at the Kenyon College in May of 2005. In the speech Wallace implores listeners to hear his words from a non-biased perspective for what they are; his words are not a reprimand to the selfish, but an offer to those seeking knowledge to broaden their perspective. Wallace warns against closed mindedness by using examples of his own experiences along with clichés, and the repeated idea that “…a liberal arts education is not so much about filling you up with knowledge as it is teaching you how to think.”-(Wallace, 2005 Kenyon Commencement Speech). Wallace expands on that cliché, showing the audience that the need to be taught is not an insult to their intelligence, but a tool that can be used to broaden the mind and experience life to the fullest.…

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In his article “The New Liberal Arts” Sanford J Ungar, President of Goucher College advocates a radical clarification of several misconceptions about the liberal arts degree. He believes that these issues are the main reasons for the decline in liberal arts education today. He insists that a liberal arts education is still a valuable degree in modern society.…

    • 113 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    But even though the word liberal is used in both cases, “a liberal education (...) has nothing whatsoever to do with politics(...)”(Ungar 230). This means that there is a difference and a Liberal Arts degree should not be devalued by men and women who devalue themselves with open arguments that do not even go far enough to state a true point. Everyone hopes to be better than that and learning of the arts and sciences is certainly a way to…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Robert Harris’ article, “On the Purpose of a Liberal Arts Education” on page 1-6 of the website VirtualSalt (March 14, 1991), is written in enumeration mode. The purpose of the article is persuading the reader to think about the advantages of liberal arts education. The article has a positive tone because it is optimistic, and respectful. Harris lists several rewards of liberal arts education. First, liberal arts education can help you become a broad thinker. Second, liberal arts education gives you a chance to learn and empower you to discover the world. Also, it elevates you to increase your knowledge and teach you how to become a good leader. Finally,…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In today's society, education is more liberal, allowing people to think for themselves and providing them with a broader education. This differs from many years ago, when education was more conservative. Education was very basic, consisting of only academic classes and no electives. People with a more conservative education would never go against what they were taught. However, liberally educated people of today can go against what they are taught, research it themselves, and make new conclusions about their studies. A liberal education enables people to deal with the forces that control their life. It frees them from the restraints in everyday life. Having such a broad education allows people to deal with such forces. Four psychologists have written essays and constructed theories that can agree that liberal education is of a greater stature than conservatively educated. The essays are "The Theory of Multiple Intelligences," written by Howard Gardner, "The Personal and Collective Unconscious," written by Carl Jung, "The Allegory of the Cave," written by Plato, and "From the Interpretation of Dreams," written by Sigmund Freud.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Among the several parts of the historical background of Liberal Arts, “The Unifying Principle” is one of the most important ones because it has been a significant partof many people’s lives. “The first task of the Liberal Arts is to secure the liberation of the mind from those many fetters that can bind it; notably ignorance, prejudice, and the influence of the passions. In and through this essential freedom, the freedom of the mind, our ‘humanity’ is revealed,” (Flannery, 6). This strong quote from the explanation of “The Unifying Principle” helps show us how being a liberally educated person is like being free, or liberated. Additionally, it keeps the liberally educated person’s mind from being bias towards anyone or anything. These are both important characteristics to have in our society, and liberally educated people acquire them as they receive their liberal education. They are very strong-willed, and always…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Edmundson

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Mark Edmundson’s “On the uses of a Liberal Education” provides interesting points on why the liberal arts education is becoming part of consumer goods and how education is being advertised. Edmundson states different causes for this effect and comes up with consumer culture in society. He believes that the liberal art education is unsuccessful because Americans are attracted to consumption and entertainment. Education is becoming more about consumerism and not about students’ education because it is what they are expected not because they want they choose to higher their education. Edmundson’s view on what education means that the students are learning and improving their education and not just doing it for consumerism.…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The world is quickly changing; less people spend time in any one career. Liberal Education prepares students to be a responsible at both the local and national level, as well as competent global citizens. The main difference between regular education and Liberal Education is at the end, where regular education provides access to prosperous careers, while Liberal Education had always had an ambitious end. Liberal Education has always been about the education of the whole person, providing multiple ways of thinking and creating, making people able to develop lifetime skills and…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mark Edmundson’s essay, “On the Uses of a Liberal Education,” was published in Harper’s magazine in the fall of 1997. Edmundson begins the article by giving us a glimpse into his own experiences teaching. He speaks on how, he dreads evaluation day at the end of each term, he feels he is being reviewed more on his entertaining ability and less on if the student felt changed by his course. Near the end of the article, Edmundson states, “My overall point is this: It’s not that a left-wing professional coup has taken over the university. It’s that at American universities, left-liberal politics have collided with the ethos of consumerism. The consumer ethos is winning.” (pg. 48) This article is about how the younger generation has been raised with…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Many people turn to a Christian college to fulfill their ‘checklist’ of a perfect college. However, a Christian liberal arts education is often misunderstood or underrated. What is the benefit of a school that offers this type of education? Why attend a Christian liberal-arts college? Why does a Christian college even exist? In Arthur F. Holmes’ book, “The Idea of a Christian College”, these questions – and more – are examined and answered. The four main themes I took from Holmes’ book are as follows: there is a distinct niche and purpose for a Christian liberal arts education; faith and learning are integrated and is thus a unique aspect to a Christian college; academic freedom is an integral part of a Christian education; and, the purpose of an education is more than to simply become trained or knowledgeable in one specific subject.…

    • 1948 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays