Preview

Critical Evaluation of Rosenhans Study 'on Being Sane in Insane Places'

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1580 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Critical Evaluation of Rosenhans Study 'on Being Sane in Insane Places'
The question of what it means to be labelled ‘psychologically abnormal’ is examined closely in Rosenhans study of ‘On Being Sane in Insane Places’. This study highlights the usefulness and consequences of being diagnostically labelled.

Rosenhans study ‘On Being Sane in Insane Places’ tests the hypothesis that ‘We cannot distinguish the sane from the insane in psychiatric hospitals’. (Rosenhan, 1973) This study is an influential criticism in testing the validity of psychiatric diagnoses, contextual factors in reaching these diagnoses, and what happens after a patient has been diagnostically labelled as ’psychologically abnormal’. The aim of Rosenhans study was to prove a positive hypothesis. During the study 8 participants of various backgrounds, including Rosenhan himself, gained admission in to 12 psychiatric hospitals across the US. These hospitals were a random selection, from research based to private, modern, old and with varied staff-patient ratios. The pseudo patients gained entry to the facilities by feigning that they could hear voices, reflective of a personality disorder, including words such as ‘hollow’ and ‘empty’. These words were selected by Rosenhan as an opportunity to demonstrate that these voices might be reflecting on the individual’s life. After admission to the hospital Rosenhan claims that the pseudo patients cease any abnormal behaviour and continue life within the institution and normally as possible. Rosenhan instructs the pseudo patients to not alter any personal information about themselves to the staff of the hospital such as their education or family background (except their name for security purposes) whilst being psychologically assessed. The study tests whether the patients, after their original symptoms have alleviated, will be given a psychiatric diagnoses and the consequences of being labelled as such. The outcome of the study was that 11 out of 12 participants were discharged as having ‘Schizophrenia, in remission’. Rosenhan

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The study consisted of two parts. The first involved ‘pseudopatients’ – people who had never had symptoms of serious mental disorder – who, as part of the study, briefly reported auditory hallucinations in order to gain admission to psychiatric hospitals across the United States. In the experiment eight pseudopatients presented at psychiatric hospitals complaining of hearing a voice. Asked what the voices said, they replied that the voices were often unclear, but as far as they could tell, said “empty,” “hollow,” and “thud.” Beyond alleging this symptom, and falsifying their names and vocations, no other falsehoods were told. Upon admission to the ward the pseudopatients are reported to have ceased to claim symptoms and behaved as they…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although the two readings, The Saints and the Roughnecks (Chambliss) and On Being Sane in Insane Places are extremely different, they both have one thing in common: After one has been socially labeled then the person will continue to act as they have been labeled.…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rosenhan theorized that if the criteria for the diagnosis are adequate, then the mental health professionals should be able to distinguish between the sane and the insane. Also, he wanted to identify if the diagnosis are tied more to the situation than to the patient. To prove his theory, Rosenhan introduced normal people…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rosenhan Summary

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Rosenhan (1973) study contains many ethical issues such as deception to the hospital staff and stress for the actors. Although this experiment significantly reflected on the inaccuracy of psychiartric diagnosis, the degree of generalizability on applies to psychiatric hospitals in the United States. The methodology of this experiment produced accurate results. In another sense, concepts of abnormality are cultural bound therefore this experiment may not be an accurate representation in other cultures. Since…

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Stanford professor David Rosenhan conducted a study that challenged psychiatrist’s ability to properly diagnose their patients. Rosenhan, along with eight peers, set off to various mental health institutions with the intention of being admitted. The test group was comprised of sane, professional people who were to complain of only one issue: “I am hearing a voice. It is saying thud.” And aside from that, they were to act completely normal. His theory of misdiagnosis seemed to have been proven, as 8 of the 9 fake patients were diagnosed schizophrenic and the other with manic depressive psychosis. After being published in Science, the magazine, various psychiatrists expressed their opposition to his findings, but none more than Robert Spitzer,…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    2ap3 Midterm

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This course discusses the issues and controversies surrounding the meaning and categorization of psychological abnormality. We will also describe the major symptoms, hypothesized or suggested causes, and accepted treatments for major categories of mental disorder as described in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) of the American Psychiatric Association, version IV-TR, always keeping in mind the criticisms of this categorization system. The goals of the course include a deeper understanding of the nature, causes of, and current treatments for, psychopathology, and - more importantly - an appreciation for the tentative and incomplete nature of our understanding of mental illness.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Psy 300 Week5 Team Final

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages

    To help illustrate our research on abnormal psychology, this section will compare and contrast normal and abnormal psychology. Normal psychology focuses on the different ways different people see life and want to live life, rather than relying on generalizations made about whole populations of people. These generalizations can often do harm because without proper consideration they can often imply norm of behavior inimical to a person’s existence. A normal psychology in this way doesn’t imply a perfect individual existence, nor that there aren’t any pathologies.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One definition of Abnormality is deviation of Social Norms. Social norms are accepted ways of behaving within a society. They are the unwritten rules that members of a society regard as being normal and acceptable, and any deviation from them can be regarded as abnormal behaviour. Examples include ways of dressing, such as women wearing feminine clothing and men wearing masculine clothing, not appearing naked in public, saying 'please' and 'thank you', opening doors for women and elderly people etc. Social norms may, however, vary between cultures - clothing is an example of this as some African tribes wear very little clothing whereas Western cultures keep certain areas of the body covered at all times. The problem with defining abnormality as deviation from social norms is that probably the majority of behaviour that deviates from social norms is unlikely to represent mental illness. Eccentric behaviours, for example the case of John Slater (Weekes & James, 1995) who lived in a cave that was often flooded by seawater because the open space helped him think more clearly, are not necessarily abnormal to the extent that health is harmed.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    D Rosenhan Summary

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Once admitted, the subjects proceeded to behave normally, showing no signs of schizophrenia at all. Nonetheless, they had an extremely difficult time convincing the doctors and nurses that they were "normal." It took between seven to fifty-two days for each subject to be released from the medical ward. Moreover, every single one of their mental health statuses were established as "schizophrenia in remission" when they were all released. The medical staff was not able to discern any of the subjects from actual patients. On the other hand, other patients suspected the subjects to be imposters. Overall, the significance of this study is learning about the impact of labels. Once a person is categorized in society, it is extremely difficult to remove the label. In the study, the subjects were diagnosed as schizophrenics. When they were permitted to leave, they were still called schizophrenics, but in…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    David Rosenhan is known for the classic, yet controversial study “On Being Sane in Insane Places” of progress within the mental health field. Rosenhan’s study (1973) of eight people with no previous history of mental illness were admitted at various mental hospitals in America and complained of individual symptoms (auditory illusions, e.g., ‘thud’). He investigated whether psychiatrists could distinguish between those genuinely mentally ill and not. Each pseudopatient behaved normally, and symptoms were not re-reported. However, the average length of hospitalisation was 19 days. This shows context has a powerful role in determining how behaviour is labelled. This led to question the truth in psychiatric diagnoses. The predominant issue was unauthorised diagnoses and needless treatments for a fictional mental illness tolerably accepted. Today, it is the difficulty in gaining treatment for real symptoms of mental disorders.…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this chapter of the book “Sane in insane places” “Lauren Slater, Opening Skinner’s Box” David Rosenhan totally exploited the way doctors diagnosed patients and how patients were treated as almost convicts in mental hospitals. He also proved using psychology is not a consistent way of diagnosing patients with loads of pills most patients didn't need. Also how the same experiment Rosenhan came up with was repeated years later but was due to the fact doctors weren't giving thorough examinations. I agree with the idea that psychology isn’t a good way of diagnosing pseudopatients in medical hospitals because they cannot correctly determine with what is wrong with the patient in need.…

    • 272 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    reality of the mentally insane and the expression of human nature. I will attempt to explore these…

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Also, the value of diagnostic labeling can be used effectively, and ineffectively. The value of diagnostic labeling is classifying patients for identifying disorders that suggest appropriate treatments, and help patients to understand symptoms. However, there is a problem with labeling diagnosis. Labels create therapist and social expectations about client, which can be led them perform self-fulfilling prophecy. Any unusual behavior would be attributed as to disorder. Also, labels make it easier to access stereotypes about client. Then client actually may ¡°become¡± the disorder. For instance, Rosenhan¡¯s study in 1973, he and a number of associates sought admission to a number of mental hospitals. All claimed that they had been hearing voices. All were admitted to the institutions as suffering from schizophrenia. At that time, ceased reporting any unusual symptoms and behaved as they usually did. However, none of the doctors, nor nurses recognized that they are not real patients, but only real…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mental Illness

    • 1997 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Everyone once in their life has either thought as themselves or another as crazy. In today’s day and age people find it fun to be called crazy, that was not the case in the past. People in our past who were demined “Insane” were sent away, hidden from society’s eyes and subjected to cruelty and unnecessary torture. America’s health system has changed dramatically for the good and also it recent cases for the bad for some people.…

    • 1997 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Schizophrenia

    • 1828 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Schizophrenia is often misinterpreted and distinguished as a split personality, yet observers classify it as a hallucination or insanity state of mind. Because of schizophrenia’s frightening symptoms, it has a debilitating effect on the lives of the people who suffer from it. Usually, patients have difficulty telling the difference between real and unreal experiences, logical and illogical thoughts, or appropriate and inappropriate behavior. It also impairs a person’s ability to function at work and play. Also, regular constant hospitalization is required for precautionary hazard to oneself.…

    • 1828 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays