Preview

David Brooks Harmony

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
587 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
David Brooks Harmony
The New York Times article, “Harmony and the Dream,” David Brooks provides the argument that the world social classes are divided into individualists and collectivists. He goes further to give the idea that that the division is misconstrued result of economic turmoil or just world perception. Brooks shares facts about several social experiments with the contrary ideologies and social responses between Americans and Asians. He continues by linking the lack of human interaction, with the downfall and demise of the American economy. The Asian community tends to easily advance economically, and Brooks alludes that their relational values will soon become the new American dream. Americans are being left behind, due to focusing on their individuality instead of working for the greater good of the American people.

Brooks begins by showing social contrast between the American people and Asian people. He
…show more content…
Collective societies are known to fight for harmony and have a sense of duty. They undervalue their selves and their skills and their ability to contribute to a group setting. Brooks paints a picture of a society that is collective as a whole, and moves in harmonious unity. He warns that Americans are the only idealistic society, and that it will lead to our downfall.

Brooks asserts that the Asian culture focuses on others more, and that they put value on their relationships above all else; while most Americans have a decreasing number of active relationships. He mentions how many Americans are dealing with depression and high anxiety, due to their lack of value on relationships. They spend more time living on social media, than living their lives. Brooks then analyzes how the Asian society appears to be a happier society due to the healthy relationships they have

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Many individuals interpret diversity differently specifically in the United States because of its melting pot of distinct cultures and lifestyles. In his essay “People Like Us”, David Brooks’ argues that although the United States is a diverse nation as a whole, it is homogeneous in specific aspects like interactions between people. To some extent, his observation is true; people tend to stick to what or who they are comfortable with. There are also exceptions where the American people attempt to establish relationships with others because of their desire to expand out of their norm. For instance, Brooks excludes the explanation of diversity integration in the United States, where instead focuses on racial integration as the definition of diversity in America. He also makes assumptions that people purposefully intend to segregate themselves and underestimates their capability of living together because of their location, political values and personal appeal.…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    prosperous from its diversity, epitomizes the "American Melting Pot". It is complicated to relate such different backgrounds, but with an overview of history, culture, religion, and integration on a small scale, a reader is capable of applying the values to the American culture as a whole.…

    • 2976 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ronald Takaki retells the American history from the bottom up, through the lives of many minorities. The stories of many ethnical groups who helped create America’s mighty economy and rich culture, in his book, A Different Mirror. All these indigenous people were a part of what America is today, a more multicultural country. These peoples were looking for a better life, and they helped create a concrete backbone for America’s economic structure. This led to the rise ‘market revolution’, which changed America culturally. The revolution was good for America, but for the immigrants, it was abysmal. They were not viewed as Americans, despite their efforts to make America what it is today. We will see as the Irish were deprived of their land, coming to the land of the free in search for a better life, how they later marginalize the Mexicans. The Market revolution opened the way to making America more multicultural but not all cultures were equal.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The Soul of a Collectivist by Ayn Rand, the narrator shows similar idea’s advocating collectivism. Ellsworth M. Toohey addresses Peter Keating, his victim saying “The world i want. A world with obedience and unity. A world where the thought off each man will not be his own, but an attempt to guess the thought in the brain of his neighbor who’ll have no thought of his own but an attempt to guess the thought in the brain of his neighbor and so on” (Rand The Soul Of A Collectivist). The rhetoric behind collectivism sounds significant at first look. Although it is natural for humans to form groups, the danger comes in when you realize a substantial amount of people can be held against for anything that a single person amongst them may or may not have…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Residing as a foreigner in China for two years, Hessler was able to observe the Chinese way of life and their selflessness, which contradicted his view of the American lifestyle. The Chinese were generous; they cared for the sick and elderly; they had close relationships with their family and friends. Americans were selfish; they abandoned the elderly at retirement homes; they lived distant social lives. Similarly, Morris Berman, a social and cultural historian and critic, believes that Americans live a life devoted to consumerism. Interviewed by David Masciotra of The Atlantic, Berman discusses his view that American culture is superficial and obsessed with social status based on wealth and possessions. While Hessler also identifies China’s generous and caring way of life, both men realized America’s cultural weaknesses of monetary obsession and selfish…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    America is developing a cultural divide between the elites and the working class. The American divide is blatantly clear to the majority of Murray’s audience. The so called new divide is derived from the cultural quality. Instead of a gap dividing segments of our country because of one’s achievements or income, now there are distinctive practices widening the gap between the two Americas. Murray states the problem, providing statistics and a list of SuperZIPs, all of which support his claim. Working towards the conclusion of his argument, Murray contemptuously ignores, that what many believe to be actual solutions to this ongoing cycle: reconstructing the tax structure and "scholarships for working-class children” and further more "the new…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Great Depression and World War II left an imaginable and remarkable mark on America’s history and its citizens. Through these trying times, some Americans were able to unite, come together, support one another and try their best to live the best standard of life they could, while other americans become more divided and began to turn against each other. During the Great Depression and World War II, some American’s became more unified through things such as FDR’s New Deal, the Bonus Army March, the generosity of farmers and the Salvation Army and Rail Riding, while other American’s became more divided due to cultural differences, the implementation of Japanese-American interments camps and the disownment of family members due to a lack of resources to support one another.…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Historical Report on Race

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages

    We struggle to adapt to the culture of America. We find the need to identify with our roots in Asian religion, thought and practices. Sometimes we are looked at oddly due to our customs or our beliefs; we truly wish to take care our own. We will always lend a hand, but that same hand has also been bitten by those we've helped. It is our cultural way to be quiet and reserved, keep our business private and not share our problems. Our way of life is unique to the American culture, much of it remains a mystery but with time we've shed much light into our own culture and traditions.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Templeton Stereotypes

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Between the late 1940s and early 1950s, the United States enjoyed a booming economy, loomed as the world’s military hegemon, and made technological goods and services available to more people than ever before. However, this period was also an era of conflict: the nascent civil rights movements and the crusade against immigration exposed the underlying divisions in society. Blacks, Hispanics, and Asian Americans suffered as targets of discrimination in both employment and property ownership, and a growing number of people spoke out against this injustice. The struggle and fight against ethnic segregation entered the mainstream of American life, leaving almost 70 million children in the baby boomer generation confused about the role of ethnicity…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    At the beginning of the XIX century the USA became one of mighty powers of the world. The monopolies, trusts, and corporations developed. The riches were becoming richer, and the poor were becoming poorer. In the country there was an intensive development of the western territories became populated by million emigrants from Europe (Gooding-Williams, 2009). Respectively the national structure of the state changed too. It should be noted that during this period, the majority of inhabitants of the USA still kept reckless belief in a phenomenon of "the American dream", guaranteeing to each citizen, "new Adam" paradise on the guilty of the earth. It seemed like all class and religious barriers are broken, social, educational, ideological and other restrictions are liquidated, and the person has unlimited opportunities and can express him or her self as an individual. Consequently, the chances to achieve success are equal for all. And nevertheless the society has many of problems especially according to the right of the Afro-Americans and to these cases, the most significant impact had the American literature that viewed all the aspects of that time. Everything in America: the appearance of industrial and…

    • 2546 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Just as Europe had Europeanized the Americas, the United States of America is doing so now to the East. Country’s cultures are reshaped by American industries (i.e. McDonalds) leading to new diets (causing obesity) and new social ideologies such as the rights of women. Now, when an Americans leaves his or her house to visit a country they are still surrounded by the ‘comforts’ of home. Although slavery is banned around the world, racial discrimination and racial prejudices are still woven in the fabric of our culture…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For this comparison in particular, both Asian American and African American experiences will be examined in relation to the general society to determine similarities and differences that have led to the present-day political, economic, and social climate the twenty first generation Americans face. Understanding all the different aspects of these experiences goes beyond the scope of this paper, but some critical analysis can still be applied through an examination of the experiences both Asian American and African Americans had in the beginning interactions with whites. This method of observation and analysis is chosen due to the unique nature of intercultural interactions and how they relate to the political, economic, and social environments at the time, which is precisely what this paper is seeking to analyze. Both qualitative and quantitative information will offer a deeper look into the unique influences and general outcome of key interactions in both ethnic groups took part of throughout key events in America’s…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Among these types is positive solidarity in which an individual is either directly bound to its society and without the assistance of a third party or they are simply dependent upon their society and each of its components. In other words, an individual can be a product of their society and think in accordance with the common conscience despite their rivaling personal conscience or an individual can succumb to the collective and allow for their solidarity to the group to take its effect on their individual personality. Durkheim goes as far as to distinguish between each scenario’s uses of the word ‘society’. According to the reading, the first scenario views society as “a more or less organized totality of beliefs and sentiments common to all members of the group [i.e. the collective type]” (Durkheim, 96). Whereas the second scenario in which everyone is solitary features society as a “system of different, special functions which definite relations unite” (Durkheim, 96). Using Durkheim’s words to distinguish between these two instances is crucial to understanding how ultimately, despite their variances, these two societies make up one singular reality. One reality in which two separate roles take place for an individual: the tendency to think and act as the majority…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A young Chinese girl is dating her new boyfriend in Starbucks. They drink Frappuccino, taste Tiramisu, and chat in English sharing interesting experience of studying abroad. A hearty laugher could be heard all the time. The girl’s grandmother might be shocked by this and the girl’s mother would probably shake her head in disbelief (Friedman 4). Thirty years ago, marriages were arranged by the family, the young had no voice in who their future husband and wife would be. Drinking American coffee, tasting Italian pastries or having a romantic date was almost impossible, not to speak of learning English and studying abroad. Changes did not happen until recent years when the upsurge of globalization is sweeping across China, bringing the thought of liberty. Same as China, globalization impacts Asian people’s lives by bringing a great variety of goods, increasing access to learn foreign cultures and casting off old customs that against human rights and liberty. Asian countries benefit from culture exchange. Globalization is not a threat to Asian countries because globalization increases individual freedom.…

    • 1709 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Takan,Y., & Osak,E. (1999). An unsupported view: Comparing Japan and the U.S. on individualism/collectivism. Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 2(3) 311-341.…

    • 10647 Words
    • 43 Pages
    Powerful Essays