Preview

david the boy raised as a girl

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
840 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
david the boy raised as a girl
Child psy 202

David the Boy Raised as a Girl

In 1965 in Canada Janet Reimer gave birth to healthy twin boys Bruce and Brian but during routine medical procedure goes horribly wrong and the Reamers’ were faced with a horrible decision to make to raise their son with a deformation or to raise their son as a daughter. With this unbearable decision they searched from doctor to doctor to find what to do, when they found dr. money they thought they had found their savior, he had a theory that gender wasn’t just based on genetics but it was based on your upbringing. So for dr. money he had found the perfect candidate to test this theory on. One boy who was raised and born a boy and one boy who would be born a boy and raised as a girl. For this one mistake on this routine procedure were the equipment had malfunctioned and burned the boys penis during a circumcise it had profoundly changed this families lives. Dr. money believed that during the first two years of a child’s life that the child was natural and that it was not just your biology that decided your gender identity but also your upbringing. So these Reimer case was just the perfect to test his theory and so the Reamers’ did as the doctor in instructed and dressed him as a girl and raised him as a girl and they changed his name to Brenda. He told them they were to never tell Brenda she was born a boy or it would never work. They would visit every two years to visit and record the results. The first few years seem to be ok, Brenda seemed to be wanting girl things and everything seem to be working as dr. money said they would. At the age two her testicles were removed. And it wasn’t until Brenda was 7 years old when her mother had doubts about the progress of the gender issue. As Brenda got older she felt like she was crazy for feeling like a boy and wanting to play boy games and feeling like an outcast. As she grew older she started looking more masculine and the doctor pushed for

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    This video about Bruce/Brenda Reimer's story and Dr. Money was very interesting and sad. Originally, the traditional view of gender identity is a nature stance. It is stating basically that boys and girls are already born with innate features that make them specifically a boy or a girl. On the other hand, Dr. Money believed that boys and girls are born blank. That the environment, society or culture are the catalysts that how a girl and boys should behave. He believes the way a child is reared may influence the child's identity. He was more on the nurture scale versus…

    • 101 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    First of all David Reimer (then known as Bruce) was genetically born a boy however in 1966 his penis was destroyed by accident during a circumcision, his parents then took him to a psychologist and sexologists John Money. Money advised the parents to change the sex of their child since penis reconstruction wasn’t an option then, he was a supporter of the idea that gender wasn’t predetermined genetically and was from the influence of the environment.…

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1965, David Reimer, an 8-month-old Canadian twin brother to Brian Reimer, was a victim of unethical psychiatric practices that lead us to understand Nature Vs. Nurture, and how both aid in the development of adulthood. Dr. John Money was first introduced to David, when physicians used an electro cautery needle instead of standard scalpel, which lead to the burning off of his reproductive organ. According to Intersex Society of North America “David’s parents agreed to have him “sex reassigned” and made into a girl via surgical, hormonal, and psychological treatments—i.e., via the system Money advocated for intersex children.” This approach has then provided the perspective in which modern countries use to assume that gender identity is…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the documentary John, who identifies himself as a boy has a hard time having a difficult relationship with his father. One of the reasons why John’s father did not want to accept his situation is because of his religion views. He believes that when someone is born they should live as their natal gender. The other reason why John’s father did not accept his daughter decision to change her gender is because he said that he felt like he is losing his daughter and it felt as if his daughter was morphing into another…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Dr money used David Reimers case to try and prove that nurture has more of an influence than nature, initially this seemed to be the case but later on, around the age of 12 David(who was then Brenda) refused oestrogen and showed masculine traits. When Dr Money published his findings on the case he deemed it successful and said that it showed nurture over nature, although Dr Money did not publish all of his findings, the one's that may have disproved his theory he ignored and concentrated on the positive points.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Marines

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Bruce Reimer was born one of a set of identical twins. At the age of seven months, his mother noticed that he and his brother were having trouble urinating, so she took them in to be circumcised. Bruce was first to undergo the operation, but tragedy struck, when a power surge caused the needle used to cauterise the wound to burn off most of his penis. Instead of repairing the organ, doctors suggested that Bruce's gender should be reassigned; hypothesizing that gender identity is socially determined and therefore malleable, they found in his identical twin Brian -- whose circumcision was forgone and, as his condition went away on its own, ultimately unnecessary -- an ideal "control" case. The parents agreed, and the child was thenceforth raised as a girl, Brenda.…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1) Bruce Reimer, who lost his penis as the result of a botched circumcision in 1996 and was raised by his parents as a girl. As Bruce grew up he knew something was wrong in his life, and he later reclaimed his male identity. Reimer’s story is often cited in nature – versus – nature debates as evidence that people are shaped more by their biology than by their environment.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the introduction, “What makes this woman”, Brizendine takes a difference perspective by stating some basic differences of women and men. I really appreciate her curious nature toward the topic. “While enrolled at each of these institutions, I learned little or nothing about female biological or neurological difference outside of pregnancy.” (pg. 2, Brizendine) I remember being in biology classes and I never had that thought cross my mind. I was so inundated with information, that I never thought how male centric my courses were. And when we did cadaver work, it was always a male specimen. Even in the beginning of this book, I am brought back to my own personal experience; inspiring questions that I wished I had asked myself back when.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Composing Gender

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Composing Gender by Rachel Groner and John F. O’Hara, there is the discussion of how society shapes gender and imposes gender roles on children, even before they are born, through simple things such as names and gender-themed baby showers. Many people think of anatomy equaling gender, however it is not that simple. Gender is more than just the boy and girl binary. It is the way that different toys are separated into “girl sections” which are typically all pink and “boy sections” which are typically blue. From an early age, society separates boys and girls by gendering things such as names and products. In 1972, there was an article published by Ms. Magazine, written by Lois Gould, about how it is always a battle for a child to not fall into stereotypical gender roles. Her idea for an experiment of raising an androgynous child could change the way society sees gender, if it were to ever be carried out. It made me…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Five Sexes, Revisited

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The reading The Five Sexes, Revisited was about the misrepresentation of today’s two-sex system in society. The central issue Anne Fausto-Sterling addresses is that there are people born outside of dimorphism and most people do not understand this (pg. 122). The most important point or central argument is that the two-sexes, male and female should no longer be accepted. Instead, five-sexes should be accepted: male, female, “herms”, “merms”, and ferms” (pg. 121). An important fact the author makes is, “…we calculated that for every 1,000 children born, seventeen are intersexual in some form” (pg. 122). This bit of information proves that there are infants born between the sexes male and female. It is important for people to realize that mixed babies are in existence. Anne Fausto-Sterling also shares a story of a born intersexual. “Consider for instance, the life of Max Beck: Born intersexual, Max was surgically assigned as a female and consistently raised as such. Had her medical team followed her into her early twenties, they would have deemed her assignment a success because she was married to a man. Within a few years, however, Beck had come out as a butch lesbian” (pg. 124). It all comes down to society and this story proves it. If the world were more open to these sex issues, then we would not have these issues in the first place. In Max’s case, being born intersexual would not have been an issue in Max’s life. Instead, the doctors chose Max’s sexuality without any consent from Max. Another interesting fact that Anne Fausto-Sterling uses to back up her argument is “The logical structure of the commonly used terms “true hermaphrodite,” “male pseudohermaphrodite” and “female pseudohermaphrodite” indicates that only the so-called true hermaphrodite is a genuine mix of male and female…Because true hermaphrodites are rare – possibly only one in 100,000 – such…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first few chapters are an introduction to Brave New World, which describes the process of embryos forming and transforming them into containers. In our society, babies can be created without intersexual course by using technologies and medicine. Couples who could not reproduce may try implantation methods to try to reproduce. Women do not have to choose to have sex to get pregnant. Sperm banks are widely used in the 21st century for women who does not wish to do it the old-fashion way. Drugs are used every day in America, either from over-the-counter or illegal…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 2013, a 6 year old boy from Colorado Springs always felt that she was meant to be a female. As early as 18 months old, when she was first able to communicate with her parents, she expressed herself as a girl. This child brought national attention to the pre-adolescence transgender child issue. She was denied access to the girls’ bathrooms at her school. Her parents filed a complaint with the Colorado Civil Rights Division and the subject of whether children really know their gender at this age came up for debate.…

    • 504 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Room For Intersexed

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The major strength of this article was the numerous cases of intersexed children, who were…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This Common Secret

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In 1976, in Portland, Oregon, Susan had a horrible abortion experience. She was dating a guy named David, had three jobs, and no money. While having her abortion she kept asking what was happening, but the lady was getting impatient with her questions. Then the male doctor was very rude to her as well. Her daughter Sonja’s birth was a more positive experience because of the home birth and having loved ones surround her.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    David Reimer

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There are several parties to blame for David Reimer’s lifetime of traumatic experience, however the man involved with the most audacity is Dr. Money. Not only were his methods unethical, the man undoubtedly had an agenda. Dr. Money used an innocent young boy’s sexual reassignment to push his theory of gender neutrality. Based on the glowing reports by Dr. Money, and the opposing remarks by David, it’s obvious David was used as a pawn to further Dr. Money’s career. Not only is the story of David Reimer an example of unethical health professionals, it is also a perfect illustration of nature vs. nurture, proving that biology and genetics play a significant, even vital role in one’s identity. Presently GID clients that undergo sex reassignment surgery must first psychologically prepare by living as the opposite gender for at least two years. Hormone therapy is required because biologically speaking a man and woman’s hormones differ and…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics