Neg. 1st speaker
Good afternoon. Basically, children are sent to school to receive a sound education. Our opponents insist that the handicapped should receive a normal education, but is it really beneficial to them?
Most mainstream schools such as DGS do not have the facilities or resources which handicapped students require. For example, how would students in wheelchairs travel around? Textbooks designed for mainstream students do not cater for blind students as well, thus few have corresponding Brailled versions.
On the other hand, special education schools provide all that the handicapped students need, ranging from learning materials to specially designed desks for wheelchair-bound students. Recently, Chief Executive Tung Chee Hwa announced giving over 10 million dollars to 17 special education schools to install air-conditioners, so that students with physical afflictions would feel more comfortable. Were they studying in mainstream schools, they would not receive equal benefits and might have to suffer.
Moreover, mainstream schools encourage students to participate in non-textbook-based activities. When a deaf student sees his classmates singing, a blind student hears his friends cooking, a lame student sees his peers running, he would definitely not feel the 'privilege' of studying in a mainstream school. He would only feel isolated and left out, unable to keep up with his peers, and his self-esteem would plummet down to zero.
What, then, is the point in letting handicapped students study in mainstream schools? Researches show that even handicapped children in mainstream kindergartens have to repeat a year in order to achieve the standard of ordinary children. Imagine how they would feel if they had to repeat school year after year of their education, eventually dropping out in despair. Thank you.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Education has also seen notable improvements when the act came into fruition as the percentage of those with special educational needs achieving 5 or more A*-C grades rose by a total of 56% between 2005 and 2011(2). Whilst the grades of those with disabilities have improved, it appears that the experience in education hasn’t had a great effect due to the act as 26% of disabled people in education reported having a negative experience largely due to the attitudes of others and lack of correct facilities(3). The poor attitudes and lack of facilities may come from the fact that 83% of disabled students are in mainstream education (4) which cannot necessarily cater for their needs to the same standard of a special needs school.…
- 722 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
First of all, there are too many factor involved that can affect whether a student is performing at their potential (i.e., lack of sleep, skipping a meal, not feeling well, failed to study, problems at home, etc). These same factors can affect whether or not a student without a documented disability achieves to their potential. Second, IDEA was meant to provide access to a free and appropriate education. Third, if courts began approving services for students with disabilities to have the capability to achieve to their potential instead of providing access to a free and appropriate education, this would increase costs/funding required to provide special education services and other individuals with disabilities might get slighted in some way from services that may be needed to ensure access. Moreover, if students with disabilities were given services to achieve/perform at their potential, then students without disabilities in a sense would be slighted by the law because no one would be addressing the fact that they don’t always achieve at a level consistent with their…
- 459 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Within the educational setting there are many pieces of legislation that must be adhered to. One of these is the disability and equality act 2010, this piece of legislation ensures that pupils who are disabled or have a mental illness are given the right to attend education and learn and achieve without being discriminated against or excluded. For example if I have a pupil arrive in a wheel chair I will have to make reasonable adjustments for that pupil i.e. move the whole class to the ground floor or see if they could attend an alternative course but in most colleges now a days they will have a lift so I will have to rearrange tables and chairs to accommodate for that pupil.…
- 1279 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Research has found that placing children with Down syndrome in a regular education classroom will benefit their social and emotional development. Studies show that the language skills of children with Down syndrome that were placed in “special schools” were 2 ½ years behind children with Down syndrome that were placed in regular “mainstream” schools. Other ways children with Down syndrome benefit from being in a regular classroom are their speech, behavior, social…
- 419 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The parents who demand it motivated mainly by their own need or in the words of Sean’s mother, Dee Begg, are they moved by a child’s need "to be out in the world, to experience it"? The parents who stay with schools like Ridge maybe limiting their children’s potential or as Bobby’s mother maintains, would sending him to a regular school be like “putting a 5-foot-2 kid on the varsity basketball team and expect to succeed". The teachers who complain about the burden of teaching disabled children maybe merely shirking or are they responsibly concerned that the rest of the class is being deprived of its due attention?…
- 745 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
A second issue that has been brought forth as being detrimental is one that I have also seen as being a pro, the socialization aspect of inclusion. Opponents to inclusion feel that the socialization part of learning takes precedence over the student’s academic achievement. If this is so, then the disabled student would be missing out on necessary skills that would ensure academic progression while at the same time putting the regular…
- 641 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
From the beginning of time until the end of time, there will always be students who require special education services. Throughout the 20th century, there have been many laws written to try and protect and help students with disabilities. Two in particular are the Education for All Handicapped Children Act of 1975, and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA 1990). Special education classes were available in the 1950’s, but the outcome for the students was not what parents expected. The students in these classes could not preform academically, and were considered unteachable. They…
- 1148 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Special Educational Needs and Disability Act 2001 states that practitioners should not treat disabled children less favourably than other children. It also states that schools must ensure that they make reasonable adjustments to ensure that children with disabilities are not placed at a disadvantage.…
- 3926 Words
- 16 Pages
Better Essays -
But the new schools gave them the ability to go to school and fit in with others like them, making them feel apart of the group. The new schools for the deaf, blind and mentally disabled, helped children to feel apart of society and apart of the…
- 1169 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Student with disabilities are still being encourage to believe that there is still expectation for them to succeed. Students with mild disabilities are in the regular education classroom and learning the same materials other students are learning. In the future Special Education will thrive for the best, because there will be more voices and concern for the privileges of educations. The students will also be allow to have more choices for their education and hopefully the budget and spending will be prosperous for more resources and supplies to give out to the Special needs.…
- 860 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In 2001 the Department for Education released a document stating that parents of children with special educational needs should be supported whether they choose to send their child to a mainstream, or a special school (p.6). In addition to this their document titled Special Educational Needs: Code of Practice, “enhances the rights of children with special educational needs to be included within mainstream schooling” (2001). Collectively, these points imply the government is trying to support parents and children with special educational needs with school…
- 1097 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Segregation based on disabilities is similar to segregation based on race in many ways. The main, and probably most important to be addressed, is treatment. Students, and adults, who have disabilities are often talked down to or treated as children. Many go in with the mindset that the disabled won't understand them or that they aren't smart enough to comprehend a given topic. Sometimes, people even believe that they shouldn't be in school at all because they wouldn't be able to keep up. Most often, disabled students are put into separate classes that are meant specifically just for those that have any sort of disabilities. It is very similar to how we used to separate black and white students in schools. At the time, many believed blacks…
- 164 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Prior to this acknowledgement, more than half of children with disabilities were not receiving an appropriate education, and one million disabled children were denied access to an education in the public school entirely (Altshuler & Kopels, 2003). Although Verstegen (1994) confirmed that some states established schools for students with specific disabilities as early as the 1820s (p. 18), these were separate from the public schools and provoked the segregation of children with disabilities. States continued to pass segregation laws based on the idea that disabled children would not benefit from an education, and allowed children to be turned away from school if they required any special form of transportation (p. 18). These laws highlight the severity of the social problem and the oppression children with disabilities faced. Not only were disabled children not given a chance, but their dignity and worth was completely diminished by the belief of others that they were incapable of becoming a contributing member of society. Eventually, parents of disabled children began to advocate and demand educational rights for their children, arguing that this right should not be provided as a form of charity, but as a civil right (Verstegen,…
- 1504 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Special education teachers use various techniques to promote learning. Depending on the student, teaching methods can include intensive individualized instruction, problem solving assignments, and small group work. When students need special accommodations to learn the general curriculum or to take a test, special education teachers ensure that appropriate accommodations are…
- 1085 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Like any other child, these children with exceptionalities are also a part of our society. Therefore it is important that they get the same opportunities as other children. Sometimes these children are clled Special and are placed in a special education program. However there are some children who never attended school.…
- 1450 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays