Preview

Descartes Fourth Meditation Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1026 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Descartes Fourth Meditation Essay
At the start of Descartes fourth meditation, there are three certainties that Descartes has so far concluded. The first being that god exists. The second that god is not a deceiver. And third that god created him and is therefore responsible for all of his faculties (which includes his faculty of judgment). The first two convictions seem sound enough to Descartes yet the third convict evokes some conflict within him. Descartes speaks about how, if everything within him comes from god, and God did not award him with a faculty for making mistakes, it would appear as if he could never go wrong. This is what is referred to as Descartes problem of error, which motivates Descartes to try and correct the two contradictory statements.

Descartes first
…show more content…
Surely the all-powerful God would not want him to make mistakes? Descartes provides two possible reasons as to why he was created as such. His first being that Gods creations are incomprehensible. His second is that to see the perfection of what god has created you cannot just examine one thing by itself, you have to look at the universe as a …show more content…
Can somebody truly believe in something just because they will to? Descartes states that a persons intellect puts forward ideas or propositions and a persons will can chose whether or not to believe them to be true or false. As an example, if a man was cheating on his wife and the wife had undeniable proof of this, it would seem incorrect that the wife doesn’t believe him to be cheating. It is however possible that she might not change her behavior once she finds this out but that still doesn’t imply that she actually believes that he is not cheating on her. If a person would will their beliefs, it would then make sense that a person’s beliefs would be irrespective of the truth, which would not actually be representative of the reality that we live

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The existence of God has an extreme influence on the majority of philosophical debate and questioning and no more so than with Descartes and his meditations. His meditations and his method of approaching philosophical questioning all derive from a rationalist ideology. Therefore he argues that all humans are thinking beings and have ideas prior to experience due to their intellectual existence and not of a sensual one. His meditations are primarily to dismiss Empiricism and to reveal that doubt is necessary to our life. Perhaps even to warn us of the dangers of our own deceitfulness and not to trust anything forced upon us by our perceptions. That is why God is so important to his meditations; as Descartes believes God is perfect and cannot be deceived and cannot fail us therefore in his trust we do not need to doubt.…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Descartes’s Meditations III, the Meditator describes his idea of God as "a substance that is infinite, eternal, immutable, independent, supremely intelligent, supremely powerful, and which created both myself and everything else."(70) Thus, due to his opinion in regards to the idea of God, the Meditator views God containing a far more objective reality than a formal one. Due to the idea that of God being unable to have originated in himself, he ultimately decides that God must be the cause of the idea, therefore he exists. The meditator defines God as such, “by ‘God’ I mean the very being the idea of whom is within me, that is, the possessor of all the perfections which I cannot grasp, but can somehow reach in my thought, which subject no defects whatsoever.” (70)…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Throughout Meditation One in The Meditation of the First Philosophy, Descartes reflects on a number of falsehoods he has believed throughout his life. He does this to create a system in order to clarify whether they are true or false, so that he can build a basic structure from which future knowledge can be based. This approach is called Method of Doubt. Doubt is defined as a feeling of uncertainty. Descartes opens Mediation One by stating that if he wants to establish information that is firm and lasting in the sciences, he would have to begin from the earliest foundations from which his current knowledge has been built upon. He establishes that the task includes breaking down the components that make up his general knowledge.…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes proves that God exists in his third meditation. He proves that God exists because he wants to be certain about things outside of himself. But, he cannot be certain of these things if he is ignorant about the existence of God. This is because if a supreme God exists, he could cause Descartes to be mistaken in the one avenue to certainty that he has. This avenue is known as clear and distinct perception, and, according to Descartes, it is what is necessary to be certain about a thing. However, a supreme God could easily be deceiving him even when he thinks he is correct as a result of this clear and distinct perception. This is known as the metaphysical doubt. Therefore, to remove this basis for doubt, it is important to Descartes to establish whether this supreme God is capable of deceiving him. But first, he must establish whether this God exists.…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In Descartes’ First Meditation, Descartes’ overall intention is to present the idea that our perceptions and sensations are flawed and should not be trusted entirely. His purpose is to create the greatest possible doubt of our senses. To convey this thought, Descartes has three main arguments in the First Meditation: The dream argument, the deceiving God argument, and the evil demon “or evil genius”. Descartes’ dream argument argues that there is no definite transition from a dream to reality, and since dreams are so close to reality, one can never really determine whether they are dreaming or not. To reinforce that argument, Descartes presents the deceiving God argument. He says that since God is all powerful, then he has the power to deceive us about reality or our dreams. But again, Descartes feels this argument is missing something, which is why he concludes with the evil genius argument. The evil genius argument’s purpose is to tie all these arguments together and strengthen Descartes’ entire argument. The evil genius argument goes like this: God is omnipotent and supremely good, which means God cannot be the one who deceives humans, rather, a separate entity -- an "evil genius, [who is] supremely powerful and clever, who has directed his entire effort at deceiving me" (Descartes 492). By deceiving, I mean tricking humans that their sensations and perceptions are real, when they are indeed not real. To overcome this evil genius, Descartes says he will regard all external things as “hoaxes of my dreams, with which he (the evil genius) lays snares for my credulity” (Descartes 492). In this analysis, I will further discuss Descartes’ arguments in the First Meditation, the purpose of the evil genius argument, how Descartes attempts to overcome the power of this great deceiver, and ultimately why his attempt is…

    • 1451 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Descartes v Hume

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In Meditation I, Descartes reflects on his past beliefs and realizes how so much that he once believed to be true was actually false. To separate what is truth from fiction; Descartes decided to completely reject anything which he can doubt at all. He wrote, “If I am able to find in each some reason to doubt, this will suffice to justify my rejecting the whole” (Descartes 4). The belief that inspired this method was that genuine truth was clear and distinct and that any doubt whatsoever could not provide absolute certainty. In essence, if any component of something was in the very least questionable, then any conclusion drawn from it would be at the most questionable. This method led Descartes to doubt practically everything he once believed, especially knowledge attained through the senses. He wrote, “All that up to the present time I have accepted as most true and…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    After this doubt Descartes reasons that rather than a Deity, it is an evil demon that deceives him. Here he starts to doubt things such as the sky, air, Earth, colors, figures, and sounds. He attributes these to being mere illusions of dreams. By the end of Meditation one, Descartes has doubted his senses, his prospect of reality, God, and an evil demon. All of these things lead him back to where he started at the beginning of his writing. He even states himself that he has “fallen back into the train of my former beliefs.” With this, Descartes has chosen to retreat back under his personal blanket of ignorant…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes and Skepticism

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the Third Meditation, subtitled "On God’s existence," Descartes is certain that he is a “thinking thing” (pg 142) and sets out to prove God’s Existence. There were two major standpoints noted in his argument, though they were found to be closely linked.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Through Descartes first three meditations he arrives at a conclusion that the only things we know with absolute certainty are, that my own thoughts and god exist. He solidifies this stance by two foundational arguments laid out in the first meditation to build off of. I find that these arguments to reach these beliefs to be flawed by Descartes own reasoning and by scientific advancements made since his time. Before I can debate these arguments I need to outline Descartes purpose and reasoning for them. Then I will present my case and justifications on why Descartes process of reaching his beliefs is unconvincing.…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Descartes was a believer in God, but he decided to question everything he knew to find out if he was being deceived or if everything he knew was the truth. Before he proves that he exists, he must doubt everything that he knows. He even contemplates the idea of God being a deceiver because he feels that everything he senses is in someway a lie. He concludes that it is not God that deceives him, but there might be a more powerful “demon” that has the goal of deceiving him. Descartes proposes to himself to not let the demon deceiver win, and to find truth in every aspect of his life, no matter how hard it could be.…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes argues that we often have perceptions in life that seem incredibly obvious and unquestionable, things that surely must be real. Yet at times our senses can deceive us. But why would God deceive us if he is the model of perfection? Instilling a fault from a faultless being doesn’t make sense, as doing such would go against him being as impeccable as he is, unless it isn’t god who is behind this curtain of confusion, but instead a deceiver, a cunning demon causing me to question my own judgements.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his first Meditation, “Meditation 1: Concerning Those Things that Can Be Called Into Doubt”, Descartes focuses on those questions in a person’s life that could cause some doubt in their own life. Descartes had some…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes’ Discourse on Method and Meditations Essay In Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes discusses the existence of God. Descartes believes in God and provides two arguments that support his theory. His supporting evidence is that he possess a clear idea of God and second that any cause must be at least as great as it effect. Descartes convinces the reader hat he believes in God, but not that God exist.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes venture to justify the presence of God, and to institute that only God can warrant certain and true knowledge. Through an analytical observation of the controversy advanced by Descartes in his most outstanding work, Meditations on First Philosophy, respecting the presence of God and the role God partakes in the pursuit of sure knowledge, we are able to clarify that although the intensions of the Cartesian project were praiseworthy, the existence of various philosophical deviations and probable guesswork depleted its legitimacy beyond reconstruction. The formation of the reality of God is absolutely crucial to Descartes’ epistemic project. In the course of Descartes’ approach of methodical disbelief and complete exclusion of the amount…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes wrote Meditation One with the intention of questioning and challenging the beliefs he holds, especially of there being a supreme God, in order for these beliefs to become stronger. The first meditation starts with him recalling the false opinions he had in the past. He seeks to doubt and reevaluate these things, and he also wants to directly attack the foundations that held up his beliefs. He then continues by talking about the senses which may sometimes be deceptive. There are still things, though, that a person cannot doubt even though they are perceived through these senses that may deceive. Descartes then gives an example of himself sitting in front of a fire. He wonders if the hands he sees in front of him and his body are his,…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays