Preview

Descartes Discourse For The Existence Of God

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
652 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Descartes Discourse For The Existence Of God
Descartes’ Discourse on Method and Meditations Essay In Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes discusses the existence of God. Descartes believes in God and provides two arguments that support his theory. His supporting evidence is that he possess a clear idea of God and second that any cause must be at least as great as it effect. Descartes convinces the reader hat he believes in God, but not that God exist. Descartes’ argument fails to be completely convincing because he assumes all people possess the same innate ideas about God and a cause isn't always as great as its effect. Following Meditation II Descartes has established that he is a thinking thing. However, he still possess doubt as to whether or not he is being deceived. …show more content…
He argues that if his ideas “are considered only in themselves, and are not referred to any object beyond them, they cannot, properly speaking, be false.” Everything that Descartes perceives clearly and distinctly, he believes to be true because he is not referring his ideas to anything outside of his mind. Error only arises when “judging that the ideas which are in us are like or conformed to the things that are external to us.” Basically, Descartes believes mistakes happen when one attempts to compare and contrast the idea with external notions, such as already existing beliefs. This argument is flawed because though it proves that Descartes believes in God it does not confirm the existence of God. Descartes believes these ideas to be true solely because they are clear to him and posses infinite objective reality. In “Descartes on Gods Ability to Do the Logically Impossible," La Croix point outs that Descartes’ view of God is “complicated because his account of God’s omnipotence occurs exclusively in his treatment of the Cartesian doctrine that God created the eternal truths.” Descartes only proves that he possess the innate ideas of God. They do not serve a evidence to the existence of …show more content…
Descarates states that he alone could not produce the idea of God because he is “a finite being.” This implies that one’s thoughts are relatively simple, and any complex thoughts must’ve been planted in the mind by a complex being. This leads to the cause and effect argument, according to Descartes, every cause is at least as great as its effect. This argument preposes that infinite ideas must be created by an infinite being. It would be impossible for him to conceive this idea by himself. The idea had to have been produced by an infinite mind. Since Descartes already believes God to be an infinite being, he concludes that in order for the idea of God to exist, God must actually exist. One’s perception of God is “a product of the cave into which one was born.” (Baird 233) Descartes’ two arguments establish that he believes in God. He provided theories and ideas that support his belief that God exist. However, ultimately Descartes’ ignores two critical flaws in his argument that prevent readers from being persuaded. Descartes’ assumes that everyone posses the same innate idea of God and that every initial cause is produced to a divine being. Considering the Descartes’ arguments, one can conclude that Descartes’ beliefs are more rooted in faith than logic. Moreover, faith and logic do not coincide with one another. Referencing the phrase, “leap of faith," the concept

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the Second Meditation, he comes to the strong conclusion of the cogito. “As long as I am thinking, I cannot help but to exist.” This discovery gave Descartes grounds to search for other metaphysical truths. He then continues onto his Third Meditation where he attempts to prove the existence of God. The reason why Descartes sought to prove…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The existence of God has an extreme influence on the majority of philosophical debate and questioning and no more so than with Descartes and his meditations. His meditations and his method of approaching philosophical questioning all derive from a rationalist ideology. Therefore he argues that all humans are thinking beings and have ideas prior to experience due to their intellectual existence and not of a sensual one. His meditations are primarily to dismiss Empiricism and to reveal that doubt is necessary to our life. Perhaps even to warn us of the dangers of our own deceitfulness and not to trust anything forced upon us by our perceptions. That is why God is so important to his meditations; as Descartes believes God is perfect and cannot be deceived and cannot fail us therefore in his trust we do not need to doubt.…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to this principle, the reality of the cause must be greater than or equal to the reality of the effect. The idea of God has infinite reality and, by theory, the only cause of this infinite idea can only be God. With all this said, the reality of God is the only plausible cause to the reality of the idea of God. Descartes gives another proof in Meditation Five where he has reasoned that a triangle must have all the properties he assigns to it, because the triangle exists as an idea in his mind and he clearly and distinctly perceives all these properties. He then reasons, by analogy, that God exists as an idea in his mind and he clearly and distinctly perceives all of his qualities. One of these qualities is existence, so it follows from his clear and distinct perception that God must exist. If existence is the essence of God, then God would not be God if he did not exist, just as a triangle would not be a triangle if it were not three-sided. At the very least, then, the existence of God must be as certain as the properties of mathematical and geometrical objects since he can prove them in the same way. Having concluded that God must necessarily exist, Descartes goes further and then asks how he received the idea of God. He could have not invented the idea. Therefore, the idea must be innate which, according to Descartes, means that God must have created him…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Descartes casts everything into doubt in the first meditation, including God Himself. He then comes to this disproval of this theory therefore concluding that God exists. This is brought about through the causal argument.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes proves that God exists in his third meditation. He proves that God exists because he wants to be certain about things outside of himself. But, he cannot be certain of these things if he is ignorant about the existence of God. This is because if a supreme God exists, he could cause Descartes to be mistaken in the one avenue to certainty that he has. This avenue is known as clear and distinct perception, and, according to Descartes, it is what is necessary to be certain about a thing. However, a supreme God could easily be deceiving him even when he thinks he is correct as a result of this clear and distinct perception. This is known as the metaphysical doubt. Therefore, to remove this basis for doubt, it is important to Descartes to establish whether this supreme God is capable of deceiving him. But first, he must establish whether this God exists.…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    When Descartes decided to tear down his beliefs and start fresh, he needed a foundation upon which to build his ideology. When judging what reality is, God must be considered. He/she must be taken out of a religious concept and proven to exist, exist in a way in which we cannot be deceived into only thinking is real. The proof of the existence of God in this way forms the backbone of Descartes’ further forays into proving what is reality.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Descartes Meditation Iii

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the "Mediations of First Philosophy" Descartes tries to prove the existence of God in the third meditation. He does this by coming up with several premises that eventually add up to a solid argument. First, I will explain why Descartes ask the question, does god exist? And why does Descartes think he needs such and argument at this point in the text. Secondly, I will explain, in detail, the arguments that Descartes makes and how he comes to the conclusion that God does exist. Next, I will debate some of Descartes premises that make his argument an unsound one, including circular reasoning. Finally, I will see if his unsound argument has diminished and undermined his principal goals and the incorrigible foundation of knowledge.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Cartesian Circle

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages

    At first glance, it seems that Descartes has blatantly committed a logical fallacy, leaving his argument entirely defenseless. However, if it were be possible to disprove one of his two premises, any notions of circularity would be dissolved, legitimizing Descartes’ proof. The first defense takes a deeper look into Descartes’ writings in order to disprove his first premise, that God is an essential and necessary component for the formation of knowledge from a perception.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Descartes believed that God must exist because God alone could conceive of the idea of infinite goodness. He briefly considered the idea that God might be an evil genius or a deceiver, but he concluded that this was not the case. His idea of God is like Anselm’s in that he believes that God is a perfect and infinite being. Additionally, Descartes uses some ideas in his arguments which are like those of Aquinas regarding the casual principles of the arguments. The first way Descartes attempts to proves God’s existence is by starting with the idea that God is a perfect being.…

    • 1860 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Through Descartes first three meditations he arrives at a conclusion that the only things we know with absolute certainty are, that my own thoughts and god exist. He solidifies this stance by two foundational arguments laid out in the first meditation to build off of. I find that these arguments to reach these beliefs to be flawed by Descartes own reasoning and by scientific advancements made since his time. Before I can debate these arguments I need to outline Descartes purpose and reasoning for them. Then I will present my case and justifications on why Descartes process of reaching his beliefs is unconvincing.…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Descartes was a believer in God, but he decided to question everything he knew to find out if he was being deceived or if everything he knew was the truth. Before he proves that he exists, he must doubt everything that he knows. He even contemplates the idea of God being a deceiver because he feels that everything he senses is in someway a lie. He concludes that it is not God that deceives him, but there might be a more powerful “demon” that has the goal of deceiving him. Descartes proposes to himself to not let the demon deceiver win, and to find truth in every aspect of his life, no matter how hard it could be.…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Firstly, Descartes in the third meditation sets out to prove that God does indeed exist. To begin with, he considered that the source of an idea must be as real as the idea itself. He thought that since his idea of God had overwhelmingly unlimited content, then the one who caused the idea must be infinite and that it must be god, and thus asserted that what is more perfect cannot arise from what is imperfect. In his conclusion, Descartes says that God is a substance that is omnipotent, omniscient, independent and infinite. He argued that if the objective reality of an idea could not come from him, then it could have come from something else. The basis for the arguments he put forward lies in the…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Based on Jennifer Nagel’s Knowledge: A Very Short Introduction (33–36), Descartes argues that our senses must be trustworthy because ideas that are innate to us, but defective, would not have been built into us by a God that is perfect (36). He shows this by first arguing for the existence of God, and from there he deduces that all of our clear and distinct ideas are innate and entirely trustworthy (36). By proving that all of our clear and distinct ideas are caused by God and that God is an infinite and perfect (non-deceptive) being, Descartes believes that he will be able to show that all of our clear and distinct ideas are entirely trustworthy. So he begins by proving the existence of God. The argument, in deductively valid form, could be…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the start of Descartes fourth meditation, there are three certainties that Descartes has so far concluded. The first being that god exists. The second that god is not a deceiver. And third that god created him and is therefore responsible for all of his faculties (which includes his faculty of judgment). The first two convictions seem sound enough to Descartes yet the third convict evokes some conflict within him.…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    His argument that God cannot create an error because he is good, and that he is source of all good, is undoubtedly a weak one. He also fails to see possibility that God may not have created everything that exists, and that evil could play a big role in it. It seems to me that all positive and good comes from God, but evil comes from us. Additionally, he is convinced that God exists because he can clearly and distinctly perceive that idea, but he can trust his clear and distinct idea because he knows that God exists. In conclusion, Descartes arguments seem very convincing at first, but after detailed analysis, it still remains unclear, which leaves problem of error…

    • 2028 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays