Many countries in Africa have governments that do not perform up to the required standards resulting in economic crises. Neo-liberals and International Financial Institutions maintain that this consequently arises from state intervention . Personally I believe state intervention is necessary for sustainable development, equitable distribution of scarce resources and eventually peace and stability. To procure all these, the state has to shoulder various developmental roles. The World Bank identified in its report on development five fundamental tasks of a government. They are as quoted by Owen Hughes:
“(1) establishing a foundation of law, (2) maintaining a non-depository policy environment, including macroeconomic stability; (3) investing in basic social services and infrastructure; (4) protecting the vulnerable and (5) protecting the environment.” (2003:89) Hughes argues that these roles are not the basic roles of a minimal state but rather sees them as necessary for markets to appreciate what the government does. He goes on to identify yet another set of seven general functions of government as set out by Anderson James (1989) which include providing economic infrastructure, provision of various collective goods and services, the resolution and adjustment of group conflicts, the maintenance of competition, protection of natural resources, minimum access by individuals to the goods and services of the economy and stabilization of the economy. In this paper I will identify and discuss four developmental roles of the state as stated by Mr. Molaodi, a lecturer of Public Administration at the University of Botswana and incorporate into them Anderson’s government functions stated above.
ROLES OF THE STATE IN A DEVELOPING COUNTRY
The first role that a state in a developing country must obtain as quoted by Mr. Molaodi is the development agent role. Here the state focuses on defining national strategic goals for the development of the country. The state comes together with political parties, the executive, Non-Governmental Organizations, Ministers and other important groups of people to come up with these goals as well as how they are going to be achieved. Implementation is usually done through the bureaucracy or public servants. For example, the national condom strategy and implementation plan is carried out by the Ministry of Health in Botswana.
The state as a development agent also analyzes alternatives and ranks choices on the basis of resource availability. This is to say that the state decides on what should be done first looking at the available resources and the importance of alternatives. For instance the state may decide to build a school at Bonwapitse village instead of a clinic on the basis that the clinic will need nurses and doctors whom the country of Botswana is running short of and therefore it would be better to educate children of Bonwapitse as they are the future nurses and doctors of that village. Also building a clinic is more costly than building a school. While the structure of a school is limited to classrooms and a staffroom, the clinical structure may require a male ward, female ward, dispensary unit, a delivery unit, a laboratory and many more. Therefore, the state may decide that whoever may need services of a health worker at a time where there is no clinic in Bonwapitse may visit those in surrounding areas such as Kalamare and Shoshong health posts. The state also ranks choices looking at their level of importance. For instance the state might decide to build a bridge before extending the structures of a school and extend a school before refurbishing the council offices.
Under this role, the state also takes up national development planning guided by national principles and political values. This is where national development plans (NDPs) are created with the purpose of guiding the overall development of the country. NDPs contain government strategies to be followed in the development process, programs and projects to be implemented for the achievement of such strategies and the estimates of expected revenue and expenditure(Government of Botswana). As already stated, national development planning is guided by national principles and in Botswana these principle are Democracy, Development, Self-reliance, Unity and Botho. When coming up with a development plan, each of these principles has to be taken into consideration for the smooth governing of Botswana. Other functions of the state as a development agent include analyzing clientele attachment and reaction to chosen policies, ensuring organizational adaptability to changing development results and challenges as well as providing the institutional framework for development being the organizational structures and their functional relevance.
The second role that a state assumes is the entrepreneur role. Here the state takes responsibility of injecting capital finance for investment since investment is an ideal structure of development. This is done through public finance which relates to the taxing and spending activities of the government. Public finance includes money raised from a variety of sources by the state. These would include taxes, sales, lotteries, charges, borrowing and many more. Stabilization of the economy is a function that also falls under this role of state. Fluctuations in the alternating increases and decreases in the level of economic activity require state intervention where the state may use the budget, monetary policy or control over wages or prices to alleviate such fluctuations .
Public and private sectors are not mutually exclusive, they should be partners. As an entrepreneur, the state determines the extent of public/private partnerships in the chase for efficiency, effectiveness and equity. With these concepts at hand,the state may privatize any public institution which would perform utterly well in the private sector. This is so because the private sector is profit oriented and therefore presents high standards of efficiency, effectiveness and equity as compared to the public sector which serves to render services to the public without any profit.
The third role is that of a controller/regulator.The state should be able to create an appropriate and conducive legal environment. Justice is a concept that should never be compromised for anything. In his book, John Rawls summarizes justice in the following manner,
“Justice is the first virtue of social institutions, as truth is of systems of thought. A theory however elegant and economical must be rejected or revised if it is untrue, likewise laws and institutions no matter how efficient and well-arranged must be reformed or abolished if they are unjust.”(1971:3)
The state ensures that the development process is “guided and supported within the framework of rights as defined by the African Charter on Human and Peoples ' Rights adopted by the Organization of the African Unity (OAU) in 1981”. Freedom from discrimination, oppression and exploitation are some of the rights defined.
The state also needs to maintain competition particularly in the private sector. This is basically for the protection of the economically weak from the economically strong because “in the absence of regulation, companies would be able to form cartels, restrict access to their products and fix prices.” .
The fourth role of the state in a developing country is that of the state as an assurer of individual and group rights. This is in relation to accessibility, participation and control. The state should be able to identify and define the clientele composition of various development programs, indicate who takes part in the programs and clearly state who the main decision makers are at various levels of the development structure. For example the youth grant policy in Botswana is mainly accessible to Botswana citizens of 18-35 years who have finished their studies and are unemployed.
The state is responsible for the resolution and adjustment of group conflicts “in pursuance of justice, order and stability.” . In the instance of the taxation process in Botswana, the taxing strategy is such that those who earn large amounts of income pay a considerable percentage of tax that is not equal to those who earn less income. If the tax percentage was fixed across all income classes, then it would mean that the high income class pays less tax as compared to the middle and low class income. This could actually cause an upheaval from the low income class thus the need for government intervention in such issues.
CONCLUSION
The state assumes many different roles as seen in the preceding paragraphs. These roles include amongst others the state as a development agent. In this role the state has to provide the institutional framework for development, define national strategic goals for the development of a country and create national development plans guided by national principles and political values.
REFERENCES
BOTSWANA GOVERNMENT (n.d.). MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND DEVELOPMENT PLANNING. Retrieved SEPTEMBER 20, 2013, from GOVERNMENT OF BOTSWANA: HTTP://WWW.GOV.BW
Hughes, O. E. (2003). Public Management & Administration: An Introduction. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Hwedi, O. (2001). The State & Development in Southern Africa: A Comparative Analysis of Botswana & Mauritius with Angola, Malawi & Zambia. Retrieved September 20, 2013, from African Studies Quarterly: http://web.africa.ufl.edu/asq/v5/v5i2a2.htm
Lumumba-Kasongo, T. (2002). Reconceptualizing the State as the Leading Agent of Development in the Context of Globalization in Africa. African Journal of Political Science .
Rawls, J. (1971). A Theory of Justice. New York: Belknap Press of Havard University.
References: BOTSWANA GOVERNMENT (n.d.). MINISTRY OF FINANCE AND DEVELOPMENT PLANNING. Retrieved SEPTEMBER 20, 2013, from GOVERNMENT OF BOTSWANA: HTTP://WWW.GOV.BW Hughes, O. E. (2003). Public Management & Administration: An Introduction. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Hwedi, O. (2001). The State & Development in Southern Africa: A Comparative Analysis of Botswana & Mauritius with Angola, Malawi & Zambia. Retrieved September 20, 2013, from African Studies Quarterly: http://web.africa.ufl.edu/asq/v5/v5i2a2.htm Lumumba-Kasongo, T. (2002). Reconceptualizing the State as the Leading Agent of Development in the Context of Globalization in Africa. African Journal of Political Science . Rawls, J. (1971). A Theory of Justice. New York: Belknap Press of Havard University.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Edgerton, Robert B. The Troubled Heart of Africa. 1st ed. New York: St. Martin 's P, 2002.…
- 2151 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
[ 7 ]. Ndulo, Muna. "The Democratization Process and Structural Adjustment in Africa." Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 10.1 (2003): 315-367. Web. 16 Mar 2010.…
- 2758 Words
- 12 Pages
Best Essays -
We all know Africa is a poor, underdeveloped country, especially compared to rich, highly developed countries like America or Europe. Despite that fact, Africa is on the rise, thanks to globalization. According to a recent article by The Epoch Times, of the world’s fastest growing economies, 5 of the top 12 and 11 of the top 20 are now in Africa. The globalization of technology in Africa is making the continent more connected to the rest of the world economically, politically, and socially. Globalization of democratic governmental practices (democracy, neoliberalism, etc.) are transforming African governments into positive, sustainable governments. A sustained world commodity price increase and globalization of African commodities have also had a great impact on economic growth.…
- 614 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
By understanding what went wrong in the Congo’s case, we can apply what and why to avoid forming more weak states. Samuels credits the difference between Botswana, a successful African state, to Zimbabwe, a disaster similar to the Congo, to “diamonds, civil war and political leadership” (Samuels 49). Through the corruption and exploitation of natural resources, the Congo’s profits were never returned back to the people. Unlike Botswana, the Congo’s post-independence government failed to use the natural resources, like diamond, to improve infrastructure and stabilize the interior of their nation. Through a poor legacy from the colonial government, the Congo was not equipped with enough educated people nor the self-sustaining intuitions to govern themselves. The lack of qualified political leadership contributed to their failures and perpetuation of a weak state. And finally, because the Congo started as a weak state internally, it opened opportunities for external violence to invade as well as civil war. The lack of enforced borders leads to violence destroying infrastructure and stealing valuable potential income. By understanding these factors, today’s new states can learn how to avoid these pitfalls and the international community can…
- 970 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
By attributing less agency to poor African countries than other poor countries, it ignores those communities’ political and economic success stories. When a country in the West believes they know what is best for a country outside of their own, it is not only not true usually, but it diminishes the assistance that they are trying to offer. The interference of paternalism is justified by saying that the group will be better off because of it, but as we can see from the past, it is rarely true and an idea that those in the West must work hard to re-contextualize their understanding of countries outside of the West to fit with their true…
- 1140 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The countries of Mozambique, Mali, Eritrea, Ghana, Uganda, Benin, Botswana, Ethiopia, Ivory Coast, and Tanzania are trying to find new ways to stabilize the human and natural resources that are so important. They are trying to make models of development despite the crumbling of the other countries. With the hard work that these countries have put forth, they are building a nation based on the prosperity and the security that they are willing to work hard for, and building a nation based on political and economic advances.…
- 419 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
At the beginning of this paper, I tried to define development and either way you look at it, the leaders in Sub Saharan Africa have in many occasions got the development agenda wrong for their countries. For instance let us assume that their intention was to create wealth even without minding so much about the well being of the citizens, in many instances such wealth is often created for individuals and not the country. An example would be the Golden Berg scandal that rocked Kenya in the…
- 933 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Online dating is a which allows individuals, couples and groups to make contact and communicate with each other over the Internet, usually with the objective of developing a personal, romantic, or sexual relationship. Match making occurs over the Internet using computers or cellphones.…
- 1706 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Bibliography: Vision 2016 Council (Bots) National Stakeholders Conference (2010) Welcome to Botswana Vision 2016, [online], www.vision2016.co.bw (accessed on 01 October)…
- 518 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Hall, R. & Peyman, H (1976). The Great Uhuru Railway: China’s Showpiece in Africa. New York: Gollacz Salvaterra, N. (2012), « U.S. Aims to Lift Investment in Africa », The Wall Street Journal [Online], Available: http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/ SB10000872396390443517104577573152210348294 Nunn, A. & Price, S. (2004) « Managing Development: EU and African Relations through the Evolution of the Lome and Cotonou Agreements », Historical Materialism 12. Nyere, J. (1974), Freedom and Development. Dar Es Salaam: Oxford University Press.…
- 2246 Words
- 8 Pages
Best Essays -
Since independence African states like Tanzania have sought to use macroeconomic policy to pursue economic development to meet their own agendas as independent states (Mkandawire, 2004, p295). States sought to assert their new status in the world whilst raising living standards for their people. The states’ ability to exhibit autonomy of action has been limited by the realities of their starting point, and world economic events, sustaining trade deficits influencing their actions.…
- 2806 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
1. It has been observed that, “the basis of the modern African state is the colonial state.” In what ways is this so and how has the reality impacted efforts to achieve political stability, democracy, and development in post-colonial Africa?…
- 1265 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The state can be seen as a concept which has emerged over thousands of years in order to sustain the needs of societies growing in size and complexity. This growth in size and complexity was coupled with the growing need for authority and order, due to special mechanisms being needed for society to benefit from its increased social power and productive capacity (Petho, 2010:6). State formation passes through stages of development and hinges upon ecological, demographic, economic and political factors (Petho, 2010:2). As a result of this, not all states developed in the same way. States which developed prior to 1945 and post-1945 experienced very different state formation as well as a changed economic environment (Spruyt, 2007:223;25). This literature review will aim to analyse the literature covering the way in which the modern state is defined as well as the two theories which discuss how it came to prominence as we know it today, additionally reference will be made to how the modern state differs from the post-colonial state in Africa.…
- 2595 Words
- 8 Pages
Best Essays -
The reason for why governments play a bigger role in developing countries is because of how they handle conflicts of the citizens. Developed countries compared to developing countries, people in rural areas lack of access to health care, education, food and shelter, hence, the role of the government is more important in this situation. However, there are responsibilities that both government and citizens should have in a country. For example, securing the citizens’ well being should be the government’s utmost priority and it’s the citizens’ responsibility to respect the government to some extent. For example, they should respect the rules and regulations of the country, such as paying taxes regularly. However, the relationship between the government and the citizens starts to fall apart when both parties don’t agree on same thing. For example, during the Syria Civil War, President Bashar al-Assad responded to this conflict by harming the citizens since it was more like a war between the government and the citizens. There was a huge raise in the number of death tolls, injured people and refugees. This proved that sometimes governments take advantage of their power without thinking about the consequences of overusing their…
- 1356 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
In the first turn of the 20th Century, Africa was reconfigured by widespread political regimes and repackaging of power blocs across the African continent triggered by the implosion of the former communist regimes, increased pace of globalization, the triumphalism of western liberal democracy, and increasingly assertive civil institutions. This has raised political issues such as, Why is opposition weak in Africa? Has Africa reached the TINA mode vis-à-vis globalization and liberal globalization? or Are there any new leaders in Africa or it is just old wine in new bottles? Despite a capitalistic economy, Ethiopia has adopted the Dominant Party State model of China, Taiwan and North Korea which is communist in its orientation where opposition politik is generally criminalized. The UNDP Report purports that,…
- 1157 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays