Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Did the New England Puritans Live Up to Their Idealized Vision of a Structured Community?

Good Essays
449 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Did the New England Puritans Live Up to Their Idealized Vision of a Structured Community?
Personally, I think that the New England Puritans did live up to their vision of a community for a certain amount of time. I feel this way because they did in fact have a set of rules that mostly everyone followed. Also, they had a set form of government to follow, and over time they realized what it took to survive in the Chesapeake area.

The Puritans had a very specific opinion on what they valued. This happened to be religion, and they agreed to live in a community that had those values in common. So, they started a colony that followed this example. However, if you are going to have a community, you must have leaders to make decisions. These were the religious leaders, who were also the political leaders. In this new government that they had created, they needed a set of rules that everyone must abide by. The religious leaders were very well respected, as well as listened to, so, therefore, this situation created a Theocracy (a government in which religion is the main motivation, and the religious leaders are also political leaders). This is very important because most colonies that were attempted at this time ended up failing due a lack of a set of rules. These colonies did not have a structured government! An example, in Jamestown, (the suggested destination of the Puritans), starved to death because they had no source of food. There was no leader to make decisions or create rules.

The Puritans had a set form of rules that mostly everyone followed. This made sure to keep organization, arrangement and order in the Massachusetts Bay Colony. The people of this colony understood what was necessary to make everything flow, and what they should do to avoid catastrophe. One member of the colony said, “We shall be as a city on a hill” The people thought this meant that they had to spread His word and become the best and most powerful colony in the world if they wanted to make Him glorified. These set rules kept a structure to the colony. All these rules were successful until Roger Williams wrote “The Bloody Tenet of Christian Persecution” in 1644. This document caused people in the colony to question the set rules.

Lastly, the Puritans’ work ethic was successful for the first four years. They had established peace and organization for the most part. Other colonies expected the work that the Puritans were doing to be done for them. Sure, they got riches and power, but the Puritans’ learned the more difficult way. These reasons prove that the Puritans lived up to their idealized vision of community and why they were successful.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Plymouth: Plymouth was a colony settled by Pilgrims who were religious separatists. They migrated to America to maintain their English identity. Since they didn't have a royal charter, they created the Mayflower Compact. It was essentially the first American constitution. The Puritans created a political structure that highlighted their self-governing and religious attitudes. They were religiously tolerant, and they became a vibrant and healthy community. Over time, their colony grew, so they created a legal code, which formed a representative self-government, political rights, and religious freedom. This created a stable democratic political foundation for the colony.…

    • 3439 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In coming to the New World, the New England Puritans had great expectations in numerous ways. Their idealized vision of America was some sort of a Utopia, as an opposite to their troubled society in England. They dreamed of a land with no wars, much wealth and power, and freedom to practice whichever religion they chose, (although, quite ironically, they attempted to force Puritanism upon everyone). In these ways, the New England Puritans lived up mostly up to their expectations, with a few faults here or there.…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the 1630`s to the 1660`s the Puritans had a frat influence on the New England colonies. Puritans were protestants that arose within the Church of England. They demanded to have a greater and more rigorous discipline and were not satisfied with what the Church of England offered.They separated themselves from the Church of England but still considered themselves from the Church of England. when their desires were not fulfilled they left to settle in the Americas.Many spread throughout the colonies and settled in places like New Hampshire and Rhode Island. The Puritans made an impact on the political, economical, and the social development of New England colonies through the 1630`s and the 1660`s.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mr. Quincy Hunter

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Massachusetts’s sole purpose was for the Puritans to escape from religious persecution. Puritans searched far and wide for a place to settle until they found Plymouth Rock. They started their colony on a much larger scale than any other colony with one thousand people. Massachusetts was the first permanent settlement for Puritans, but it was the West Indies that attracted more Puritans due to the great climate and fertile soil. John Winthrop was Massachusetts’s first governor and he too was also part of the Great Migration. The Puritans of the Bay colony thought that they were to be the model that God sought for all mankind. Winthrop thought that democracy was the cruelest form of government because he said, “If the people be governors, who shall be governed.” Although Puritans were viewed as extremely harsh and intolerable, they enjoyed the simple pleasures such as eating plenty, drinking often, and making love frequently.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Unhappy with the Church of England, the Puritans traveled all the way to the New World to create a society based solely on their religion. Their goals in this endeavor were to establish settlements in which they were governed by Puritanical religious scriptures and in which no other religion was practiced. As opposed to having laws and a proper Constitution as the United States now has, their law was to be strictly based upon the guidance of God. In their eyes, this would provide a safe place to practice their religion exactly as they wished and it would allow them to integrate their spirituality into the very backbone of the society. Though this seemed like the perfect type of society, it was flawed in several ways. The Puritans’ plan of…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Puritans were passionate reformers seeking to bring the Church of England to a state of purity in comparison with Christianity at the time of Christ and decided to form their own religious colonies in America. They considered religion to be a complex and highly intellectual affair. Thus, leaders were highly trained scholars with authoritarian positions that developed a “built-in hierarchism” (http://xroads.virginia.edu/%7eCAP/PURITAN/purhist.html#pil, 3). Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson believed and preached “Individualisme”…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    England in the 1620s was filled with tension between the Puritans and King James I and his son Charles I. Their primary goal for their country was to revive Roman Catholicism and rid of any religions that would not conform; so, they mainly targeted Puritans. This intolerance motivated the Puritans to pursue their economic interests (which later turned into religious interests) and establish a place for themselves in the New England colonies in 1630. What they originally intended was to create a colony in which they could practice their religion freely. They did not think of accepting others. Eventually, their society became just as strict as English society: their political, social, and economic advancements were structured and very much parochial.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A large number of Puritan merchants obtained a grant of land for Massachusetts and New Hampshire, and acquired a charter form the king to create the Massachusetts Bay Company. This meant that Massachusetts and New Hampshire were part of a Charter Colony—supported by a Company instead of the crown. A large migration of 17 ships and 1,000 people set sail for New England for one reason: to build a Puritan refuge. Their main goal was religious freedom instead of economic gain; the Puritans only wanted freedom from the crown. They elected John Winthrop as governor, and soon established several towns within New England. The Puritans were hard working people. They believed that their work ethic led to material success, which was evidence of God’s favor. Because of this, the Puritan settlers were quick to establish farms and set up communities based on family and hard work. They had a rough beginning, as well, but nowhere near as bad as Jamestown. Their belief in building a “city upon a hill” inspired the community to stay close to God and family. This dominance of families caused a feeling of commitment to the community and a sense of order among settlers. However, Massachusetts Bay was a theocracy- meaning there was no separation between church and state. The Puritans had no more religious freedom than they had in England. This just encouraged them to work even harder for the betterment of the…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    But if to observe this issue from the Native American perspective, we would definitely notice that the practices of Puritans were extremely intimidating and they significantly damaged the authentic American culture. Therefore, such change would only mean the total revision of moral and family values among Indians who could sacrifice their traditions, culture, religion and language, beginning to live in European style. Some scientists even speculate that Puritans were intended to use their practices in order to strengthen their control over the densely inhabited area. Through the establishment of a colony and through the implementation of their Puritanism, they wanted the native population to accept all their obligations and to feel positive about their colonization. The Puritans did not have the moral right to mix religion with politics. The creation of colony implied the use of power and control for social order. Nowhere in the Bible has one seen such things. And this is one more evidence to state that Puritans failed to build their “City upon a Hill” or their ideal society. They failed to realize the Bible itself and the words of Jesus. None of the Puritans denied himself, none of them was peaceful and none was intended to help, caring exclusively about personal…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    It is clear that the Puritans values and ideas helped shape the New England colonies through their strict leadership in church, the economy, the community, and the…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Puritans had a religious leader, John Winthrop who became governor and their political leader as well. As a result, in the colony, religion and politics were the same. Laws came from religious ways and beliefs. An example is when Anne Hutchinson was against some beliefs of the Puritans, saying that God had a personal relationship with people who were not in politics or church, and that God’s favor and love were stronger than laws, they kicked her out of the colony. Her followers were “those against the law” – Antinomians. To repeat, the state did not allow her beliefs, because it was the same as the Puritan church. This relationship between the church and religion was becoming a bigger and bigger problem and because of that, Roger Williams wanted to separate the church and the state. Roger Williams established Rhode Island colony, and it was the first one to separate the state and the Church. Because of this separation of religion and politics, people were now able to practice, in any colony, their beliefs, which, as a result was used in the Constitution of the United States of America. So this union between the church and government shows the strong influence of religion on the development of…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In America today, many of us are motivated by vague ideas like the “American Dream”, but the 1600’s equivalent to that were the Puritan values. The Puritan way of life is one was influential, and essential in the development of the New England colonies. Puritans in the New England colonies were hard working and held themselves to a high moral obligation to be a good influence on those around them, this influenced all aspects of colonial life from politics to economy to society as a whole because it made the Puritans try to be the best at everything they did. Politically, Puritan beliefs defined a social hierarchy and limited church and government authority. Economically, Puritan beliefs led people to be less lazy in an attempt to better themselves,…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Once they got to Massachusetts, the Puritans were allowed to make their own laws. There was a meeting house at the center of each Puritan village. At the meeting house, the men of the…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Eight Puritan men signed off to 4 rules, the introduction being, “We whose names are underwritten, being God’s providence engaged together to make a plantation… do mutually agree to certain articles and orders to be observed and kept by us and by our successors…” The plantation had to be added into this specifically because in Massachusetts, and the starting of America, there were a lot of men who owned fields that grew crops and that was how they lived their lives, and what they based their wealth off of. One of the rules was, “That everyone shall have a share of the meadow or planting ground…” This was a way so no one would become poor or die from not making a wealth in their life. From it becoming a rule, it was something you had to obey which caused for a man or women to not get left behind.…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most people today do not believe that Puritans had the right idea about how we should live our lives; however there are advantages to having Puritan views and values such as religious peace and a close knit community.…

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays