From the onset Joan Didion explicitly denounces the 'comfortable ' and 'happy ' lifestyles of the turn of the last century 's industrial rich as she takes us beyond the 'handwrought gates ' of their Newport, Rhode Island mansions to expose an ugly, harsh reality that she sees as born from the very belly of industrial pits,rails and foundries. An ugliness that permeates from the underworld and taints the air of the island and therefore all that should inhabit 'The Seacoast of Despair '. Didion successfully puts us in this under world and despite all its gilded trappings this Newport remains but that, ...a gilded trap or cage for the women of the industrial rich as the women serve to add to the aesthetics that mechanically states we are 'comfortable ' and 'happy ' here at Newport.(Didion, 1993, pp10-12)
In this essay Didion 's style strays away from merely reporting the facts as it informs by engaging us with a narrative that allows us to experience the situation via an intimate dialogue with the author allowing her to give of her opinion thereby introducing a subjective approach to her work.
' ... and Newport is a monument to a society in which production was seen as the moral point, the reward if not exactly the end, of the economic process. '...(Didion, 1993, p10)
In re-presenting the reality of Newport as experienced by her, Didion, effectively adopts a cultural interest in the lives and experiences of its inhabitors via the literary practice known as New Journalism. (Wolfe, 1974, p9) It is this literary exploration into the cultural values and experiences of the Bellevue Avenue residents of Newport that would make Didion 's work of interest to those in the field of Cultural Studies especially as she affords us a parallel between the women of Newport and the women of the Western Frontier. '...Newport is curiously Western,..”Didion begins and then goes on to add, “...And like the Frontier, not much of a game for women.” (Didion, 1993, p12) Here, she has placed the the two 'women ' side by side inviting us to probe more deeply behind the 'handwrought gate ', beyond the, 'filigreed gazebos... ' to see the Newport women as she does, nothing more than a prize to adorn their men 's domain...a 'happy ' ordament put out for display to attest to her man 's successful and 'comfortable ' life.(Didion, 1993, pp10-11) Didion goes further to expose the raw yet fragile connections of these two women as she depicts the island much as we might expect someone to describe the Western Frontier.
“...the island is physically ugly, mean without the saving grace of extreme severity, a landscape less to be enjoyed than to be dominated... ..A contemplation of “Rosecliff” dissolves into the image of Big Jim Fair, digging the silver out of a mountain in Nevada so that his daughter might live in Newport..” (Didion, 1993, p11)
Like the 'island ' the Western Frontier was also a landscape that men felt a need to dominate ..and so men did...try, at first with agriculture and buildings, then as gold and silver fever took hold mines were carved into the earth leaving scars and embellishments and to transport these earth 's offerings industries were born to fuel men 's dream of domination in the form of the Industrial Revolution and Newport, “...its logical extreme...”(Didion, 1993, p10) Didion sees that men, by hard work or other means, accumulate dominance over the landscape and success by measure of their fortune and assets. They then grant their chosen women the privilege of living in their Castle albeit homestead or mansion and yet as proposed by Didion, happiness remains elusive to them.
To equate the destructive domination of the landscape with the subsequent destruction of the main character/s is a thematic technique within the literature discipline, one that Didion utilises to bring what she sees as the ills of society to our attention...(Blom, 1999, p 172). As Didion refers us to the mean and ugly landscape and an air that...”proclaims only the source of money” (Didion, 1993, p11) so too does D.H.Lawrence in his 'Lady Chatterley 's Lover ' when he writes of the, “...utter soulless ugliness of the coal-and -iron Midlands ...the house was full of the stench of this sulphureous combustion of the earth 's excrement.” (Lawrence, 1993, p13) Lawrence 's Lady, Connie, arrives at Wragby, the ancestral Chatterley home that lords over the mining village of Tevershall. Gradually, the once voluptuous Connie has her vitality smothered in her, her life force drained by the very mines that supply her household with the means by which to live. The environment steals into the rooms of her home and her life and she soon finds herself feeling dis-connected, ill and as sterile as her husband. Although Connie is the Lady of the Manor, “...she felt she was living underground.” captive with no apparent escape nor will to,(Lawrence, 1993 p13)
“...Well, there it was: fated, like the rest of things!...but why kick? You couldn 't kick it away. It just went on. Life, like all the rest!” (Lawrence, 1993, p13)
As with Connie, so too with the women of Newport and the West as Didion concludes,
“...They could be cajoled, flattered, indulged, given pretty rooms and Worth dresses, allowed to imagine that they ran their own lives, but when it came time to negotiate, their freedom proved trompe l 'oeil.” (Didion, 1993, p12)
Upon reading “The Seacoast of Despair”, and experiencing Didion 's literary non fiction treatment of Newport, I was immediately reminded of the writings of D.H.Lawrence, in particular his, “Lady Chatterley 's Lover” Both authors allow us to to see through their eyes what they perceive as the hidden menace that consumes and masters the lives of those that 'live ' upon their page. Both have their women trapped within an underworld tainted by money making mine pits, 'a consumption ethic ' that is 'devoid ' of a true 'connection 'to themselves, other people and, therefore, '...devoid of the pleasure principle ' (Didion, 1993, p10)
Bibliography
Blom M.B, 1999, Stories of Old: the Crisis of Historical Symbology in the 1970 's, vol 106, Uppsala University.
Didion J, 1993, The Seacoast of Despair, in Slouching towards Bethlehem, Flamigo, London.
Lawrence D.H, 1993, Lady Chatterley 's Lover, Cambridge University Press. Cambridge, UK.
Wolfe T, 1974, “The New Journalism”, (online). Available from: www.answers.com/topic/joan-didion 14/04/2010
Bibliography: Blom M.B, 1999, Stories of Old: the Crisis of Historical Symbology in the 1970 's, vol 106, Uppsala University. Didion J, 1993, The Seacoast of Despair, in Slouching towards Bethlehem, Flamigo, London. Lawrence D.H, 1993, Lady Chatterley 's Lover, Cambridge University Press. Cambridge, UK. Wolfe T, 1974, “The New Journalism”, (online). Available from: www.answers.com/topic/joan-didion 14/04/2010
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The author of this essay uses the literary element of description well. He is able to pull his audience into the event with him. Through his use of concrete words and description, he is…
- 221 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Reilly, Deborah. The Cairns Collection of American Women Writers, 1620-1900: A Guide and Working List. [Madison]: University of Wisconsin--Madison, 1984. 8+. Print.…
- 2538 Words
- 73 Pages
Powerful Essays -
At first glance, Dr. Brenda DoHarris’ Calabash Parkway appears to be a novel about a Guyanese woman meeting an old friend from her native land, in New York, after several years. Upon further reading, the novel has resilient records of feminism in the protagonists Agatha, Evadne, and Gwennie. The three are emasculated by poverty, neglect, and abuse. Living in a masculinized country the three women refuse to succumb to their struggles of life. These powerless characteristics of the three young women are overcome after immigrating to New York and Canada.…
- 2017 Words
- 9 Pages
Better Essays -
In the article “To Finish What’s Begun’: Anne Bradstreet’s Last Words”, the author depicts the personal and professional events of one of the world’s cherished poets Anne Bradstreet, who was concerned with finishing her writing during the seventeenth century. A time when women were viewed as being inferior to men and a woman’s role was limited to being a house wife. Bradstreet challenged that notion by rebelling both openly and covertly against her male-dominated culture (Kopacz). Despite her successes, Bradstreet endured hardship in the early period of her life when her family sailed to America. The experience was traumatizing, and the harsh conditions during the journey were different from the library she was used to at home.…
- 519 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
[ 1 ]. F. Kleiner. Gardner’s Art Through the Ages: A Global History. 14th edition. (Boston: Thompson, 2012), 997, Fig. 33-12.…
- 512 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
There are various accounts in the world in which the setting or time period plays an infinite roll, but in Harriet Jacobs, “Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl”, and Rebecca Davis’s “Life in the Iron Mills”, the characters make all the difference. From the amazing role of Hugh Wolfe, to the vital words from Harriet Jacobs, we will explore how these stories have shaped our past, present, and future. Most people have experienced challenges in life that cause them to either act or suppress those times as if they did not happen. In Harriet Jacobs’ case, she chose to take her experiences and place them at the core of her existence, in order to press for change. On the other hand, Rebecca Davis was able to illustrate the distinct differences between upper class and lower class lifestyles.…
- 1268 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Despite Daum’s confidence, she begins to sound disturbed finding her attacker’s motive. She reveals facts about her past to reject being “privileged”. Daum’s argument which is usually sarcastic and unemotional becomes vulnerable. The accuser tries to discredit her reliability, which is an important piece to writing. Readers need to know Daum, and this criticism could unravel her credibility. Being Meghan Daum, she immediately attacks her opponent’s argument.…
- 750 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the novel Claire of the Sea Light, Edwidge Danticat utilizes Max Ardin Junior and Flore Voltaire’s interactions and relationship to reveal the dominance of wealthy males in Haitian society; however, despite these circumstances, Danticat illuminates the ability for women to empower themselves and find redemption. The consequences of Flore’s rape reflect the sexist nature of society in Haiti that knowingly traps poor and vulnerable women in harmful and violating situations at the favor of rich men. On the other hand, using Flore’s reaction to her rape, Danticat explores the opportunities women have to stand up to the detrimental male power and take their dignity back. Ultimately, the events involving both Max Jr. and Flore allow Danticat to…
- 907 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This essay’s purpose is to provide facts and convincing examples to persuade the reader to agree with the prompt .The inclusion of the general individuals of history ; Nancy Wake and Gale Halverson made the essay much stronger and easily supported the prompt, as a wide range of information was used that the reader could relate with. Conflict is a situation which one cannot easily forget and is haunted by it all through life. The movie Paradise Road showed women of various ages and nationalities and presented us with women who did display heroic qualities compared to others. It shows the different approaches and sacrifices people are willing to make in order to give hope to the distressed victims of the conflict.…
- 274 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
As it was stated, this is a narrative essay where the author reinforces his message by expressing his personal experiences. This can make the audience understand in a sensitive way his point of view. That is, his personals stories can help to not only understand what he believes or how he sees the situation, but to understand what he feels about the…
- 744 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Bannan, Helen M. “Jones, Mary Harris.” American Women Writers: A critical reference guide from colonial times to the present. Ed. Taryn Benbow-Pfalzgraf. 2nd ed. Vol. 2. Deltroit: St. James Press, 2000. 286-287. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 2. Mar. 2010…
- 1416 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Carol Ann Duffy seems to ask political/feminist questions in the following poems and believes women to be partly responsible for mass production, industrialisation and technology. The women in Duffy’s poems are seen as obsessive (The Diet, Work) and not in control (the woman who shopped). All three poems seem to combine aspects of femininity into one character such as gluttony, self-harm/losing oneself and seek to change themselves in some way. It seems Duffy has a major conflict with herself and the female population in general. Everyone seems to want to be the next top model or superstar. These cravings and affections are the downfall of women these days. They are unable to control themselves of anything going on in the media or the papers and relentlessly dive in to get involved. The main problem with women is that they struggle to realise their identity and try to conform to a certain audience to gain that identity. It seems Duffy has a major distaste for market capitalism and its effect on women. Duffy is almost blaming women for global capitalism as much as they are the victims of it.…
- 876 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“The tragedy of these women is the tragedy of the civilization which bore them, nourished them, and cast them out.” This quote by Robert Emmet Jones, an associate professor specializing in sociology, parallels with A Streetcar Named Desire, in which the decline of the southern aristocracy left women, who were little more than decorative beauties, at the mercy of the real world. Knowing only their purpose of beauty, these women sacrificed their dignity for support, often facing and accepting abuse at the hands of men. One of the victims of this tragedy is Blanche Dubois, a delicate and fragile minded outcast. Ostracized by her hometown and abandoned by her family, she resorts to prostitution and alcoholism for consolation. In her efforts to assure herself of her own worth in her growing age, and to rescue her sister, Stella, from an abusive lifestyle, she offends the male-dominated society in which she is trapped. Despite Blanche’s controversial lifestyle and destructive actions, she is nonetheless a tragic heroine whose downfall resulted from poor treatment at the hands of a cruel society to which she refused to comply.…
- 2528 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In Parenti’s essay, “Class and Virtue”, Parenti, states that, “The entertainment media present working people not only as unlettered and uncouth but also as less desirable and less moral than other people” (Parenti 406). Parenti also states that “…virtue is more likely to be ascribed to those characters whose speech and appearance are soundly middle- or upper- middle class” (Parenti 406). Parenti presents the story of Treasure Island as an example of this. Parenti cites how “The squire and his associates dress in fine clothes, speak in educated diction, and drink brandy” (Parenti 407) and then contrasts them to the appearance of Long John Silver and his companions who “…dress slovenly, speak in guttural accents, and drink rum” (Parenti 407). The differences between these two groups in appearance, speech, and even choice of drink, manipulate the viewer into rooting for the squire and his men.…
- 1454 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Cited: Baym, Nina. The Norton Anthology of American Literature.: Package 2 : 1865 to the Present. London: W W Norton &, 2007. Print.…
- 882 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays