Robin Black
…Divorced, Beheaded, Survived
Losing a loved one is something most people have tried. It could have been a grandparent, a mother, a father or even both of them. And no matter who it is, it always hurts more than anything else. But the memory they leave behind is the something we always keep with us. It can make us happy or sad at times. It reminds us to live our lives and it reminds us that we are and have to be the survivor.
The text is a short story written in a unique and curious setting, allowing you to see the world of an ordinary family whose lives have been affected by the deaths of the friends and family. The story grasps some of the problems that death can bring upon a family. I will analyze and interpret Robin Black’s short story about the unnamed narrator and how the impact of her younger days has affected her and her life.
The story is based upon her brother’s death and the acts they played with their friends shortly before. The story’s structure is quite flowing, but jumps back and forth in time. It takes place over roughly 30 years, but the reader does not have trouble keeping track of the time, because of the markings of each section. Even though the tragic events of her brother’s death thirty years ealier sill affect the narrator, the writer does not use a climax in the story. The writer and the narrator are just stating what has happened to her brother, what has been the affect of her brother’s death and how her life has been since he died. But Terry’s death did not just affect the narrator, his sister, but also their mutual friends. By using the last sentence in the story “ “Divorced, beheaded, died, divorced, beheaded, survived.” Miss Rafferty wrote the rhyme out on the board while Molly Denham and I dutifully copied it into our notebooks, as though we might otherwise forget.” (p. 5, l. 174-176), Robin Black is showing how they both pretend not knowing about King Henry VIII and how it is an attempt to avoid being reminded of the heartbreaking death of Terry years before.
In this short story the writer deals with different kinds of grief in dealing with death. They are set up as themes: how to deal with death, how it affects us and how to move on, including death at a young age. The dealing with death is quite different in reality than in role-play. “And Terry would hold his face in both his hands, his shoulders heaving in enormous, racking, make-believe sobs. But in real life, it was all silent hours. Vacant stares.” (p. 4, l. 99-101) The mood around Terry is now full of silence, while in role play they symbolized death with tears and sobs. Death was a game, but it changes as soon as Terry gets sick. Because Sarah has experienced grief in dealing with her brother’s death, she has the ability to help her son in dealing with the death of his good friend, Pete.
With the affect death has on people, Sarah is a person who it affected very much, but strongest in her young years. After her brother’s death all of their mutual friends drifted apart. Later in life, when Sarah’s son Mark is old enough, she decided it was time to put Terry’s picture away. It had been with her through her entire life, but because the lines between her own son and Terry were too easily drawn, she decided it was time. The impact death had on Sarah and her friends shows how people can be torn apart by it, but it also shows how it can bring people closer to each, for example when Sarah helps her son Mark with the death of his friend.
The way that Sarah does not think of Terry every day and putting away his picture, shows she is moving on and living her life. She does not dwell in the sorrow of losing Terry, but gets a life of her own. Sarah is about 40 years old, which means her parents were either 35 or 40 years old when they had her. That shows they took a long education and did not have children until they were settled and had jobs. You can also read that in the text where Sarah talks about what her father does. “By that spring, when he was eleven, he knew for sure that he wanted to be a history professor, like my father.” (p. 2, l. 31-32) It seems to me that Sarah has chosen a different way of life. She is about 40 years old, as said before, and she has a son at the age of 16, which means she probably had him at the age of 23 or 24. That shows she became a mother at a very young age, different from her parents. It also does not say in the text if she took an education other than High School, which makes me think she is a stay at home mom. In that way her life is very different from her parents.
The text is a sad story about a normal family who deals with grief. But what makes it interesting is the tale about Henry VIII and his six wives and how Robin Black uses it to describe different kinds of grief. She compares the role play and the deaths in real world with each other. Then she finds the similarities and differences between the two and makes a short story out of it. It is a good way to show the difference between real life and fiction and how people react differently towards sorrow, grief and death.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Arriving home from school, being picked up by his neighbors, “At two o’ clock our neighbors drove me home”(3). He heard the devastating news that someone died in his family. Upon arriving home, “In the porch I met my crying father”(4), showed how death can causes so much trauma and confusion. His father crying,…
- 694 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the memoir "Things that Went Bump in the Night," by Anna Bella Kaufman shares her story of having to watch her son slowly reach death. With the use of themes and symbols, Kaufman personifies death and the feelings associated with this experience to bring it to live and draw a vivid picture in the readers' minds. Her writing of this tragedy does not only captivate the feelings of the audience but it does a good job of sharing a personal story in an interesting fashion.…
- 107 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
A few days ago I became aware of Keeneka Jenkins and her story. It has been on my mind every minute and every hour since then. I have not been able to discuss the tragic event with anyone or share my thoughts on it, so that is why I am dedicating this journal to her and her peculiar death. Keeneka Jenkins was a beautiful woman born and raised in Illinois, Chicago. She was the daughter of Teresa Martin who raised her since birth.…
- 1025 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout history, human beings have always been intrigued by the cycle they are destined to follow: The Circle of Life. They question things that they cannot answer such as what comes before, what comes after, and what they will do to cope when they lose someone they love. William Armstrong and Thornton Wilder are two authors who chose to write about the thing that is often forgotten: life itself. William Armstrong’s novel Sounder consists of a mother and a boy who cope very differently with death. The boy is hopeful and optimistic, while his mother’s outlook has been shaped by the hardships she faced. She looks death straight in the eye and is not discouraged but sings out, “When life is so tiresome, there ain’t no peace like the greatest peace--the peace of the Lord’s hand holding you.” In Thornton Wilder’s play Our Town, death is…
- 923 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
While reading the story “ What the living do” one could equate the poem to something that has taken place in their own life. Through out life everyone has or will have a time when they lose someone near and dear to their heart. People choose to deal with this in different ways. Many chose to express their feelings for this tragedy in writing. As illustrated in “What the living do”, Marie Howe uses tone, irony, and diction to express the loss of her brother and how she chooses to cope with it.…
- 632 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
pity in the reader by reflecting on the traumatic childhood of her father, and establishes a cause…
- 1014 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
“The pleasure of remembering had been taken from me, because there was no longer anyone to remember with. It felt like losing your coremberer meant losing the memory itself, as if the things we’d done were less real and important than they had been hours before.” (John Green). In my opinion, loss is one of the worst things one can face in life. It hurts. It sucks. It makes you feel as if you are the one who is dead.…
- 975 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Suffering and loss is a regular situation in the human life cycle, it is vital to learn how to deal with it so that it doesn’t affect the rest of our lives negatively. In Scott Russell Sanders’s Ten Reasons Why We’ll Always Need a Good Story he explains that one of the reasons is to help us deal and become aware of suffering, loss, and death. During our youth we often don’t consider the end of the life cycle. However, in life we will always encounter grieving from a loved one’s death. The first time we experience some sort of grieving it may be very hard to handle and may cause depression. Stories help us prepare for moments of suffering, loss, and death with fictional experiences which show us how to deal with these unfortunate events. In the three short stories we read at least one character in each story is forced to deal with suffering, loss, or death. In the short story Bluffing by Gail Helgason, Liam has an unfortunate accident and experiences physical pain as well as the emotional pain of his deteriorating relationship with Gabriella. In Two Words by Isabel Allende, Belisa Crepusculario is devastated by the death of her entire family due to their impoverished lifestyle and the love between her and the Colonel causes them to miss each other. In The Indisputable Weight of the Ocean by Darryl Berger, Edmund deals with not being able to see his father and deals with the suffering of moving to a suburban area.…
- 1481 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
We had never seen our mother in such despair; it was a shock to see our mother’s vivid emotions. My mother asked us if we wanted to see our father and we all replied “yes” and so she took all of us to see our father. However, my siblings and I went individually, but little did we know that what we were about to witness would shatter our hearts, feelings, souls, and…
- 1852 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Never having enjoyed, to any considerable extent, her soothing presence, her tender and watchful care, I received the tidings of [my mother’s] death with much the same emotions I should have probably felt at the death of a stranger.…
- 1858 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
The death of a loved one can be the most common form of grief; throughout life most people will experience this type of loss. The loss of a loved one can trigger grief such as depression, anger and fear. The person lost could have been a big influence in the life of the bereaved offering them love and security but now that the person has gone they may feel a sense of insecurity like how will I pay the bill or who’s going to cook tea as the person who has gone may have been the main source of financial income for the family and who would do most of the cooking and household chores, and loneliness having the suffered the loss of a companion or a lifelong friend that you would talk to and see almost every day.…
- 1662 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Loss is something we all share and experience in life. There are different types of loss which affect our everyday lives, emotions and relationships. If our attachment is strong then we will feel stronger emotions. The complexity of our attachment will also dictate how we move through our grief.…
- 1281 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
When a loved one dies, grief can feel like a dagger in your heart. Often, grief triggers raw, intense emotions. You might wonder how you 'll ever pick up the pieces and heal your wounds — yet not feel as if you 're betraying your loved one 's memory.…
- 15224 Words
- 61 Pages
Good Essays -
Death, an event that cannot be avoided is often paired with tragedy. Poem at Thirty-Nine by Alice Walker shows a daughter grieving for her dead father, Mother in a refugee camp tells the story of a mother’s care for her dying son, and Rosetti looks at a dying woman wanting her lover to forget her and move on in Remember. Death has been taken on by many poets from Thomas Hardy to Seamus Heaney, and whilst they explore death’s effect from different viewpoints, they all agree on the sorrow that it can bring.…
- 1491 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
In this poem, Duffy explores how the tragic loss of a close friend affects the mourner, and powerfully portrays the implications of their death using imagery, structure and emotive language. She touches upon each of the 5 stages of grief and bereavement, and conveys the psychological process of each of these: Denial, Anger, Guilt, Depression and Acceptance.…
- 2545 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays