Preview

Dr. Eagleson's Argument Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1581 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Dr. Eagleson's Argument Analysis
Elaine Pedreira Rabinovich of Sáo Paulo University spearheaded a social psychology study in an attempt to delve deeper into the earlier research conducted in the 1940’s by Dr. Eagleson. Her hypothesis suggested that the socioeconomic group of a child’s parent would affect the name chosen for that child (Rabinovich, 1993). The theory is an interesting one, yet it is faulty. The argument presented is inductive, albeit a weak and uncogent inductive argument. There are several key issues with this study. The evidence presented in support of the comparative claim to socioeconomic groups and children’s names is flawed, at best. A child’s name is not necessarily related to his or her parents’ socioeconomic group. The premises given in the article …show more content…
The first of these is the variation between the groups. The study divided the two groups into fifty, but there are differences that cause the groups not to parallel. The first of these is the variation on the split of the children in the study. A group made an even half between boys and girls with 25 each; meanwhile, Group B was slightly incongruent to this method. There were 28 boys and 22 girls. This may not seem like a massive issue, but when the sample size is as small as it is and makes the level of claim that it does, it is a big deal. This causes the scale to tip when statistics are being drawn concerning boys’ names. Another issue is the age variation between the studies. The children in Group A ranged from 1 to 7 years old, and the children in Group B varied drastically less with participants being 1 month to 1 year old (Rabinovoch, 1993). This ever so slightly dates the information given by Group A. If there were multiple siblings between the child in the survey and the time of the survey, information on the why the parents chose a name could have been confused or clouded with time. Perhaps the greatest problem with this study is the lack of expounding upon definitions of words. The study concluded that parents who chose their child’s name together (those from Group A) reflect an egalitarian system, and those families where only one parent chose the child’s name (Group B) were part of a hierarchical system. The question behind this is what exactly determines a family is egalitarian or hierarchical? Could any of the parents been single parents who selected the name alone? Absolutely. Definitions played a further role when the terms “aesthetic” and “neutral-sounding” are called into question. What constitutes a name as being “short,” “nice,” or “easy”? Is Robert a neutral sounding name, chosen because it can be shortened to Bob? Perhaps it is imaginative, as the parents did not know anyone with that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    On 05/29/2016, at approximately 2246, Night shift Officers responded to 2451 Teeple St. in response to a shooting call. Prior to receiving the call at Teeple St. there was already an afternoon shift officer out with a Deshawn Matthews who had shown up at St. Marys Hospital with a gunshot wound to his leg. Officers located a victim (Joshua Hopkins) at 2451 Teeple St. who was transported to UT Hospital for a gunshot wound to his leg (non-life threatening). During the investigation it was found that Deshawn Matthews was one of the suspects involved in the shooting at 2246 Teeple St. along with his accomplice (Theron Taylor Jr.). Theron Taylor had driven Deshawn Matthews to the Hospital in a white Chrysler 300. Officer observed firearms in plain…

    • 194 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a non legit study identical resumes were sent to employers with exactly the same information but different names, and the white resumes always garnered more attention. (Levitt, 2007) The data from California revealed that people with black names normally have a worse life than a person with a white name, but only because they are usually born into very different households. Those with black names typically come from poor, uneducated,house holds, and this is why they tend to stay in the cycle as they grow up themselves. The next section of the chapter asks where names come from. The California data answers these questions well. When sorting baby names by economic status, there is a difference between middle-income, low-income, and high-income parents. The same being true of educated and uneducated parents. Typically, names that are spelled incorrectly also signify a low-education parent. More naming data also reveals a turnover of naming popularity. Within twenty years, nearly every name on the top name lists provided changes. The data also reveals a pattern, names catch on among high-income, highly educated parents first, and then start working their way down the socioeconomic ladder. Levitt hypothesized that parents, whether they realize it or not, like the sound of names that sound “successful.”(Levitt, 2007) He…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anderson and Graff have an argument about setting battle room scenarios unfair or not. Ender is placed in the Rat Army. The commander, Rose De Nose, immediately hates Ender and warns Ender to stop practicing with the Launchies. Ender sees Dink, (Ender is assigned to Dink’’s platoon) as a kind soul,but is suspicious sometimes because of Dink’s actions. Ender and Dink talk one day and Ender finds out that Dink was promoted twice, but refused to be commander because he didn’t believe in school. Dink says the real enemy is the teacher, not the students. Dink doesn’t want the adults to ruin his childhood and life. Dink tells Ender that he thinks the Buggers have vanished and the school is running to keep the I.F. in charge. Ender doesn’t believe…

    • 229 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This article was written by Maggie Astor, a reporter on The New York Times, a newspaper considered to be one of the most reliable source of information. Astor also has a degree in political science from Barnard College, therefore the information she provided is highly credible. In the article, she reports of a recent Dove ad that caused an outcry in the social media for its racist undertones. Astor quotes Dove’s spokeswoman and her apologetic remarks, stating that the ad was intended to convey a different message and that the company will re-evaluate its internal processes for creating and reviewing content. Critics are unimpressed of the apology. Astor then lists examples from the past of ads that were accused of racism: Intel, Popchips, Nivea…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The author employs sufficient sources and data to support her claim. Miller cites from various and professional organizations to strengthen her argument. For example, Miller utilizes a study done by Bettina Hoeppner from Harvard to illustrate the discrepancy of alcohol consumption between men and women. Miller often refers to NIAAA for her argument and uses the data from NIAAA as a baseline for excess alcohol consumption. Miller also seems to favor one specific intervention program, the BASICS program, that helps to prevent and decrease dangerous drinking activities among teens and young adults.…

    • 92 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Donald L. Niewyk’s fifth and sixth chapters both deal more with outside perspectives and outside reactions than it does with those who were persecuted. The fifth chapter, “Bystander Reactions,” offers four different arguments as to why bystanders acted they way they did during the Holocaust. The sixth chapter, “Possibilities of Rescue,” discusses three different viewpoints on what foreign governments could have done to prevent the Holocaust. These two chapters conclude Niewyk’s book The Holocaust and wrap up the final sequence of events surrounding the Holocaust and the camps.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As stated in Lee Bollinger's article, "admissions policies do not meaningfully affect a white student's chances of admission" so there is no actual proof that affirmative action is reverse discrimination against whites. Also affirmative action does not demean individual accomplishment, but enhances it because according to Nell Irvin Painter "without affirmative action, it never would have occurred to any large, white research university to consider [her] for professional employment." So if anything, affirmative action helps individuals have more successful lives by providing people with better opportunities than they would otherwise have. I think that Lee Bollinger's argument is the strongest, since he provides concrete evidence and actual…

    • 129 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Starting a national system of licensing with appropriate penalties for alcoholics or problem drinkers would help our country a lot. Drinking can be caused by just trying it for the first time or friends force you to drinking. Some might do it to relax ,others will because they are feeling depressed about something and they will drink until they are drunk. Earl Rochester's argument is stating that they should make a license for alcoholic drinkers and I agree on that topic.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    With this I connect to the change that happened for the aristocrats in the 16th century. Names became as important as who one was birthed by. Suddenly one could marry into a powerful and mighty family name. With this I’m sure that the lower class questioned this system, as however not everyone could marry rich.…

    • 573 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Antony Flew (1955) introduces the concept of theology and falsification by referring to John Wisdom's parable of the Believer and the Skeptic in reference to the existence of a beautiful garden in the jungle. The Believer asserts that there must be a gardener taking care of it regardless of whether he can be seen, heard or felt, while the Skeptic believes there is no gardener and the garden blooms independently of a caretaker. Even after setting a watch, patrolling with dogs and setting up an electrified fence, there is no physical evidence of a gardener, only the presence of a garden. However, the Believer in the parable does not waiver from his belief in the existence of the gardener despite the efforts of the Skeptic to question acceptance of this person based…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are times when people are put in the position in which they must choose between being selfless and helping others or not doing anything and only worrying about themselves. If the people choose to disregard their own safety and put another person’s life before theirs, it shows how ethically responsible they are. For an action to be ethically responsible, it must be done out of someone’s own intention to ensure the wellbeing of someone else. Ethical responsibility is defined as the obligation to do something that is morally sound in order to make sure a person is in good physical and emotional health. In the article titled, “Can the Law Make Us Be Decent?,” written by Jay Sterling Silver, the author states that there is not a federal…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though Rosenau missed and left out many critical points in his chapter, he did successful interpret many shifts. Primarily, his understanding that power is shifting away from the state, and towards the individual is an undeniable truth. Like Rosenau, Zacher made a similar statement that in the decline of the Westphalian system of states, power is shifting away from the state and towards cities and corporations. Many cities and corporations, like Los Angeles and Walmart, are larger than certain countries around the world, so this power shift is not surprising. Rosenau’s argument that citizens can gain power by coming together holds weight, especially considering that a group of citizens in cities such as Los Angeles might have more power than…

    • 180 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Genralisabiltiy, the study was not very genralisable, it was a study that took place I the USA and social norms there could be very different to a lot of other coutures around the world. Also the sample although fairly varied culturally for its size (it had a painter and housewife alongside 3 psychologists and others) it was very small, with 8 participants, and only 7 of these being put into the insertitution.…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I feel like the first sentence of Earl’s statement is true because those two-thirds of adolescent and adult usually start drinking at a young age. That would make it easier for them to get attached to alcohol . Having people take a written test just to get a drinking license could help but it wouldn’t help as much. I also think that stores would lose money because not everyone that drinks is going to have a drinking license. I disagree with Earl Rochester argument.…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life. I am writing to express my appreciation to you and your assistants for your extensive research and your dedication in determining the lasting effects of unequal childhoods. I feel that this research project was important to answer the question of how unequal childhoods affect a child’s future. Your methodology was thorough and unique. You and your assistants not only interviewed children and their families, but also immersed yourselves in their family and social lives. Your research in examining how middle class, working class and poor families raise their children was very detailed and informative. Every chapter had interesting examples of how the differences affected the child or children involved.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays