The skill of Iago was extraordinary, but so was his good fortune. Again and again a chance word from Desdemona, a chance meeting of Othello and Cassio, a question which starts to our lips and which any one but Othello could have asked, would have destroyed Iago’s plot and ended his life. Instead, Desdemona drops her handkerchief at the moment most favorable to him, Cassio blunders into the presence of Othello only to give him a swoon, Bianca arrives precisely when she is wanted to complete Othello’s deception and incense his anger to fury. All this and much more seem to us quite natural, so potent is the art o Of all the tragedies of Shakespeare, Othello stands out prominently as the one in which the role of chance and accident is the largest. However, the larger occurrence of chance and accident in this play doesn’t mean that the significance of these in Othello is also greater than in other tragedies of Shakespeare. Bradley has excellently pointed out the importance of chances and accidents.
The skill of Iago was extraordinary, but so was his good fortune. Again and again a chance word from Desdemona, a chance meeting of Othello and Cassio, a question which starts to our lips and which any one but Othello could have asked, would have destroyed Iago’s plot and ended his life. Instead, Desdemona drops her handkerchief at the moment most favorable to him, Cassio blunders into the presence of Othello only to give him a swoon, Bianca arrives precisely when she is wanted to complete Othello’s deception and incense his anger to fury. All this and much more seem to us quite natural, so potent is the art of the dramatist; but it confounds us with a feeling… [that] there is no escape from fate, and even with a feeling absent from that play , that fate has taken sides with villainy.
Distinction: Not all that Bradley mentions can be legitimately regarded as chance or accident. Moreover, the three events which are accidents viz. the dropping of Desdemona’s handkerchief at the moment which suits Iago, Cassio’s coming upon the suspicious Othello when he is in a swoon and Bianca’s arrival at just the right time for Iago, don’t constitute a pattern running through the play such as there is in Romeo and Juliet, but happen so closely as to form a single event. It cannot be granted that the absence of a chance word from Desdemona, a chance meeting of Cassio, a question which starts to our lips, constitute accidents in the above sense. This is to confuse the events of the play which are critically relevant, with possible events in real life, which are not.
Contrivance: There is large element of contrivance on Iago’s part in the events which are, or seem to be, accidents. For example, Brabantio is summoned, in the beginning, to learn of Desdemona’s deception of him, and this to embarrass Othello with his outcry and provide a principal ground of Othello’s later distrust of her with his.
Look to her, Moor, if thou hast eyes to see:
She has deceived her father, and may thee.
Iago’s contrivance of Cassio’s pleading on part of Desdemona and his success in proving him her lover are very good examples of contrivance which defy accidents. There seems to be only one incident of handkerchief, but after that Iago is master of the situation. He uses handkerchief to poison Othello’s mind. So handkerchief itself has no act of its own until and unless exploited by Iago. What matters are not the circumstances, but Iago’s skillful insinuations for which Othello sees through the eyes of Iago which causes his fall. Othello has no independent power of reasoning; he sees what Iago shows him.
Impact: It is difficult to agree with Bradley that these accidents lessen our sense of the importance of the Character in the tragedy. The accidents do not absolve Othello of his responsibility. We can’t accept this sentimentality. We can’t see reason to be controlled by passion and will. Iago’s deliberate malice infects Othello’s mind, corrupts his reason and renders him ‘Passion’s slave’. Othello is fully responsible for what he does and he accepts this at the end, but the remorse he feels for the wrong he committed, destroys him; that’s why he is fully tragic.
Human Element: The reason why it must be maintained that the role of accidents in Othello is far less important than it seems, is that they are not blows of fate, but situations painstakingly manipulated and exploited by a human agent – Iago. Iago – up to the catastrophic turning-point – plans most of the events, calculates the motives and responses and his victims, and profits with diabolical cleverness from the chances which do occur and which he makes serve his purposes. Thus the tragic effect of Othello turns upon the inevitability inherent in the malice of Iago and the character of Othello which Iago know so well how to influence.
Tragic Circumstances: What gives the play a tragic outcome is primarily the working of character, and not chances, accidents or coincidence. Desdemona is a Venetian and Venice was notorious for its women of loose character. Othello is a man of sudden resolve and vehement feelings. He is unfortunately deeply impressed by Iago’s honesty. Othello has known Desdemona for long. He has little knowledge of women in any case. His military life left him with little time to socialize and study women. But, principally, he was a man in the grip of jealousy, subject to uncontrollable passion. Such a man can easily be put to a tragic end with malicious designs.
Chance and intrigue: To some extent, it can be called that Othello is a tragedy of intrigue. The chance has a dominant role because chance cannot be excluded from tragedy. It is an essential element of human life, it has a right to be a principal force in the dramatic development only in comedy. Othello may be invulnerable in respect of his military expeditions and a man of noble nature, but he has occasioned his tragedy himself.
f the dramatist; but it confounds us with a feeling… [that] there is no escape from fate, and even with a feeling absent from that play .
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
"Death of A Salesman" is really about how reality and illusion interplay in each and everyone's personality in the context of achieving success in life. All people dream and most consider a dream as a typical example of an illusionmerely a construct of the imagination that extends past and present experiences of one's life into a realm that is not bound by logic. Reality, on the other hand, is what one directly perceives through the basic senses of perception.…
- 980 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In Death of a Salesman, a play written by Arthur Miller, Willie Loman is a salesman! In the introduction of the play, we can see exactly how Miller feels about a person being a salesman by the reply he made to a comment and said " he sells what a salesman has to sell, himself. As Charley insists , the only thing you got in this world is what you can sell. As a salesman he has got to get by on a smile and a shoeshine. He has to charm. He is a performer, a confidence man who must never lack confidence. His error is to confuse the role he plays with the person he wishes to be" (as cited in Death of a Salesman,1998, pp xxv). Arthur Miller understood the impact that the societal beliefs of what constitutes being a success had on the average man and how he viewed his current social status in relation to what his dreams of it were. I don't view Willie Loman as being some crazy old man, but a man who has worked hard to provide for his family. I see him as a man that had the same hopes and aspirations for his sons that every parent has. I respect Willie Loman. However, as a medical professional I am going to stick with my original assumption that in addition to being a salesman, he is a man that is suffering from Alzheimer's dementia. My goal is not to take away from the belief that Willie is a man that just hasn't figured out yet who he is, but as Willie Loman, an ordinary man that is suffering from Alzheimer's Dementia. I am going to provide information collaborating the parallels between symptoms of Alzheimer's and Willie's actions throughout the play.…
- 1210 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Shakespeare’s plays are famously renowned for their intimate connections between character and responder, creating significant relationships relevant to audiences today. Othello focuses on relationships between lovers, families, friends and foes, to captivate the responder and express concerns and ideas of human nature. The intense relationship between Othello and Iago plays centre piece to the play and it is through betrayal of trust and manipulation leading to the downfall of the protagonist that relates to audiences and captivates their attention.…
- 1110 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The reader is revealed to a noble man of the Northern African decent, an outsider who has come to be well regarded as a leader of Italian military might. He notably outwits Iago’s first attempt to separate him from Desdemona. Othello sways the duke’s opinion through eloquent speech and a steady hold of composure even when confronted with Brabanzio’s absurd accusation of witchcraft. Othello has wooed Desdemona through his rousing tales of adventure and war. As the seed of doubt grows and plans of revenge stem Othello loses his articulate speech and compelling words. As the reader is led up to the climax of his dreadfully evil action, it’s seen that Othello’s speech becomes sporadic and full of unwarranted emotion. Sentences are full of hiatuses and exclamation points; this ruins the sense of coherent flow of thought. Othello has become deeply rapt in the tales of the Iago, his distracted mind becomes more and more confused and overwhelmed by the supposed deception that is taking place out of his control. Othello is engrossed in…
- 623 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In Shakespeare’s “Othello,” Othello is highly respected and looked up to but later is influenced by the antagonist, Iago, resulting in a jealous insecurity ultimately leading to his murdering of his own wife and the plotting of murdering of his ex-lieutenant, Cassio. The reader first notices Othello’s shift in character…
- 749 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Iago is a cruel and evil man who uses ways to ruin Othello and Desdemona’s relationship. Othello appointed Cassio, to be his lieutenant. Iago was mad when he heard about it, he believes that he should be the one for the position since he knows more. This started off with his jealousy of Cassio. When Othello and Desdemona got married without letting anyone knowing, Iago begins to plot his plan. He used Roderigo to help him throughout the process of his plan to bring down Cassio. He then told Othello lies to ruin his own relationship. He also use Bianca as his part of the plan. Iago got people into thinking he was a nice honest guy, but he uses other people's jealousy and gullibleness for his own benefit.…
- 749 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
From the onset of Othello, the audience is unknowingly subject to Iago’s manipulative customs. Despite being a stereotypical Shakespearian antagonist, Iago is a complex, two faced, yet three dimensional, character. Despite being an eponymous play, suggesting Othello’s importance, his absence in light of Iago’s presence allows the audience to be influenced and therefore misled by Iago’s representation of Othello…
- 1063 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
| Iago ‘only loves’ Desdemona out of revenge and jealously of Othello as he believes he has slept with his wife. The ‘infidelity’ that is occurring behind is back is eating him alive and so he plans to manipulate Othello in beliving Desdemona is having an affair with Cassio. ‘Deception’ aids him to accomplish this task…
- 453 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Later, chapter 3 will be based on an analysis of gradual behavioral changes in Othello, with regards to Act 3, Act 4 and Act 5. Moreover, this chapter will disclose the impact of Iago’s insinuations in manipulating Othello’s mental state, which will be observed by analyzing Othello’s rage, and his work sheet for revenge on infidelity of Desdemona.…
- 392 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The tragedy play, one that has captivated many for its effectiveness in understanding the human flaws and how they can lead to eventual downfall is one that Shakespeare’s plays embody. However, there is such a play that contains these elements, yet it manipulates the genre’s conventions for a new effect, the play Othello. This play is centered around a Moorish noble, a soldier who faces conflict regarding his beloved Venetian wife. The themes present in this play are that of trust, jealousy, honesty, love, stereotypes, friendship, and above all deception. Through the use of all of these themes, it sets the stage for how Shakespeare…
- 893 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Shakespeare’s play, Othello tells the audience the story of a very successful General of Venice, Othello and how has was deceived by someone he believe to be an honest man, Iago, his ensign. The plot speeds up quickly Othello promotes Cassio instead of Iago. Iago vows revenge and slowly convinces Othello of Desdemona’s infidelity with Cassio, the lieutenant to whom Othello had given the position Iago had sought. Iago also gets Roderigo to help him in his evil plan by telling him that he can have Desdemona if he helps get rid of Cassio. Oblivious to Iago’s master plan Othello is ultimately a victim of his own naïveté.…
- 1559 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
In the tragedy Othello, Shakespeare relinquishes the power to Iago, the playwright within the theatrical work, to invent the storyline. With this mastery, Iago devotes his time conspiring against Othello and Desdemona by using a handkerchief, a symbol of Othello's mysterious past and his exoticness. Othello’s profusion of passion and trust catalyzes his collapse. Othello, a North African, and Cassio, a wealthy Venetian, do not foresee Iago to exploit their traits and turn these assets into flaws. The English author joins these men to examine the discrepancy in demise betwixt an outsider and an insider.…
- 707 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Othello’s own desperate plea for certainty is also evident from the offset. Although he refuses to hide from Branbantio and denounce his frabrications, he suggests that Desdemona should testify freely how their love came about. Some may argue that Othello holds a number of insecurities about himself and this is a prime example of him desperatly needing Desdemona to justify her reasoning for marrying him. After all, he displays an incredible vulnaribilty, ‘a free and open nature, that thinks men honest that but seem to be so.’ Iago works on these traits and his pretended disapproval of the relations between Cassio and Desdemona rouses Othello’s curiosity, thence his insistance that he be told, and finally his fear that Iago’s information, got in his duty as an honest man, will harm him. At first, Othello appears to be confident of Desdemona’s love for him as he declares she ‘had eyes and…
- 776 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The extent of which Othello is a tragic hero has been open to much debate; the basis on which he is judged falls to Aristotle’s established view of the crucial elements that distinguish whether a person is truly tragic. According to Aristotle, a tragic protagonist is a nobleman or person from high status, who contributes to his own demise and illustrates a flaw or weakness in judgment. The tragic protagonist must make a fall from a high state of being to a low state or death. The tragic hero’s downfall, said Aristotle, was brought upon by some error of judgement. Aristotle’s theory is not the final word on tragedy, however it can support in pinpointing the pivotal traits in Othello’s character and when they occur, with great accuracy. This tragic ‘flaw’ has sometimes been incorrectly interpreted in moral terms, and some critics have looked for some moral weakness in the tragic hero. For Othello, this has led to the commonplace assertion that his fall is because he was too naïve and trusting in his subordinate, Iago. Although, metaphorically speaking he does fall from a great height, it would be wrong to suggest that because Othello satisfies one of the Aristotelian criteria, it makes him a tragic hero. It is only when the six basic ideas are considered, can a hero be justly regarded as ‘tragic’.…
- 1469 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Shakespeare’s Othello is a tragedy not because of Othello’s decision making but by the effects of deception and manipulation that the characters invoke. In Othello, Shakespeare suggests that the discrepancy between idealized expectations and reality such as Othello’s reluctance to make changes, Iago’s manipulation tactics and the insecurities Othello has between him and Desdemona ultimately led to Othello’s downfall. These reasons show he is not willing to accept reality because he can’t seem to admit his failures. This concept can be seen in a critical article in “Iago, Heroic Tragedy, and Othello” by William Hazlitt. Hazlitt argues the wide margin in terms of character personalities between Othello and Iago and explores how their respective…
- 1440 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays