Intro Bus
Critical thinking exercise 4-2
Ethical Dilemmas
5. You are the vice president of a beer company in a state that sets the legal drinking age at 21. Your boss asks you to organize a lobbying effort to have the drinking age reduced to 18. What would you do?
A. I would do research and report my findings to my boss.
Although it might seem like a good idea to do so -higher sales, and therefore higher revenue and profit- lowering the drinking age would be a losing battle.
States can lower the drinking age back down to 18 or 19 but the amount of federal highway funds they'd lose (about 10%) makes it too expensive for them to do it.
Many politicians don't want to risk getting involved. Why change something that appears to be working. Young people might like a beer at 18 but young people don't vote.
77% of Americans are opposed to lowering the drinking age to 18 according to a 2007 Gallop poll.
Research shows that the law saves lives. It is one of the most researched public health laws on the books. When the law was raised to 21, alcohol-related deaths for young people decreased; when it was lowered, deaths increased.
Scientific research about brain development and function, traffic accident records and population death rates show clearly that 18-21 year-olds handle alcohol poorly.
The idea is strongly opposed by social and religious conservatives, parts of hospitality and retail industry concerned about liability, groups like Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) and Support 21 Coalition. These groups have money and clout with political institutions.
It costs American taxpayers nearly $61.9 billion annually, according to the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs. That includes medical costs, work loss and lost quality of life.
If an industry leader like Anheuser-Busch were to try and start an ad campaign to lower the drinking age, in addition to teaching teens safe drinking habits and the consequences of binge drinking, they would immediately be demonized for trying to shove alcohol down the throats of teenagers. People would think they acted only out of corporate greed, looking for higher profits at the expense of our nation's youth's health and safety.
In the long run, launching a joint ad/ lobbying campaign to lower the drinking age would likely have an adverse effect on sales and revenue as well as a PR nightmare.
References
Age 21 Minimum Legal Drinking Age. (2009). Retrieved from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: www.cdc.gov
Alcohol's Damaging Effects on the Brain. (2004). Retrieved from National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.
Dean-Mooney, L. (2008 ). Retrieved from http://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2008/09/08/a-lower-age-would-be-unsafe
Effects of Minimum Drinking Age Laws: Review and Analyses of the Literature from 1960 to 2000. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.collegedrinkingprevention.gov/SupportingResearch/Journal/wagenaar.aspx
Griggs, B. (2014). Should the U.S. lower its drinking age? Retrieved from http://www.cnn.com/2014/07/16/us/legal-drinking-age/index.html
Has the alcohol lobby ever tried to lower the drinking age to 18? If not, why? (2012). Retrieved from http://www.quora.com/Has-the-alcohol-lobby-ever-tried-to-lower-the-drinking-age-to-18-If-not-why
Keen, J. (2008). States weigh lowering drinking age. Retrieved from Usatoday.com: http://drinkingage.procon.org
Most Americans Oppose Lowering Legal Drinking Age to 18 Nationwide. (2007). Retrieved from www.gallup.com
Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD). (n.d.). Retrieved from www.madd.org
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism . (2002).
New Support 21 Coalition Formed to Support the Minimum Legal Drinking Age Law. (2007). Retrieved from http://www.cadca.org/resources/detail/new-support-21-coalition-formed-support-minimum-legal-drinking-age-law
Smith, N. (2011). Argument in Favor of Maintaining the Legal Drinking Age. Retrieved from http://www.articlemyriad.com/argument-maintaining-legal-drinking-age
The Surgeon General’s Call to Action to Prevent and Reduce Underage Drinking. (2007). Retrieved from U.S. Department of Health and Human Services: http://www.surgeongeneral.gov/topics/underagedrinking/calltoaction.pdf www.chooseresponsibility.org. (n.d.). wwww.alcoholpolicy.niaaa.nih.gov. (2009).
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Many people believe that eighteen year olds are not responsible enough to make correct decisions involving alcohol.…
- 877 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many pros and cons to lowering the national drinking age from 21 years of age to 19 years of age. I believe the drinking age should stay at 21 even though many of my peers feel otherwise. People under the age of 21 are drinking whether it is legal or not. They may have a fake identification or have someone purchase alcohol for them, the fact is they are drinking. When I talk with others about this topic, comments are always made such as: when a person turns 12, they can get a hunting license and carry a gun, at 16, they can get a driver’s license and quit school, at 18 they have the right to vote, serve in the military and are considered an adult. They can have a baby and get married but can’t have a glass of champagne to celebrate. I understand these thoughts and sometimes wish it was 19 but when you look at the research, it is better for everyone that every state to set the legal drinking age 21.…
- 1251 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
The legal drinking age should remain twenty-one. It should not be lowered because teenagers are not mature enough to drink responsibly. If you are allowed to have a credit card, provide for a family, and vote, you should be able to drink at the age it already is. We all know the consequences to what we do to our bodies, that is why we have choices. Drinking can be addicting just like coffee, cigarettes, medications, and body building.…
- 639 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In America, 38 states have the minimum drinking age at 21. However, the other 12 have exceptions to that law. Although underage drinking has been a problem in society. Lowering the drinking age would create responsibility in young adults (Top pro and con arguments). It would also allow young adults make better decisions and take responsibility for their actions.…
- 420 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
A number of States in the U.S. are considering legislation to lower the legal drinking age from the current age of 21 to 18. The move would defy a generation of federal law and public opinion in America which is strongly opposed to lowering the drinking age. In 1984, congress set the legal drinking age to 21 from 18, threatening to cut highway funding to states which did not comply, mostly to cut down on drunk driving deaths caused each year by drinking and driving. But advocates argue teenagers are going to drink anyway even if changed. Should the drinking age be lowered? In my opinion, the drinking age doesn't need to be reduced to 18, the drinking laws need to be changed completely.…
- 581 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
All fifty states set their minimum drinking age back to twenty one in the 1980’s because they felt that eighteen wasn’t the appropriate age. Some people did not agree with this change because at the age of eighteen people can vote, drive cars, fly planes, pay taxes, marry, become a legal guardian, own a gun, risk their lives a member of the U.S. armed forces. Honestly, today the drinking age doesn’t matter, whatever the age a person will always try and find a way to drink. Even though some believe the drinking age should be lowered because that way students and young teens won't binge drink and will know how to handle their alcohol better, lowering the drinking age is not a good idea and can cause harm to others. Teens will end up taking advantage of this and it’s a health risk.…
- 1004 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Now people say that the drinking age should stay the same but the legal adulthood age is 18 so why can’t the drinking age be lowered to 18? At the age of 18 you have the right to vote, to get married, join the army, and on top of that you could have contracts, so the drinking age should be lowered to 18 as well.(drinking age procon.org) Once you are 18 you should be able to have the rights to make your own decisions to buy a drink you want a drink.(newsweek.com)…
- 92 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
There is a giant debate on what the legal minimum drinking age should be in the United States. Many people think that it should remain at 21 years old and others believe that it should be lowered to 18. While both have their own various reasons, this has been an important topic in our country for a long time. President Ronald Reagan signed and passed the National Minimum Drinking Age Law in 1984 which obligated states to raise their legal drinking age to 21 or suffer reductions in Federal highway funds. The highway funds and drinking age was linked together by the young lives lost on our highways. Even though this was a satisfactory reason to raise the drinking age there are still more reasons to why it should be 18. Despite what most people…
- 1237 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
People say eighteen year olds can’t handle alcohol, because they make to many mistakes. If you start to drink at eighteen or twenty one your chances of making mistakes are still the same. No matter what age you start to drink, you don’t know how much you can handle until you start drinking. So when people say eighteen year olds make to many mistakes when they drink it’s only because they started drinking, just like a 21 year old will make mistakes when he or she starts to drink. Society uses teenagers as scapegoats for alcohol problems when it really doesn’t matter if your 17, 21 or 38 years old. Alcohol is still a serious problem on all people. It does not go away when you become 21 years old.…
- 446 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
the legal drinking age would not be in the best interest of the public 's safety, as well as…
- 1204 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
One of the reasons why the legal drinking age should be lowered is because it would diminish the thrill of breaking the law to get a drink. According to Ruth C. Engs, Pofessor, Applied Health Sciences, “Although the legal purchase age is 21 years of age, a majority of college students under this age consume alcohol but in an irresponsible manner. This is because drinking by these youth is seen as an enticing "forbidden fruit," a "badge of rebellion against authority" and a symbol of adulthood." This implies, students and people under the age of 21 will drink in an irresponsible manner because of peer pressure or just wanting to show adults that they don’t have to listen to them anymore. This also shows, if legal drinking age was lowered then most students and people under the age of 21 would learn that they don’t need to rebel to get a drink or break laws and since 18 year olds get a lot of responsibility like voting, this would add to it and show that they can be trusted with not over drinking.…
- 307 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Lowering the minimum legal drinking age 21 would give high schoolers and even middle schoolers easier access to alcohol. The minimum legal drinking should stay at 21 because people tend to be more mature and responsible at 21 than 18. As stated in the article,”The Legal Drinking Age: 18, 21, or 25?”, “Many proponents of a lowered drinking age blame the above behaviors on the fact that drinking is a taboo for most young people and, therefore, an act of rebellion.” 18 year olds are typically entering a new phase of independence from their parents through college or the workforce, and are more susceptible to binge drinking,…
- 682 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The percentage of deaths caused by alcohol only is 25 percent. Alcohol is already proven as a fatality for persons aged 21 and up, imagine if there was the 18-year-old age group added to the rate of those fatalities all over the country. The rate would be dramatically increased because younger people drink more. 10.1 million people are underage drinkers in America. The drinking age should stay at 21 years because the brain is not fully developed yet which can cause problematics to the brain through the final stage of its completion due to alcohol use. Alcohol violence comes in the shape of family, friends, loved ones, and associates when they are under the influence of alcohol. No matter how nice a person is, when they are under the influence, they are not the same person as they are when sober. The drinking age needs to stay at 21 for health and well-being…
- 800 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Drinking age has become one of the most debated issues among adults and teenagers in the United States. Majority of teenagers would say that there are many cons to the drinking age being set at 21 but for every con there is a pro.…
- 301 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Consequently, there’s increasingly amounts of young people that binge drink. Furthermore, binge drinking is also lethal, insomuch as, it can cause health related deaths. Gabrielle Glaser states, “A 2009 study published in The Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs found that between 1998 and 2005, the number of cases of alcohol poisoning deaths among 18- to 24-year-olds nearly tripled, jumping from 779 cases to 2,290. The study also tracks a rise in fatalities from hypothermia and falls. Some reports link excess drinking to sexual assault.” It was amazing to discover that many argue quite differently and their assumptions were actually quite comical. In contrast in my research I discovered that many feel lowering the drinking age keeps the dialogue open, and promotes a safe environment. Additionally, I even read that many feel lowering the drinking age may provide a safer environment for women. However, I have personally witnessed men becoming overly aggressive toward women who have consumed too much alcohol making themselves vulnerable to unscrupulous men. Furthermore, Therefore, I stand behind my argument that alcohol can be lethal in the hands of under aged…
- 927 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays