Economic theory; freedom and rights
Briefing Paper
November 2001
Economic Theory, Freedom and Human Rights:
The Work of Amartya Sen
This Briefing Paper reviews the ways in which the Nobel Prize winning economist Professor Amartya Sen has focussed international attention on the significance of fundamental human freedoms and human rights for development theory and practice.
In the past, dominant approaches have often characterised development in terms of GDP per capita; food security in terms of food availability; and poverty in terms of income deprivation.
Emphasis was placed on economic efficiency – with no explicit role being given to fundamental freedoms, individual agency and human rights. In contrast, Sen’s research has highlighted the central idea that, in the final analysis, market outcomes and government actions should be judged in terms of valuable human ends. His work has contributed to important paradigm shifts in economics and development – away from approaches that focus exclusively on income, growth and utility, with an increased emphasis on individual entitlements, capabilities, freedoms and rights. It has increased awareness of the importance of respect for human rights for socio-economic outcomes – challenging the proposition that growth should take priority over civil and political rights, while highlighting the role of human rights in promoting economic security, and the limitations of development without human rights guarantees. Moving theoretical and empirical economics forward: The building blocks of Sen’s approach expanding the types of variables and influences that are accommodated in theoretical and empirical economics. His contributions include far-reaching proposals for incorporating individual entitlements, functionings, opportunities, capabilities, freedoms and rights into the conceptual foundations and technical apparatus of economics and social choice. These proposals reflect a number of central recur r ing themes including: •
November 2001
Economic Theory, Freedom and Human Rights:
The Work of Amartya Sen
This Briefing Paper reviews the ways in which the Nobel Prize winning economist Professor Amartya Sen has focussed international attention on the significance of fundamental human freedoms and human rights for development theory and practice.
In the past, dominant approaches have often characterised development in terms of GDP per capita; food security in terms of food availability; and poverty in terms of income deprivation.
Emphasis was placed on economic efficiency – with no explicit role being given to fundamental freedoms, individual agency and human rights. In contrast, Sen’s research has highlighted the central idea that, in the final analysis, market outcomes and government actions should be judged in terms of valuable human ends. His work has contributed to important paradigm shifts in economics and development – away from approaches that focus exclusively on income, growth and utility, with an increased emphasis on individual entitlements, capabilities, freedoms and rights. It has increased awareness of the importance of respect for human rights for socio-economic outcomes – challenging the proposition that growth should take priority over civil and political rights, while highlighting the role of human rights in promoting economic security, and the limitations of development without human rights guarantees. Moving theoretical and empirical economics forward: The building blocks of Sen’s approach expanding the types of variables and influences that are accommodated in theoretical and empirical economics. His contributions include far-reaching proposals for incorporating individual entitlements, functionings, opportunities, capabilities, freedoms and rights into the conceptual foundations and technical apparatus of economics and social choice. These proposals reflect a number of central recur r ing themes including: •
References: Coles, J. and P. Hammond (1995). ‘Walrasian Equilibrium Without Survival: Existence, Efficiency and Remedial Policy’ Desai, M. (1990), ‘Rice and Fish: Asymmetric Preferences and Entitlement Failures in Food Growing Economies with Non-Food Producers’, European Journal of Political Economy. Drèze, J. and A. K. Sen (1989). Hunger and Public Action. Oxford, Clarendon. Eide, A. (1998-9) ‘Report Updating the Study on the Right to Food’ & ‘Updated Study on the Right Adequate Food and to be Free From Hunger’, UN.Docs.E/CN.4/Sub.2/1998/9, E/CN.4/ Sub.2/1999/12. Hayek, F. A. (1960), The Constitution of Liberty, Routledge & Kegan Paul. Maxwell, S. (1999) ‘The Meaning and Measurement of Poverty’, ODI Poverty Briefing, 3: February 1999. Nozick, R, (1974). Anarchy, State and Utopia. Oxford, Blackwell. O 'Neill, O. (1996). Towards Justice and Virtue: A Constructive Account of Practical Reasoning. Cambridge, CUP. O 'Neill, O. (1986). Faces of Hunger: An Essay on Poverty, Justice and Development. London, Allen and Unwin. Sen, A. K. (1970). The Impossibility of a Paretian Liberal’. In Choice, Welfare and Measurement (1982). Oxford, Blackwell. Sen, A. K. (1982a). ‘Rights and Agency.’ Philosophy and Public Affairs 11(1) (Winter 1982). Sen, A. K. (1985a). ‘Well-being, Agency and Freedom: The Dewey Lectures 1984.’ The Journal of Philosophy 82(4). Sen, A. K. (1985b). Rights as Goals. Equality and Discrimination: Essays in Freedom and Justice. S. Guest and A. Sen, A. K. (1992). ‘Minimal Liberty.’ Economica 59 (May 1992, No. 234.): 139-160. Sen, A. K. (1993a). Capability and Well-Being. The Quality of Life. M. Nussbaum and A. K. Sen. Oxford: OUP. Sen, A. K. (1996). Welfare Economics and Two Approaches to Rights. Current Issues in Public Choice. J. Casas Pardo and F Sen (2000), Is food more important than political freedom? BBC World Service, 20 October 2000. Vizard, P.A., (2000), Conceptualising Poverty in a Human Rights Framework: Foundational Issues in Ethics, Economics and International Law