Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Evaluate and Compare Two of the the Five Major Approaches to Psychology

Powerful Essays
1290 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Evaluate and Compare Two of the the Five Major Approaches to Psychology
Author: Ciarán O 'Sullivan
Five Pages 1205 Words

In this essay I hope to give a brief outline of the history & critiques levelled at the
Psychodynamic and the Behaviourist approaches to psychology and then attempt to offer a comparison. Psychodynamic.
Sigmund Freud 's early work in psychoanalysis was the precursor to the psychodynamic approach. His theories were later modified by others including Alfred Adler and Carl Jung.
The psychodynamic approach includes all the theories in psychology that see human functioning as based upon the interaction of drives and forces within the person, particularly unconscious conflict between the different structures of the personality.
(Barker, 2003)
Freud posited that the mind consisted of three areas the conscious, the unconscious and the preconscious and that within that framework the personality of a person existed. Freud further divided the personality into three parts. The ID a selfish unconscious area that operates on the pleasure principal, the Ego a conscious area that operates on the reality principle and the
Superego where a persons concept of right and wrong exist. Freud used Dream analysis and Free association (Talking therapy) as a means to gain access to a patients unconscious thought.
Freud believed that the personality has five 'Psychosexual Stages ' of development that must be experienced and resolved in order to avoid later neuroses. “Failure to resolve the oral stage would lead to oral fixation (such as smoking, excessive drinking, or eating disorders), and failure to resolve the anal stage would lead to excessive control and hoarding (obsessive compulsive disorder).” (Field, 2003).
I
When parts of the personality conflict Ego Defence Mechanisms are unconsciously employed to protect the self from anxiety. For example, “we speak of people as 'repressed ' if they appear not to show their emotions and as 'in denial ' if they refuse to accept unpalatable facts.” (Jarvis, 2003)
While Freud is where psychodynamic theory originated other theorists have added to it and modified aspects based on their own observations. Alfred Adler saw birth order as being important in the development of a person’s personality. Jung had the theory of a collective unconscious based on the experiences of our ancestors and reflected in cultural myths and symbols. Jung also saw people as being born with an ‘introvert’ or ‘extravert’ personality type.
Criticism has been levelled at how data is gathered by practitioners of the psychodynamic approach. That it is based on qualitative rather then quantitative data, primarily single case studies and the analysts own interpretation of each case rather then large scale recreatable experiments making it unfalsifiable or not rigorously scientific. But despite these issues, the approaches and terminology used in psychodynamic theory have entered the public arena and is regarded by many, weather right or wrong, as the common sense approach to therapy.
Behaviourism.
The ground work for the field of Behaviourism was developed simultaneously by Ivan Pavlov and John Watson at the beginning of the 20th Century. The basic assumption of the behaviourist is that the mind is a black box that can not be studied and all that can be studied is a subject’s observable response to a stimulus.
II
In
1913 Watson in his so called “Behaviourist Manifesto” printed as the article “Psychology as the behaviourist views it.” laid out the framework for the future behaviourist. This document stated that: l Psychology must be purely objective, excluding all subjective data or interpretations in terms of conscious experience. l The Goals of psychology should be to predict and control behaviour. l Human behaviour is simply a more complex form of the behaviour of other species. (Gross, 2005)
While giving an address to the American Psychological Association in 1915, Watson discussed his recent 'discovery ' of Ivan Pavlov and his work on reflex responses, or classical conditioning.
While studying gastric reflex in dogs, Pavlov discovered that a salivary response could be activated in the dogs by a conditioned stimulus (CS) such as a bell ringing, if this stimulus was linked to a previously unconditioned stimulus (UCS) like the presentation of food. When the dogs where given food they naturally produced a salivary response this is the unconditioned response (UCR). With the linking of the UCS to the CS the dogs learned to expect food when the bell rang. They would start to salivate at the hearing of the bell even if no food was produced this is called the conditioned response (CR).
While Watson and Pavlov where concerned with reflex responses another area of study for behaviourists is operant conditioning or voluntary behaviour. This theory of behaviour was arrived at by Burrhus Frederic Skinner and is an evolution of Edward Thorndike’s (1913) “Law of effect”. Thorndike used his 'Puzzle Box ' to show that behaviour was formed through “trial and error learning” (Malin & Birch, 1998). Skinner used a similar method namely his 'Skinner
III
Box ' to show that rats could be trained to act in specific way for reward. These experiments showed that the behaviour of the rats could be shaped, to press a lever, when a suitable reward, food, was used as a positive reinforcer. Conversely he found rats could also be trained to stop a negative action occurring. The Rats learned that to stop receiving an electrical shock they had to press a lever, this being a negative reinforcement.
While behaviourism improved psychology’s status among the scientific community for its laboratory experiments and clearly defined theory 's. It is regarded by many as being limited in its application, it does not describe how spontaneous or creative behaviour is produced. It completely ignores internal mental processes as irrelevant regarding the mind as an impenetrable 'black box ' . Also its reliance on animal research has been questioned in terms of how accurate it is to say animal behaviour can be related to human behaviour when there are innate differences such as language.
While behaviourism developed as an opposing response to psychodynamics and that psychodynamic theory focuses on internal mental behaviour and behaviourism on external viewable behaviour. They can still be seen to have things in common. Both approaches believe that current behaviour is a product of past experience. The psychodynamic approach believes that what happened to you in your formative years gets suppressed into the unconscious and can effect your attitudes and behaviours in later life. Behaviourism believes that you act the way you do from past experiences through conditional learning. You learned that a particular behaviour has positive or negative consequences so you act accordingly in a given situation.
IV
Both approaches stem from the deterministic standpoint that uncontrollable forces are the cause of behaviour. The ID in psychodynamic theory is the manifestation of biological determinism and behaviourism comes from environmental determinism which states that local environments and available learning opportunities can explain current and predict future behaviour.
I chose to evaluate and compare these two areas of psychology because in the 20th century these two areas of psychology where the guiding force in a new era of modern psychology. I felt that
I would not have been able to explain humanist or cognitive psychology 's for example without referring in some way to these areas of study. OK my conclusion sucks and will be amended but the fact that I 've finally reached some semblance of a final article is moderately relieving despite the amount of re writes it took.... Try not to be too harsh I 'm very breakable :)
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Malin, T. & Birch, A. (1998). Introductory Psychology. London: Macmillan Press Ltd.
Barker, M. (2003).Introductory Psychology: History, Themes and Perspectives. Exeter: Crucial.
Field, A. P. (2003). Clinical Psychology. Exeter: Crucial.
Jarvis, M. (2003). Psychodynamic Psychology: Classical Theory and Contemporary Research.
London: Thomson Learning .
Gross, R.. (2005). Psychology: the science of mind and behaviour. 5th ed. London: Hodder and Stoughton.
V

Bibliography: Malin, T. & Birch, A. (1998). Introductory Psychology. London: Macmillan Press Ltd. Barker, M. (2003).Introductory Psychology: History, Themes and Perspectives. Exeter: Crucial. Field, A. P. (2003). Clinical Psychology. Exeter: Crucial. Jarvis, M. (2003). Psychodynamic Psychology: Classical Theory and Contemporary Research. London: Thomson Learning . Gross, R.. (2005). Psychology: the science of mind and behaviour. 5th ed. London: Hodder and Stoughton. V

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Critical Lens

    • 1317 Words
    • 1 Page

    preconscious, and unconscious mind. The ego works to meet the demands of the id, while…

    • 1317 Words
    • 1 Page
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Freud’s idea states that the psyche - which is made up of the (id, ego and superego), should all work in perfect harmony with each other to avoid being an abnormal person. It is the idea that conscious thoughts and feelings are determined by the unconscious mind, and essentially being mentally healthy requires a good balance between: the id (which controls the desires for which we live for in order to satisfy ourselves), the superego (which takes into consideration morals and the difference between right and wrong) and the ego (which balances the superego and id to keep our behaviour in check). From these 3 components in the psyche, you can quickly see that the id and superego are constantly in conflict. This ultimately means that for a person to not develop a psychological disorder - a strong ego is necessary as it will “get the best of both worlds” and create a balance, while allowing the superego and id to express themselves (when suitable), without dominating the personality and hence, causing a psychological disorder. An example of an abnormality which could occur from the id being too strong in kids (is developing conduct disorders). In adults (they become psychopaths), all because of the personality being taken over by the id. If the superego is too strong socially acceptable pleasures will be hard to come by as neurotic behaviours such as phobias and obsessions will be apparent, as they will be constantly fixated with things that they want to do but “cant” because their too scared.…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Freud’s work is now the most heavily cited in all of psychology. Most of Freud’s patients did not need treatment so he resorted to using hypnosis. He used the technique of free association in order to understand the causes of mental and physical problems in his patients. Dreams to him were saw as pieces and hints of unconscious. The problems of inner conflict and tension are found in dreams. There are three structured parts in the mind according to Freud. The three parts are id, ego, and superego. Freud’s and Jung are compared by using unconscious sexuality in their theories. The id, das es in German means the it; it operates according to the demands of the pleasure principle to reduce inner tension. Ego is the Latin word for I. Personality that deals with the real world according to the reality principle to solve real problems. Superego rules over the ego and parts are unconscious, though it constrains our individual actions. Freud looked for meaning in minor connections thoughts and behaviors. Now 100 of years later there are no three levels id, ego, and superego. Freud was correct in concluding that certain parts of the mind are not subject to conscious awareness. His theories opened new approaches to human nature and psychotherapy.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    One of such theories is the psychoanalysis. It lies in the researches of the human minds and the principles of its working. Main theorists, S. Freud and J. Breuer, emphasized the role of the childhood memories in explaining of different fears and psychological problems of the clients. In fact, S. Freud singled out three components of a human mind. They are id, ego, and superego. The Id is that part of the personality, on which the instinctual drives and needs have a great impact. This aspect is very unstable and dynamic. In other words, it is unmanageable as it is ready to satisfy all demands and avoid pain and problems in any way. Therefore, there is the other element called ego. It deals with the realistic purposes and tries to slow down the impulsiveness of the id. Ego balances between the instinctive drives and realistic principles trying to achieve as many benefits as possible. However, there is a third element superego. It deals with the morality principles. In fact, superego makes instinctive needs and drives reflect in the socially accepted ways. Morality principles and social laws limit the individual 's desires to satisfy basic needs (Masling, 1990).…

    • 1036 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our personality is our characteristic pattern of thinking, feeling and acting (Psychology David G Myers), it’s the combination of traits that ‘outlines the doctrine of uniqueness’ (Gifts Differing – Understanding Personality Types) that sets us apart from everyone else. Psychologists vary between themselves concerning the meaning of personality. Most would agree that it originated from the Latin word persona’ – meaning a theoretical mask – but they differ on how an individual obtains this ‘unique mask’ (i.e. how they develop their personality) and thus this brings the divers theories of personality. This essay will compare and contrast two popular theories: one being the: Psychoanalytic theory, and the other a Humanistic approach.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    counselling theory essay

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As a way of freud understanding people’s thoughts and motivations he introduced the idea of distinct psychosexual stages. The psychosexual stages are oral, anal, phallic, latency and genital.…

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gross R, 2005, Psychology: The science of mind and behaviour, 5th Edition, Hodder Arnold: London…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the main assumptions of the psychodynamic approach to psychology is that the personality consists of three separate divisions; the id, the ego and the superego. The id represents all of your selfish needs and wishes, and your desire to have them satisfied immediately. The superego is your morality, the part of your brain which conflicts with the id, for example if your id tells you that you need a new X-Box game immediately, your superego stops you as it would reason that you don’t want to upset your mum by asking for it. The ego finds the ground between the two, a compromise as you couldn’t satisfy both the id and the superego at once.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Psychodynamic Approach

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Freud believed we as children go through a series of 5 psychosexual stages: The Oral Stage, The Anal Stage, The Phallic Stage, The Latency Period and lastly the Genital Stage. Oral stage begins at birth right up to the child is 18 months old where our erogenous zones include our mouth, lips and tongue and forms enjoyable activities such as sucking, biting and chewing. Following this is the anal stage which happens between 18 months and 3 years old, an example here would be toilet training the child. The erogenous zone involves stopping or having bowel movements, while fixation is when the parents are rewarding or punishing the child on how they done. Moreover, the Phallic stage ranges from 3-6 year olds and focuses on the genitals and admiring the opposite sex and adapting the our behaviour of the same sex.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

     This copy of the dissertation has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is understood to recognise that its copyright rests with the author and that no quotation from the dissertation, nor any information derived therefrom, may be published without the author 's prior, written consent.…

    • 17817 Words
    • 72 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Freud’s personality structure is divided into three sections, Id, Superego, and Ego. Freud explained this concept by using an iceberg. He says that the tip of the iceberg or the part that floats above water is our conscious awareness which would be the ego also known as the executive mediator, below the surface the much larger area is the Id, and the superego which is just a little above water and also a little below water. The ego and superego operate both consciously and unconsciously. The id is driven by the pleasure principle which demands for immediate gratification, needs, or wants. According to Freud the Id strives to satisfy basic sexual and aggressive drives. The ego is the conscious mind that mediates among the demands of the Id, superego, and reality, it satisfies the Id’s desires in ways that will realistically bring pleasure rather than pain. The Superego is the aspect of personality that holds all of our internalized ideals, or more like our sense of right and wrong, it somewhat filters our judgments.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Psychoanalysis

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Austrian physician Sigmund Freud (1856)founded the psychoanalysis theory which views sex, aggression and the unconscious as being majorinfluences on behaviour.Freud believed the mind operated on three levels: unconscious, preconscious, and conscious and that the mind was composed of three elements: the id, the ego, and the superego. He also looked at the psychosexual stages of development and the use of defense mechanisms…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Surrealism

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Was based on Freud the idea of the conscious mind struggling against the irrational and the unconscious…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Freud’s greatest contribution to personality theory is his exploration of the unconscious and his insistence that people are motivated primarily by drives of which they have little or no awareness. To Freud, mental life is divided into two levels, the unconscious and the conscious. The unconscious, in turn, has two different levels, the unconscious proper and the preconscious. In Freudian psychology the three levels of mental life are used to designate both a process and a location. The existence as a specific location, of course, is merely hypothetical and has no real existence within the body. Yet, Freud spoke of the unconscious as well as unconscious…

    • 2100 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sigmund Freud is known for his study on the three basic components that greatly affect our personality. He created the three levels of awareness that are congruent to the three different parts of the mind: conscious mind, preconscious mind, and subconscious mind. According to him, our conscious mind includes our current or present mental processes contributing a major part in our current awareness.…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays