Preview

Evaluate The Effectiveness Of Law Reform Essay

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1121 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Evaluate The Effectiveness Of Law Reform Essay
Evaluate the Effectiveness of Law Reform in Dealing with Defences to Criminal Charges in the Criminal Justice System.

Evaluate: Make a judgment based on criteria
- Equality
- Accessibility (Draft Bill and Report)
- Enforceability (In the future - provocation bill)
- Resource Efficiency (Time taken to establish the committee and the time the committee has taken)
- Protection of Individual Rights
- Meeting Society’s Needs / How Responsive (Fast response due to media outcry)
- Rule of Law
- Achieving Justice (Is it better now for “society”, is there success for the abusers or the victims)

Law Reform - Provocation:
- Where an attacker loses control based on the actions or the words of the deceased person and where those action could have …show more content…
(Committee report)
• Reform follows on from the April 2013 release of the Final Report of the Select Committee of the NSW Parliamentary Inquiry into the operation of the partial defence of provocation
• “Without provocation, vulnerable defendants would be convicted of murder and risk long terms of imprisonment.” (Problem)
• In the most controversial cases, men who have killed a female intimate partner in response to a relationship separation or an alleged confession of infidelity have been able to avoid a conviction for murder by arguing that it was the non-violent conduct of the victim that provoked them to kill.

Evidence - Crimes Amendment (Provocation) Bill 2013 (NSW)
• Partial Defence of Extreme Provocation
The defence will now require the provocative conduct on part of the victim to be a serious indictable offence
Advantage to battered women

Evidence - Green v The Queen 1997
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Cja34 Week 3 Individual Worksheet
    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Cja34 Week 3 Individual Worksheet

    References: Schmalleger, F., Hall, D. E., & Dolatowski, J. J. (2010). Criminal Law Today: An introduction with…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Describe the Extent to Which Recent Reforms to Murder in the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 Are a Change for the Better but Have Not Necessarily Satisfied Those Who Campaigned for Change.
    • 1882 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Describe the Extent to Which Recent Reforms to Murder in the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 Are a Change for the Better but Have Not Necessarily Satisfied Those Who Campaigned for Change.

    There are three stages to proving loss of self control. Stage one is the defendant’s actions (in doing or being a party to a killing) must be down to the result of a loss of self control. There is no need for loss of self control to be ‘sudden’ however in court a jury can still take into account the delay between the incident and the killing, this is now available to a defendant if they acted in a ‘considered desire for revenge.’ A case related to this is Duffy 1949, the defendant killed her husband after mistreatment, she removed their child from the home and when her husband was asleep she killed him with a hatchet and hammer, she was found to be guilty. Previously any cooling off period might have counted against the defendant. This was problematic for women who were in violent relationships; they were unable to plead the defence due to the perceived element of pre-meditation. In Ahluwalia a woman had been in an arranged marriage, her husband was very violent towards her over a period of 10 years. She poured white spirit over her husband and set it alight causing his death. The courts accepted the possibility of a slow burn reaction; however it is very difficult to prove. Court of appeal concluded diminished responsibility.…

    • 1882 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    CJA 464 Week 3 DQs
    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages

    CJA 464 Week 3 DQs

    DQ 1: What is the historical evolution of policy within the criminal justice system? How has the approach to poli...…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Legal Studies- Webquest on Law Reforms
    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Legal Studies- Webquest on Law Reforms

    * Changing social values- The Law will reflect these changing social values i.e. Decriminalisation of homosexuality and prostitution.…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    NFO Criticisms
    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages

    NFO Criticisms

    The greatest criticism is that because the OAPA was passed in1861 the language is outdated and antiquated, which causes confusion. Words like ‘grievous’ in s20 GBH have been modernised by case law, DPP v Smith stated that grievous should mean ‘really serious harm’. However this still calls into question the severity of ‘really serious’. Another ambiguous term from s20 GBH is ‘wounding’, this was defined in Eisenhower, an example of case law improving the statute. Yet case law can also be misleading as with the word ‘immediate’ when defining Assault, in Smith v CSI Woking Police the assault was ‘sufficiently immediate for the purposes of the offence’. This was then extended in R v Ireland and R v Constanza to include phone calls and letters, so immediacy has become a very broad definition. Despite this there is a clear gap in law if a threat is made for the next day. As well as the unclear meaning of some terms, the definition of some has changed as the English language has developed over time, some words used for Non-Fatal Offences have acquired new meanings or are no longer used in everyday language, a brilliant example of this is ‘assualt’ which now, in everyday language, is used to mean a physical form of attack, which obviously…

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Summary: Declining Homicide Rates In Canada
    • 2310 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Summary: Declining Homicide Rates In Canada

    Serran, G., Firestone, P. “Intimate Partner Homicide: A review of the male proprietariness and the self-defense theories.” Aggression and Violent Behavior. (2004). Vol. 9, pp.1-15.…

    • 2310 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Criminal Law and Social Factors
    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Criminal Law and Social Factors

    The aim of this case is to present a contemporary criminal case. The case must have occurred in the last ten years. It must be an indictable offence, a more serious criminal charge where the defendant has the right to trial by jury and has been found guilty. The analysis of the case will be carried out through the extent which the law balances the rights of victims and offenders.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Law Reform- My Report
    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Law Reform- My Report

    * Law reform is the change in laws as society’s morals and ethics change. Example-capital punishment.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    How Serial Rapists Choose Their Victims
    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages

    How Serial Rapists Choose Their Victims

    every aspect of the victim as well as the offender. My research proposal aims to determine what,…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Arguments Against Domestic Violence
    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Arguments Against Domestic Violence

    What is the effectiveness of the legal responses in achieving justice for women against domestic violence?…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Research and Analysis
    • 2539 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Research and Analysis

    Caroletta, A. S. (2010). Male victims of intimate partner violence in the United States: An examination of the review of literature through the critical theoretical perspective. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 5(1), 163-173.…

    • 2539 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Provocation Restrictions
    • 222 Words
    • 1 Page

    Provocation Restrictions

    In the Anglo-American modern theory of criminal law, provocation refers to the words or actions that the victim (sometimes referred to as a third party) can impose on the defendant, which can and in fact makes a rational defendant temporarily lose self-control. But the protection of provocation defense is the product of the common law.However, the common law in the recognition of the victim provocation defense, but the establishment of the provocation was very strict restrictions.In the traditional common law theory, the establishment of the victim Provocations have strict limits on the existence of a limited number of acts that can constitute provocation, and that the words, and the murder of the spouse or adulterous person by the spouse's…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Recklessness
    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Recklessness

    The development of the law in this area will be looked out with the aid of case law such as R v Cunningham [1957] R v Caldwell [1982] and R v G [2003]. In order to identify and understand the concept of recklessness, intention needs to be discussed. The 19th century criminal legislation required that defendants had to have acted `maliciously’ and `unlawfully’ when committing an offence. The accused will act unlawfully if D fails to present a lawful reason for D’s act, D would be considered acting maliciously once D satisfies the level of Mens Rea required for the Actus Reus. The word `malicious’ introduces the requirement of Mens Rea. The statutory definition of `malice’ is, requiring an actual intention to do a particular kind of harm that in fact was done, or reckless as to whether such harm should occur or not. The accused has foreseen that…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Domestic Violence Against Women
    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Domestic Violence Against Women

    The United States Surgeon General reports that domestic violence is the greatest single cause of injury among U.S. women, accounting for more emergency room visits than auto accidents, mugging and rape combined (Shupe). According to, The Federal Bureau of Justice Statistics Report, 95% of all documented domestic assault crimes are committed by men against women; in 1996 there were 15,000 calls to law enforcement agencies in Sacramento County for domestic violence response (FBI). It is very difficult to know the exact number of victims of domestic violence, especially sexual assault and other incidents committed by the intimate offenders, due to the many occurrences not reported to the police. There are many factors that victims consider in their decision not to report it to the police, but the greatest reason is the fear that threats to kill you or your family will become reality. Other reasons include embarrassment, shame and hopes that his promises to change will come true this time. There is an assumption in our society that there is a clear relationship between anger and physical violent behavior. However, anger is a human emotion and studies have shown that physical violence or abuse is a learnt behavior and the perpetrator is more often than not, going to repeat this behavior. All human beings experience anger at one time or another. People get angry with their…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    The Provocation Debate
    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Provocation Debate

    * Provocation- common law, criminal defence * Either or both statutory or common law * Possible defence by excuse or exculpation alleging a sudden or temporary loss of control- in response to another’s provocative conduct to justify an acquittal, mitigated sentence or conviction of lesser charge * Can be relevant in a court’s assessment of a defendant’s mens rea, intention or state of mind at the time of the incident * In some cases in UK, Canada and several Australian states, the defence of provocation is available only against a charge of murder- and can reduce to manslaughter * Known as ‘voluntary manslaughter’ * In USA the Model Penal Code substitutes the broader standard of extreme emotional or mental distress for the comparatively narrower standard of provocation * Under USA Sentencing Guidelines for federal courts- ‘if the victim’s wrongful conduct contributed significantly to provoking the offence behaviour, the court may reduce the sentence below the guideline range the reflect the nature and circumstances of the offenceHistory- * Developed in English courts in 16th – 17th century * At that time a conviction of murder carried a death sentence- thus a lesser offence was needed * At the time it was seen as socially required for a man to respond with controlled violence if ‘his honour or dignity was insulted or threatened’ * It was then considered to be understandable that the violence might be excessive and end in murder * In the 19th century the idea of acceptable violence when insulted began to weaken * The circumstanced were changed to- while such responses may not be ideal, they were a normal reaction resulting from loss of self- control- and thus deserved mitigating circumstances * By the end of the 20th century and beginning of the 21st century the defence of provocation and when it should be applied has caused much controversy * Many put it down to anachronism-…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More

Related Topics