In this assignment I will be evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of activity and disengagement theory and how these theories can be applied to Mr Lee. When people get older they can take different approaches to aging and may have different theories that are relating to the aging process whether it being disengagement theory or activity theory. The elderly all deal with aging different, some can chose to be active or disengage themselves from society whether it being because of depression or may not deal with depression well.
Both activity theory and disengagement theory have different views and opinions on aging process. There are many services that are available for the elderly’s which aims to help the elderly stay active, socially, emotionally, intellectually and physically developed. All the developments just mentioned are very important for the elderly to keep them mentally and physically healthy which can include day centres where they can meet new people who are going through the same thing as them which will increase their social development.
Mr Lee is a 76 year old man who was married to his wife for 50 years who sadly passed away 2 years ago. They had 3 children who live close by with their families. One factor of activity theory that can be seen to influence Mr Lee’s ageing and health and social care provision is the fact that Mr Lee has always been fit and active which will increase his physically development in the sense that it will allow Mr Lee to maintain a healthy weight and reduce the risks of cancer and other diseases, even diseases that a prone as you get older such as arthritis. In addition to this, Mr Lee works as a volunteer at the age exchange in Blackheath. which he enjoys meeting customers and participants at the shop which will expand his social development as he will get to meet new people are make new friends and it will prevent Mr Lee from feeling like he is alone, this will also increase Mr Lee’s self confidence and self-esteem due to the fact that he is still involved with society that because he has retired he should disengage from society.
However, activity theory may not apply to Mr Lee’s ageing and health and social care provision because Mr Lee has suffered with mild low back pain for the past 20 years which could prevent him from maintaining an active lifestyle and he be restricted in many things such volunteering, if he doesn’t go and get it checked out it could result in Mr Lee having to stop his volunteering and participating in workshops with schools and the university of Greenwich.
One factor of Disengagement Theory (Cumming and Henry, 1961) that can be seen to influence Mr. Lee's ageing and health and social care provision is being lonely and socially disengaged from society because as people start to get older and begin to fall in the aging processes such as mobility. Mobility can be problem such as unsteadiness whilst walking, falling or having problems getting in and out of chairs, joint problems such as arthritis. For example, Mr Lee suffers from back problems so it is very important he gets it checked whether it being as the local GP or hospital which will prevent his pains from getting worse. Also being socially isolated from society can affect self-esteem and confidence which could occur as the elderly person may not want to disturb other people with their problems and may see themselves as burdens to society so they should just disengage themselves as they think they are helping society out.
However, disengagement theory may not apply to Mr Lee’s ageing and health and social acre provision as he is very active and he volunteers with age Exchange which allows him to be involved with other people in society that are going through the same process as him.
In my conclusion, the theory that applies to Mr Lee the most is the activity theory because Mr Lee stays active and is fit and doesn’t have a problem with being restricted from social connections because he does a lot of volunteering. Mr Lee’s life, even at seventy six it is more like a middle-aged lifestyle. The disengagement theory does not apply to him as much because Mr Lee is not withdrawn or disengaging because he has a lot of family around him and is not by himself all the time, even though his wife passed away.
Even though he has had a problem with his back, it has not stopped him from going out to help out at schools and at the University of Greenwich. Physically his health is good and with him not smoking, he is giving himself a better chance to be able to stay active and fit. The disengagement theory states that it is normal if older people withdraw from social interactions but because of Mr Lee’s volunteering, he always has friends or people to speak to and this all applies to the activity theory. The activity theory is more like Mr Lee’s life than the disengagement theory because the life that he has been living does not fall into the disengagement theory.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Cox, H. G. (2006). Later life: The realities of aging (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ:…
- 1403 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
This is the first formal theory of aging and it was brought forward by Elaine Cumming and William Henry in 1961, and they looked at how society views older people. During their research they found that older people disengaged from society. They argue that older personnel withdraw from society, for example they stop working/retirement, they stop socialising, they feel that they are no longer needed by wider society, for example they younger generation, the wider society does not include family and friends, and that age is a number that represents what we can and cannot do. On reflection we can see that this view is flawed because it is very dated and does not show a true picture of today’s society and views. Also this view is the total opposite of the newer activity theory.…
- 2500 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Novak, M. (2009). Issues in Aging. (2nd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.…
- 1299 Words
- 38 Pages
Better Essays -
Some people might want to still go out with their friends or some might disengage and this might be due to their spouse been diagnosed with an illness so they have to stay in and look after them which could lead to depression. There are many services which can help older people and these are provided so that they can help the elderly people remain active socially, physically, emotionally and intellectually. All of these are aspects are important when trying to keep older people mentally and physically healthy. These services can be a day centre where they can go to do activities and be able to socialise with their friends. Another service where elderly people could go to such as Activities For Older people which are led by a group of social workers who support them and also assistance the elderly. Activities that you could do when you are there are going out shopping, going out to parks, visiting friends or help them with everyday tasks that will help build up their confidence so that they can do it at…
- 1056 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Unlike the Disengagement theory the Activity theory by Havinghurst and colleagues in 1963 is the idea that the more active an older person is the greater their life satisfaction. Within the Activity theory there is the idea of role changes, for example you once worked but now retired you have filled the time with volunteering, family and socialising. The activities the older people decide…
- 4391 Words
- 18 Pages
Better Essays -
The Activity theory theorizes that when individuals engage and interact with their environment are all things that elderly individuals can be positive to their life and can be a positive sense of self, i.e. retiring may not be so harmful if the person actively maintains other roles, such as familial roles, recreational roles, and volunteer & community roles. They believe individuals should be encouraged to remain active & develop own-age friends.…
- 938 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
M2 Discuss two major theories in ageing in relation to the development of the individual…
- 2430 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Activities exclude bathing,dressing,eating,toileting,moving about indoors and getting in and out of bed, elderly people are more likely to be at least partially dependent upon others for assistance with these activities, there personal beliefs and attitudes, physical illness and wellbeing…
- 1340 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Cox, H. G. (2006). Later Life: The Realities of Aging (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ:…
- 1751 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
During the ageing process, the elderly may take different approaches to aging and may apply to different theories of aging such as disengagement theory and the activity theory. All elderly individuals will deal with aging in different ways. They may wish to stay active or they may wish to disengage themselves due to depression or they may be unable to deal with the processes of becoming older.…
- 260 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
[11] Butler, R. (1974). Successful aging and the role of life review. Journal of the American Geriatric Society, 22, 529-535.…
- 7719 Words
- 31 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The activity theory is the needs of staying active in older age and continue being involved in activities. People transitions from midlife to the older age and will remain at the current level of activities. This theory is the focus changes the old age people also have the same motivation, wants, and needs as the middle life counterparts.…
- 216 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The long-term care argument is relevant when discussing the plight of the aging in the population. As noted in the text, the aging population comprises an important part of the current population, which are the baby boomers. The present reality that these individuals could be above the age of 65 years means that they will have recurrent concerns related to their health status. The number of this aging population is even more in the rural setting where there is often minimal focus on health care insurance (Kirn, 2005). For this reason, long-term care policies for the elderly in the society present an important platform to develop a health care system that can adequately deal with the challenges of dealing with the health needs of an aging population.…
- 242 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
They argue that disengagement in old age happens voluntarily and with the approval of the younger generation because it frees up work for them. They suggest it is normal and appropriate that has benefits of society and the older people. The disengagement theory has been criticised for the acceptance of the social exclusion for older people, They say that you could be argued that age is then restrict the ability of some older people, They think that they are not active citizens and they withdrawal from active social roles and it's not a choice. Their original research has been criticises well is based on small sample of American adults who were taken to be typical of or older people everywhere they also just suggest that many older people remain engaged with their family and friends and then no more socially active in these types of groups once they have retired from work. To Mary worked until an old age and she would've been acted until then going to work playing with her children when she grows older she may Now still be active with walking to the shops or going to different…
- 464 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Two major theories explain the psychosocial aspects of aging in older adults. Disengagement theory views aging as a process of mutual withdrawal in which older adults voluntarily slow down by retiring, as expected by society. Proponents of disengagement theory hold that mutual social withdrawal benefits both individuals and society. Activity theory, on the other hand, sees a positive correlation between keeping active and aging well. Proponents of activity theory hold that mutual social withdrawal runs counter to traditional American ideals of activity, energy, and industry. To date, research has not shown either of…
- 1747 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays