Preview

Examples Of Restitutio Integrum

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1127 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Examples Of Restitutio Integrum
Introduction
This essay argues that the underlying principle on which damages for personal injury are awarded, which is restitutio in integrum is fundamentally flawed. Firstly, the damages assessment for future earning capacity based on an individual's occupation and race is discussed as discriminatory since it promotes social inequality. Secondly, the entrenching social issue of gender-based assumptions is examined as another flaw of the principle due to its unfair outcome.
Furthermore, the legislative changes influenced by the Ipp Panel Report are discussed as failing to address the discriminatory aspect of the principle.
Lastly, the impossibility of predicting the future and placing monetary value to compensate intangible injuries are examined
…show more content…
The differential valuation of an individual's loss based on systematic factors such as gender, race and socio-economic status can detrimentally affect the damages awarded for future earning capacity . The restitutio principle attempts to reimburse an individual had the tort not occurred by placing an emphasis on their social identity. Accordingly, a person from a more privileged background such as in Norris v Blake, would benefit from the principle, while others from a less fortunate background would experience discrimination. For example, in Dixon v Davies, the damages for future economic loss was calculated on the basis of the injured individual's Aboriginal identity. This led to the reduced compensation because of the expectation shorter working life compared to other members of the society . The court's consideration of Aboriginal morality in determining damages is problematic because it is discriminatory against individuals of that background. In this regard, a claimant may receive different rewards for the same injury because it depends on their racial identification. Thus, the restitutio principle is deemed undesirable because systemic inequality is consistently reproduced in the courts through the disproportionate allocation of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In this case the court considered the defendant’s argument that discrimination on the basis of sex because of safety concerns is allowed in certain situations. To help illustrate this point the court examined Dothard v. Rawlinson, a case where a maximum-security male penitentiary was allowed to hire only male guards to be in contact with inmates because more was at stake then simply their own safety. This case, used by the defendant, was rejected by the court in that in this situation the well being of third parties were not involved. The court also considered that while there was a risk to the fetus, the extent of injury that is likely to occur was not addressed. Even without this information, the policy reaches to far in that there is no showing that it is necessary to ensure the safe and efficient operation of Johnson Controls. The court also considered that until 1982, Johnson Controls operated without this policy and has since failed to provide information to lead one to believe that it is reasonably necessary to its normal operations or that they suffered any adverse effects prior to its…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Have you ever followed a court case and been astonished at the outcome and the damages awarded in the case? I believe we have all heard about cases where the plaintiff is awarded a very large sum of money for a case that appears not to warrant the award. Most of these scenarios take place in cases where the tort law applies. According to authors Kubasek, Brennan and Browne (2009), tort law is defined as injury that to a person or their property. Tort law is primarily a state law and stipulations can vary. Tort law was put in place to encourage civility, discourage people and companies from private retaliation and to compensate innocent people who are injured due to the wrongful act of a person or company. According to The Legal Environment of Business A Critical Thinking Approach, there are different types of damages awarded in relation to tort cases. These damages are nominal, which is usually awarded when the plaintiff has not suffered serious damage, compensatory, which include general and special damages, and punitive damages. Punitive damages are usually intended to punish defendants and often go beyond simply compensating the plaintiff. (Kubasek et al.,2009)…

    • 3046 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    B law

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Due to the conflicting provisions in each Act, problems has create from the differences, anomalies and inconsistencies. In the second part, this assignment is going to Identify and discuss the differences, anomalies and inconsistencies between the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) and other personal injury Acts within Victoria in respect to damages and the problems that arrive therein, especially the difference with personal injury damages.…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Rawls’ Fairness Approach is an appropriate ethical framework to use when assessing this dilemma. This approach questions if everyone involved is being treated fairly (is there favoritism and discrimination?). The Fairness Approach examines how fairly or unfairly the actions of an individual or group distribute benefits and burdens everyone else. With this approach, consistency of treatment among persons is key. The only insistence when treatment must differ is if there is a morally relevant difference between people (Andre, Meyer, Shanks, Velasquez, 1989). There are three different kinds of justice -- Distributive, Restorative, and Compensatory. Distributive justice focuses on the benefits and burdens evenly distributed amongst society’s…

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Australian legal system doesn't deliver justice equally for all Australians. In this essay, the issues of the relationship between laws to ethics, morals and values, access to the legal system and issues of fairness in the law will be discussed. There are several relevant examples that have influenced the viewpoint of this essay. The case of Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss, the case of Amy vs Adam (www.lawcouncil.asn.au) and the case of Brendan Dassey.…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this section of the essay, we will prove the that the laws are fair from a personal injury law standpoint. According to law 218, “If a surgeon has operated with a bronze lancet on a free man for a serious injury, and has caused death, his hands shall be cut off. I believe this is fair because, a surgeon should know what he’s doing. I also belive if someone is “punished” for another's actions, the one who caused the injury should be punished also.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Court recognized that Aboriginal offenders merit special consideration by the criminal justice system due to their unique historic background and overrepresentation in the prison population (R v Gladue, at para. 77). Moreover, the Court emphasized how the sentencing judge can have a direct impact on how the criminal justice system treats Aboriginal offenders, and should come up with sentences that are meaningful for the offender and their community (para 74). Consequently, when considering the circumstances of Aboriginal offenders, the Court directs judges to assess whether prison is the best form of punishment and to give more consideration to culturally appropriate sentences. Furthermore, in their ruling, the Court emphasized that although section 718.2(e) of the Code is intended to apply to all offenders, judges should bear in mind the special circumstances of Aboriginal offenders when sentencing (para…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    uncertainty in the evaluation of an injury claim and the extent of a claimant's physical abilities.…

    • 1718 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tma2 131

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages

    With reference to The Act there appears to be many aspects of unfair treatment taking place based on a very old law which hasn’t as yet been updated to move with the current times.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Advanced Directives

    • 3334 Words
    • 14 Pages

    Fitzerald, Patrick, Krueger, Kurt V. (2005, Nov 19). Tort Remedy in the Law Versus Economic Restitution for Personal Injury and Wrongful Death. South Economic Association 75th Annual Meeting, Retrieved June 2006, from http://johnwardeconomics.com/Research%20and%20Data/Tort%20Remedy%20v%20Economic%20Restitution.pdf…

    • 3334 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What would happen in the event that the injured, loses the case? What about the fate of the plaintiff? This would mean that, the harmed party would suffer more since they would not be compensated after losing the case. On the other hand, the defendant would lose no dime even after causing injury to another party. This screams injustice in any reasonable society.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    * The Civil Rights Act of 1991: It specifies that women who face job-related discrimination are entitled to monetary damages. Women who observe discriminatory behaviour can consult with lawyers, including civil rights advocates who offer free advice and may even take a case and charge small or no legal fees. However, equal rights for women in the workplace does not eliminate the reality of merit-based pay and variable pay scales for workers based on seniority and job effectiveness. Women are simply entitled to the same…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Concern over the quality of health care services in Bangladesh has led to loss of faith in low utilization of public health facilities, and increasing outflow of Bangladeshi patients to private hospitals. The public health sector is plagued by uneven demand and perceptions of poor quality. Countrywide, the underutilization of available facilities is of significant concern. For example, one study shows that the overall utilization rate for public health care services is as low as 30% (Ricardo et al. 2004). Moreover, the trend of utilization of public health care services has been declining between 1999 and 2003, while the rate of utilization of private health care facilities for the same period has been increasing (CIET Canada 2003). The unavailability of doctors and nurses, as well as their negative attitudes and behaviors, are major hindrances to the utilization of public hospitals. The situation is further compounded by lack of drugs, and long travel and waiting times (HEU 2003a). What is particularly disturbing is the lack of empathy of the service providers, their generally callous and casual demeanor, their aggressive pursuit of monetary gains, their poor levels of competence and, occasionally, their disregard for the suffering that patients endure without being able to voice their concerns—all of these service failures are reported frequently in the print media. Such failures can play a powerful role in shaping patients’ negative attitudes and dissatisfaction with health care service providers and health care itself. The private health care sector also deserves close scrutiny as about 70% of the patients seek medical care from this sector (World Bank 2003). Between 1996 and 2000, private hospitals grew around 15% per annum (HEU 2003b).…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Partnerships

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Partners are joint bearers of the rights of the partnership and are jointly and severally liable for the obligations and debts of the partnership. In South Africa there is no specific legislation which pertains to partnerships.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    a unique time for a child to acquire a foreign language naturally and similarly to the mother…

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics