Preview

Explain Why It Is Difficult to Talk Meaningfully About God

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
761 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Explain Why It Is Difficult to Talk Meaningfully About God
Religious Language
Explain why it is difficult to talk meaningfully about God (30 marks) Religious language is defined as the communication of ideas about God, faith, belief and practice. This definition makes it difficult to talk meaningfully about it as each of these words have concepts behind them and each and every individual interprets these differently, so religious language is different to everyday language, as it only denotes to an individual’s belief and faiths traditions.
There are also many problems with religious language as a whole as it anthropomorphises God, by using terminology such as ‘Him’ ‘King’ and ‘Shepherd’ this is limiting and subjects God to have human qualities, which is against what The Bible wants to portray God as. Also another problem is that some think that religious language is cognitive, thus something must be known about God to talk meaningfully about it. Yet this creates the problem that religious statements are not about objective facts that can be proved true or false but are answers to questions that are unable to be validated, as they are based on objective facts that are open to cognition.
These issues have led to religious believers to find ways in which they can talk about God in a meaningful way and the opposite as non-believers are searching for ways to render religious language meaningless. A group of philosophers called the logical positivists who as a group did not seek to understand how we gain knowledge of the external world, but how we use language to convey it. They believed that everything that can be verified is meaningful. Thus the verification principle was developed which stated that if it could be empirical tested by the five senses then it was meaningful, for example, a house is made of gingerbread, is meaningless as it can be proved false by taking stone samples from the house. Yet this causes a problem when talking about philosophical and religious aspects. The logical positivists

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Those who believe that religious language is non-cognitive and so meaningless stem their beliefs from the Logical Positivist. The Logical Positivists were a group of philosophers who were primarily concerned with the truth contained in statements we can make, or in other words, with what can be logically posited, or stated. The group began in Vienna, Austria in the 1920s and gathered around a philosopher called Moritz Schlick. The group was heavily influenced by a philosopher called Ludwig Wittgenstein and in turn, the group influenced many philosophers of religion.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I am naturally inclined, then, even after reading the heavyweight philosophers of religion, to ponder this pressing issue. After all, what one person may gather out of serious consideration of this problem could totally alter his or her life. Even though I have been raised in the Episcopal Christian faith and have attended church regularly, I have never really taken the time to scrutinize the very existence of a being I have been worshipping for my whole childhood. Reading the famed selections in this course has alerted my attention to the topic, and this major philosophical problem continues to eschew my understanding.…

    • 1537 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Religious language being meaningless is an outlook shared by the logical positivists who have their origins in a group called the Vienna Circle in the 1920-30s. This group of philosophers believed that statements are only meaningful if they are able to be verified by an actually experience or is a tautology; a statements that is true by definition, this is the verification principle. Any statements that don’t meet this criteria are merely opinions which have no value or worth. For example the statement ‘I believe God is evil’ is meaningless unless it can be verified empirically as it isn’t true be definition (tautology). The views of the logical positivists and the Vienna Circle are that metaphysics, religion and ethics should be avoided and the importance of knowledge through science should be advocated. It should be noted however that logical positivist aren’t saying that God doesn’t exist, just that it is meaningless to talk about the issue of God’s existence. This view however has been criticised for being too rigid as it suggests we can’t make statements about certain historical events as they can’t be proven with physical evidence. In addition, the verification principle becomes stuck by its own definition, using the definition of verification the verification principle becomes meaningless as its isn’t a tautology and can’t be proven be actually experience, therefore why should we bother to abide by…

    • 1812 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ayer, in his first edition of ‘Language, Truth and Logic’ (1936), asserts that a statement is meaningful if and only if it can be verified by the sense observation or a tautology. By this he means that they are either a priori (before sense experience) analytic, where the predicate is entailed by the subject, or a posteriori (after sense experience) synthetic, where the predicate is not entailed by the subject. An example of a priori analytic statement would be that ‘all unmarried men are bachelors’ and this is also a tautology as it is true by definition. An example of a posteriori synthetic statement would be that ‘John is a bachelor’. For Ayer, if a statement cannot be verified in this way, then it is factually insignificant and thus, meaningless. He affirms that religious statements fall into neither category of priori analytic nor posteriori synthetic. This therefore, according to Ayer, provides a strong challenge to religious belief.…

    • 989 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    chp 5 Dr.Beckers book

    • 18144 Words
    • 73 Pages

    After briefly introducing the concept of revelation within Christian theology, this chapter first explores the problem of talking about God in our secular world, particularly about the objections to God-talk, especially from the atheistic position. The chapter then proceeds to discuss what Christian theologians call "the general revelation of God." This type of revelation is based on the natural knowledge of God which is generally or universally available to all human beings. The chapter investigates various objections to such knowledge, most especially those within atheistic critiques of both religion and God. The chapter then describes the principal positions that Christian theologians have taken regarding the possibility of a natural knowledge of God.…

    • 18144 Words
    • 73 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Language: Something which is used in communication. This can be either in the written form or spoken form. Though this is not just verbal; language can refer to any form of communicating messages to one another in order to be understood, such as sign language and body language.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The first assertion of the meaningless of religious language is the school of philosophical thought known as Logical positivism. Friedrich Waismann who was a member of the Vienna Circle. Logical positivism he saw as the belief that “Anyone saying a sentence must know under what conditions he calls it true, and under what conditions he calls it false. If he is unable to state these conditions, he does not know what he has said. A statement which cannot be conclusively verified cannot be verified at all. It is simply devoid of any meaning.”…

    • 904 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Outline the Ontological argument for the existence of God and consider the view that, while it may strengthen a believer’s faith, it has no value for the non ....…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Week 2 Jainism Vs

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Molloy, M. (2012). Experiencing the World’s Religions. Tradition, Challenge, and Change (6th ed.)Chapter 5. Retrieved from https://newclassroom3.phoenix.edu/Classroom…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It allows the people within a culture to communicate with each other and reflects all aspects of culture. It helps establish a cultural identity and can divide people. Language diffusion can happen by when people migrate and take their language and takes hold in the region, or it can also follow trade routes or be invented. Religion consists of a belief in a supernatural power(s) that are regarded as the creators and maintainers of the universe. Religions are categorized as one of three types which are monotheistic, polytheistic, and animistic. Monotheistic is believing in one god, polytheistic is believing in many gods, and animistic is believing in divine forces in nature. They spread across the world through diffusion and converts people who give up their former beliefs for a new…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nvq Level2

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Religion- religion means what we believe in and our faith. Religion is a collection of beliefs, culture and world views. Many religions presents by symbols, traditions and sacred histories to give meaning to the life, or explain the universe.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    * John Hick questioned whether the verification principle renders religious statements meaningless – two travellers down a long road and arguing whether it leads to a celestial city, just as with God and heaven, the walkers can verify at the end of the journey (eschatological verification)…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the bible, many of the attributes of God are shown. Both Jews and Christians have views from the bible on characteristics of God, each with their own variations. These both can be compared to Aristotle’s prime mover, as they include many similar characteristics. These characteristics however, do differentiate within the Judeo-Christian religion, and even in the bible.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    essay

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages

    1. Suppose you’re in a conversation and the person you are with claims to know that God exists (or that God does not exist—it’s up to you). What does such a knowledge claim amount to? In other words, what sorts of conditions have to be satisfied for such a knowledge claim to be legitimate? Do you think such a person could meet those conditions? Why? Be sure to discuss not only the classical model of knowledge, but also the challenges posed to it by basic beliefs and Gettier counterexamples. (Be sure to give a Gettier-type example and explain its relevance to the knowledge issue.)…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The most common failing in defining religion is in failing to account for the many different nuances and possible expressions of religion (Molloy, 2013). One possible definition of religion is a unified set of beliefs, shared among a group, to connect with an idea of the sacred. This definition may be discounted due to its lack of reference to the worship of the divine; however not all religions are focused on the worship of a divine (Molloy, 2013). Another objection to the proposed definition is the requirement of a group. Requiring that a group hold the beliefs, however, can be said to what separates personally held faith and religion. The separation of faith and religion is vital to the study of religion because, even within a single religion, the privately held faith can change from one individual to the other. Lastly, this definition, by relying solely on the beliefs rather than the rituals, symbolism, and myths, allows for the existence of religions that may lack them, so long as the group shares the underlying beliefs of the religion.…

    • 859 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays