Preview

False Consciousness Vs Free Will Psychology

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
488 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
False Consciousness Vs Free Will Psychology
This article discusses the concepts of false consciousness and free will in conjunction with the male gaze. It begins by discussing the different ways women have dealt with the pressures placed on them by men. The argument that the two authors created deals with women who have undergone elective mammoplasty surgery. They discuss how there are two feminist perspectives that connect to this surgery; false consciousness and free will perspective. “…for women to feel comfortable with their embodied self, they must find ways to change their physical self to better match their internalized sense of what are appropriate female body should look like” (Gagne and McGaughey, 202). Meaning, that if women do not feel comfortable in their own skin, they find ways to change their physical self to adhere to what they believe the female body should look like. …show more content…
The authors discuss power between the false consciousness and free choice perspective. They look at different agents of beauty such as; “....media and fashion, their observations of other women, and their own perceptions of men’s observations of themselves and other women” (Gagne and McGaughey, 208). Meaning, these are where the women's’ perceptions came from. While interviewing the women, the authors noticed, that the women stated that they were influenced by certain things to want to undergo the elective mammoplasty surgery. Most of their responses were social factors, that aligned with the agents of beauty. With both of those things combined, women developed insecurities that they wanted to fix to fit the hegemonic beauty

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Lisa Kramer Distortion

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Lisa Kramer’s contemporary work Woman in the Mirror (2011), she used mixed medium and oil paints to portray a women figure staring into three different mirrors, and in each, a different distortion of her self appearance. Kramer has borrowed styles from the past such as surrealism and impressionism to help portray this representation of distorted self. She states “We live in a Barbie doll world; anorexia, bulimia, looking old, looking normal and not plastic are problems many women face today.” (Fine Art America, Lisa Kramer, 2011). Harsh self judgement is a common problem in todays society, with the endless articles and videos instructing us to look better and compare our selves to other “beautiful” or “sexy” figures. It is clear that external influences, such as cultural context, have distorted Kramer’s self image as the woman looks in the mirror to not see herself accurately, and doesn’t see her true…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Uglies By Scott Westerfled

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This book will teach the generations to come that if you want to be beautiful you’ll have to be a whole new person, a photo shopped fake. Today in advertisements and magazines we are presented with beautiful images of men and women, girls and boys. We are presented with fake pictures, imaginary pictures, something that will never happen, but we are totally fooled into believing that true beauty is what’s presented in magazines and advertisements. This book teaches us that our imperfections make us beautiful, that for beauty you lose your people, and you’ll regret it. The imagination of being perfect is told in someone else’s point of view. Our society is proven to believe that a person with a combination of qualities that pleases others is beautiful, but your imperfections are what make you beautiful. As Marilyn Monroe said “Imperfection is beauty. Madness is genius, and it’s better to be absolutely ridiculous than absolutely boring.” Tally is taught in The Smoke, that alongside the surgery, “uglies” face tiny complications from the anaesthetic used in the operation, tiny lesions in the brain that were barely visible. These lesions were basically a…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Comparative Essay

    • 1396 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In today’s society, the ‘ideal look’ is an image that women strive to accomplish and fulfill. Perfection becomes an idea that all women feel like they need to become to receive simple things such as recognition, acknowledgement and most importantly love. This is evident in “The Birth Mark” where Aylmer, a natural philosopher, is intrigued and even obsessed with a birth mark on his wife’s face. Although he is very much in love with his wife, it becomes clear that his love and appreciation of her would increase with the removal of her birth mark. He believes that his wife is “nearly perfect” (CITE) if it not for her “visibly mark of earthly imperfection” (CITE). Through this quote, we are able to see that Aylmer is fixated on this one birth mark that he believes to be a flaw. Moreover, the birth mark he considers to be a flaw causes him not to appreciate or recognize that his wife is beautiful. This is significant because it shows that Aylmer’s wife does not conform to Aylmer’s idea of perfection which ultimately prevents him from acknowledging the beauty that his wife is. Through this we see that the female stereotype of perfection is an…

    • 1396 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Humans are born without choosing gender; the men and women are equal. In fact, most people suppose that the women represent beauty from their bodies and faces. In addition, some people think that the women who are not strong and powerful, are suitable for housework and sewing. According to “Miss Representation” video, Jennifer Siebel Newsom helps people realize the real women’value, criticize deviant thoughts on beauty from the social media, and understand the women pressure in beauty which bases on the video content.…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Male Gaze Analysis

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As woman artist Pauline Boty says, 'women's bodies are regulated by the normative culture of masculine privilege and authority'1. Are we really still living in a world where men can control women bodies, how they look and how they should act? Where women are objects and not treated as the intelligent, flexible people that they really are?…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jean Kilbourne

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Many women choose their physical appearances over their intelligences, because of how our society has created that importance towards the side-out; this social issue should be taken more seriously and we should make big chances by now, in order to save our girls and boys lives. . Because I am a feminist, I look for equality and I’ve seen how media has been the main key to portray this inequality between sexes. Therefore I look upon the many problems this objectification of women’s bodies has harmfully brought in our society. As Jean Kilbourne states, “In this problem nobody wins, neither men nor women, unfortunately women lose more, because this image makes them seem as weak, therefore it leads to…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay of “There Is No Unmarked Woman”, Deborah Tannen explains it best through the statement that “There is no unmarked woman” (Tannen 412). No matter what hairstyle, clothes, shoes, or style a woman may choose to wear, every one of her decisions will convey a meaning to the public. “If a woman’s clothing is tight or revealing…it sends a message…If her clothes are not sexy, that too sends a message…” (Tannen 412). There are even instances where the clothes are not the cause of criticism, for a woman may be criticized upon her genetic features. As written in the poem “Barbie Doll” by Marge Piercg, a little girl grows up healthy and intelligent, but because other people deemed her as physically inadequate by having “a great big nose and fat legs”, the girl is coerced into change, and not anything like a difference in wardrobe, but permanent change with cosmetic surgery (Piercg 378). Such an occurrence is not far from reality for there are women who will do whatever it takes to be deemed as conventionally…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though, the modern media has had many positive impacts on our lives, when it comes to women’s image, especially in commercial advertisements and programs, it usually has such misleading interpretations about the perfect images of beauty and the happiness of women. Thus, many women who have already been struggling with their uncertain self-identities have become even more insecure and unsatisfied with their “imperfect” physical appearances and their unrealized “ideal” life styles. Therefore, the conflict about who they really are and whom they wish to be has caused such confusions that some women would lose touch with reality, and make decisions which can never bring them true happiness. In this paper, I will discuss the impact…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Beautiful, pretty, good-looking are all the adjectives that women and girls aspire to be or encouraged to strive for in their life. From the first years of a young girl’s life, she’s told to wear dresses and comb her hair so when she looks into the mirror, she’ll see beauty reflected back at her so that consequently this shallow image of beauty is adopted by her consciousness. Yet as the years pass, she comes to a point in her life where the very aspect of her being is put into question because of what she’s seen on television or heard on the radio so that as a young woman she constantly feels the need to conform to a patriarchal society’s standards of beauty in order to be accepted. Now let’s look at this transition in a young female’s life through the eyes of an African-American girl who grows up being told to wear this and to do her hair like this in order to look pretty. At such a young age, she may not have been affected by the demands and expectations of beauty that was put upon her, but as she grows and develops a deeper understanding of the images around her, she will realize that the images of beauty presented before her do…

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Race Class and Gender

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In “Finding My Eye-Dentity”, Olivia Chung, a Korean female, was being pressured to get a surgery on her eyelids to look more like a ‘beautiful Korean’. “You know your aunt? She used to have beany eyes just like you! She used to put on white or black eyeliner very morning to make them look BIG. Then she went to Korea and got the surgery done. Now look! She looks so much better! Don’t you want it done? I would do it …” (p485). Many females are in the need to perfect their bodies, similar to the models and actresses they see on the televisions and magazines. Olivia thought about going with her mother’s suggestion, but wanted to see if there was another way of getting the crease in her eyelids. Magazines such as Seventeen or CosmoGIRL magazine persuade their readers that you must have a certain look to be beautiful. Proclamations made like this, are the reasons why females strive to modify everything about them. Although, Olivia almost went through with her mother’s suggestion, she did not. On the other hand, Olivia kept her non-crease eyelids the way they are. “I remember feeling a confused hurt, realizing that I looked…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Conformity

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Ever since the beginning of time and throughout history society has oppressed women and forced them into conformity. This can be seen in the articles “Declaration of Sentiments” and “Reality Meets Plastic Surgery.” These can also be seen in the shows “The Swan” and The Twilight zone “Number Twelve looks just like you.” These stories and shows, show that women are being forced into conformity.…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Illusion of free will

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In our society, free will is something that is ingrained in our set of beliefs that every citizen of the world should possess. We generally believe that we possess free will because of the choices we make on a day-to-day basis that is generally not forced upon by any direct outside force like in a totalitarian society out of a science-fiction story: the decision of whether or not to go to school in the morning, or finishing an essay at the last minute or allowing the grade to drop for an extra day are excellent examples of my view of free will. In Paul Halbach’s “The Illusion of Free Will”, he systematically attempts to debunk the debate between the combating theories of free will and hard determinism. He conveys his argument by stating that determinism and free will are incompatible with one another: one cannot exist if the other is true. If he can thoroughly prove that determinism is true, then free will would be deemed incapable with the human condition which we must accept. Holbach breaks down his strategy into two parts, the first of which he explains how the thought process and decision making of human beings are complex, yet mechanical, which boils down to the fight of competing desires. Lastly, he attacks different views on actions people would normally view as explanations of free will.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With popular culture setting the norms for society women are left at a large disadvantage as far as how they are viewed and treated in society. As stated in the lecture “These sources have created many different cultural norms and expectations as well as have affected sexuality and sexual behavior. These sources have dictated many gender expectations and have subjugated women in many aspects of social life.” (Reali, 2017) In popular culture beauty among women is one of the most romanticized topics.…

    • 1730 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many women believe Mary Kay Ashe said it best when she observed, “While clothes may not make the woman, they certainly have a strong effect on her self-confidence — which, I believe, does make the woman.” (educators.fidm.com). This observation simply means that a woman’s appearance can have a tremendous influence on how she really views herself. Two advertisements from the world famous Levi’s Jean Company portrays this concept of self. One advertisement from a Seventeen magazine published in 1954 presents four women standing in a posed position, showcasing various types of Levi clothing attire. Another advertisement, published fifty years later, in 2009 in the W+K magazine presents a different view by drawing the viewers attention to only one woman, who is only clothed waist down with a pair of Levi jeans. The advertisements show a vast cultural change by the way the two photographic meanings are displayed in the various images. The two advertisements demonstrate a change in a woman’s perception of self through the change in the stages of rebellion, confidence, and most importantly independence in women, which are each brought about in the advertisements. This cultural change is evident in the different slogans of the ads, overall various images of the women, the angle of the shots, the use of technology, the color scheme and layout of the two advertisements.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As viewers, people are always making meaning of what they see in images, although every image have a dominant meaning, they are interpreted and use by the viewers in ways that do not always conform to these meanings .however, the viewers point of view can be greatly influence when gets interpellate by the dominant meaning when we are hailed into subject (You identify me and I become that me that you have identified) in the dove add created by the cosmetic company DOVE; we find a great example of interpellation, by creating an ad campaign for a targeted audience of women that are not physically beautiful according to society. Their intended meaning is to widen the narrow definition of beauty that is presented to as in all other media commercials. It challenges the hegemonic ideal beauty impose by the media ;The Campaign for Real Beauty focused on the idea that women are bombarded with unrealistic, unattainable images and images of beauty that impact their self-esteem.it was created to act as an agent of change to inspire and educate girls and women about a wider definition of beauty.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays