Preview

Freire, Dewey, And Rosenblatt's View Of Critical Literacy

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
519 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Freire, Dewey, And Rosenblatt's View Of Critical Literacy
Unless, the author of a text is physically in front of the reader explaining her intentions at the moment of writing, the reader is the only one who is able to give meaning to the text. Rosenblatt (1993) rejects this dualism by explaining that the writer exhibits an aesthetic stance while writing her piece trying to bring as many clues as possible for the reader, however, the text could be interpreted from aesthetic or an efferent stance. The reader could enjoy reading complex mathematical theorems (aesthetic reading), whereas for others reading mathematics could be a torturous task (efferent reading) assigned to pass a class. In summary, the transactional theory of literary work, defined by Rosenblatt (1978) in The Reader, the Text, the Poem, is based on the following premises: (a) the reader reacts on the text, she interprets it, and the text produces a …show more content…
The work with a group of immigrant women demands an understanding of critical literacy. The way in which the culture circles were conceived, as spaces for earning the literacy mechanics (reading and writing), has a different meaning when they are thought as places to promote democratic discussion and dialogue as means to problematize the context of the participants of the cultural circles. Luke (2012) claims that learning the mechanics of a written language brings the individual to positioning herself into the collective action, but the Freirean approach demands to go beyond the importance for the collective to have literate citizens; it is the individual the one who experiences new ways of knowing to act upon the world, and for which critical literacy practices are deemed

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Julia Alvarez’s speech “Entre Lucas y Juan Mejia”, She start explaining the challenges we faced as an immigrant. She said, “As an immigrant, you leave behind an old world and enter into a new world in which the old ways no longer apply” (1). In my opinion as an immigrant I can related to this quote, because when I came to United States I felt that I entered in a completely new world. In which I had to start a new life with a different language and culture. Also, Julia Álvarez mentioned the challenges she had as a female writer in another country that has a different language.…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anzaldua

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When analyzing Gloria Anzaldua’s writing “How to Tame a Wild Tongue,” it is important to look at her background. She comes from a very diverse background; her parents were immigrants, she was born in south Texas, and she identifies herself as a Chicana feminist. The different discourse communities seen through her writing is the struggle she has between the different languages she has to adapt to around different people in her life. Writing from the borderlands between American, Mexican, Spanish, Indian, Chicano, and Mestiza culture, Anzaldua creates a representation of the wide range of forces within herself and the culture from which comes.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Changing literacies, changing populations, changing places – English teachers’ work in an age of rampant standardisation1 BARBARA COMBER Queensland University of Technology ABSTRACT: School-age populations in many nations are becoming increasingly diverse (in terms of languages, countries of origin, ethnicity, faith traditions and so on) especially in low socio-economic communities where recent arrivals tend to be accommodated. In Australian classrooms, it is not unusual for a single classroom to include children who speak many different languages. Their family trajectories to their current dwellings and lifeworlds may be very different from each other. Catastrophic weather events and other disasters change the very landscapes in which families and teachers work. At the same time, what constitutes literacy continues to evolve as new technologies and communication media enable different forms of meaningmaking. Yet simultaneously, what counts as literacy is increasingly “fixed” by the normative demands of high-stakes, standardised tests. This paper employs Hilary Janks’ (2010) synthesis model of critical literacy to explore some of the risk and possibilities for innovative and equitable pedagogy inherent in this contemporary demographic, policy and practice mix. KEYWORDS: Critical literacy, access, diversity, dominant discourse, equity, pedagogy, design, standardised testing. INTRODUCTION School-age populations in many nations are becoming increasingly diverse (in terms of languages, ethnicity, faith traditions and so on) especially in low socio-economic communities. In Australian classrooms it is not unusual for a single classroom to include children who speak many different languages. Their family trajectories to their current dwellings and lifeworlds may be very different from each other. At the same…

    • 9489 Words
    • 38 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tienda, M., & Haskins, R. (2011). Immigrant children: Introducing the issue. The Future of Children, 21(1), 3-18. Torres-Padilla, J. L. (2005). Death to the Originary Narrative! or, Insurgent Multiculturalism and Teaching Multiethnic Literature. Melus, 30(2), 13-30.…

    • 2419 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    If the reader is given full authority on the meaning of a work, then their interpretation of the work will take precedent over the facts and contexts that surround the work. In addition, when meaning is completely shifted to the reader, then the meaning of a work becomes too fluid. The meaning of the work changes from reader to reader. As a result, there is no longer an avenue for the meaning of the work to be questioned or examined. These examples show the implications of exclusively committing to either authorial intent or reader-response.…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    English experts have tried to solve our ever declining literacy rates with different theories and years of research. Two of the front runners, Paulo Freire and E. D. Hirsch, have come up with two ideas that have caused agreement and contention between those who are trying to increase literacy rates. Freire gives us the idea that we need to expand on critical literacy and relate our words to our world and our world to our words. He wants students to have more freedom in their learning environment. On the other hand, Hirsch wants a more centralized curriculum to expand our country’s Cultural Literacy. While these two ideas might seem to be complete polar opposites of each other they actually have some similarities. Great ideas can be taken from both of these authors and applied to the reform of our education system desperately needs. There are parts that I agree and disagree with from both Hirsch and Freire, but I believe Freire makes more applicable points. While Hirsch makes the good point that cultural knowledge is required for literacy, I believe that Freire’s critical literacy and “word-world” association would provide a better foundation for pedagogical reform because it is more open for students with different learning abilities and incorporates both culture and personal experience into literacy.…

    • 1895 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “To emphasize the work seems to involve severing it from those who actually read it,…” (23). If all the focus would be on just the text of the literature, then it’s easy to say we are doing nothing more than ignoring the context and reducing the analytical explanations of literature; making them into a set of rhetorical devices. Brooks, throughout his essay, explained how he was attacked multiple times for his use of New Criticism but he does commiserate those who would “recommend brighter, more amateur and more human criticism” (25). Much like with poetry, ignoring the context means we would be ignoring the emotional effects it would bring towards the readers. With these disadvantages, there would be limitations with the theory.…

    • 122 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Rodriguez is a Spanish author who writes about his first hand account of being a bilingual child in America and how it affects him and his family in “Aria”. In both Rodriguez’s essay and in Kingston’s novel the use of language and the meaning behind it is prevalent. Through the power of language in both of these pieces we see how it affects a family and the community that surrounds them. For Kingston it shapes her into becoming an adult and how it shapes her views while also affecting how she people should use language. At the same time both of these authors face challenges that all arise from the power of language.…

    • 1999 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ap World History 24

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. Literacy critic Edward Said wrote that “the major contest in most modern cultures concerns the definition or interpretation of each culture.” To what extent do the case studies of this chapter support Said’s assertion?…

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Higher levels of literacy can be achieved in many ways. Two factors which play a role in acquiring these levels are the attachments of students to their previous cultures and their previous languages, more specifically the dialect, that they speak. These factors tend to change one’s personal identity and play a huge role in how one reaches higher literacy levels. In our two readings, Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez and Voices of the Self: A Study of Language Competence, we see Richard Rodriguez and Keith Gilyard respectively go through these changes at home and in their school settings. Gilyard has a point of view which geared more towards incorporating one’s culture into his academic life is the proper way to go out to attain higher literacy levels. On the other hand, Rodriguez has a view saying that one must to completely rid oneself of his culture background in order to succeed and receive higher literacy rates. One can prove from their writings that in order to achieve higher literacy rates and succeed in doing so Rodiriguez’s view of ridding oneself of his culture is the best way in order to attain these levels.…

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The world of literature exists because of the literary works that have been uniquely crafted throughout time; in fact, such works of literature exist thanks to the great masterminds of literary authors—both dead and alive. When one thinks of the literary world, he or she should think about its sub work—the world of literary interpretations. Why? Think about it: The world consists of diverse readers, and for that reason, one is exposed to a wide range of literary interpretations; thus, enabling he or she to formulate his or her unique literary analysis. When it comes to interpreting a literary text, it is pivotal for one to realize that his or her job is to develop an understanding of the text’s meaning—develop his or her own philosophy of the text. In addition, at times, one will encounter individuals that make such a beautiful impact in his or her life, to a point where he or she cannot imagine what life would look like without him or her.…

    • 194 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Critical reading

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Preview the Seaman reading assignment: The title of the article is “How Bingeing Became the New College Sport” written by Barrett Seaman, published on 8/29/2005 by Time International (Canada Edition). I feel that this article is going to be an opinionated paper on college binge drinking and how it has spiraled out of control.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout my first year as a middle school Language Arts teacher, I have developed a theoretical understanding of what I believe are the necessary components to providing a meaningful and generative environment in which students develop and expand literacy skills. The teaching of literacy needs to include a balance of reading, writing, speaking and listening activities, and needs to be a social endeavor that provides a variety of instructional strategies to meet the needs of all diverse learners. My teaching strategies, beliefs and personality that I bring to my classroom can be characterized as a blend of two types of philosophical theories: social constructivism and relational teaching and learning. My philosophy of literacy education centers around five different ideals which I believe make my classroom a successful learning environment that promotes literacy acquisition. Those five elements in no particular order are: 1. building meaningful relationships with students, 2. encouraging collaborative learning, 3. providing generative learning experiences, 4. bringing relevance to subject matter, and 5. empowering students. I will discuss the research that supports these five methods, along with specific examples of their practical application in my classroom.…

    • 3066 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    However popular these works are in classrooms, and by no means disputing their importance in the literary canon, there is one overarching theme that can be recognized, and could be considered concerning – the lack of women and minorities within the works taught in school. According to Applebee, “Strong voices have argued that the English curriculum is white, male, and Eurocentric, marginalizing the contributions of women and of people from other cultural traditions. Equally strong voices have reasserted the values of a traditional liberal education, arguing that the curriculum in English has already been diluted too much” (Applebee p.27). While a debate could ensue arguing these two points relentlessly, the purpose of this Wiki is not to debate which side is better, but to look into the strategies of implementing the work of women and minorities into the classroom, as well as their place in the literary canons of today.…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Handmaids

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages

    ‘The true measure of a text’s value lies in its ability to provoke the reader into awareness of its language and construction, not just its content’…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays