Preview

Graded Response Critique of a Marriage Proposal

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1191 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Graded Response Critique of a Marriage Proposal
Response-Critique of Alix Kates Shulman’s “A Marriage Proposal” [ww—watch for this elsewhere, too] Shulman is best known for the novel “Memoirs of an Ex-Prom Queen” and most recently, Shulman has written the award-winning memoir, “Drinking the Rain”. She is an American writer of fiction, memoirs, and essays, as well as being an early radical feminist activist. She was one of the planners of the first national demonstration of WLM and she has written two books on anarchist-feminist and three children’s books. Upon researching this piece of writing I have found that there is a lot of controversy concerning the roles of men and women that have been set in place for centuries. In her methods of change, Shulman seeks to find peace in her newly chaotic life in the document,”A Marriage Proposal”, in which she provides valid arguments against the typical family household. [The intro should give more information about the specific article you’re discussing, and it should give an overview of your opinion regarding “A Marriage Agreement”. The thesis needs to sum up your overall opinion of the article/agreement.] In the first portion of the article she describes her life with her husband before starting a family, then moves on to tell us [avoid “you,” “us,” “we,” etc.] about the burdens of being a full time homemaker. She describes the stereo typical life in that time period where the husband often worked late and spent little time at home, while she was at home taking care of every day chores as well as the taking care of the children. When her children had become older, she stated that she was, “restricted to the company of demanding preschoolers and to the four walls of an apartment”.
As well as feeling the pain of raising two small children, she discusses the physical work of day to day housework and the scheduling conflicts. It was not until she “had been with the children for six years” that she “began to attend meetings of the newly formed Women’s



Cited: Shulman, Alix Kates. “A Marriage Proposal.” Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum. Tenth Edition. Behrens and Rosen. NEW YORK: PEARSON/LONGMAN. 303-307 Print. "Shulman, Alix Kates." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. 31 Jul 2009, 01:53 UTC. 2 Oct 2009 . [Remove hyperlink] Highlight your citations on this page, and then right-click. Click “paragraph.” Under “Special,” change the setting from “none” to “hanging.” Click “ok.” GRADE: 77% GRADE:

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Drake the Rapper

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the reading from Rosie to Lucy the ?author points out the stereotypical society that existed within that era “?stereotype" of women being ?nothing more than a mere house wife in the 1950s. Within the reading it explains that “?the media lavished their praise on women who devoted themselves to family and home”?. ? ?Now day’?s ?women of this ?present era ?highly disregard such a claim. With what society ?claim to be ?a "proper social standing for women". Betty Friedan was one woman who "resented the wide A great difference between the idealized image society held of them as housewives and mothers and the realities of their daily routines"). She seemingly questioned her motives and wonder about ?her purpose as a woman, if being a housewife was ?all their is to , ?was being a house wife something she was destined to live, why did she want more out of life? ?…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    At the beginning of the essay Neil explains the social changes that have occurred in the last few decades showing the stark rise of “unmarried –partner households.” He claims that…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many men in the early 20th century viewed women as a pedestal by which they relied on for their everyday needs. The sarcasm of the essay shows the reader how a wife feels about how she is treated. Brady states in her closing sentence, “My god who wouldn’t want a wife?”(525), which basically states that wives are unappreciated and over worked in many…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cited: errault, Charles. "Cinderella." Writing and Reading across the Curriculum. 7th ed. Ed. Laurence Behrens and Leonard J. Rosen. New York: Longman, 2000. 598-602.…

    • 563 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 1970’s, the fight for women’s suffrage was a major highlighted impact amongst the nation as women everywhere fought for their equality with men. Within this time, women were considered to be obligated to take of the family and the home without any gratitude. Judy Brady effectively points this out to the readers of Ms. Magazine in 1972, where she publishes an article that opens eyes across the nation. In her article, “Why I Want a wife,” Brady uses techniques such as pathos to discuss her duties as a wife and to show the unfairness and inequality that her position upholds.…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is a picture of grace , confidence , and power . She also refers to statistics based on the actual time spent by working moms and determined they worked an extra month of twenty-four hour days a year (3 She is intent to illustrate the reality behind the flying hair illusion , as well as document the disparity of the second shift workload . She approaches her research by discussing the role of gender family myths and illusions , as well as what she believes is the cultural cover-up (11-32 . She sets out to explore the reality of the division of labor in the various couples , as well as the individual couple 's background and attitudes . She does so without seeming to have an agenda . Her main thesis and focus is the economic or social reason for more women...…

    • 2029 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Many mothers find their careers to be put on hold because they cannot go to school on top of everything else. This leads to disputes between income needs and family needs. This is commonly a call for divorce and other family members fear in anger that it could end a marriage. Father’s should want to take on family roles as the mother does. While most mothers make sure the needs of the child are fulfilled most fathers do not pay mind to things like; doctor visits, school sicknesses and playdates. They just expect a clean house, a warm meal, and a well maintained child. Mom’s are expected to drop everything including their jobs to take after the child, meaning having to leave work or be late to work, or having to stay home with a sick child. It all means the same, it’s not necessarily tradition of housewives but the role of mothers has simply changed. Too many families are failing to realize this drastic life style change that Bennett’s encounters. If roles were to ever switch fathers would understand the financial and emotional needs of a child, piled on to a full time job. One day Leslie hopes this will…

    • 675 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The way woman are perceived is constantly changing. In our culture there are so many aspects of the role woman portray. In the Book, “The Radical idea of marrying for Love” Coontz explores the many different cultures and how the way perceive marriage has changed. Their was a time when we looked at marriage as a need for survival to society and to our race, in some coutries marriage is still seen this way. Our culture today looks more upon the emotional aspect of marriage. Men and woman want a more sexually and emotionally fulfilling relationship. Coontz also looks at other cultures such as England that marry for station and the need to produce an heir to the throne. Is there truly a happily ever after? With Divorce on the rise and The expectations of your mother are not the same as for you. Taking care of your family has taken on a different set of challenges and obstacles, and with the addition of so many single mothers this has become the only honorable choice. Does this mean that one job is more important than the other? Housewives work, equally as hard as mothers who join the workforce; however, they do not receive the same respect as a mother with employment outside of an apron. Both positions have equally the same challenges and downfalls. The same author shows two different insights in this opposition, one in the defense of the housewife, the other written by a woman who gave up her life for her family and in return was left alone and uneducated with no means of taking care of herself. This would be the defense for woman in the workforce.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    A major point that Edelman brings up in her writing are gender roles in parenting and what society expects each to do as a parent. Edelman says that coming into her parenthood she thought that if she contributed half of the families’ income, then her husband would contribute half of the housework and child caring (Edelman 284). She says that she did not want to be the dominant parent in the house and wanted more of a “shared responsibility” instead of one parent doing all of the care-taking and household duties (Edelman 284). She also talks about her parents’ relationship and parenting when her and her siblings were young. She says that her mother always seemed to do everything around the house, while her father only went to work, came home and sat around (Edelman 284). Her father did provide the families’ income; however, Edelman believes her father should’ve done a little more to help around the house (Edelman 285). Edelman also says that whenever her mother passed away the household duties never were done how they used to be and the house was just different (Edelman 285). After seeing this Edelman told herself that she didn’t want the same relationship her parents had (Edelman 285). Edelman says later that women start…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women's Role Since 1930's

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Women have fought throughout history in order to achieve different roles as well as to acquire recognition, independence, equality and respect. It has not been easy since they have had many barriers to overcome; their role in the family as wives, mothers and daughters; their role in society fighting for their rights, being heard and treated as men; their role as career women, not only receiving an education but also being able to work.…

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Anne-Marie Slaughter’s “Why Women Still Can’t Have It All,” she addresses how society’s stigma on the workplace and inflexible, hefty workloads keep women from having their dream life. She explains how the extensive hours at her job took away from her time spent in her teenage boys’ lives. Slaughter highlights on the decisions that women have to make more so than their male counterparts and on the perceived notion that choosing parenthood over work is for the faint of heart. With recent debate over parental leave in the news, Slaughter’s claim that women can’t have it all in today’s society versus Richard Dorment’s counterclaim that women and men both have it difficult in partaking in a balanced work-life, brings back the old rivalry,…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to society, it is always natural for the women to be the nurturers and the father to be the provider. Hope Edelman expresses her need for an evenly split marriage hoping her husband would abide.Edelman believed that co-parenting was an attainable goal. She has always thought of co-parenting as a shared responsibility. She clarifies that her husband work hours increased, so she had to cut back on her work hours. Edelman pointed out that she had to pick up the slack around the house due to her husband’s lack of home time. She then discusses the struggles her mother experienced as she was forced into being a housewife. Her father worked constantly and her mother was the chauffer, maid, and cook.”When I was growing up in suburban New York, my mother seemed to do everything. Everything Carpooling, haircuts, vet appointments, ice cream cakes, dinners in the Crock-Pot, book-report dioramas—the whole roll call for a housewife of the 1960s and 1970s” (52). As a result, Edelman barely knew her father. With this in mind, she did not want the same outcome for her daughter. She then sadly speaks about how truly difficult it is to split marriage equally.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Family Dynamics

    • 291 Words
    • 2 Pages

    •Participants of all ages share concerns about fatherhood as program pioneers shift to mosque ~ May 17, 2008…

    • 291 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Marriage and Family

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In “Her Divorce” women lose the husbandly figure and now have the burden of carrying the financial and child-rearing weight by themselves. Even though she might have emotional and financial worries she tries hard to become the complete parent for her kids regardless of the lack of a consistent father figure. I believe the descriptions in this chapter are fairly accurate, this is what…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Gender Roles and Marriage

    • 3719 Words
    • 15 Pages

    The development of gender awareness is fundamental for our sense of self and is also predominant in any assessment made of another person as from birth on people respond differently to males and females. Gender identity can be seen as one of the earliest social categories that children learn to apply to both themselves and other people. This is suggested in Schaffer’s (1996) definition where gender identity is the correct labeling of self and others as male or female. There are three main theories that have been explored which all suggest multiple ways in which gender awareness is developed: Bandura, Kohlberg and the Gender Scheme Theory. Firstly, Bandura (1977) notes that the idea that social influences clearly plays a very significant role in the development of gender identity. Socialization makes children aware that there are differences between male and female, and that these sex differences matter. These social pressures also suggest there are specific genders stereotypes that they are expected to conform to. Nevertheless, it can also be seen that biological and cultural changes interact with these social factors, thus defining how an individual eventually develops the gender identity of a man or a woman. An alternative theory, expressed by Kohlberg (1966), suggests that children are not the recipients of any physical information from social experiences and therefore they search for specific regulations which will explain the way in which males and females are expected to behave. In addition, gender tends to be the first thing a parent wishes to find about their child. It can be suggested that from then on the child will be treated depending on the fact that they are male or female. This is shown in research attempting to clarify the development of sex roles including: preferences of toys, personal…

    • 3719 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays