Preview

H. J. Mccloskey's 'On Being An Atheist'

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1698 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
H. J. Mccloskey's 'On Being An Atheist'
The “Proof’s” of God’s Existence:
A Response to H.J. McCloskey’s “On Being an Atheist”

1
2

3
I. Introduction

In this paper, I will be making a response to a well-known writer and atheist, H. J. McCloskey, to his article entitled, “On Being an Atheist.” “An atheist is a person who disbelieves or denies the existence of God or gods.” It is very clear to me that McCloskey is a smart and intelligent man but he also seems to be a little on the arrogant side. His purpose for writing this particular article was to inform other people as to why he believes that “atheism is a much more comfortable belief than theism and why theists should be miserable because they are theists.” I believe that everyone has the right to believe whatever they so desire and that everyone is entitled to his/her own opinion. I am a saved, sanctified, and born-again Christian and I wholeheartedly believe in my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. I am in total disagreement with
…show more content…
He, McCloskey, refers to these arguments as “proofs” and he makes the implication that they cannot accurately prove that God really exists. These particular arguments are the cosmological proof, the teleological proof, and the argument from design. I believe that idea of having to have “proofs” is over-rated and/or over exaggerated. I personally do not believe that you have to have “proofs” or “signs” to know that God exist. I can feel him in my heart. For the people who are unsure of what to believe and the non-believers, reading God’s word, the Holy Bible, should be

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    We are looking for evidence god exists, so we turned to an evidential argument in favor of God: the cosmological argument.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Another problem I found in his philosophy was, throughout his writing, McCloskey talks about how Christians use arguments as “proofs”; however, they are not proofs but merely ideas and arguments that when looked at as a whole, seem to give support to a claim. Since they do not definitively establish a case for God, McCloskey says these arguments should be abandoned. Again, McCloskey seems to think that he knows the inner mind of “most” theistic people and claims that we hold certain ideas or theories as proof. I know quite a few theists; however, I can’t recall ever hearing a single one saying that they have definitive proof of…

    • 2632 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 1970’s philosopher McCloskey brings into question the three major arguments that are commonly presented against the question of God’s existence. McCloskey does so in an article entitled “On Being an Atheist.” In this article McCloskey commonly refers to these arguments as “proofs” rather than simply arguments. Furthermore, he argues that these “proofs” can’t be positively established and therefore one should throw said “proofs” out. In terms of a theistic view on the question of God’s existence theist openly admit that there arguments could indeed be defeasible. Theists acknowledge that there is a possibility that a defeater can be presented to shut down the conclusion…

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Argumentative Essay on “The Ethics of Belief” PHIL 2641 Online – Section 001 February 13, 2008…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It goes without question, that human beings will always question the existence of “God”. Whether these questions are formed in support or denial of an omnipresent creator they are important in helping shape our morality. H J McCloskey and his article “On Being and Atheist” is very critical of theists. It thus presents several arguments on how believers are incorrect in their belief in “God”, cosmological and teleological. McCloskey also focus’s on the existence of evil and how one can find comfort in atheism when facing evil.…

    • 1881 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    PHI 208 (RELIGION)

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages

    When you talk about proof, you are talking about establishing some degree of certainty about the existence of God. That is where Faith comes in Faith is: The assurance, confirmation, and the title deed of the things we hope for. The proof of things we do not see. The conviction of their reality and it perceives as real fact what is not revealed to the senses (Hebrews 11). It takes greater faith to believe that an unseen God exists than it does to just dismiss Him because you cannot physically confirm that He is there. No-one can ever prove that God exists by scientific methods. Religion and faith in God is based on individual beliefs. This is where the problem seems to lie, because most people fail to look inside themselves for God. Instead, they are so busy looking to their surroundings and other people to prove God exist. Romans clearly outlines what the real problem is and that is man’s rebellion and refusal to accept the evidence of nature or creation by God. The creation of the world God’s invisible qualities his eternal power and divine nature have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse. For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor…

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Rise of Christianity by Rodney Stark offers a sociological view of the growth of Christianity during the first four centuries A.D. The book provides a new perspective on how Christianity won the West. According to Stark, early church historians and the New Testament itself claimed that Christianity grew in number despite an unsuccessful plight to the Jewish population of Rome. Stark rejects many of conventional claims such as this one, and claims that Christianity grew rapidly because of miraculous demonstrations that drew large numbers of converts. Mr. Stark uses a quantitative approach to explain his theories on how Christians could have gained so many converts without miraculous methods.…

    • 2203 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Philosophy 201 Theism

    • 1719 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As I mentioned in the paragraph above, the existence of the world does prove that a being had to create the objects in our universe. I suppose in the reading McCloskey is right in that the mere proof of objects existence does not give us the right to claim an all-powerful, all perfect being created these objects. What I do believe is given this knowledge why would one not want to further educate yourself on this conclusion and open your eyes to the idea of “god”…

    • 1719 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    On Being an Atheist

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages

    McCloskey makes the claim that he is reminding fellow atheist why they believe there is no God. He claims that the traditional proofs have no merit. I believe the sheer magnitude and complexity of the world we live in is strong evidence of an intelligent designer and creator. Only an intelligent creator could form a world where the air that we breathe is part of such a complex system. We also live in a world that has morals, which points to a morally perfect Being that we model our lives and society by. The Cosmological, Teleological and Moral arguments create a cumulative case for why God exist. God’s existence is not solely dependent on any one argument, rather an accumulation of several arguments. Although McCloskey tries to argue the Cosmological, Teleological and Moral arguments from the same point, they are intended to build upon each other.…

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Christopher J.H Wright delivers an excellent treatment of the scriptures in his book “The mission of God. Following YHWH through the cannon of scripture, he truly captures The Mission of God. Wright’s larger argument is that there is a missional framework through which we can see the entire scriptures. God has been on mission from eternity past to eternity future, and he has woven his people into his story to display his glory. Wright puts on display through scripture the character of God and his mission. He seeks to define who is this God and what does his identity have to do with his mission. Wright further strings his missional hermeneutic through the people of God. How does the nation of Israel and God’s Word that has been entrusted to…

    • 1430 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As a matter of fact, many exchanges between atheists and theists turn out to be frustrating and unsatisfactory because no one ever bothers to stop and explain what is meant by the key term "god." Unless and until that happens, no serious, productive, or rational discussion can take place. Unless we know what the theist means by "god," we'll never have any chance to judge if anything said in defense of belief is adequate. Only when we know what the theist means by "god," will we be able to seriously…

    • 2099 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    References: [1] Antony Flew, There Is a God: How the World’s Most Notorious Atheist Changed His Mind [2] Derek Raine, An Introduction to Science of Cosmology (Astronomy & Astrophysics) [3] Justin L. Barrett, Why Would Anyone Believe in God? [4] http://www.cam.ox.ac.uk/publications-original/why-would-anyone-believe-in-god/ [5] Dr Olivera Petrovich, Childs Theory of World [6] Justin L. Barrett, Jonathan A. Lanman, The Science of Religious Beliefs…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    My first question to the atheist will be: "What is the definition of God?" For a person to say there is no God, he should know what is the meaning of God. If I hold a book and say that ‘this is a pen’, for the opposite person to say, ‘it is not a pen’, he should know what is the definition of a pen, even if he does not know nor is able to recognise or identify the object I am holding in my hand. For him to say this is not a pen, he should at least know what a pen means. Similarly for an atheist to say ‘there is no God’, he should at least know the concept of God. His concept of God would be derived from the surroundings in which he lives. The god that a large number of people worship has got human qualities - therefore he does not believe…

    • 2006 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is a matter of debate whether my lack of belief in the existence of an Omnipresent, Omniscient God is due to my arrogant pride and vanity. It never occurred to me that sometime in the future I would be involved in polemics of this kind. As a result of some discussions with my friends, (if my claim to friendship is not uncalled for) I have realised that after having known me for a little time only, some of them have reached a kind of hasty conclusion about me that my atheism is my foolishness and that it is the outcome of my vanity. Even then it is a serious problem. I do not boast of being above these human follies. I am, after all, a human being and nothing more. And no one can claim to be more than that. I have a weakness in my personality, for pride is one of the human traits that I do possess. I am known as a dictator among my friends. Sometimes I am called a boaster. Some have always been complaining that I am bossy and I force others to accept my opinion. Yes, it is true to some extent. I do not deny this charge. We can use the word ‘vainglory’ for it. As far as the contemptible, obsolete, rotten values of our society are concerned, I am an extreme sceptic. But this question does not concern my person alone. It is being proud of my ideas, my thoughts. It cannot be called empty pride. Pride, or you may use the word, vanity, both mean an exaggerated assessment of one’s personality. Is my atheism because of unnecessary pride, or have I ceased believing in God after thinking long and deep on the matter? I wish to put my ideas before you. First of all, let us differentiate between pride and vanity as…

    • 5849 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Punjabi Essay

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Is Atheism a Religion? ATHIESM: A RELIGION? Throughout the countless generations of our existence, we as a global community have pondered a variety of noteworthy enquiries. Most notably...…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays