As the play develops, we see that Horatio treats Hamlet with more kindness than both Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. This is exemplified in Horatio's actions in particular, his first meeting with Hamlet where he informed Hamlet about his father's ghost, then advised him not to follow the ghost, and helped him perform the mousetrap in order to prove Claudius' guilt in the murder of King Hamlet. In the beginning, after witnessing the appearance of King Hamlet's ghost, Horatio informs Hamlet of what he saw. "I think I saw [your father] yesternight." (I, ii, 188). The fact, that Horatio would tell his friend that he saw the ghost of his dead father every day for the last week proved that Horatio cared for Hamlet. Next, Horatio tried to protect Hamlet by warning him of possible dangers that could arise if he followed his father's ghost.
Hamlet: "It will not speak, then I will follow it"
Horatio: "Do not, my lord...What if it tempt you toward the flood, my lord,/ Or to the dreadful summit of the cliff." (I, iv, 62-63, 69-70)
From this scene, Horatio is shown to be protecting Hamlet from dangers that could occur, an act that a true friend would carry out. Finally, Horatio helped Hamlet to perform the mousetrap in order to determine if Claudius really killed King Hamlet.
Hamlet: "one scene of it comes near the circumstances which [Hamlet] have told [Horatio] of [his] father's death... Observe [Claudius]: if his occulted guilt."
Horatio: "well, my lord:/ If [Claudius] steal aught the whilst this play is playing,/ And 'scape detecting, [Horatio] will pay the theft." (III, ii, 75-76,79, 87-88)
In this act, Horatio has agreed to team up with Hamlet, and defy his allegiance to the King of Denmark, to see if the Claudius killed King Hamlet. These events are evidence of the true friendship Horatio has with Hamlet.
During the play, Hamlet is also introduced to his childhood friends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. Though they have known each other from a young age, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern prove not to be as true in their friendship to Hamlet as Horatio. This is evidenced by their reason come to Denmark, their first meeting with Hamlet, and the way in which they treated him. When Rosencrantz and Guildenstern arrive in Denmark they are welcomed by Claudius and Gertrude because they were sent for by the King and Queen. "Welcome, dear Rosencrantz and Guildenstern... The need we have to use you did provoke/ Our hasty sending." (II, ii, 1, 3-4). Since Rosencrantz and Guildenstern came to Denmark because they were called upon, and did not come on their own free will, this proves that they are not true friends to Hamlet. Next, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern agreed to Claudius and Gertrude's proposal to spy on Hamlet.
Claudius: "... and to gather, ...Whether aught to us unknown afflicts him thus,"
Guildenstern: "But we obey" (II, ii, 15-18, 29)
Since Rosencrantz and Guildenstern agreed to spy on Hamlet, their own friend, this reveals that they are not true friends. Finally, after Hamlet figured out that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern were sent to spy on him did they finally confess "my Lord, we were sent for." (II, ii, 292). After the truth came out, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern tried to make Hamlet feel better because he felt that he was in a prison living in Denmark because the ghost told Hamlet of his murder and the adulterous relationship Gertrude had with Claudius. From examining the events surrounding the relationships of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern with Hamlet, it is plain to see that they were not good friends to Hamlet.
In comparing Rosencrantz and Guildenstern relationship with Hamlet to Horatio's relationship with Hamlet, it is clear that Horatio was a better friend. From the initial meeting of the two sets of friends to how they treated the main character, Horatio proved to be kinder to Hamlet throughout. First of all, the fact that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are called to Denmark by the King and Queen and did not come because they wanted to see their friend is very telling of the level of friendship they have with Hamlet. This is unlike Horatio, who goes out and seeks Hamlet in order to tell him about his father. Secondly, Hamlet shows his trust towards Horatio when he indulges his plan to figure out if Claudius killed his father. This is in contrast to Rosencrantz and Guildenstern who agreed to help Claudius figure out what was wrong with Hamlet. Finally, Horatio wanted to protect Hamlet from dangers when he warned him that something negative could possibly happen if he followed the ghost. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern only acted nicely to Hamlet once he figured out that they were sent to spy on him. These events provide evidence that Horatio was a better friend to Hamlet than Rosencrantz and Guildenstern were.
In conclusion, from comparing the relationship between Rosencrantz and Guildenstern with Hamlet versus the relationship of Horatio with Hamlet, the evidence viewed, such as his first encounter with Hamlet, the way the main character is treated, and how the friends act with him, showed that Horatio was a true friend to Hamlet. Though, a person may make many friends throughout their lifetime, their actions provide the evidence that is used to determine who are in fact true friends.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Hamlet, having suffered a sudden of death of a loved one, had to watch the marriage of his mother “with wicked speed” to his uncle, Claudius (Shakespeare 31). Grief stricken and “taking (his mother’s actions) to heart”, it would make sense that the sarcastic Hamlet coped with his feelings through acting without care (Shakespeare 27). Horatio, Hamlet’s friend “from Wittenberg,” would have a genuine relationship with Hamlet, demonstrated by how he decided to tell him about the ghost at all and his loyalty throughout the entire play (Shakespeare 31). Knowing Hamlet for a while, Horatio would be understanding of Hamlet’s method of grieving, but would be annoyed at the lack of interest of what he has to say, since he knows how important it is. Hamlet,…
- 189 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Horatio believes that the ghost is appearing because foul play was involved with Hamlet Sr.’s death. He is not positive…
- 378 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In this book “Hamlet” Hamlet is obsessed with suicide even though he never does it. Hamlet falls in deep love in the book and Hamlet's mother marries Hamlet's uncle after his uncle kills the king with poison. Claudius killed Hamlet Sr with poison in his ear and then not long after marries his wife. Hamlet then is told about a ghost that is haunting the kingdom Hamlet declares to see this ghost and ask it questions because they think it is his father. Hamlet sees the ghost and ask it what its purpose is for being in the kingdom and Hamlet says “To be, or not to be”(3.1.63) speech and he felt he needed to find the truth in the ghost’s words of wisdom so he would know how to respond to the ghost and that's how Hamlet finds out that Claudius…
- 695 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In William Faulkner “A Rose for Emily’’ we think about who is Emily, what does the rose symbolizes, and most of all who is the narrator. Throughout most of Faulkner’s story for me as a reader I wanted to figure that out. In the beginning Emily is presented as a woman who grew up wealthy never having to worry about anything. But over time things changed after her father’s death. Later on, Emily never really takes notice of the present.…
- 480 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
He possesses a level of knowledge demonstrated throughout the play, while advising Shakespeare on what he believes he should do or not do. The first sign of this is when Horatio and Hamlet encounter the ghost of King Hamlet. "Why, what should be the fear? I do not set my life at a pin 's fee, and for my soul, what can it do to that"? (Shakespeare 653) Hamlet has already made up his mind about following the ghost, and finding out what it wants. Horatio pleads for Hamlet not to go, but he doesn 't listen anyway. Although Horatio couldn 't sway Hamlet from following the ghost, at least he was concerned and made Hamlet take the time to think about it…
- 656 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Hamlet loved his father, King Hamlet, and it was his death that broke young Hamlet's heart. It is the love he had for his father that brought him to his doom. After King Hamlet's death he appeared as a ghost moving through the castle at one o'clock every morning. When the guards and Horatio, Hamlet's best friend, noticed this ghostly figure, Horatio quite intelligently believed that he could get the ghost to speak with Hamlet. The next day the two guards, Horatio, and young Hamlet were present to speak to the ghost of King Hamlet. The ghost told Hamlet that he was murdered by Claudius, his brother, who had been sworn in as the new king and married his wife, Hamlet’s mother, Gertrude. After hearing this, young Hamlet was asked to avenge his father’s death, but in doing so his mother was to remain unharmed. Hamlet, being the loving and devoted son he was, and unable to accept Claudius as the leader to replace his father, accepted King Hamlet’s request. After this encounter, young Hamlet refused to tell the guardsman and Horatio what happened but made it known that he would act like a…
- 1099 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Opening the play with a masked identity of its own, the late King, Hamlet’s father, appears as a ghostly figure. This alone gives the audience a sense of false facing because the King is thought of to be dead. Not only does he appear at the beginning of the play in the presence of Horatio, Barnardo, and Marcellus, but two more times throughout the plot to his son Hamlet. To further confirm that the ghost was false facing the image of the dead King, Horatio remarks that it is wearing the same armor the King wore when fighting Norway. As the three men draw their swords in fear, they request that Horatio, the scholar, address the ghost.…
- 1350 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Hamlet's friend Horatio is a foil for him because he brings out the revenge and betrayal in Hamlet. He is a listener for Hamlet. Horatio seems to be the only one who is sympathetic of Hamlet concerning the death of his father and his mother's quick remarriage. He is very loyal to Hamlet. Horatio, through conversation, develops Hamlet's image. He is the only person Hamlet can come and talk to about all that is going on in his life. Hamlet uses Horatio as a release and tells Horatio some of the plans he has in order to take revenge. In act 2, scene 1, Hamlet tells Horatio that however odd he may act, it is just that, an act. Hamlet trusts Horatio not to tell his secret and not to give him away. He also tells Horatio of his plan to catch Claudius during the play, and he asks Horatio to watch every emotion of the king. When Hamlet came back from England and his terrible trip, Horatio is the character that Hamlet first went to see. Hamlet tells Horatio how he was tricked by the king, and how the deaths of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern came to be. Horatio is seen as the window or insight into what Hamlet feels and what he does.…
- 643 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Act I Scene 1 : Horatio’s fear about the Ghost is “something to worry about”, he talked about the emperor Julius Caesar, and how the corpses rose out of their graves and ran through the streets. There were threatening signs and now Horatio believes that the ghost of Hamlet was sent down here as if heaven and earth has joined together to warn them what is going to happen.…
- 3411 Words
- 14 Pages
Powerful Essays -
However, that is the fact that he has to face since his meeting with the Ghost. Since the beginning of the story, Hamlet has suspicious about Claudius being the killer; however, after meeting with the Ghost, all of the Hamlet’s actions are based on the “fact” that Claudius murder the king by pouring poison through his ears. This including The Mousetrap. Meeting with the Ghost makes Hamlet discard all of his previous postulations and putting his mind on the direction that the Ghost pointed to. The Ghost also forbids Hamlet from any murderous intentions toward Gertrude, he also order Hamlet to stop Gertrude’s relationship with Claudius.…
- 1409 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
The key concern of Deception is clearly conveyed through the interaction between Hamlet and Ophelia and also in the tense interaction between Claudius and Hamlet. Hamlet and Ophelia’s relationship becomes completely transformed due to the selfish acts of other characters exerting forceful influences on their relationship. Polonius and Laertes insist that Ophelia should not continue to fraternize with Hamlet as it will lead nowhere: “Do not believe his vows, for they are brokers” (Act 1). Shakespeare’s imagery in the use of “brokers” emphasizes Polonius’ belief that Hamlet is “playing” but will not marry her. The key concern of Deception is also prominent the play due to the fact that several characters have an external appearance that is very different to their true internal self. Claudius is a complex, multi-faceted character who ultimately finds himself in an intimate battle between illusion and reality. It appears that he is finally feeling guilt when he…
- 726 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Hamlet decides to get more information / prove what the ghost was saying before doing…
- 3020 Words
- 13 Pages
Good Essays -
After talking with the ghost, Hamlet, comes back to Horatio and Marcellus and tries to explain to them never to let anyone know what has happened. Both are very scared but agree to the prince's, but both are still looking to find out what happened between the ghost and him. Further on in the evening Hamlet takes Horatio to the side and explains to him that no matter how odd he acted that Horatio say nothing. (And therefore as a stranger-you most need help you Act1 sc5 line 187-202) He basically explained to Horatio that he was going to be acting much differently than normal, and he told him not to ask questions. This here proves he knew what he was going to have to do. It shows that he was willing to get his revenge by any way possible.…
- 792 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The ghost in Hamlet is a manipulative figure who serves as a reflection of Hamlet’s perspective of his uncle. Hamlet is too distressed about his mother marrying his uncle and the death of his father for he himself to be considered reliable. As Horatio comments, “He waxes desperate with imagination,” portraying Hamlet’s desire to find something that may not even exist. Hamlet does speak to this “ghost” and confirms his own suspicions, as if this ghost simply existed to give Hamlet confirmation of what he already believed. This ghost also refuses to speak or be heard by anyone except Hamlet, putting into question its own existence. The ghost being part of Hamlet’s imagination is supported by Hamlet stating to Horatio, “My Father – methinks I…
- 169 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The play, Hamlet, begins with Francisco, one of the sentinels at the guards platform at Elsinore,who is waiting for Bernardo to relieve him of his duty right after midnight. Bernardo calls wondering who is there, to which Francisco replies that Bernardo should tell him who he is first. There is confusion of who should be asking who the other is because both are equally ranked guards, and it would be Bernardo's turn to be guarding the castle, and perhaps both are suspicious of the other. There have been previous sightings of an apparition around this same time, so both are tense and worried, hence the demanding questions and lack of trust. Horatio is with Bernardo and Marcellus because they want Horatio to witness the appearance of the apparition so that they will have someone else acknowledge its happening. Horatio is listed as Prince Hamlet's friend and confidant and Marcellus refers to Horatio as a "scholar" when the apparition first appears.…
- 5164 Words
- 21 Pages
Good Essays