Doyle uses Watson as a narrator for two key reasons. In the first place, Watson is not as intuitive as Sherlock Holmes. In this sense, he allows the reader to join him as he attempts to live up to the master's standards. By contrast, if Sherlock Holmes were telling the story, we would have little opportunity to solve the mystery ourselves: witness, for example, Holmes' various and sundry revelations of the truth, which preclude our participation by effectively beating us to the punch.
The second reason Doyle uses Watson as a narrator is that it allows for the pace he is looking for. Even if Holmes' character can give us a chance now and then by keeping his conclusions to himself, he is still too quick a thinker to take on the onerous task of relating all the facts in detail. Only a slow-witted lackey like Watson is fit for the job. When Holmes' character does appear, he serves more as a catalyst for the action in the story, bringing things to a quick and exciting climax.
At the same time that Hound was written, Gothic fiction, which used supernatural themes, was extremely popular. Doyle himself was a spiritualist. How does the novel handle the possibility of supernatural occurrences?
The supernatural plays a major role in The Hound of the Baskervilles. Doyle uses it on multiple occasions in service of his plotline and in dialogue with other themes.
As far as plot goes, Doyle takes full advantage of the excitement, and power of a Gothic-style mystery-an ancient curse, and a common plotline, with two dead bodies at the hands of possibly a supernatural beast. At the same time, however, he evinces a strong faith, at least in Holmes, of a logical, rational explanation for even the most mysterious occurrences.
Thematically, the supernatural ties together questions of class, which run throughout the novel. Superstition is linked to weakness (as with the infirm Sir Charles), but most prominently with lower class status. In this sense, it is interesting that Doyle regularly refers to the superstitious commoners but only rarely lets us meet them first hand.
How do Sherlock Holmes and Arthur Conan Doyle handle class differences?
Both Holmes and Doyle come from a very specific and presumably similar cultural milieu in which gave privileges to the educated white male and denigrated virtually every other kind of human experience. Though they relied on and even fostered what might be called a space for only men, they almost certainly had no time for homosexuals. Though they relied on the lower classes to fetch them things and rummage through their garbage, they took little account of them or their dignity either. Two arguments can be made: one, that the prejudices of the past cannot be judged by the standards of our current cultural moment and two, that Holmes and Doyle were racist and sexist.
It probably makes the most sense to take the middle road, to situate classisms and racisms in their appropriate cultural context, while at the same time insisting on their inappropriateness in our modern world.
Suggested Essay Topics
Why does Holmes get involved in this case in the first place?
How do images of modernity interact with mystical legends of the past?
Why does Doyle seem so intent on creating men-only spaces (Holmes and Watson, and, in the end, Henry and Mortimer)?
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
1. The narrator, Dr. Watson, visits his Holmes one day, and finds him in talking to Jabez Wilson, an old, redheaded man. Holmes invites him to come in and listen to Wilson’s case, which he claims is the strangest he has ever heard. Holmes amazes them when he lists facts about Wilson that he has gathered from observation, but that no one has told him. Wilson begins to tell his story.…
- 605 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Why did you choose to tell Burnham and Holmes's stories together? Why did you make the chapter structure switch between Burnham's and Holmes's perspectives?…
- 92 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The author shows that Holmes is very mindful because he can notice things that the common person cannot. In the play Holmes begins to tell everyone what he observed and how he knew who committed the crime from the very beginning. “Elementary, my dear Watson. I knew that Spaulding was awfully keen to spend time in Mr.…
- 218 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The famous fictional detective Sherlock Holmes, created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, is known for his keen observation skills and logical thinking that has outsmarted criminal masterminds. His ability to conclude a theory from reason and logic is impressive; however, “It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data. Insensibly one begins to twist facts to suit theories, instead of theories to suit facts" (Scandal, 3). For his cases, Holmes gathers up data and information in any way he can, one being the art of disguise. The use of disguises play a significant part in crime solving because they allow Holmes to conceal his identity so he can gather information and ultimately deceive society.…
- 457 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Sherlock Holmes is a very strange man. He is a detective who can solve a mystery without even seeing what seems to be like too much evidence. His ethics are very interesting. He believes that murder cases turn out to have very complex ways of happening. He does not believe in the solar system, which the narrator thought was very weird. His decision to join the case to help was a just decision, because without him the case wouldn’t have been solved correctly. Holmes seems to always stick with his beliefs, not matter what the situation was, even after the case seemed like it was solved.…
- 396 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
5. This is an interesting question to think about in my opinion. Holmes had somewhat well-known motives in this book. These motives were clearly to murder and destroy people and places. People need to understand these motives so that they can stop them from occurring and t prevent other people to act like Holmes.…
- 764 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
It is also suggested in the story near the end that something exciting may happen Holmes character becomes more mysterious. He brings a cane but he can walk so what for? He also asks Watson to have his gun at the ready. In the story Holmes states “Do not go asleep; your very life may depend upon it. Have your pistol ready in case we should need it.…
- 366 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Watson as a capable and brave individual, whom Holmes does not hesitate to call upon for both moral and physical assistance…
- 556 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In H.P. Lovecraft’s hair-raising, scary story “ The Hound” has the reader on their toes wondering what might happen next. The author exemplifies how two men go into a life of grave robbing, which turns out to be the worst mistake of their lives. Lovecraft uses imagery, figurative language and setting to make the story more supernatural.…
- 260 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Sherlock Holmes is a brilliant, eccentric, and moody man who has been one of the most enduring figures in modern literature. Holmes is supposed to be a detective, but he’s actually a magician; that’s the key to his popularity. Many times in his stories, he comes up with results that seem magical. For example, in The Hound of the Baskervilles, all he has to do is LOOK at a walking stick, and then can give a complete physical description of its owner. His plots usually start off as a scary, inscrutable puzzle (usually murder), and end with him revealing the “elementary” answer and how he deduced it. The thing about Holmes is that he can always explain how he achieved his results, and that’s what makes his particular magic unique and so appealing.…
- 189 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Sherlock Holmes is a name with an enigmatic connotation. It means magnifying glasses and a British accent to most people. However, to me, it means noticing the obvious. It means finding deep, lasting friendship, alongside solutions to seemingly impossible mysteries. Sherlock Holmes is a mystery in and of himself, and that’s what makes him alive. The same goes for me, for you, and for the rest of the universe. Holmes taught me that our mysteries are solvable, no matter how complex, and that was one of the most valuable lessons I’ve ever…
- 439 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The main protagonist, Sherlock Holmes is an observant, intelligent, and egotistic detective. He sometimes lacks the empathy needed in basic human relationships but manages to maintain a close friendship with his partner and roommate, Dr. John Watson. Also Holmes is able to understand the factor of human emotions in a crime…
- 454 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Have you ever heard of Sherlock Holmes? Have you ever read one of his books? Sir Author Conon Doyle wrote one of Sherlock’s famous stories, “The Speckled Band.” Doyle likes to write detective stories. This essay will be explaining how “The Speckled Band” is considered a detective story.…
- 477 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In “The Speckled Band,” Conan Doyle writes of how Holmes is able to solve a mystery involving an overcontrolling step father, Dr. Roylott, and his two step daughters, Helen and Julia. Julia has been dead for some time, and now Helen comes to Holmes to seek answers. Holmes and Watson go to the home of Helen and Dr. Roylott where they find many interesting clues. That same night Holmes and Watson stay in the house to see if Holmes’ suspicions are right. Later that night Holmes solves the mystery when he runs a snake back into Dr. Roylott’s room and kills him. The features Doyle incorporates into the story makes it very appealing to readers interested in detective stories.…
- 119 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The Sherlock Holmes novel The Hound of the Baskervilles written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle is a very unique story, but just how unique is it? The series Doctor Who originally created by Sydney Newman, C.E. Webber and Donald Wilson…
- 645 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays