Preview

Heat and Dust by Ruth Prawer JHABVALA comparison to Kipling´s poem "The White Man´s Burden"

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
301 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Heat and Dust by Ruth Prawer JHABVALA comparison to Kipling´s poem "The White Man´s Burden"
Compare the different opinions with the message of Kipling´s poem „The White Man´s Burden“ and show parallels and differences.

As it is said in the poem the British people, especially Douglas and Dr. Saunders think that the Indians are barbaric ans heathen.
It is the same Attitude as it is stated in Kipling´s poem. Because Dr. Saunders thinks that Indians have no culture and no religion but just are savage and gruesome in their kind of acting.
This is exactly the same way Kipling describes the Indians in his poem.
For Douglas, not all, but most of the Indians are violent and dangerous.
He thinks he has to rescue and to help them.
As also mentioned in the poem Douglas sees himself as the white man who has the burden to clean up India and there is nothing for him he couldn’t handle.
Dr. Saunders and Douglas are representatives of the message of the poem.

Olivia has a different opinion.
She knows that the Indians are human beings like everyone else, too and that they have their own culture and religion with their customs and traditions.
She can´t understand that there is a right for the British just because they are white to interfere and destroy the Indian way of life.
She is the complete opposite of the poems´ message because she respects the religion and doesn’t want to bring her religion to them.
She feels like a guest and does not want to rob the country and threaten the people like devils.
They act as if they want to help and as if they have the burden to bring food and peace to the poor barbaric people but actually they just rob the country and try to bring their religion and culture to India.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Indians were here before the name American even existed. In Luther Standing Bear’s essay “what the Indian means to America”, he informed us of how great the American Indian is. While many scholars would debate on the true heritage of America’s beginning, The Indian would not join this argument because they alone know the real story of this country we call home. Within this essay the Indians are a breed of people that do not lie down easily. Many would strongly agree with Luther Standing Bear’s definition that the Indian is a true American. The Indians are the roots under America soil because of their strong connection with nature, their spiritual toughness, and their musical influence.…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Lakota Woman Summary

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages

    From the beginning of the book it becomes evident that not all Indians are the same. Mary Crow Dogs grandparents grew up during a time when the United States was trying to “civilize” the Indians by forcing them to abandon their customs in favor of a Christian lifestyle. Most Indians took offence to that…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    (Background: Many white people felt that they were morally responsible to raise ignorant native peoples to a higher level of civilization. Few captured this notion better that the British poet Rudyard Kipling in his famous poem The White Man’s Burden. His appeal, directed to the United States, became one of the most famous sets of verses in the English-speaking world.)…

    • 3231 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Often perceived as a group of tyrannical oppressors, the white people have firmly established their gruesome and discriminatory image through the bloody history of its dictatorship over racial minorities. Although it is true to some extent that White people were biased and unjust to other races, it is obvious that the intransigent mindset of the native Indian people have also contributed to the intense enmity between the two races. Harold Cardinal, once president of the Indian Association of Alberta, had inaccurately accused Caucasian Canadians in “The Mystery of the White Man”. He had described White men as a group of bigoted, corrupted rapists and portrayed the Indians as some guiltless victims of the depraved White society mistreated for living up to the standard of morality. Harold Cardinal had disguised his people under a mask of innocence and blamelessness while labeling Caucasian Canadians as the ultimate obstacle to peaceful diversity.…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    social status and poor family background, it is logical to think that she will control other…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    that the Indian people were happy. They had traditions, strong family ties, and a great appreciation for everything that was. They had always supplied everything that they needed for themselves through “Grandmother Earth” and that was the way they planned to live until the end of…

    • 487 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the New England people set off to America to, “cultivate the Lord’s garden,” [pg. 26] and farm arable land, they knew the Indian people had already inhabited the area, but did not fear them. When first viewed the Indian people were believed to be savages, living as uncivilized as the Irish. To the New England people, the Indians were in deficit of all it took to be urbane, lacking attire, writing, Christianity, and urban areas, and indulging in passion and lust beyond the New England belief. Even when the Indian population tried to help the New Englanders, by bringing, “food and rescuing the starving strangers,” [pg. 35] the New England appreciation only lasted so long. The two groups soon became hostile as the New England people tried to exploit the Indian’s food supply, and fighting broke out almost immediately. With the constant fighting the governor of Virginia, Thomas Gates, decided to have the Indian people be forced to labor for the New England people. This decision was not taken lightly, but yet powerfully and unsympathetically. Even the children were treated cruelly; they would bring them to the river where they would, “put the Children to death … by throwing them overboard and shooting out their brains.”[pg. 39] Eventually a peace treaty was negotiated by Captain William Tucker, but…

    • 1788 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kipling described how people in Europe viewed men of different backgrounds as “sullen people.” He then continued with “To seek another’s profit, and work another’s gain.” This defined the relationship between the “white man” and “other man.” The white man gets the profit while those who worked must grow up and understand no matter how hard they work, they may never earn the life they might have predicted. Kipling’s intended his poem to show the U.S. to take up the “burden” of empire like the European nations had done and described the affliction by justifying…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Howard Zinn

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Chapter 7 was titled “As Long as Grass Grows or Water Runs” and it refers to how the Indians were the most foreign. Land between the Appalachians and Mississippi were cleared for white occupancy. They had called it the Indian removal. In the south it was cleared for cotton and in the north it was cleared for grain. Indians had fought alongside the British during the Revolutionary war, but since they were already on their own land, they kept fighting after the British had left. The Indians had to deal with a lot of mistreatment from the government and they made them feel as if they were aliens on their own land.…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    His usage of literary terms shows how the white people began slowly to control them. "I saw my evil day at hand." This demonstrates how the white people quickly betrayed the Indians and cheat their way into their society. Black hawk saw how soon his home was being destroyed. "They poisoned us by their touch." The white men were like a virus quickly spreading and damaging everything they set out to take.…

    • 158 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Fish Cheeks

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages

    -I think she want people to remember that it doesn’t matter where are you from or what others think about you or your culture, you must be proud of it and to never feel ashamed to be themselves.…

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sherman Alexie

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages

    First, we can see his Native American heritage in the language of the poem. For example, he refers to the elderly woman whom he is conversing with as "white" (line 1), which gives the impression he is not; there would be no real reason of mentioning skin color unless it was important to him. He is also very negative about the white woman's definition of history. The woman says, "'Look, / look at all the history,…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “They don’t understand. We know these hills, and we are comfortable here”. There was something aout the way the old man said the word “comfortable.” It had a different meaning- not the comfort of big houses or rich food or even clean streets, but the comfort of belonging with the land and the peace of being in these hills”(Silko, p117). It is this quote that essentially defines the reader response criticism. They Indians , Tayo, are victims of racism. Silko lets the reader hear their most inner thoughts. It is clear that there is an inner struggle with Tayo, between the white half of his heritage and how much better his life could be if he lived that heritage and the Indian heritage and how difficult his life is because he is Indian. Allowing the reader to feel what Tayo feels, hear what he is thinking and experience his reactions to the prejudice he faces helps “make sense out of chaos” (Tyson, 219).…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The media, and Hollywood in particular, is one avenue in which the general public becomes familiar with the role of nurses. How does the media positively or negatively influence the public’s image of nursing? What other avenues may better educate the general public on the role and scope of nursing as well as the changing health care system?…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “One of Bird's most serious charges against Alexie is that in Reservation Blues he ‘'prey[s]' upon’ his community and culture in perpetuating damaging stereotypes, including that of the drunken Indian. As she puts it, ‘Stereotyping native people does not supply a native readership with soluble ways of undermining stereotypes, but becomes a part of the problem, and returns an image of a generic 'Indian' back to the original producers of that image’ (49)” (Evans).…

    • 1280 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays