Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

How far do sources B and D support the attitude towards women of source A

Good Essays
660 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How far do sources B and D support the attitude towards women of source A
How far do sources B and D support the attitude to women shown in Source A?
Source A is a narrative painting depicting a woman comforting her husband. The title itself suggests that it is ‘woman’s mission’ in life, her role is to be there for her husband, she is portrayed as the caring wife. It looks like she has been waiting for her husband to return home and when he has opened the letter, and found bad news, he does not share these with his wife or embraces her but it is the wife’s role to be there for him. The woman depicted is clearly of a wealthy background (silver tea set, luxurious clothes and furnishings) so we can infer that they are upper class members of society, this is also true when considering the type of women that Tennyson and Ruskin in both Source B and D would be referring to, Tennyson is a Lord and Ruskin was a successful writer.
As Source A describes a woman’s mission, source D describes what the nature of a woman should be ‘instinctively’, what her correct conduct should be, supporting Source A in so far as she must live by ‘self-renunciation’ and make her mission in life, the happiness of her husband. Source D goes even further to point out all that women should aspire to be ‘enduringly incorruptibly good’ making her almost a saint in the cause of her husband’s happiness and wellbeing. This view is strongly supported by the poem from Tennyson in Source B. This idea of goodness and purity is mirrored in Source B. The poem is called ‘The Princess’ giving the idea of the innate nature of women as innocent, pure and delicate creatures.
Like in the picture in Source A, Tennyson makes a clear distinction between what a man’s role should be and women’s roles. He clearly states that women should be in the domestic sphere by attributing to her words such as ‘hearth, needle, heart’ and men ‘field, sword, head’ making a clear distinction between indoors and outdoors, between private and public spheres, as Source D, Tennyson implies that this is not by choice, but by nature ‘roots of earth and base of all’. Source D also states that women should be wise, not with their heads but with their hearts ‘wise…with passionate gentleness’ and ‘modesty of service’ she must never think of herself as cleverer than her husband ‘not that she set herself above her husband’ but accept her role with ‘modesty of service’ to him. Both sources suggest, it is women’s love and care, not their intellect that men need.
Sources B and D provide evidence to support source A, so far as to state what women’s ‘nature’ is like and what society asks of her. In the case of the picture, to be at home when her husband needs her and to be his rock in which to lean on, however this is only a snapshot of how women should react in this situation and it doesn’t give us any insight of what her day to day life should be like, whereas Source D, goes further than the picture by Ruskin stating what a woman should aim to always be. Is important to take into account he fact that Ruskin had a failed marriage and perhaps he is using this source to describe what he would have liked his wife to be, not ‘insolent’, implying, with any independent thought, but a ‘passionate gentleness’, gentleness being the key word as his ideal wife might have been naïve and innocent. Source B, goes even further by explicitly stating that by trying to alter these separate spheres and mixing up roles, we would be altering the ‘roots of earth, and base of all’, Tennyson percieves these roles as uninterchangable, permanent, fixed, anything but these prescribed spheres would lead into chaos ‘all else confusion’.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Godey's Lady's Book

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages

    b. Thesis: Godey’s Lady Book illustrates an image of true womanhood. An ideal achieved only by the minority of women. This represents an ideal woman to serve males.…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The standard of an ideal woman has changed dramatically over the centuries. And the differences are certainly apparent when comparing the modern expectations to the Puritan’s. The most important difference being that the standards were much stricter and the idea of an ideal Puritan woman was very prevalent in society. Consequently, many readings during the 16th century emphasizes the necessary qualities of an ideal Puritan woman. One of which is Jonathan Edwards’ essay, in which he offers a male perspective by describing his perfect woman, Sarah Pierrepont. Additionally, Anne Bradstreet reflects a female view on how an ideal Puritan woman should be through her poem, “To My Dear and Loving Husband.” Lastly,…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Christine de Pizan emphasizes traditional societal norms for women through the values of honor and loyalty. Rule 8 explains "how the good princess will wish to cultivate all virtues" - Pizan explains that a noble lady controls her heart, behaves "respectfully and softly", and displays a kind, gentle demeanor to all (Pizan 19). As a princess, Pizan argues that a noble lady should listen patiently and attentively to her subjects as well as listen to advice from the wise gentleman counselors (Pizan 21). It is these behavioral qualities which tie into the traditionally accepted cultural norms for women. The ideal woman, the perfect princess, is an honorable lady who is in control of herself constantly. She is dignified and wise with the help of good advice from those advisors. Rule 12 describes how a wise princess' life should be ordered. Prudence rules all, Pizan argues, and everyday begins with addressing God first (Pizan 32). There is a great deal expected of princesses and women in general, but society still considers men far superior. Even with a responsibility in government, a woman must still hold herself with the highest of dignity and listen to the wisest of men in order to seem wise herself. Another example of prudence in a woman's life is her conduct towards her husband - she must love her husband and always be at peace with him (Pizan 36). She should always humble herself towards her husband and obey without complaining - it is in this way that Pizan explains the traditional role of women in the household. Wives are expected, in that time, to watch carefully over their husbands, take everything in stride, and stay a noble lady by being true and loyal to her husband (Pizan 38-39). The welfare of her children also defines what a lady should be - a woman is expected to be naturally motherly and want her children to be honorable…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the Victorian era, women and men were assigned different gender roles. The notion of gender roles entailed that man may go outside the home and subject himself to mistakes, while women must tend to the household and stand as an example of exceptional morality. According to John Ruskin, a man is “the doer, the creator, the discoverer, the defender. His intellect is for…war, and for conquest.” However a woman’s “intellect is not for invention or creation but for sweet ordering, arrangement, and decision. She sees the qualities of things, their claims, and their places” (Ruskin). A man is free to adventure and subject himself to mistakes and questionable morals, while a woman must stay at home and provide a peaceful and morally sound shelter. Ruskin claims that despite expecting women must remain enclosed in the household, that they possess a different kind of power than men. A woman is “incorruptibly good” and “infallibly wise.” She is free to judge the man’s morality as she is never at fault. Ruskin asserts this assumption by saying that as a woman “rules, all must be right, or nothing is.” He claims that women are…

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wives as Deputy Husbands

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Wives as Deputy Husbands” by Laurel Thatcher Ulrich was written to give the author’s opinion on the roles of women in the 17th and 18th century. Some historians thought women were merely there to do housework and take care of the children. They thought they were helpless. On the contrary other’s thought they were very involved in various affairs such as: blacksmiths, silversmiths, tinworkers, shoeworkers, tanners, etc. They thought they may have been very independent. However, this article is used to understand how households were run and how women fit into both female and male roles.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The traditional Victorian image of the perfect woman was "the Angel in the House". Regardless of her relationship status, the Victorian women were supposed to be less than men when it comes to making choices, for she's seen as a powerless, fragile, helpless creature that is only meant…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Osmond, Marie Withers, and Patricia Yancey Martin. “Sex and Sexism: A Comparison of Male and Female Sex-role Attitudes”. Journal of Marriage and Family 37.4 (1975): 744–758.…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    An Ideal Husband Analysis

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Double standards are clearly represented in the novel by Oscar Wilde, An Ideal Husband, that talks about the position of women in the society. In this play, women are attributed to several things, for instance, an idea that women stand for the irrational, women have a wonderful natural feeling concerning a number of things. They are able to discover everything except the most obvious things in society. In addition to these, the play as well indicates that the life of a man is more important and valuable as compared to a woman’s life. Wilde’s An Ideal Husband highlights the role of women in society in the 19th century in England.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the fantasy novel Dealing with Dragons, Patricia Wrede tells the tale of an intelligent princess who refuses to act like a proper princess. In this fictional set in medieval times, a proper princess was to do as she is told, marry who her parents say, and dress and act beautifully. Cimorene is justified in ignoring the expected social norms of the day because it did not benefit her life, but some may disagree.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    2. The artist who created Portrait of a Noble Woman was a Bolognese woman by the name of Lavinia Fontana. Lavinia Fontana’s husband was an artist as well, although, gave up his career to help raise their eleven children which was very rare during this time. The painting, Portrait of a Noble Woman, epics a young bride dressed lavishly and accessorized with gold, pearls, and rubies. The bride is wearing a rich red velvet gown which enhances the overall virtues of wealth, loyalty, and gentility a woman at this time would bring to a marriage. Fontana definitely portrays this bride to be a woman of importance. The humanist, Alberti, views women of any social class as caregivers and should be universally timid, soft, and slow. (125 Words)…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The women pictured in Godey’s Lady’s Book show an ideal to which women aspired but in truth could not often obtain outside of the middle to upper classes. The images portrayed in this magazine represented the concept of “true womanhood”; women who were regarded as pious and domestic. They were to be the anchors of the home and the educator to children. The images displayed are of the ultimate wife and mother which were an iconic representation of the values of those who read Godey’s. The women depicted in the book looked fragile, innocent and demure. They were not fit for work in the public sphere physically as women were supposed to be frail, delicate creatures. Women were also not fit mentally or emotionally for the public sphere. They were too innocent and pure for the dangers of such pursuits as suffrage or politics.…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It can be said that society has always been quite judgmental, and at times misguided when it comes to women. The negative perceptions that society has towards females are often times directly related toward her actions. What a female does seems to degrade her identity and capabilities in the eyes of some men. In the poems “The Lady’s Dressing Room” and The essay “A Modest Proposal” by Jonathan Swift, we can see both authors use of tone, form and style to develop their works. These poems are mainly driven by men’s attitudes towards women. A man’s perceived opinion about women can negatively shape society’s views and perceptions of them.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Women were also writing this material (and sometimes, as Marie de France demonstrates, they were attempting to deliver a message through the literature), and thus while we think of the medieval populace as completely in agreement with traditional textually and religiously determined “womanhood” (that is, in opposition to women in positions of power, learning, or having authority) the fact that there were popular women writers producing literature that people enjoyed reading shows that this couldn’t have been completely the case. The situation in the medieval ages probably did not “feel” the way that it is portrayed by “the authority” (the Bible, the law, etc.). While it was stated in many places that women were expected and required to be obedient and subservient, that they were the property of their husbands or male relatives, and many other ideas that we would scoff at today, it might not just be us scoffing – just because they were portrayed a certain way in the texts that have survived, doesn’t mean that their reality was really that unfair (though it undoubtedly was, to an extent). It is not clear whether the author of The Wife’s Lament is female, but the narrator obviously is. That, in itself, is a feminist move, and it puts the woman in the position of power; the narrator is in control of the story, and the reader sees the world through her eyes. The wife’s proclamation that those who feel, “harsh pain at heart,” should, “put on/a happy appearance while enduring/endless sorrows” (The Wife’s Lament, 43-45) can be read in two ways; on one hand, it could be a critique of a society that expects women to mindlessly follow their husbands, disregarding their own sorrow and instead pretending to be happy in order to make the ordeal better for the man – however, it can also be read as a celebration of brave women, who despite their circumstances “put on a happy…

    • 1764 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Both men and women face expectations of their role in society, and stereotypes exist for both genders. Some men that enter nursing might think that they are perceived as the profession is not appropriate for men. They may feel that nirsing is "too feminine" or feel that the will be percieved as "homophobic".…

    • 53 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gender roles can be defined as the ways that women and men are supposed to act in society. They are often looked upon as a “status quo” and are rarely defied. Although society has generally solved some gender issues, they still occur today. Gender Roles were very relevant during the Victorian and Modern Era’s and were often showed through literature. Women were viewed as submissive and did not have as much luxury as men in their everyday lives. Tennyson’s “The Lady of Shalott” illustrates the oppressive nature of women in society during the Victorian Era and the consequences that occur when those roles are defined. However, in Woolf’s A Room of One's Own, gender roles are questioned showing the changing ideology behind women's rights during…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics