Preview

How Far Do the Sources Suggest That the Uprisings of 1536 Were Motivated by Religious Grievances?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
678 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Far Do the Sources Suggest That the Uprisings of 1536 Were Motivated by Religious Grievances?
How far do the sources suggest that the uprisings of 1536 were motivated by religious grievances?
(20 mark)
HISTORY PART A (UK Essay Question)

Source 1 is a primary source which clearly demonstrates the religious reasons based on the uprisings. The petition which was presented to the king at York (demonstrates its reliability as it’s derived directly from the demands of the rebels in the Pilgrimage of Grace) highlights their key requests: “the service of God is not well performed.” This quote highlights the frustrations as well as disapproval for the way the church’s direction has been altered and disrupted the divine way of God: “Bishops who have recently been promoted by the king have subverted the Faith of Christ.” Other demands detailed within the petition demonstrate the rebels’ further frustrations in regards to the “suppression of so many religious grievances.” This demand is the first stated in their demands, which shows that this religious grievance is in fact the primary cause for the uprising (Pilgrimage of Grace in the eyes of the rebels). The suppression of the religious houses are creating issues as well as directly effecting the way that the message of God is being spread among the people; not only those partaking in the Pilgrimage of Grace.
A report made by the Imperial Ambassador to Charles V supports this, as it states that “the rebellion may be the way of stopping…the changes in matters of religion.” Due to the fact that this source may overall be un-biased (as it is simply a report and interpretation of events from the Ambassador to Charles) and neutral in its motivation within the matter, this proves to be a reliable form of evidence. Due to Charles V’s overall opposition to any changes within the Catholic church, as well as Henry’s need to break with Rome, highlight a general feeling shared between Charles and the rebels against reformist ideas and actions supporting it; shown through “the demolition of the churches” and “suppression of
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Popular Protest in the 16th Century Could Pose a Dangerous Challenge to the Monarch and the State. How Far Is the Statement Accurate in Relation to Years 1536-69?
    • 1226 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Popular Protest in the 16th Century Could Pose a Dangerous Challenge to the Monarch and the State. How Far Is the Statement Accurate in Relation to Years 1536-69?

    Throughout the years 1536-69 five rebellions took place, all of which could be interpreted as a dangerous challenge to the monarch and the state, at the same time all of which can be interpreted as not a dangerous challenge instead could even have strengthen the monarch and the state. Source X agrees with the statement as ‘each monarch faced at least one serious revolt.’ Source V suggest that a lack of leadership, organisation and ‘geographic limits’ hindered the success of many rebellions such as the northern rebellion or the pilgrimage of grace. Source W agrees with the statement ‘in the right hands and with the right circumstances’ popular protest in the sixteen century could have posed a dangerous challenge to the monarch and the state. I will interpret these sources to determine whether the rebellions of the 16th century did or did not pose a dangerous challenge to the monarch and the state.…

    • 1226 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    How Effectively Did Tudor Governments Deal with Rebellion in England and Ireland?
    • 2557 Words
    • 11 Pages

    How Effectively Did Tudor Governments Deal with Rebellion in England and Ireland?

    Tudor governments were relatively successful in dealing with the problem of rebellion, although this was more effective towards the end of the period than at the beginning shown through the decline in rebellion after 1549: only 5 English rebellions occurred as opposed to 10 before 1549. Over the course of the Tudor period the main aims of rebellions were only fully achieved in the rebellions of 1525, the Amicable Grant and 1553. In addition to this the reforms made to local government, policies directly implemented by central government and the effects of trials and retribution, such as Henry VII’s concessions made to the late 15th century pretenders, Lambert Simnell and Perkin Warbeck and later in the period during Elizabeth’s reign, who recognised rebel Shane O’Neil as Earl of Tyrone, all contributed to the reduction in the frequency and scale of English rebellions. Pre-emptive strikes implemented by Tudor governments were also instrumental, especially during the start of the period in Henry’s reign and later in Elizabeth’s reign, in preventing rebellion or stopping riots from becoming dangerous rebellions. In some areas these strategies and tactics worked better in some areas than others; Irish rebellions were generally more costly and more difficult to suppress.…

    • 2557 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Henry Viii and the Break with Rome
    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Henry Viii and the Break with Rome

    The Roman Catholic Church was very powerful in England. Henry hated the fact that his country should allow someone else to have so much power of them. After all, Henry was very lustful for power, and was used to getting what he wants when he wants!…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Unit 4 Apwh
    • 2547 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Unit 4 Apwh

    Religious reform movement within the Latin Christian Church beginning in 1519; resulted in the “protesters” forming several new Christian denominations, including Lutheran and Reformed Churches and the Church of England…

    • 2547 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    DBQ PILGRIMAGE OF GRACE
    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages

    DBQ PILGRIMAGE OF GRACE

    The Pilgrimage of Grace participants were Catholics who were against the Protestant Reformation. They made armed demonstrations and protests from 1536 to 1537 against Henry VII, head of the Anglican Church, and Thomas Cromwell his Lord High Chancellor. Cromwell implemented a series of policies that included the confiscation of Catholic Church lands. The goals of these participants were to stop the Protestant Reformation and give more rights back to Catholics. They had concerns with the protestants growing more powerful and having a protestant King in Henry the VII. The goals of the Pilgrimage of Grace were to give power back to the Catholic Church in Europe and take credibility from Proestants, but instead their concerns of the Protestant Reformation overshadowed them and their goals were not reached.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Henry VIII DBQ
    • 1150 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Henry VIII DBQ

    Wanting an annulment from Catherine the Great, Henry VIII created the Anglican Church through the Act of Supremacy in 1534. This marked the beginning of the Protestant Reformation in England, and Thomas Cromwell, Henry VIII’s head of the King’s Council, instigated a series of governmental policies including new taxes, growth of royal power in the north of England, closure of monasteries, and elimination of Catholic church lands. In response to Cromwell’s doings, marchers staged protests and armed demonstrations that came to be known as the Pilgrimage of Grace. The religious goals of the participants of the Pilgrimage of Grace discussed the issues of Protestantism and the need for Catholicism to be firmly re-established. The participants also had religious and political concerns about the corruption of the church and Parliament’s authority, resulting in political opposition about treason and government from those supporting Henry VIII.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Peasants Revolts Dbq Analysis
    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Peasants Revolts Dbq Analysis

    The peasants’ revolts in sixteenth century Germany were very historically significant. As such, many groups had different perspectives on the causes of the revolts as well as different responses to them. The peasants themselves cited as the cause many of the ideas brought about through the Protestant reformation: individual rights and the godliness and equality of all people. However, many nobles and government officials saw these as acts of the peasants’ own stupidity and vengeful nature. As for the response to the revolts the members of the church had widely varied responses from whole-hearted support to condemnation. The government officials responded through acts, which gave the appearance of being reasonable, but actually were not. The…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Immediate Causes of the Saint Bartholomew's Day Massacre
    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Immediate Causes of the Saint Bartholomew's Day Massacre

    Since the Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre there has been a great deal of controversy over the causes and blame of the historic crisis. Any religious dispute is a very contentious debate due to the fact that there were generally very few impartial bystanders to record what took place. Given that the clash between the Protestants and Catholics had been an ongoing problem since Protestantism had spread to France in the early 16th century, documents that can be studied are often very biased, and historians must gather information from a third party perspective in order to form opinions about historic events such as the Saint Bartholomew’s day massacre. Attempting to figure out why such a horrific event happened is incredibly difficult. It is impossible to know why an individual acted the way they did unless they recorded their thoughts at the time. However, by encompassing various documents written by different individuals we are able to establish an understanding of the circumstances leading up to the massacre and hereby construct a recipe for the event. The formula for any sort of civil crisis is simple; it requires two groups of people who passionately disagree on an issue enough to fight over it, a situation that puts high levels of tension between the two parties, an established fear of the unpredictability of the opposing group, and finally a trigger. In the days leading up to Saint Bartholomew’s Day 1572, the recipe for a disastrous event unfolds and ultimately evolves into the slaughtering of thousands of Protestants in Paris and surrounding regions of France.…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    yo check it
    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages

    yo check it

    Do you agree with the view expressed in source e that the fall of Thomas Cromwell in 1540 was primarily the work of his enemies at court?…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    how serious was opposition to henry
    • 1958 Words
    • 8 Pages

    how serious was opposition to henry

    To an extent, Opposition to the religious reforms by Henry VIII wasn’t overly serious, the opposition did have some potential to cause damage but the danger was never severe enough to undermine the Tudor dynasty or threaten the omnipotent once of the “Most Christian King”. Opposition was only as serious as the support it had, which is why The Pilgrimage of Grace of 1536 was the most dangerous form of opposition. Henry ensured that disapproval from his kingdom would never threaten to undermine the longevity of the Tudor dynasty by using Cromwell’s key weapon: The Treason Act of 1534. This allowed Henry to eradicate any opposition that had potential to threaten Henry. The religious changes came to a halt in 1540, where Henry sends out a strong deterrent message by executing the architect of the religious changes, Cromwell.…

    • 1958 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Pilgrimage of Grace
    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Pilgrimage of Grace

    When Martin Luther posted the 95 theses in 1517, he had changed the entire path of European politics and religion. He sparked a thought in the region that in many cases, converted people’s basic Christian beliefs. At the time, the Roman Catholic Church was the most powerful Institution. However, there were many corruptions and problematic doctrines, which Luther opposed. Though most commoners became followers because of faith, political leaders sometimes became protestant for other reasons. One important figure that was influenced by this protestant reformation was King Henry VIII of England. A monarch, he had a great desire to have a son that would be his heir, the next king. Unfortunately, his first wife was only able to birth one daughter. By then Henry VIII had formed a relationship with another woman. This one promised him a son. However, the Catholic Church forbade divorce and Henry VIII was Catholic at the time. To resolve this issue, England separated from the church and began the Anglican Church, a church headed by Henry VIII himself. The Act of Supremacy in 1534 officially began England’s Protestant Reformation. With this new power of the state over the church, the head of the King’s Council, Thomas Cromwell, carried out new government policies which included new taxes, increased power of the monarchy in Northern England, dissolution of Roman Catholic monasteries, and confiscation of the lands that belong to the Church. Enraged, commoners and nobles alike began marching and protesting in what was known collectively as the Pilgrimage of Grace. These individuals that numbered in the tens of thousands, marched for political and religious reasons, while the opposition also claimed political and religious reasons for the protests to stop.…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Pilgrimage of Grace
    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Pilgrimage of Grace

    The Pilgrimage of Grace started because many people were dissatisfied with King Henry VIII's actions. The King's decisions to form a new religion sparked a controversy with the devout Catholics, but others were angry, not necessarily with the religion aspect, but just with the mannerisms of the King. For example, the King's decision to make a new religion without a Pope was not revered by some men because they strongly disagreed with heresy. Other people believe that the King was being unfair when he took away their land for his own benefit and profited from it. Some people believe that the King made inexcusable decisions on his behalf, while others believe the King was justified in his decisions.…

    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Political Issues In The Thirty Years War
    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Political Issues In The Thirty Years War

    In war there’s always more than two sides bashing heads against one another, war has many angles and cracks in it, one reason can break into two more and the deeper the war goes the more discoveries are found. Going all the way back to the beginning of the war, the root of the war was behind of felicitous tolerance. (Simmons, 2016). War has always had a background of religion being one of the many key aspects of war even becoming and uprising, the constant idea of disagreement with someone who doesn’t share the same ideas as the other. Like many wars before Thirty Years War it was fought behind land, dynastic and religious reasons, all these factors are what contributed to the outbreak. (Thirty Years War, 2017). Thirty years war was one considered to be referred as a “religious war” because of its conflicts in relation of religions before and after the war. (Wilson, 2009). Having religious tolerance being a key development of the war is important because religion branches into many different areas, not being the only leading factor of the war either. A feud that was constant in the years of the war was the feud between Protestants and Catholics. Emperor Ferdinand was a leader who took it upon himself to equated Protestantism with disloyalty. (Darby, 2001). Then came Louis XIV king of France was was also another strong leader who’s goals became accomplished when he abolished the last Protestant rights in France…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Mass Conflict Dbq
    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Mass Conflict Dbq

    During this period of time citizens were only able to think a certain way or they would be punished for stating their opinion. One philosopher named Rousseau wrote “ “Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains,” ”(Beck,1249). In this instance he was telling the public that they do not have free will and the government is taking their rights away from them. The government censors what the public can believe as having your own ideals is dangerous to society. Many citizens were weary of the government as they were being controlled like puppets. They had to attend church and listen to “...church teaching and authority”(Beck,1237). These policies were enforced so the people would not question the teaching of the church as they would not have any knowledge of outside ideals by doing so. The government tried to control every aspect of what they knew, but by doing so scientists and philosophers questioned the work of society. Government tried to bury their ideals by punishment, yet society found a way to move forward with these banned ideals. With these ideals in hand people found away to believe them, even though the government strongly distressed with them. People found a voice in themselves to rise up and not be controlled anymore. Conflict was dealt with as a result of the people having their own opinion. In…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Rebellion In Late Medieval Europe
    • 4136 Words
    • 17 Pages

    Rebellion In Late Medieval Europe

    The rebellion in Late Medieval Europe was caused by numerous individuals, events and developments in the 14th Century. In this essay I will be discussing the significance of each of these factors concerning the English, Czech and German revolts, and the opinions of Cohn, Tuchman and Walsingham.…

    • 4136 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More

Related Topics