Human Right Essay
Human Rights Study Questions
1. Under the heading “Labour Rights as Human Rights” on page 134 of reading 1 (“Labour Rights as Human Rights in the Age of Globalization”), the authors assert that “there are two principal manners to conceive of labour rights.” In the two paragraphs which immediately follow that statement, the authors list different rights that are encompassed under each of these two approaches. Please identify FOUR kinds of labour rights emphasized under the first approach, and FOUR kinds of labour rights included under the second approach. (W1)
First Principle: Labour rights are often depicted as a subset of the body of civil rights and political freedoms. The state’s role in defending worker’s rights, but workers also need to be protected from the limits of that state. Labour rights are understood by comprising: i) freedom of association ii) freedom from sexual harassment iii) “ discrimination iv) right to human dignity Second Principle: A broader outlook on labour rights. Relies on the state, but also on an active role on the part of the citizenry to advance those entitlements. Based on economic, social and cultural rights. i) the right to work ii) the right to strike iii) the right to favorable and just working conditions iv) the right to holidays and rest periods
2. Pages 64 - 73 of “Seasonal Agricultural Workers” (reading 2), contain several criticisms of the SAWP (Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program ) and TFWP (Temporary Foreign Worker Program). What are SIX different criticisms made in these pages? (W1)
6 Criticisms of the SAWP and TFWP: i) SAWP sets up a contract relationship with workers dependent on their boss for housing, transportation and immigration status. This leaves them isolated and vulnerable: it makes challenging their boss difficult ii) One the only migration programs in Canada that offer no possibility of claiming eventual citizenship status (because of workers’ low occupational classification, they can never qualify as
1. Under the heading “Labour Rights as Human Rights” on page 134 of reading 1 (“Labour Rights as Human Rights in the Age of Globalization”), the authors assert that “there are two principal manners to conceive of labour rights.” In the two paragraphs which immediately follow that statement, the authors list different rights that are encompassed under each of these two approaches. Please identify FOUR kinds of labour rights emphasized under the first approach, and FOUR kinds of labour rights included under the second approach. (W1)
First Principle: Labour rights are often depicted as a subset of the body of civil rights and political freedoms. The state’s role in defending worker’s rights, but workers also need to be protected from the limits of that state. Labour rights are understood by comprising: i) freedom of association ii) freedom from sexual harassment iii) “ discrimination iv) right to human dignity Second Principle: A broader outlook on labour rights. Relies on the state, but also on an active role on the part of the citizenry to advance those entitlements. Based on economic, social and cultural rights. i) the right to work ii) the right to strike iii) the right to favorable and just working conditions iv) the right to holidays and rest periods
2. Pages 64 - 73 of “Seasonal Agricultural Workers” (reading 2), contain several criticisms of the SAWP (Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program ) and TFWP (Temporary Foreign Worker Program). What are SIX different criticisms made in these pages? (W1)
6 Criticisms of the SAWP and TFWP: i) SAWP sets up a contract relationship with workers dependent on their boss for housing, transportation and immigration status. This leaves them isolated and vulnerable: it makes challenging their boss difficult ii) One the only migration programs in Canada that offer no possibility of claiming eventual citizenship status (because of workers’ low occupational classification, they can never qualify as