Illegal Immigration Argument Analysis
Since the presidential debates began, many American citizens have started questioning the trend of immigration to the United States. In the middle of September 2015, Republican Party candidate Donald Trump stated, “We have illegal immigrants that are treated better, by far, than our veterans” (Schleifer). His foreign policy ideas made many American citizens ask themselves contradicting questions about immigrants – Should undocumented immigrants be able to stay in this country or should they be deported? Are immigrants genuinely taking jobs or are they aiding the country by strengthening it through hard work? The rising issue of undocumented immigrants in America has caused people to either oppose them and want them to be deported or support
…show more content…
Goodman upholds the belief that illegal immigrants are a vital group in the United States, especially for the economy and major industries. However, Gheen asserts that unless the immigrants are legal, they should not be in this country at all. Despite their significantly distinct views, they do share a few beliefs in common. Both Goodman and Gheen acknowledge that the number of undocumented immigrants in the United States is massive in scale. Because of this, they both urge readers to pay attention to the subtle rise of the issue, especially since it became a controversial issue in the presidential debates. Furthermore, Goodman and Gheen also agree that the number of employed illegal immigrants is increasing annually. Goodman finds this to be a good thing, while Gheen considers it to be a major …show more content…
Much like the population rate of illegal immigrants, their employment rates are also going up. This key fact is seen in both articles. Goodman writes that, “…[illegal immigrants] are important to the U.S. economy, as well as vital to certain industries like agriculture.” Although he does not explicitly state it, the problems Gheen talks of in his article have to do with the effects of the employment in illegal immigration. However, the increase of employed illegal immigrants is as far as they agree on the employment of illegal
Goodman upholds the belief that illegal immigrants are a vital group in the United States, especially for the economy and major industries. However, Gheen asserts that unless the immigrants are legal, they should not be in this country at all. Despite their significantly distinct views, they do share a few beliefs in common. Both Goodman and Gheen acknowledge that the number of undocumented immigrants in the United States is massive in scale. Because of this, they both urge readers to pay attention to the subtle rise of the issue, especially since it became a controversial issue in the presidential debates. Furthermore, Goodman and Gheen also agree that the number of employed illegal immigrants is increasing annually. Goodman finds this to be a good thing, while Gheen considers it to be a major …show more content…
Much like the population rate of illegal immigrants, their employment rates are also going up. This key fact is seen in both articles. Goodman writes that, “…[illegal immigrants] are important to the U.S. economy, as well as vital to certain industries like agriculture.” Although he does not explicitly state it, the problems Gheen talks of in his article have to do with the effects of the employment in illegal immigration. However, the increase of employed illegal immigrants is as far as they agree on the employment of illegal