Preview

Inadequacy Of Congress

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1720 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Inadequacy Of Congress
The constitution of the United States distinctly trichotomizes judicial, legislative, and executive power between the Supreme Court, Congress, and the President, allowing a system that functions through checks and balances. Since congress is a political organ whose members have different interests, this separation of power has not been conducive to drafting policies that effectively address pressing public issues. Madison expands on this lack of efficacy when he notes that “the powers of the legislative organs of government are derived from the electorates”. This shows that members of Congress represent a particular legislative unit and as a result they will always tend to act in the interests of those they represent. In this scenario, coming …show more content…
By examining the number of bills enacted in the 112th and 113th congressional sessions, we can quite clearly see that this number has declined by a significant amount in comparison to earlier sessions. This begs the question: if congress is becoming increasingly ineffective, why should we as citizens trust our congressmen to pass the policies we so desperately need to preserve our liberty? It is this increasing inadequacy of Congress which leads me to consider the president as another possible engine of legislation. On the other side, those who are advocates of the current system recognize this slow and deliberative process not as a problem but rather as a feature of our constitution, intended to avoid poor bills and government overreach. From their viewpoint, congress is able to pass bills as needed and forcing them to vote on bills they did not propose would cause even more problems. While this argument may have some semblance of truth, I believe that it ignores some vital facts. The problem with congress is not so much that they are deliberate on purpose, but rather that this deliberation is a result of an accommodation process. The process of proposing, drafting, and voting on bills all in congress guarantees that somewhere in a bill’s life cycle, special interests will interfere and dilute its original intention. Collusion by members of Congress from differing factions and the inherent nature of bureaucracy ensures that this is bound to happen in some bills. The Affordable Care Act is one example of legislative policy that bears only little resemblance to its original form, which became a vehicle for the Senate to impose hundreds of amendments upon it. With this in mind, I assert that a system where the president proposes bills that would then be voted upon by Congress without changing anything is far superior. This capability will

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Legislators cannot be swayed by public opinion or the media; they cannot make a decision based on what will make them popular or get them reelected. In order to get public trust back, our legislators must, more than ever before, act in the best interests of the nation—to keep the long run in mind. They must take Coolidge’s words to heart—they cannot be afraid of being called a standpatter or a demagogue and instead focus on legislating to the best of their abilities. Legislators must do whatever is necessary in order to gain back the trust of their constituents—they must “Do the day’s…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Once the deadline passes and Congress is adjourned the bill has no chance of passing. There are also some factors that are in place to limit the powers of policy making for the president such as mandatory spending. This is spending is spending on certain programs required by law like medicare or social…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reaction Paper: Presidential Power and the Power to Persuade To be a strong, powerful leader, or not to be, that is the question for the President of the United States. With global issues, domestic chaos, and foreign affairs, Presidents are expected to do much more than their authority enables them to do. Because of the limit of their authority and the harsh criticism from citizens, Presidents lead with their bargaining skills and persuasiveness. If a President is too harsh or strong, people categorize him as a tyrant, and if a President is perceived as weak, citizens label him as incompetent.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Polarization In Congress

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Polarization in Congress leads to less bills reaching the President for review. While a Congress that passes every bill it meets provides no benefits, Congressmen should not shirk their duties primarily due to polarization. Representatives’ achievements for the term should instead be limited on properly in-depth debate and discussion relating to the legislature they need to pass. However, at an increasing rate, senators drop bills out of the law-generating cycle (Andris, 10). Andris, et al, explains: “The number of bills introduced seems to . . . [correlate] with a decrease in Congressional productivity.” (10). Further, Andris et al also finds that in Congress, “The average number of disagreements on roll call votes between [congressmen]…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    When the Founding Fathers wrote the American constitution, one of their key aims was to ensure that power would not be concentrated too highly in the hands of one leader. Despite the resultant implementation of checks and balances, it can be argued, as this essay will, that the president’s power has grown to an extent that makes Congress decreasingly effective. Utilising Wildavsky’s idea of a ‘dual presidency’, I will show that in both domestic and foreign policy Congress can never be fully effective in reigning in presidential power.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The biggest, and most notable short coming of Congress’s design is the democracy gap that sometimes occurs. This gap between legislators and the public most often occurs in the Senate, with Senators being responsible for representing thousands, and even sometimes millions, of people. With two people representing so many Americans it is hard for the public to actually be heard in the Senate. This issue also affects the way that Senators campaign, and could greatly hurt incumbents in the Senate. Senators often run on the idea that their decision making skills will mirror the ideology of the state, but if they cannot deliver on that promise they are in jeopardy of losing the publics support.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Legislative Gridlock

    • 2387 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Jefferson states that a “government is best which governs least,” but what affect does government inaction have of on our society, and what are the forces that promote this inaction? The competition for power between separated institutions is a driving force in this inaction. When the legislative and executive branches of our government engage in a power struggle, policies that could be potentially beneficial suffer at the hands of legislative gridlock. The polarization of the democrat and republican parties also has an impact on the difficulties faced by Congress. A polarized Congress leads to difficulties in legislating because no one is willing to compromise. The competition of power and polarization between the parties are only 2 of the forces that have led to Congress’ inability to pass laws. The structure of the US government as bicameral legislative body has proven to be the overarching vehicle in Congress’ inaction. In this paper, I explore the arguments in Stalemate (2003) to explain the level of gridlock in the 112th Congress. I focus on the impact of divided government, the polarization of parties, and bicameralism and argue that the difficulties in legislating in 2011 are likely to reappear in 2012.…

    • 2387 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Give Me a Free Essay

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The president’s power of persuasion is also illustrated by his role as chief diplomat for the United States. In this position, he negotiates major treaties with foreign countries, such Carter’s Panama Canal Treaty or Bush Snr.’s Chemical Weapons Ban. Even so, it is the job of the Congress to ratify the…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I trust the President can and should utilize official requests to make history. For one thing, it is very clear that Congress wouldn't care for an official request, however that is on the grounds that they must vote and pass laws and such. I feel that if the President, who the voters chose, sees that a specific request would be fit, at that point he or she ought to have the capacity to pass it if Congress does not choose to. Past official requests, similar to the integration of the military and the Emancipation Proclamation, have achieved significant changes. Normally, if the President is anticipating passing an official request, he gives a sensible approval to it. Congress ought to at any rate be endeavored to be worked with above all else…

    • 182 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The government works substantial just how it is. The powers between the Congress and President in the foreign policy is divided reasonably. I do not think I would make any changes in regards to Constitutional powers of the President or Congress. How it works is very significant even the requirements for the President don’t need to be changed. A lot of people would like to change on how the president does not have to be born in the United States in order to become a President. It’s better that we keep everything the way it is and how it works in the foreign…

    • 104 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Drawing on evidence from recent political developments involving healthcare, military invention and other critical issues, discuss the nature of the power relationship between the executive and legislature in the US presidential system.…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The constitutional theory provides that conservatively presidents aren’t full accustomed or adept to use their constitutional power to veto and not using the arguably most formidable remedy against Congress may prove costly (Kernell et al. 2014, p. 325). The consequence is of not maximizing the power to veto is allowing Congress to be less considerate of the president while making decisions (Kernell et al. 2014, p. 326). As it shows that number of average vetoes per year has fluctuated in the past century but on definite decline in past three decades (Kernell et al. 2014, p. 326). The general negative linear correlation in the number of vetoes help explain that the inadequate use of constitutional power, is a limiter the Congress has on the…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The necessity of a majority vote is the very heart of Representative Democracy and yet is also the core of many of the shortcomings along the road to new legislation. The vote earning process is a very interesting time as it is the pivotal moment to the success or failure of a piece of legislation, but is one of the shorter and overlooked portions of politics. Major figures in support of the bill often travel in an effort to associate their support base with the bill and thus put pressure on the deciding votes in Congress through their Constituents and their desire to remain in office. President Obama did just that during the Congressional recess over the month of August. The President also attempted to quell any fears that the general public had during this span as fear is a very effective tool for opponents of legislation (Smith 2). The public may not be the ones in the chamber voting when the time comes, but Constituents’ support works both ways. If a support base is against a bill due to false rumors, then they are more likely to lobby their Congressmen to vote against the legislation. The support of the constituency is very important to gaining votes on the floor; however, votes in the House and the Senate is the deciding factor to a bill’s success and sometimes hurdles to a majority are not…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    US Foreign Policy

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Lawmaking is the road to enacting a bill into laws is long and strewn with spikes and thorns, and it is also a “battlefield” between the legislative branch and the executive branch. Think about how Congress carries out its power to check any activities of the executive branch! The key role is oversight to make sure the laws it writes are faithfully executed. With all that power in his hands, the president meets and negotiates with the foreign leaders for making or bargaining some treaties, but until two-third of senate approve these treaties they really start. For example, in the “Understanding American Government”, Susan Welch, John Gruhl, Susan M, and Sue Thomas told that the President Jimmy Carter had to wait for the Senate's demanding and ratification, partial renegotiation of the Panama Canal treaty in its conditions is effective (335). Sometimes, Congress needs to pressure the executive branch into a new way in foreign policy by warning to pass legislation. Even Congress can amend bills in a different form from the original proposals instead the President signed them (348). In addition, the President has a right to veto bills that give a president another way to influence lawmaking, but in keeping with the system of checks and balances, the Framers gave two houses the authority to override a veto by a two- third vote in Congress. According to the textbook, in practice, presidents are rarely overridden is a maintain power and they…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The president is authorized to proposed legislation. A president usually outlines the administration's legislative agenda in the…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays