Preview

James And The Giant Peach Comparison

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
779 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
James And The Giant Peach Comparison
When the topic of movie adaptations based on written literature is concerned, there are many different opinions on if they are “real” or “accurate.”A classic example is James and the Giant Peach originally written by Roald Dahl in 1961 and adapted to film in 1996 by Disney. Originally this movie was never going to be made as Roald turned down many different offers for this to adapted to screen during his life. It was not until he died that his wife, Liccy Dahl, agreed to have it made. There are quite a few changes between book and movie versions due to artistic vision, and many have voiced their opinions about both. Although, if these works did not convert to film everyone would be losing many, many great novels and series to time and a culture that finds more joy in visual representation. The theme of this story was to show a kid trying to mentally escape from his not so wanted lifestyle and end up in a better place. A very standard type of story when people think about all the stories out there that have the same underlying concept. The way this one differs is by selling this as a children’s story in the 60’s. You have to expect this is a time period where everybody was less politically correct and therefore less sensitive to a darker type of story then would probably see these days. When Disney decided to make a …show more content…
This all but proves that if the film was never made, there would be a lot of people out there that would never even know that this was even a book. Though they had to change many things and the story’s plot was watered down, it still brought it to the masses as a now classic in both realms of media. In conclusion, if these classic novels were adapted and converted to modern times, whether they are accurate or not, they would be lost to an age where the preferred method of storytelling is

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Davie Movie Vs Book

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I think, hopefully along with you, the reader that books are greater than the movie, especially in this case. For some extra details, here are some good mentions. The book, produced in 1886, had more evidence that Alan had committed the Appin Murder than the movie! Also, the plot and timing of character scenes were off. One example was when Davie asked the woman in the book where the House of Shaws was, in the movie it was a man! Also, in the book, the woman had hatred for the House of Shaws, when in the movie he had no hatred that would of made the movie slightly more…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    After watching a movie so underwhelming to it’s counterpart on paper you question why they ever bothered to turn such a literary classic into a screenplay. It is safe to assume even the French are saying, “Pourquoi Hollywood? Pourquoi?”. A book such as Lord of the Flies (1954) by William Golding, deserved more than selling out to a complete body of American directors, writers, and actors, who would disregard the important themes and meanings behind the book due to “time restraint”. Movies are adapted to bring books to life, but someone watching the movie Lord of the Flies (1990) directed by Harry Hook, would never quite understand the meaning behind the boys, their journey, and the question being answered about man versus nature presented by…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Contemplate the fact that in the book, no women are present at the end of the novel, but in the film, women play a role in the reconstruction of the new society. Possibly, this difference reflects that the book was written in 1953, whereas the film was made 14 years later.…

    • 359 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Of Mice and Men

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There isn't as many differences as there are similarities in the stories, but they are very noticeable, for example, in the book, Lennie is described as "big" and "dark around the eyes", but in the movie Lennie isn't fat and he is white so you can see his eyes clearly. To me, he looked pretty average except you can notice there is something wrong with him by the way he acted. There are many quotes in the book that aren't said in the movie. It's good to know that both stories aren't "exactly" the same. Then, if you read or watch one, you wouldn't have to read or watch the other. Unless you are supposed to be comparing or contrasting each, that's a different story!…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Both the book and the movie are very similar, or else it wouldn't be much of a point to make a movie for a book.…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the contrary, in the movie everyone arrives by a ski lift to a cold, snowy mountain. Many of the indictments are changed between the two works. In the book, General Macarthur put his wife’s new lover in the frontline of battle, but in the book General Mandrake sends 5 men to their death. Miss Emily Brent scolds a woman into suicide in the book, while in the movie Miss Burgan kills her husband. Vera Claythorne let’s a young child drown in the book, and in the movie Ann Clide said to be responsible for the death of her sister’s fiance. Philip Lombard from the book killed a whole tribe by depriving them of provisions, while in the movie he is said to of killed the mother of his unborn child.…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    After all this years the most important thing I have noticed about films based on books is that they are never accurate and there is always a big difference in story. I feel like movie makers have their own opinion about a story which they think might get more people to watch movie. In the movie the main thing that changes is headless horseman becomes real where as in book Brom bones. In the movie the horseman actuallly kills people where as in book there are only sightings. In the movie Ichabod is a constable who visits sleepy hollow to investigate unusual murders in the town where as in the book he is a a school teacher. I feel like the movie was way different from the book but johney depp played the character very well and thats what made…

    • 144 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Whether one is reading fantasy, a literary tale, or realistic fiction, there is an abundance of orphans. The protagonist usually starts his or her adventure when they become parentless, which generally happens before the story has officially started. As a result, these characters are resilient and frequently become leaders. They also often have to learn more as well, as they do not have parents to teach them how to be good people. James from James and the Giant Peach, Mary Lennox from The Secret Garden, and Gilly from The Great Gilly Hopkins all have adventures and become resilient because they are orphans.…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Parenthood Movie Review

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The main character had a terrible relationship with his father. They didn’t see eye to eye at all. The father just took him to baseball games and left him there with an usher that he paid to watch him. The absence of a father figure was significant to his childhood. When he grew up he tried to be anything but that memory. He was involved in his children’s lives. This would be a family theme where the parent separates themselves from the child, so they could attend to their own matters in life. The next theme can be seen in the family that has the young girl being feed information like a sponge ruining her childhood so she could get ahead intellectually. The parents did not see her as a child but as some sort of machine. It is not the proper way to raise a child. She was socially awkward and didn’t have the social skills to socialize with the other children at Kevin’s birthday party. This theme is where the parents treat the child as an object rather than a living being. The next one is in the single mom with the two kids. She struggles to support for her family and her children disrespect her all the time. The son was so distant from her and left all the time, while the daughter was in love with a troubled boy. The son was having problems with himself since she went through puberty and he didn’t have a father figure to explain all the changes in his body and while he was feeling certain things. Todd became that father figure when he married the boy’s sister and got to explain what was happening through experience. This helped out the single mother trying to support her two children. The youngest son and brother of Gil the main character displayed the same type of parenting as the grandfather did with Gil, abandoning his child and dumping him with whoever would take care of him.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “There’s more magic and power in those things in that brown bag then in all the rest of the world put together,” The man said softly. “But, but what are they?” James murmured, finding his voice at last. “Where do they come from?” “Ah-ha,” the old man whispered, “You’d never guess that.” He was crouching a little now and pushing his face closer to James; until the tip of his long nose was actually touching the skin on James’s forehead.…

    • 85 Words
    • 1 Page
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many movies are derived from novels, and all of them have major differences from the book version. While there are many similarities in the movie and the book Of Mice and Men, there are many differences also. Some differences are presented through the characters, scenes, and the way the actors play their roles.…

    • 1367 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unfortunately, all of the primary methods of collecting crime data experience inherent flaws, either in the attributes data collected, or the methodology for collecting data. Ideally, a centralized database combining quantitative, qualitative, and geographic attributes would provide the best measure of statistical analysis relating to crime. However, this is near impossible to accomplish, as crime definitions vary from state to state, and there is standardized methodology for local law enforcements with regard to reporting crime (Fagin, 2016).…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many times, when a piece of great literature is published, it is made into a film and while these films are sometimes riveting and accurate to the text, there are times in which they go completely off path and tell an entirely different story. An example of this is present in The Power of One. A book about a young boys journey through his youth, is turned into a hollywood styles love story through the introduction of a character not mentioned in the book, Maria.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Remember Maurice Sendak's Where the Wild Things Are and Roald Dahl's James and the Giant Peach? Or the Japanese folktale about Momotaro, the Peach Boy who battles monstrous creatures on a distant island? Who knew that Sendak and Dahl may have plundered Japanese folklore to construct their stories about boys who set sail in search of adventure? We will never know why Dahl changed his title from James and the Giant Cherry and gave James Trotter a "great big beautiful peach" to navigate the waters, and there are no doubt multiple sources for Sendak's Wild Things (the "Jewish relatives" disguised as horses until an editor pointed out that the artist was not very good at drawing them). Both authors might have fallen under the spell of the celebrated…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The wonderful story that is To Kill A Mockingbird has been around for a long while, and has a lot to say. There is so much to it such as many themes, symbolism, and imagery. A world wide phenomenal book which was later turned into a movie. There are many similarities and differences in the book To Kill A Mockingbird and the film that was based upon it.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics