Preview

Julian Savulescu's Argument Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1435 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Julian Savulescu's Argument Analysis
In “Genetic Interventions and the Ethics of Enhancement of Human Beings”, Julian Savulescu argues that genetic enhancement is morally obligatory in order for humanity to live a longer better life. However, this argument is opposed by philosopher Michael Sandel who feels that accepting one’s shortcomings enables us to develop virtues through adversity and giftedness. Another great philosopher W.D. Ross felt that humanity had prima facie (prima facie denotes evidence that – unless rebutted – would be sufficient to prove a particular proposition or fact) duties such as the duty of beneficence, self-improvement and non-maleficence. Moreover, these duties coincide with Savulescu’s argument for enhancement and provide the basis of my argument for …show more content…

This notion stems from Ross’s prima facie duty of beneficence which states, “Some (duties) rest on the mere fact that there are beings in the world whose condition we can make better in respect of virtue, or of intelligence, or of pleasure. These are the duties of beneficence.” (Ross 115) Therefore, by choosing not to enhance is contrary to one’s duty of beneficence. For example, the lazy parent scenario which sees a child with an average trait who could have an exceptional trait, if the child’s parents pay for an inexpensive genetic enhancement. The child’s parents fail to do so, resulting in the loss of extreme potential. (Savulescu 445) Consequently, this results in a loss for the child individually, as he or she will be unable to achieve their best possible state and to humanity as a whole. It is my belief that through the improvement of others society as a whole develops tremendously, because we all benefit from the giftedness of others (artists provide pleasure through their work etc.) Hence, by not fulfilling one’s duty of beneficence we fail to provide the proper conditions for society as a whole to flourish. However, Sandel states that, “as the role of enhancement increases, our admiration for the achievement fades—or, rather, our admiration for the achievement shifts from the player to his pharmacist.” (Sandel 431) Basically, by engaging in genetic enhancement you are inadvertently revoking your right to take credit for your accomplishments. This is a valid argument, however I feel that Sandel has not considered the use of tools in society to achieve feats. An example of this would be race car drivers. When a race car driver wins a race we typically celebrate the driver of the car, but what about the car (which represents genetic enhancement) itself? Based on Sandel’s notion, society should be celebrating the vehicle

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Physically all humans are created equally from head to toe but mentally and internally some humans are granted with the natural lottery. “Since we cannot undo the inequalities of the natural lottery, John Rawls writes, we must find a way to address the differences in the rewards that result from them” (Arora 88). Agreeing with this quote, people with natural gifts receive easier rewards then people who actually have to work for their rewards. With that being said, the people with natural gifts take their rewards for granted unlike the people who appreciate their rewards through hard work. For example, celebrities just get stuff handed to them easier than a teacher who works hard too and gets paid little. When I played softball, I wasn’t as good as the others and they would always hit a home run so they didn’t really value it however for me having to practice hitting everyday just to make it on first…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “staying human” by author Dinesh D’Souza, we are given a voice of reason in response to the “techno utopians” desire to use science as a means to create perfection known as, “post humans.” D’Souza voices that the ability to do something, does not substantiate actually doing it. And, that it “it poses a grave risk to humans.” D’Souza disagrees with “techno-utopians,” and follows the belief that genetic engineering pertaining to modifying intellect and physical attributes in unethical, especially, parents who would elect to make choices about their unborn children. However, D’Souza does find a medium, and believes that genetic engineering could offer many benefits to humanity, such as preventing illness and deformities.…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Donald L. Niewyk’s fifth and sixth chapters both deal more with outside perspectives and outside reactions than it does with those who were persecuted. The fifth chapter, “Bystander Reactions,” offers four different arguments as to why bystanders acted they way they did during the Holocaust. The sixth chapter, “Possibilities of Rescue,” discusses three different viewpoints on what foreign governments could have done to prevent the Holocaust. These two chapters conclude Niewyk’s book The Holocaust and wrap up the final sequence of events surrounding the Holocaust and the camps.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Marc Prensk’s argument is that all textbooks should be banned and we should be using electronic textbooks. This way students and teachers will be able to access them from their iPad, iPhone, Tablet, or Nook. Prensky thinks that this would give the opportunity for more resources, and motivate the student to always read and refer to the textbook instead of just sticking it on the shelf where it would never be touched. “But I suggest that it 's time to go much further: to actually ban non-electronic books on campus.” (Prensky 1) He believed in freedom away from the page, and thinks that a collection of books and ideas in your pocket would be accessed more than books on a shelf. “Digital texts are also accessible anywhere, at any time, while…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Texas history, as we learned about it in text books, has only told half of the story of Texas Independence. Every school child learns the story of the Alamo and how the brave souls paid with their lives for our freedom. What the historians failed to mention was all of the patriots who were involved, leading up to the Alamo and those who fought after. One of these patriots was Juan Sequin, who ended up paying for his patriotism with banishment, and being marked a traitor. It would be many years after his death before the full story of what this man, and others, actually achieved.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “The Downside of Being a Child Prodigy” is an article written by Andrea Sachs published in Time Magazine on September 6, 2006. The article starts with a reference to a short story about Alissa Quart who had skills since she was a child. She was able to read and teach her peers at elementary school how to read. She got awards for her writings. One of her good skills is that she was able to edit her father’s writing by the age of 13. Then the writer refers to Quart’s book entitled “The Dilemma of the Gifted Child”. The book talks about the pressures that a talented child encounters in life. Some parents try to enforce their kids to learn at early stage. Some of the materials that they learn are difficult to learn. This step might put a pressure…

    • 265 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Carnegie has inspired women and men to use their funds to their communities. Although he advised other wealthy to use their money to benefit the communities and help in the preservation of the political system and America economy. I believe Mr. Carnegie’s argument is persuasive and is still relevant today. The wealthy, as well as small business owners, are the job creators in our society today. Their vision and leadership help to support the lower class in earning a decent living while allowing them to realize their own potential. The lower class today has more opportunities that were not available to them generations ago. While government is there to provide a safety net for those less fortunate, it is the wealthy and job creators that…

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There are thousands of voices all trying to talk over one another, and it’s his job to see that they don’t. He does his best to offer each one of them a deal: go through him, and you’ll get an equal chance to speak with everyone. It’s a deal many of them take. Outside of their own circle, after all, most of these voices have little chance of reaching the limelight. If they let him act as a go-between, they can get a little farther out, even if it’s just to the other people desperate to be heard.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    However, genetic manipulation is still a slippery slope for more trivial “improvements”. The people in the film did not stop at eliminating harmful diseases but they also started altering things like muscle mass, intelligence, personality traits, hair color and this is when eugenics becomes problematic. Like the society in Gattaca, we could be at risk of becoming a superficial society obsessed with perfection. For example Eugene Marrow, the man Vincent borrows his DNA samples from in order to pose as a valid was obsessed with perfection. Marrow was genetically engineered to be a winning swimmer, his entire existence was dedicated to swimming and yet he still wasn’t good enough. Eventually, we came across someone who was as better swimmer than him and he received a silver metal. Marrow began to feel useless, he was genetically perfect and yet he was not, so he attempted to kill himself by running in front of a car. He failed, survived and as a result was paralyzed from the waist down. Marrow became even more depressed, he found some use in helping Vincent but in the end, he killed himself because even though he was genetically engineered to be the “best” but he was not and thus a failure. By meeting Vincent, an invalid who was far more qualified to do great things despite his genetical disadvantages, made Marrow realize that genetic manipulation is not what makes you the “best”. Perhaps it gives you an advantage, which why Marrow decided to give Vincent, his DNA samples but that is not was Vincent eventually became an astronaut, he became one based on his own natural merit. Eugenics is about “improving” individuals but Marrow is an example Gattaca suggests that Eugenics become problematic when we stop…

    • 2232 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The technical aspects of losing weight such as regularly going to the gym and eating a strict diet is a tedious process that may be a motivator to NOT lose weight. We’ve already established that many people struggling with their weight do not feel happy in their bodies, but the act of losing that weight may never even happen. According to Sabinsky’s study on men, he discovered men “perceive too many barriers towards weight reduction” (Sabinsky). Sabinsky identifies that participants’ perceptions of necessary dietary change implied a potential loss of masculinity (Sabinsky). The sense of masculinity trumps the need to enhance their bodies and men would risk body weight and appearance for their dignity. This can explain why it’s noticable that…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    No, I don’t agree with the sentencing because had the judge given the message sentence, that may cause Sandusky grounds for another appeal on the maximum punishment for the numbers of years that he’s already going to serve. The sentence that Sandusky received assures that he will never walk the streets again. The sentence is based on the person and the crime. Given Sandusky age, the sentence is long enough even he was able to walk in general population that would be his death sentence as well.…

    • 87 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are many moral dilemmas surrounding biotechnology. It is important to distinguish between athletic and cognitive enhancements, and athletic and cognitive therapy. Athletes who wish to bulk up and build muscle is an example of athletic enhancement. The legal and ethical arguments of this issue is mainly between liberty and negative consequences. Those who choose liberty are choosing to freely do whatever they want to…

    • 1620 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sigmund Freud said it best when he said, “Every child at play behaves like a creative writer, in that he creates a world of his own, or, rather, rearranges the things of his world in a new way” (Pearson). Playtime is an activity that is constantly being eliminated or greatly reduced, in favor of more structured educational learning activities starting in kindergarten. Many educational facilities have reduced recess or play breaks in the daily, which can lead to the children becoming overwhelmed or act out, because they have not been able to express their energy. Many parents are simply too busy to be able to fully immerse themselves into playing with their children. Parents today are busier than ever and children are enrolled in a multitude of activities they are shuffled to. Often times, parents will believe that they need to provide a wide arrangement of enrichment activities to build up every skill and aptitude so that their child might become high achievers in both high-school and later on in college, and life…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethics and Natural Method

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Genetic engineering in children may not necessarily mean that it will lead to success and happiness but it may rather have a negative impact on that child mentally as shown to us from the film. Jerome has a high status of genes and is considered to be elite in all aspects; these…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Here, when parents are planning on having a baby, they are faced with having to decide whether they want a genetically engineered baby or whether they want to let nature run its course. However, this decision involves much more than a simple yes or no, as this decision will decide their child’s social location and will assign them a master status. Deciding to genetically engineer their baby, parents are assuring their baby the master label of valid, but parents who decide to let nature run its course, are taking the huge risk of having a no-perfect child who will be labeled with the master status of ‘invalid,’ one which can’t be changed.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics