Preview

Julies Disability

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
978 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Julies Disability
Moreover, further emphasising how the able-bodied person will focus on the physical differences of the disabled individual, as it is demonstrated with Julie. This is made evident when Aunt Bea first perceives Julie from afar. Aunt Bea first indicates the visual characteristics of Julie, in referring to her as the “The fat Lord,” then focusing on her “crazy brush cut” or “her funny walk” (Gowdy 9). The minor physical details that ought not to matter is what causes Aunt Bea to recognize that Julie is disabled. However, it is also important that Julie is perceived to be the opposite of what Aunt Bea ‘desired’ when she chose to foster her. This is because Aunt Bea imagined Julie as a “Jewish girl- dark (black), undernourished [...] haunted Anne …show more content…
Arguably, the societal benefit system is supposed to reach to understand individuals like Julie, however this does not happen. This inaction to understand Julie, further critiques how society fails to properly aid the vulnerable. Problematically, since Julie is recognized as the vulnerable, this also causes primal rejection in the able-bodied; consequently, this causes the able-bodied to minimize their attention towards Julie. This idea is then emphasized by how severely disabled individuals must endure a life that is an on-going foil (Burghurdt 557). Burghurdt, explains that possessing a disability will not only functionally damage the individual’s life, but also sociocultural norms will entail their abjection. Consequently, this causes the vulnerable to become abandoned within society. Furthermore, Burghurdt argues there is a generalized agreement in disability studies that the concept of being disabled is determined on the otherness in the agent’s appearances, or behaviors. Rather, possessing a disability is not recognized as a normative state that “Just is” (557). Problematically, it has become an extensive focus on the agent’s physical conditions that has been pushed to the extremes, which causes the able-bodied to ignore the injuries that are caused by the disability and focus more on their aesthetic otherness. Arguably, focusing on the appearance of the vulnerable is the able-bodied society’s way of creating a barrier against what contradicts their own ideal body. Additionally, this barrier causes the able-bodied to disregard the significances of Julies utterances, or actions throughout the story. However, the story makes Julie’s emotionally harmed state clear to the reader when the text momentarily focuses on her internal thoughts, as she “remembers there is a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    “About Being Considered ‘Retarded.’” by Amanda Baggs gives a great perspective on how those who have a disability are considered to be inferior or less human due to them being different from the societal standard of “normal”. To Baggs the way she looks and processes information is normal however compared to standards that society has placed she is different. To me Baggs is conveying the message that we label individuals who are different in this case those who have a cognitive disability and segregate them being considered normal due to the label of retarded.…

    • 94 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay “Life is Too Short for Someone Else’s Shame” by Amanda Leduc, Leduc discusses her lived experience as a disabled writer. The essay begins with a conversation she had with her manager at an organization that specialized in disability support. Leduc analyzes how her response correcting her manager from saying “disabled writer” to “writer with a disability” while ignoring the merit her manager was placing on Leduc’s potential contributions as a disabled writer, was incorrect. She notes her responsibility as a representative in arts spaces to represent disability, and the internal conflict of disclosure that many writers face. She asks the question “what kind of world makes this discomfort possible”.…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Gender reaches into disability; disability wraps around class; class strains against abuse; abuse snarls into sexuality; sexuality folds onto of race… everything piling into a single human body”. I agree entirely with this statement but rather than a sequence of ‘one is caused by another’ I find that all forces impact each other in an extremely complex web. The exact causal reason for one action or another cannot be determined in such a simplified method. The sequence of impact could be written in any number of ways. For this reason the best way to mitigate the impact of one is to work simultaneously on all. Despite being extremely confusing for those who are not pre-exposed to the various terms and concepts, Eli Clare’s ‘Exile and Pride’ is an appropriate addition to queer literature. The purpose of this book however is up for debate. As it currently stands as an addition to queer literature it serves its purpose well. If the book was intended to educate readers on disability politics then it also serves its purpose but is hindered by its medium and the language utilized to conveys the…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One of Nancy Mairs’ aims is making a change regarding the association between media and people with disabilities. Although she, herself is a great consumer, she’s bothered that not many advertisements would include someone like her to represent their products. Even moving her to ask a local advertiser as to why. His reply was, that he didn’t want to give people the idea that the product were just for the handicapped. The author feels the true reason behind it is that people cannot yet accept disabilities as something ordinary, resulting in a subject to be effaced completely- isolated.…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nancy Mairs had a normal, healthy life like any other person. Although, as time went by, she had been diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, which eats away the protective covering of nerves which interrupts the nerves’ signals that passes through the central nervous system. Mairs piece had a purpose to inform her audience about her personal life and her thoughts about being “crippled”. Mairs also includes the superficial beauty standards society has set. Mairs relates it to her and her audience’s feelings about the way it shaped people’s criticism of others that do not set to the superficial standards in society. Mairs captivates her audience to read more and be thoughtful about what she wrote is because of her uses of a variety of rhetorical…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nancy Mairs starts her essay by describing herself as a crippled woman with multiple sclerosis. She talks about her condition and how she’s never seen a crippled woman like her in the media. Then she mentions some television shows about disabled people that focus almost entirely on disabilities and neglect the person’s character. Mairs states that although disability changes a lot in one’s life, it doesn’t kill him/her. She for example, can do what every other woman her age can do. And although she’s a great consumer, advertisers never choose someone like her to represent their products publicly; and the reason for that, according to Mairs, is that people cannot yet accept the fact that disability is something ordinary. The consequences of this situation are hash on disable people, for they might feel like they don’t exist. Finally, Nancy Mairs says that anyone might become disabled. But if one sees disability as a normal characteristic then it…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the piece by co-authors Paula Fernandes, Nelson DeBarros, and Li Li, as well as the piece written by Georgina Kleege, we can see how these authors use rhetorical devices in order to draw in and persuade their audience on the topic of disability. Through a deep and thorough analysis of the texts, we will be able to understand how their focus on certain rhetorical elements and techniques creates flow in their writing, how the ideas motivating their writing are expressed, as well as how these elements combined create an effective narrative on the topic they are trying to discuss. The topics, though surrounding the topic of disability, use very different approaches and have very different targets with their works, with one being especially…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unfortunately, “Sometimes we create our own heartbreaks through expectations.” In Hurst's "The Scarlet Ibis," the unique narration and diction is used to convey the danger of pride, as symbolized by Doodle's inspirational yet devastating struggle to live up to his brother's unfair and unrealistic expectations. Throughout this paper, you will see just how different handicapped people’s expectations are for themselves than the people’s expectations around them.…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The rhetorical audience in the extract of the article is focused towards those who are activists for people with disabilities because they have the power to be persuaded to strike change. Berube’s emotional excerpt about his son Jaime sends the message of the difficulties it takes to raise a child with down syndrome, yet at the end of the day it is still Jaime and he is still his son. The rhetorical opportunity Berube offers his audience is the idea of treating everyone equally. Regardless of how certain people are, disabled or not, they are their own unique individuals who should be treated as such. The emotional statements that Michael Berube includes in Life as We Know It such as, “Almost as a form of emotional exercise, I have tried, on occasion, to step back and see him as others might see him, as an instance of a category, one item on the long list of human subgroups,” provides the audience with specific ways to sympathize and also persuades the audience to be more open to change. Berube’s story mainly uses emotional means to persuade and convey the message to the reader to change the way people view others and to try to continue changing others to see people as Berube sees others. Berube also compares his two children, Jaime and Nick, and explains first hand how much more difficult it is to take care of Jaime, and how much more time is needed to control Jaime, yet in the end he still views Jaime as Jaime, not as a disabled child. Regardless, just as any parent does, Berube explains how sometimes he and his wife question, “where we’re doing enough for him.” Berube, as the rhetor, uses multiple ways to convey the message to the audience and is able to persuade many people to change their views and current lifestyle.…

    • 589 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the essay, “Becoming Disabled” by Rosemarie Garland-Thomas, her main claim that she argues is that she wants the disabled community to be politicized in the eyes of society. First, Garland-Thomas talks about politicizing disabilities into a movement. She compares and contrasts movements for race and sexual orientations to the movements about disability (2). Disability movements have not gained as much attention as race or sexual orientation movements because so many Americans do not realize how prominent disability separation is in America. She wants people to start recognizing that disability is just as important as race and other movements. Next, Garland-Thomas speaks about different types of disabilities and how they aren’t always…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The first perspective she defines is the functional perspective, this can be characterized by the idea that someone is unable to perform normal tasks. These normal tasks could include, eating, and walking. Doris Hoffer was portrayed to represent the functional perspective, in saying she is unable to complete these everyday task, charactering that she has some type of disability. Next, Owens outlines the concept of Bio-medical perspective, which is when disability is defined as a disease, disorder, and medical condition. Both Bio- medical perspectives and functional perspectives are seen as a biological, cognitive and/or physical malfunction. Then, she looks at the Social/environmental perspective which is characterized by a disability that is presented as the result of barriers in the social environment that prevent persons from full participation in the community. Doris Hoffer has trouble walking, a lot of places in society are not wheelchair accessible, or do not have a ramp for someone who finds it hard to walk up stairs. Doris needed help in completing these tasks like going to the store, going to get food and even walking, stopping her from participating in full in the community. Lastly, Human rights perspective focuses on the respect for human dignity and protection against discrimination and exclusionary practices in the public and private spheres. The…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    People treat other people differently based on how they act, and no one can deny that because that's how you make friends. But people with a disability such as Charlie, in the book “Flowers For Algernon” “by Daniel Keys” are shunned and ignored all the time just because they can’t think straight. In this book, Charlie his whole life has been unable to read or write. This caused people to judge him as a clueless 30 year old man even though it’s just because he has a disability. There is proof of people being mistreated just because they have disabilities, Like kids at school getting a math question that was easy to everyone else wrong and he is all the sudden considered dumb even though it’s not his fault. In this essay i am trying to prove how just because someone is slow at learning it doesn't mean they are “dumb”.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    She talks about ‘labels’, how very often we are labelled by others, allowing them to define us, and in many cases, limit us. Labels such as gay, lesbian, disabled, and many more. Once you are labelled as a ‘disabled’, it seems that you are automatically not allowed to do many things. I remember Ms Casey saying, ‘If you had been labelled as a disabled child, you don’t get dreams, you are not allowed them, to be a ballet star, or to be a footballer or whatever.’ Indeed, disabled children do not get that opportunity because most don’t understand them, thus very often people assume that they know what the best is for them. I have learnt that we should not let ourselves be defined by others; every one of us must be the very best of ourselves, regardless of how others may see us.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    John Nash a Beautiful Mind

    • 6096 Words
    • 25 Pages

    Of American novels that engage with the topic of mental disability, few are more popular than Daniel Keyes's Flowers for Algernon. Such popularity seems based on a simplistic reading of the novel where the mentally disabled are objects of good-natured compassion. A more thorough reading of how Charlie Gordon is presented, however, leads to the conclusion that mental disability is the embodiment of death in the novel. Readers are first taught to pity the pre-operative Charlie, but once they come to respond to the ethical voice of the post-operative Charlie, his regression to his original state becomes the rhetorical villain in the novel. At first an object of pity, the mentally disabled Charlie Gordon eventually becomes the metaphorical horror of oblivion that no character has the power to overcome.…

    • 6096 Words
    • 25 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women In Fan Fiction

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages

    But the media is one of the four main sources of socialization, meaning that the media, which includes Supernatural, needs to show that women can be heroes too. This is mirrored in Avellaneda’s degradation of Cervantes as a cripple. But despite the fact that Cervantes was proud of the fact that he lost his hand fighting for Spain, Avellaneda’s comment must have made him feel less than he did before. Clearly, he was able to live an independent life and write, all with only one hand, which is the message amputees always need to hear. And negative messages like Avellaneda’s aren’t just insulting, but make people devalue themselves if they aren’t young and able-bodied. Thus, insults breaking the unspoken respect between writer and audience have larger consequences than many would…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays